Unmet Needs as Sociomedical Indicators

Abstract

This paper discusses the Meharry Medical College Study of Unmet Needs designed to measure the effectiveness of alternative health care delivery systems: (a) comprehensive care with broad outreach, (b) comprehensive care with limited outreach, and (c) traditional care. Unmet needs are defined as the differences between services judged necessary to deal appropriately with health problems and services actually received. The central hypothesis is that comprehensive health programs will be more effective than traditional care in reducing unmet needs. Unmet needs are viewed as measures of program outcome and are one of several types of sociomedical indicators which use factors other than biomedical or biological states as measures of outcome. The distinction is made between unmet needs indicators and health status indicators.

Various approaches to measuring unmet needs are discussed and the relatively limited focus of these is contrasted with the more comprehensive Meharry approach. Household interviews and clinical examinations provide the data base for deriving professional judgments of unmet needs in the medical, dental, nursing, and social services areas. The Meharry work suggests several areas in which further work on unmet needs would be useful.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Flook

E. E.

Sanazaro

P. J.

, editors. Health Services Research and R & D in Perspective. Health Administration Press, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 1973.

Wolfe

The Meharry Medical College Center for Health Care Research. J. Natl. Med. Assoc. 65 (4): 293–295, 1973.

Elinson

Toward sociomedical health indicators. Social Indicators Research 1 (1): 59–71, 1974.

Hoffer

C. R.

Schuler

E. A.

Measurement of health needs and health care. Am. Social. Rev. 13 (6): 719–724, 1948.

Hoffer

C. R.

Schuler

E. A.

Determination of unmet needs for medical attention among Michigan farm families. Journal of the Michigan State Medical Society 46: 443–446, 1947.

Schuler

E. A.

Mayo

S. C.

Makover

H. B.

Measuring unmet needs for medical care: An experiment in method. Rural Sociology 11 (2): 152–158, 1946.

Rosenfeld

L. S.

Donabedian

Katz

Unmet need for medical care. N. Engl. J. Med. 258: 369–376, 1958.

Wallace

H. M.

Eisner

Dooley

Availability and usefulness of selected health and socioeconomic data for community planning. Am. J. Public Health 57 (5): 1762–1771, 1967.

Kessner

D. M.

Kalk

Contrasts in Health Status. Vol. 2, A Strategy for Evaluating Health Services. Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D. C., 1973.

10.

Contrasts in Health Status. Vol. 3, Assessment of Medical Care for Children. Institute of Medicine, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D. C., 1973.

11.

Trussell

R. E.

Elinson

Chronic Illness in the United States. Vol. 3, Chronic Illness in a Rural Area. The Hunterdon Study. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1959.

12.

Chronic Illness in the United States. Vol. IV, Chronic Illness in a Large City. Commission on Chronic Illness, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1957.

13.

Pearman

J. R.

Survey of unmet medical needs of children in six counties in Florida. Public Health Rep. 85: 189–196, March 1970.

14.

Salisbury

A. J.

Berg

Health defects and need for treatment of adolescents in low income families. Public Health Rep. 84: 705–711, August 1969.

15.

National Center for Health Statistics. Vital and Health Statistics, Series 1, No. 10a and No. 10b, Plan and Operation of the Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, United States-1971–1973. U. S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, Washington, D. C., February 1973.

16.

Carter

Measurements of need. In Social Work Research, edited by Polansky

Norman

, pp. 201–222. University of Chicago, Chicago, 1960.

17.

Center for Health Care Research, Meharry Medical College. Report of Contract HSM 110-69-199, Evaluation of Health Services in a Largely Black City Slum. Submitted to the National Center for Health Services Research and Development, July 1971.

18.

Wolfe

Carr

Revo

L. T.

Neser

W. B.

Edwards

Martin

Penn

Lefkowitz

The Meharry Medical College Study of Unmet Needs for Health and Welfare Services. Paper presented at 102nd Annual Meeting of the American Public Health Association, New Orleans, La., October 1974 (mimeographed).

19.

Donabedian

The evaluation of medical care programs. Bull. N. Y. Acad. Med. 44 (2): 118, 1968.

20.

Veney

Health status indicators. Inquiry 10: 3–4, December 1973.