Sally Satel's PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine constitutes an attempt to weaken the influence of egalitarian and antiracist scholarship in contemporary public health. This book has been widely distributed and has received many positive reviews in academia and the general press. Surprisingly, Satel has enlisted the direct or indirect support of prominent public health academics. The authors' critical review of this book indicates that Satel uses a combination of tactics to convince the reader of the danger involved in egalitarian public health efforts. Among them are insults, traditional “red baiting” tactics, “triangulation,” exaggeration, emotionally charged examples, omissions, and a strong appeal to individual responsibility to explain social inequalities in health. PC, M.D. reveals a scientific and ideological conflict over the determinants of health in populations that takes place within and outside the public health discipline. Efforts such as PC, M.D. suggest that social epidemiologists and other egalitarian public health scholars are having some impact in shaping how the public views health disparities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
KovelJ.Red Hunting in the Promised Land: Anticommunism and the Making of America. Continuum International, London, 1997.
2.
FoxD. M. PCMD. N. Engl. J. Med.433: 462, 2000.
3.
SatelS.PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine. Basic Books, New York, 2000.
4.
HofstaderR.The Paranoid Style in American Politics and Other Essays. Vintage, New York, 1967.
5.
ShermanS., David Horowitz's long march. Nation271: 11–18, 2000.
6.
GranadosTapia J. A., Is epidemiology an applied science or a technology?Am. J. Public Health89: 599–600, 1999.
7.
SchwartzS., and Diez-RouxA., Causes of incidence and causes of cases: A Durkheimian perspective on Rose. Int. J. Epidemiol. 30: 435–439, 2001.
8.
HitchensC.Nobody Left to Lie To. Verso, London, 2000.
9.
CockburnA.Al Gore: A User's Manual. Verso, London, 2000.
10.
NavarroV. (ed.). The Political Economy of Social Inequalities: Consequences for Health and Quality of Life. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 2001.
11.
LantzP., Socioeconomic disparities in health change in a longitudinal study of US adults: The role of health risk behaviors. Soc. Sci. Med.53: 29–40, 2001.
12.
LynchJ.KaplanG., and SalonenJ. T., Why do poor people behave poorly? Variations in adult health behavior and psychosocial characteristics, by stage of socioeconomic lifecourse. Soc. Sci. Med.44: 809–820, 1997.
13.
MuntanerC., and LynchJ., Income inequality, social cohesion, and class relations. Int. J. Health Serv.29(1): 59–81, 1999.
14.
LynchJ., Social capital as investment strategy for public health: A neo-material rejoinder to Baum. J. Epidemiol. Community Health54: 404–408, 2000.
15.
LynchJ., Income inequality and health: Expanding the debate. Soc. Sci. Med.51: 1001–1005, 2000.
16.
LynchJ., Absolute income and life expectancy: Author's reply. J. Epidemiol. Community Health55(2): 151–152, 2001.
17.
MuntanerC.LynchJ., and Davey-SmithG., Social capital and the Third Way in public health. Crit. Public Health10: 107–124, 2000.
18.
MuntanerC.OatesG., and LynchJ.The social class determinants of income inequality and social cohesion. In The Political Economy of Social Inequalities, edited by NavarroV.. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 2001.
19.
MuntanerC., and LynchJ. W.Social capital, class, race and gender conflict, and population health: A review essay of Putnam's Bowling Alone with implications for social epidemiology. Int. J. Epidemiol., in press.
20.
LiftonR. J.The Nazi Doctors. Basic Books, New York, 1986.
21.
RoseS.KaminL. J., and LewontinR. C.Not in Our Genes: Biology, Ideology, and Human Nature. Penguin, Harmondsworth, England, 1984.
22.
LinkB. G., and StueveA., Evidence bearing on mental illness as possible cause of violent behavior. Epidemiol. Rev.17: 172–181, 1995.
23.
MuntanerC., Arrest among psychotic inpatients: Assessing the relationship to diagnosis, gender, number of admissions and social class. Soc. Psychiatry Psychiatr. Epidemiol. 33(6): 274–282, 1998.
24.
25.
MowbrayC. T., Consumer-run mental health services: Results from five demonstration projects. Community Mental Health J.24: 151–156, 1988.
26.
NonnemakerL., Women physicians in academic medicine: New insights from cohort studies. N. Engl. J. Med.342(6): 399–405, 2000.
27.
DavisK.Reshaping the Female Body: The Dilemma of Cosmetic Surgery. Routledge, New York, 1995.
28.
BairdK. L., The new NIH and FDA medical research policies: Targeting gender, promoting justice. J. Health Polit. Policy Law24: 531–562, 1999.
29.
LeeP. Y., Representation of elderly persons and women in published randomized trials of acute coronary syndromes. JAMA286: 708–713, 2001.
30.
CarrP. L., Comparing the status of women and men in academic medicine. Ann. Intern. Med.119(9): 908–913, 1993.
31.
TopelR.Specific Capital, Mobility and Wages: Wages Rise with Job Seniority. Working Paper No. 3294. National Bureau of Economic Research, Washington, D.C., 1990.
32.
SchulmanK. A.BerlinJ. A., and HarlessW., The effect of race and sex on physicians' recommendations for cardiac catheterization. N. Engl. J. Med.340: 618–626, 1999.
33.
ReskinB. F.The Realities of Affirmative Action. American Sociological Association, Washington, D.C., 1998.
34.
HenryJ.Kaiser Family Foundation. Race, Ethnicity and Medical Care: A Survey of Public Perceptions and Experiences. Menlo Park, Calif., 1999.
35.
Erlich Transcultural Consultants.New America Wellness. Morehouse College of Medicine Multiethnic Healthcare Attitudinal Research, Woodland Hills, Calif., 1999.
36.
MuntanerC., Social mechanisms, race and social epidemiology. Am. J. Epidemiol. 150(2): 121–126, 1999.
37.
KriegerN., and SidneyS. S., Racial discrimination and blood pressure: The CARDIA study of young black and white adults. Am. J. Public Health86: 1370–1378, 1999.
38.
FeaginJ., and SikesM. P.Living with Racism: The Black Middle-Class Experience. Beacon Press, Boston, 1994.
39.
EssedP.Understanding Everyday Racism. Sage, Newbury Park, Calif., 1991.
40.
HooksB. Killing Rage: Ending Racism. Henry Holt, New York, 1995.
41.
MuntanerC., Nieto, J., and O'Campo, P. Race, social class, and epidemiologic research. J. Public Health Policy18(3): 261–274, 1997.
42.
ArmsteadC. A., Relationship of racial stressors to blood pressure and anger expression in black college students. Health Psychol. 8: 541–556, 1989.
43.
HarburgE., Skin color, ethnicity and blood pressure. I: Detroit blacks. Am. J. Public Health68: 1177–1183, 1978.
44.
MuntanerC.EatonC., and DialaC., Social inequalities in mental health: A review of concepts and underlying assumptions. Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness, and Medicine4(1): 82–106, 2000.
45.
CohenC.Social inequality and psychiatry: Implications for training and clinical care psychiatric services. 2001, in press.
46.
WilkinsonR. W.Clarifying the theory: A response to Muntaner and Lynch. In The Political Economy of Social Inequalities, edited by NavarroV.. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 2001.
47.
MarmotM., and WilkinsonR., Psychosocial and material pathways in the relation between income and health: A response to Lynch et al. BMJ322: 1233–1236, 2001.
48.
KriegerN., Racism, sexism, and social class. Am. J. Prev. Med.9(Suppl. 2), 82–122, 1993.
49.
DavidR., The racial gap in infant mortality widens as class inequality worsens. Pediatr. Perinat. Epidemiol. 15(4): A7–A8, 2001.
50.
RothmanK. J.AdamiH. O., and TrichopoulosD., Should the mission of epidemiology include the eradication of poverty?Lancet352(9130): 810–813, 1998.
