Worker Training in Job Safety and Health: How Do We Know it Works?

Abstract

Two methods of occupational disease and injury prevention specifically required by Federal law are education and training of workers in job safety and health. Basic assumptions underlying these strategies are that they will increase safe behavior thereby reducing health risk. However, questions continue to arise regarding the effect of ongoing training as a preventive measure and, therefore, about the practical usefulness of these assumptions. The purpose of this study was to examine the extent to which evaluations of ongoing training programs can provide information to test the basic assumptions. A self-administered mail survey concerning the evaluation practices of occupational health professionals responsible for the evaluation of health and safety training programs was conducted. Results suggest that for many evaluations the information collected is inappropriate for the uses to which it is put. Furthermore, the results also suggest that measurement validity is a problem. Thus, in effect, we have no way of knowing whether or not the majority of training programs are effective.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Public Law 91–596, Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, Statutes at Large, 84, p. 1590, Title 29 U.S. Code Section 1976, p. 1560.

Robbins

, Foreword in Occupational Health: Recognizing and Preventing Work-Related Disease, Levy

B. S.

and Wegman

D. H.

(eds.), Little, Brown and Company, Boston, 1983.

Yodaiken

R. E.

Robbins

A. W.

, Occupational Ill-Health-A Review of the Symptoms and Signs, Journal of Occupational Medicine, 22, pp. 465–471, 1980.

Propositions pour une politique de prevention, La Documentation Francaise, Paris, 1982.

Quinot

Le Phenomene , Le Travail Humain, 42, pp. 87–104, 1979.

Bruner

, The Process of Education, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1977.

Goldstein

J. L.

, Training, in The Human Side of Accident Prevention: Psychological Concepts and Principles Which Bear on Industrial Safety, Margolis

B. L.

and Kroes

W. H.

(eds.), Charles C Thomas Publisher, Springfield, IL, 1975.

Cohen

Smith

M. J.

Anger

W. K.

, Self-Protective Measures Against Workplace Hazards, Journal of Safety Research, 11, pp. 121–131, 1979.

Margolis

and Kroes

W. H.

, Introduction, in The Human Side of Accident Prevention, Margolis

B. L.

and Kroes

W. H.

(eds.), Charles C Thomas, Springfield, IL, 1975.

10.

Heath

E. D.

, Worker Training and Education in Occupational Safety and Health: A Report on Practice in Six Industrialized Western Nations, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 2, pp. 379–403, 1981.

11.

U.S. Department of Labor, OSHA, Hazard Communication; Final Rule, Federal Register, 48, pp. 53280–53348, 1983.

12.

McElveen

J. C.

Jr. , Despite Pre-Emption Threats-Local Rights-to-Know Laws Increase, Occup. Safety Health, 54, pp. 20–26.

13.

Cohen

Colligan

M. J.

, and Berger

, Psychology in Health Risk Messages for Workers, Journal of Occupational Medicine, 27, pp. 543–551, 1985.

14.

National Academy of Science, Informing Workers and Employers About Occupational Cancer, US Dept. of Labor Contract J-9-F-5-0012, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, 1977.

15.

Vojtecky

M. A.

Kar

S. B.

, and Cox

S. G.

, Workplace Health Education: Results from a National Survey, International Quarterly of Community Health Education, 5, pp. 171–185, 1984–85.

16.

United States Department of Health and Human Services, Request for Proposal: Evaluation of the Effectiveness and Efficiency of Workplace Health Enhancement Programs. RFP-15-83-HHS-OS, 1983.

17.

Vojtecky

M. A.

, and Berkanovic

, The Evaluation of Health and Safety Training, International Quarterly of Community Health Education, 5, pp. 277–286, 1984–85.

18.

Komaki

Barwick

K. D.

, and Scott

L. R.

, A Behavioral Approach to Occupational Safety: Pinpointing and Reinforcing Safe Performance in a Food Manufacturing Plant, Journal of Applied Psychology, 63, pp. 434–445, 1978.

19.

Komaki

Heinzmann

A. T.

, and Lawson

, Effect of Training and Feedback Component Analysis of a Behavioral Safety Program, Journal of Applied Psychology, 65, pp. 261–270, 1980.

20.

Zohar

Cohen

, and Azar

, Promoting Increased Use of Ear Protectors through Information Feedback, Human Factors, 22, pp. 69–79, 1980.

21.

Maples

T. W.

Jacoby

J. A.

Johnson

D. E.

Ter Haar

G. L.

, and Buckingham

F. M.

, Effectiveness of Employee Training and Motivation Programs in Reducing Exposure to Inorganic Lead and Lead Alkyls, American Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 43, pp. 692–694, 1982.

22.

Vojtecky

M. A.

, and Schmitz

M. F.

, Program Evaluation and Health and Safety Training, Journal of Safety Research, 17, pp. 57–63, 1986.

23.

U.S. Department of Labor, OSHA Training Guidelines: Request for Comments and Information, Federal Register, 54, p. 14, 1983.

24.

Enforcement Directive Issued on Hazard Communication, Occupational Health and Safety, 54, p. 14, 1985.

25.

Dixon

W. J.

and Massey

F. J.

Jr. , Introduction to Statistical Analysis 4th Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York, 1984.

26.

U.S. Department of Labor, OSHA Safety and Health Training and Education for Workers: United States, in Worker Training and Education in Occupational Safety and Health: A Report on Practice in Six Industrialized Western Nations (PB82–13699) National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA, 1980.