I present a version of a nonrestricted identity theory as well as refutations of Searle's objections to the theory. The objections countered are: 1) the theory violates Leibnitz' Law and 2) that consciousness is not reducible to neurons. Searle's arguments are refuted on the basis of the first-personal nature of consciousness. It does not violate Leibnitz' law when regarded from the subjective view of the individual under observation and it appears to be irreducible because it cannot be observed from a third-person perspective. In the discussion I point out why consciousness mistakenly appears to be immaterial instead of physicochemical and I suggest a method by which consciousness might be studied empirically.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
SearleJ., Mind: A Brief Introduction, Oxford, 2004.
2.
SearleJ., The Mystery of Consciousness, The New York Review of Books (Publisher), New York, p. 138, 1999.
ArmstrongD. M., A Materialist Theory of the Mind, Routledge, London, 1998.
5.
BrooksE. M., Toward an Understanding of Perception, Consciousness, and Meaning, pp. 57–59. Unpublished. Copyright 1994.
6.
BrooksE. M., Journey Into the Realm of Consciousness. How the Brain Produces the Mind, First Books, imprint Author House, Bloomington, IN, 2002.
7.
MatsonW. L., Sentience, University of California Press, Berkeley, California, 1976.
8.
PepperS. C., A Neural Identity Theory of Mind, Dimensions of Mind, HookS. (ed.), Collier Books, New York, pp. 45–61, 1960.
9.
PutnamH., Psychological Predicates, Art, Mind, and Religion, CapitanW. H. and MerrilD. D. (eds.), University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, pp. 37–48, 1967.
10.
SperryR. W., Mental Phenomena as Causal Determinants in Brain Function, Consciousness and the Brain, GlobusG. G.MaxwellG., and SavodnikI. (eds.), Plenum, New York, pp. 161–177, 1976.
11.
KunzendorfR. G. and SheikhA. A. (eds.), The Psychophysiology of Mental Imagery, Baywood, Amityville, New York, p. 16, 1990.
12.
ChalmersD. J., The Conscious Mind. In Search of a Fundamental Theory, Oxford University Press, New York, p. 3, 1966.
13.
DennettD., Consciousness Explained, Little Brown and Company, Boston, p. 55, 1991.
14.
SmythiesJ., Consciousness: Some Basic Issues—A Neurophilosophical Perspective, Consciousness and Cognition, 8, p. 168, 1999.
15.
SmithN. K., A Commentary to Kant's ‘Critique of Pure Reason,’Humanities Press, New York, p. xliv, 1962.
KimJ., Mind in a Physical World, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, Ch. 2, 1986.
22.
NovotnyD. D., Searle's Ontology of the Mind in the Universe: A Criticism, University of Buffalo, Buffalo, New York, pp. 4–14, Spring 2002. (Also “Searle's Ontology of the Mind in the Universe: A Criticism” on Internet under Google, Causal Reduction, p. 2, 2002.)
23.
VelmansM., The Relation of Consciousness to the Material World, Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2:3, pp. 255–265, 1995.
24.
BaarsB. J., In the Theater of Consciousness: The Workspace of the Mind, Oxford University Press, New York, p. viii, 1997.
25.
CrickF., The Astonishing Hypothesis, Charles Scribner's Sons, (Maxwell Macmillan International), New York, 1994.
26.
BorstC. V., The Mind Brain Identity Theory, Macmillan, St. Martin's Press, London, p. 16, 1970.
27.
DavidsonD., An Essay on Mental Events, in Essays on Actions and Events, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 207–277, 1980.
28.
PenroseR. and HameroffS. R., What Gaps? Reply to Grush and Churchland, Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2:2, pp. 99–112, 1995.
29.
ZoharD., The Quantum Self, Morrow, New York, 1990.
30.
ShumyatskyG. P.MalleretG.ShinR. M.TakizawaS.TullyK.TsvetkovE.ZakharenkoS. S.JosephJ.VronskayaS.YinD.SchubartU. K.KandelE. R., and BolshakovV. Y., Stathmin, A Gene Enriched in the Amygdala Controls Both Learned and Innate Fear, Cell, 123, pp. 697–709, November 18, 2005. (Also Science News, 168:22, p. 341, November 26, 2005.)
31.
RockmanM. W., Ancient and Recent Positive Selection Transformed Opioid cis-Regulation in Humans, PloS Biology, p. 387, December 2005. (Also Science News, 168:22, p. 342, November 26, 2005.)
32.
VosshallL., Science News, 167:11, p. 173, March 12, 2005.
33.
NicolelisM. A. L., Nature, November 2000.
34.
BrooksE. M., Multiplicity of Consciousness, Imagination, Cognition and Personality, 24:3, pp. 271–280, 2004–2005.
