Professor Irving J. Selikoff (1915–1992) was America's foremost medical expert on asbestos-related diseases between the 1960s and early 1990s. He was also well known to the public for his media appearances on the burgeoning asbestos problem. Yet his reputation has been strikingly mixed. On the one hand, he has been portrayed as a mischief maker and irresponsible demagogue, who exaggerated the risks of asbestos and so destroyed an industry; on the other, as a pioneer in asbestos epidemiology, whose landmark studies of insulation (and other) workers demonstrated the severity of a modern occupational and public health tragedy. Drawing upon unprecedented access to the Selikoff archive at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City, this article demonstrates that the most serious criticisms of Selikoff are either ill-founded or simply false. It also shows that Selikoff, in the highly politicized world of asbestos science, was a far more complex and conservative individual than previous studies have suggested.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CastlemanB. I., Asbestos: Medical and Legal Aspects, New York, Aspen Publishers, 5th edition, 2005.
CarrollS. J.HenslerD.GrossJ.SlossE. M.SchonlauM.AbrahamseA., and AshwoodJ. S., Asbestos Litigation, Santa Monica, CA: RAND, pp. 16–18, 2005.
4.
LaDouJ., The Asbestos Cancer Epidemic, Environmental Health Perspectives, 112, pp. 285–90, 2003.
5.
LandriganP. J., In Memoriam: Irving J. Selikoff, 1915–1992, American Journal of Public Health, 83, p. 609, April 1993.
6.
BrodeurP., Expendable Americans, New York, Viking, 1974.
7.
BrodeurP., Outrageous Misconduct, New York, Pantheon Books, 1985.
8.
LiddellF.D.K., Magic, Menace, Myth and Malice, Annals Occupational Hygiene, 41, pp. 1–12. 1997.
9.
CornJ. K., Environmental Public Health Policy for Asbestos in Schools: Unintended Consequences, Boca Raton, Lewis Publishers, 1999.
10.
BartripP.. Irving John Selikoff and the Strange Case of the Missing Medical Degrees, Journal of History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 58, pp. 3–33, 2003.
11.
EgilmanD.TweedaleG.McCullochJ.KovarikW.CastlemanB. I.LongoW.LevinS., and BohmeS. R., P.J.W. Bartrip's Attack on Irving J. Selikoff, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 46, pp. 151–155, 2004.
12.
GreenbergM., Biological Effects of Asbestos: New York Academy of Sciences 1964, American Journal of Industrial Medicine43, pp. 543–52, 2003.
GarfinkelL., Asbestos: Historical Perspective, CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, 34, pp. 44–7, 1984.
15.
SelikoffI. J.ChurgJ., and HammondE. C., Asbestos Exposure and Neoplasia, Journal of American Medical Association, 188 (1964), pp. 22–6.
16.
SelikoffI. J.HammondE. C., and ChurgJ., Asbestos Exposure, Smoking, and Neoplasia, Journal of American Medical Association, 204, pp. 106–112, 1968.
17.
HammondE. C.SelikoffI. J., and SeidmanH., Asbestos Exposure, Cigarette Smoking, and Death Rates, Annals New York Academy of Sciences, 330, pp. 473–90, 1979.
18.
SeidmanH.SelikoffI. J., and HammondE. C., Short-Term Asbestos Work Exposure and Long-Term Observation, Annals New York Academy of Sciences, 330, pp. 61–89, 1979.
19.
SelikoffI. J.HammondE. C., and SeidmanH., Mortality Experience of Insulation Workers in the United States and Canada, 1943–1976, Annals New York Academy of Sciences, 330, pp. 91–116 (1979).
20.
NicholsonW. J.PerkelG., and SelikoffI. J., Occupational Exposure to Asbestos: Population at Risk and Projected Mortality 1980–2030, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 3, pp. 259–311, 1982.
21.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Laura Job, NYS Department of Labor, Brooklyn, New York, 31 March 1988.
22.
LandriganP. J. and KazemiH. (eds.), The Third Wave of Asbestos Disease: Exposure to Asbestos in Place. Public Health Control, Annals of New York Academy of Sciences, 643, pp. 1–628, 1991.
23.
SamuelsS. W. and UptonA. C. (eds.), Genes, Cancer, and Ethics in the Work Environment, Solomons Island, Maryland, Ramazzini Institute/OEM Press, 1998.
24.
Philip Landrigan, interviewed by J. McCulloch, Mount Sinai Hospital, 17 November 2006.
25.
SwetonicM. M., Death of the Asbestos Industry in Crisis Response; Inside Stories of Managing Image under Siege, GottschalkJ. (ed.), Detroit, Gail Research Inc., pp. 289–308, 1993.
26.
RichterE. D., personal communication to G. Tweedale, 17 December 2006.
27.
Stephen Levin, interviewed by J. McCulloch, Mount Sinai Hospital, 27 October 2006.
28.
SelikoffI. J., letter to L.L. Moerwald, 11 August 1986.
29.
SelikoffI. J., The Asbestos Tragedy. Statement to Senator Christopher Dodd, Hartford, Connecticut, 23 October 1983.
30.
SelikoffI. J., Statement to Subcommittee on Health & Safety of the Committee on Education and Labor (chairman Joseph M. Gaydos), Washington, 17 July 1985.
31.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Senator Lowell Weicker, 2 May 1989.
32.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Professor Keith Griffiths, Tenovus Institute for Cancer, 6 April 1989.
33.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Professor Dan Mintz, 18 October 1991.
34.
Anon, Environmental Science in the City that Never Sleeps, Environmental Health Perspectives103, pp. 654–9, 1995.
35.
Arthur Frank, interviewed by G. Tweedale, 18 December 2006.
36.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Peter Visser, 5 April 1982.
37.
Anon, letter headed “Dear Sirs and Brothers”, c. 1970.
38.
SelikoffI. J., letter to P. Kotin, 24 January 1978.
39.
SelikoffI. J., Statement, 7 March 1968, before the House Committee on Education and Labor, Select Sub-Committee on Labor, HR 14816, Occupational Safety & Health Act of 1968.
40.
SelikoffI. J., Partnership for Prevention—The Insulation Industry Hygiene Research Program, Industrial Medicine, 39, pp. 21–25, 1970.
41.
SelikoffI. J., Address to the Second International Safety Conference, United Steel Workers of America, AFL-CI0. Conrad Hilton Hotel, Chicago. March 25, 26, 27, 1971.
42.
SelikoffI. J., letter to M. Toljagic, 13 May 1991.
43.
SelikoffI. J., interview with Sheffield Star, December 1977.
44.
SelikoffI. J. and LeeD.H.K., Asbestos and Disease, New York, Academic Press, 1978.
45.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Dunnigan, 7 November 1985.
46.
SelikoffI. J., Deposition in Claude J. Tomplait v. Combustion Engineering, US District Court for Eastern District of Texas Beaumont Division, Civ. No. 5402, New York, 4 March 1968.
47.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Alan Dalton, 24 October 1983.
48.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Chief Justice Warren Burger, 5 October 1982.
49.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Gorbachev, General Secretary, Kremlin, Moscow, 22 June 1987.
50.
Horace Beasley, memo 25 February 1974 re. AIA/NA meeting 21 February 1974 to Capco (Birmingham, Alabama). Copy provided to authors by David Egilman.
51.
SelikoffI. J., letter to William P. Raines, AIA/NA, 2 April 1971.
52.
TweedaleG. and McCullochJ., Chrysophiles versus Chrysophobes: The White Asbestos Controversy, 1950s–2004, Isis, 95, pp. 239–59, 2004.
53.
SelikoffI. J., letter to P.K. Kelly, 13 February 1978.
54.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Sheldon Samuels, AFL-CIO, 29 May 1973.
55.
HardellL.WalkerM. J.WalhjaltB.FiredmanL. S., and RichterE. D., Secret Ties to Industry and Conflicting Interests in Cancer Research, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 50, pp. 227–332007.
56.
McCullochJ., Saving the Asbestos Industry, 1960 to 2003, Public Health Reports, 121, pp. 609–14, 2006.
57.
SelikoffI. J., letter to M. Greenberg, 31 December 1979.
58.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Dr Arthur C. Upton, 14 May 1990.
59.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Arthur C. Upton, 20 December 1989.
60.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Greenberg, 28 February 1978.
61.
KlugerRichard, Ashes to Ashes: America's Hundred-Year Cigarette War, the Public Health, and the Unabashed Triumph of Philip Morris, New York, Alfred A. Knopf, pp. 207, 325, 361, 1996.
62.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Dr. M. Newhouse, 12 December 1984.
63.
McCullochJ., Asbestos Blues: Labour, Capital, Physicians and the State in South Africa, London, James Currey, 2002.
64.
HardyH., letter to Selikoff, 26 July 1978.
65.
SelikoffI. J., letter to Hardy, 2 August 1978.
66.
SelikoffI. J.ChurgJ., and HammondE. C., Asbestos Exposure and Neoplasia, Journal of American Medical Association, 252, I, 41–51, 1984. Reprinted from Journal of American Medical Association, 188, pp. 22–6, 1964.
67.
SelikoffI. J.ChurgJ., and HammondE. C., Asbestos Exposure and Neoplasia. CA: Cancer Journal for Clinicians, 34, pp. 48–56, 1984. Reprinted from Journal of American Medical Association, 188, pp. 22–6, 1964.
68.
StellmanS. D., Issues of Causality in the History of Occupational Epidemiology, Sozial-und Praventivmedizin, 48, pp. 151–61, 2003.
69.
GochfieldM., Chronological History of Occupational Medicine, Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 47, pp. 96–114, 2005.
70.
MorganR. W.FoliartD. E., and WongO., Asbestos and Gastrointestinal Cancer, Western Journal of Medicine, 143, pp. 60–5, 1985.
71.
World Health Organization, Asbestos in Drinking Water, WHO/SDE/WSH/03.04/02, Geneva, WHO, 2003.
World Trade Organization, European Community—Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos-Containing Products, Report of the Panel, WT/DS135/R, 18 September 2000.
74.
World Trade Organization, European Community—Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos-Containing Products. Report of the Appellate Body, WT/DS135/AB/R, 12 March 2001.
CastlemanB. I., WTO Confidential, International Journal of Health Services, 32, pp. 489–501, 2002.
78.
LandriganP. J., Health and Environmental Consequences of the World Trade Center Disaster, Environmental Health Perspectives, 112, pp. 731–9, 2004.
79.
LilisR., Award Acceptance Speech, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 49, pp. 705–7, 2006.
80.
RichterE. D. and LasterR., The Precautionary Principle, Epidemiology and the Ethics of Delay, Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, 11, pp. 17–27, 2005.
