This article critically assesses the ideology of industrialism in light of Ivan Illich's Medical Nemesis. The paper is divided into three sections. The first section is a description of the main features of that ideology, the most prevalent and influential one used in sociological literature to explain the state both of Western societies and of our health services. Also in this section, it is shown how these features appear in Illich's analysis of our societies, of our health services, and of the different clinical, social, and structural iatrogeneses that health services create. The second section examines the assumptions underlying Illich's analysis and discusses their validity to explain the nature and function of our Western health services and their iatrogenic effects. Where Illich's explanations are considered invalid, alternative explanations are presented. Among them, it is postulated that it is not industrialism, but the assumedly transcended category of capitalism that is the cause of the social and structural iatrogeneses. The third section discusses the political implications of Illich's analysis, in a moment when our Western societies are supposedly in crisis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CohenN. M.BackettE. M.Medical nemesis. Book Review of Medical Nemesis by IllichI., LancetII(7895): 1503–1504, 1974.
2.
KozolJ. Quoted in IllichI., Deschooling Society. Calder and Boyars, London, 1971.
3.
SchwarzenbergL.Le “bon sens” de Monsieur Illich. Le Nouvel Observateur523: 3, 1974.
4.
IllichI.Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health. Calder and Boyars, London, 1975.
IllichI.Medical nemesis: The destructive force of professional health care. Social Policy5(2): 3–9, 1974.
7.
BlackburnR.A brief guide to bourgeois ideology. In Student Power, edited by CockburnA.BlackburnR., pp. 163–213. Penguin Books, Baltimore, 1969.
8.
FrankenbergR.Functionalism and after? Theory and developments in social science applied to the health field. Int. J. Health Serv. 4(3): 411–427, 1974.
9.
GalbraithJ. K.The New Industrial State, p. 389. Houghton-Mifflin, Boston, 1967.
10.
RostowW. W.The Stages of Economic Growth. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1962.
11.
NavarroV.The underdevelopment of health or the health of underdevelopment. Int. J. Health Serv. 4(1): 5–27, 1974.
12.
KahnH.WienerA. J.The Year 2,000. Macmillan, New York, 1967.
13.
CronkiteW.Report on industrialization. CBS News, August 1973.
14.
BellD.The post-industrial society: A speculative view. In Scientific Progress and Human Values, edited by HutchingsE.HutchingsE., American Elsevier, New York, 1967.
15.
AronR.Progress and Disillusion: The Dialectics of Modern Society. Praeger, New York, 1968.
16.
IllichI.Tools for Conviviality. Calder and Boyars, London, 1971.
17.
IllichI.Deschooling Society. Calder and Boyars, London, 1971.
18.
FriedmanM.Capitalism and Freedom. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1962.
19.
KesselR. A.The A.M.A. and the supply of physicians. Law and Contemporary Problems35: 267–283, 1970.
20.
KesselR. A.Price discrimination in medicine. Journal of Law and Economics1: 20–53, 1958.
21.
NixonR. M. U.S. Presidential Address, 1972.
22.
NavarroV.From public health to health of the public: The redefinition of our task. Am. J. Public Health64(6): 538–542, 1974.
OllmanB.Alienation. Cambridge University Press, London, 1974.
31.
PappenheimF.The Alienation of Modern Man. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1974.
32.
Worker Alienation, 1972. Hearings before the Subcommittee on Employment, Manpower, and Poverty of the Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, United States Senate, 92nd Congress. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1972.
33.
SheppardH. L.HerrickN. Q.Where Have All the Robots Gone? Worker Dissatisfaction in the '70's. The Free Press, New York, 1972.
34.
Special Task Force to the Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare. Work in America. M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1973.
35.
ZernanJ.Organized labor versus “the revolt against work”: The critical contest. Telos21: 194–206, 1974.
36.
LevisonA.The Working Class Majority. Coward, McCann, and Geoghegan, New York, 1974.
37.
DreitzelH. P., editor. The Social Organization of Health. Macmillan, New York, 1971.
38.
HoweH. F.Health and work. Editorial. Am. J. Public Health65(1): 82, 1975.
39.
BravermanH.Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century. Monthly Review Press, New York and London, 1974.
40.
MarglinS.A.What do bosses do? The origins and functions of hierarchy in capitalist production. The Review of Radical Political Economics6(2): 60–112, 1974.
41.
NavarroV.Social policy issues: An explanation of the composition, nature and functions of the present health sector of the United States. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine51(1) second series: 199–234, 1975.
42.
SusserM.Ethical components in the definition of health. Int. J. Health Sen. 4(3): 539–548, 1974.
43.
GalbraithJ. K.Economics and the Public Purpose, p. 31. Houghton-Mifflin, Boston, 1972.
44.
MarxK.The German ideology. In Selected Works, Vol. 1, p. 47. Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1962. (Quoted in AndersonC.H., The Political Economy of Social Class, p. 60. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1974.).
45.
SweezyP.BettelheimC.On The Transition to Socialism. Monthly Review Press, New York and London, 1971.
46.
SweezyP.The nature of Soviet society. Monthly Review26(6): 1–16, 1974.
47.
BettelheimC.Cultural Revolution and Industrial Organization in China: Changes in Management and the Division of Labor. Monthly Review Press, New York and London, 1974.
48.
BoorsteinE.The Economic Transformation of Cuba. Monthly Review Press, New York and London, 1968.
49.
NavarroV.What does Chile mean: An analysis of events in the health sector before, during and after Allende's administration. Health and Society, Milbank Mem. Fund Q. 52(2): 93–130, 1974.
50.
SilberI.The Cultural Revolution, p. 58. Times Change Press, New York, 1970.
51.
FuchsV.Health care and the United States economic system. Milbank Mem. Fund Q. 50(2, part 1): 211–237, 1972.
52.
MeyerJ.Interview, FM-WMG Washington Radio Station, September 1974.
53.
ComelyP. B.The hidden enemies of health and the American Public Health Association. Am. J. Public Health61(1): 7–18,1971.
54.
The great American animal farm. Time, pp. 58–64, December 23, 1974.
55.
Citizens' Board of Inquiry into Hunger and Malnutrition in the United States. Hunger U.S.A. Revisited, p. 9. National Council on Hunger and Malnutrition and the Southern Regional Council, Atlanta, 1973.
56.
ToynbeeP.Quoted among press opinions of Illich's works, IllichI., Medical Nemesis, p. 184. Calder and Boyars, London, 1975.
