Doctor-patient interactions were tape-recorded and coded according to a modified system of Interaction Process Analysis. These data, combined with a series of patient interviews and a self-administered questionnaire completed by physicians, were analyzed to determine the extent of patient compliance with doctors' orders and how variations in patient compliance are influenced by some selected patient characteristics and by the structure and process of the doctor-patient relationship.
None of the demographic characteristics of patients investigated here was associated with compliance. However, the ways in which doctors and patients initially fit their activity into the presumably institutionalized patterns of behavior appropriate for doctor-patient interaction and the way they deviate over time from the institutionalized role expectations was found to be related to variations in patient compliance.
BendixR: Compliant behavior and individual personality. Amer J Soc58:292–303, 1952.
3.
DavisMS: Variations in patients' compliance with doctors' orders: Analysis of congruence between survey responses and results of empirical investigations. J Med Educ41:1037–48, 1966.
4.
DixonWMStradlingPWootonI: Outpatient PAS therapy. Lancet273:871–73, 1957.
5.
LuntzGRAustinR: New stick test for PAS in urine. Brit J Med1:1679–83, 1960.
6.
Wynn-WilliamsNArrisM: On omitting PAS. Tubercle39:138–42, 1958.
7.
DavisMSEichhornRL: Compliance with medical regimens: A panel study. J Hlth Hum Behav4:240–49, 1963.
8.
SchwartzDWongMZeitzL: Medication errors made by elderly, chronically ill patients. Amer J Publ Hlth52:2018–29, 1962.
9.
CobbBClarkRLMcGuireC: Patient-responsible delay of treatment in cancer. Cancer7:920–25, 1954.
10.
HardyMC: Psychologic aspects of pediatrics: Parent resistance to need for remedial and preventive services. J Pediat48:104–14, 1956.
11.
MatherW: Social and economic factors related to correction of school discovered medical and dental defects. Penn Med J62:983–88, 1954.
12.
MacDonaldMEHagvergKLGrossmanBJ: Social factors in relation to participation in follow-up care of rheumatic fever. J Pediat62:503–13, 1963.
13.
DonabedianARosenfeldLS: A follow-up study of chronically ill patients discharged from hospital. Paper read at the annual meeting of the American Public Health Association, November 1963, Kansas City, Missouri.
14.
JohannsenWJHellmuthGASoraufT: On accepting medical recommendations. Arch Environm Hlth12:63–69, 1966.
15.
PragoffH: Adjustment of tuberculosis patients one year after hospital discharge. Publ Hlth Rpt77:671–79, 1962.
16.
CobbBClarkRLMcGuireC: Patient-responsible delay of treatment in cancer. Cancer7:920–25, 1954.
17.
MizruchiEPerrucciR: Norm qualities and differential effects of deviant behavior: An exploratory analysis. Amer Soc Rev27:391–99, 1962.
18.
BerkowitzNHMaloneMFKleinMW: Patient follow-through in the outpatient department. Nurs Res12:16–22, 1963.
19.
BerkowitzNHMaloneMFKleinMW: Patient care as a criterion problem. J Hlth Hum Behav3:171–76, 1962.
20.
JohnsonWL: Conformity to medical recommendations in coronary heart disease. Paper read at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, September 1965, Chicago, Illinois.
21.
DavisMSvon der LippeRP: Discharge from hospital against medical advice: A study of reciprocity in the doctor-patient relationship. Paper read at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, September 1965, Chicago, Illinois.
22.
EllisR: The relationship between psychological factors and remission of duodenal ulcer. Doctoral dissertation, University of Chicago, 1964.
23.
AbramsonJHFatimaGHMMajolaCC: What is wrong with me? A study of the views of African and Indian patients in a Durban hospital. S A Med J19:690–94, 1961.
24.
AmbuelJPCebullaJWattN: Doctor-mother communications: A study of information communicated during clinic visits for acute illness. Abstr: Midwest Soc Pediat Res65:113–14, 1964.
25.
EllingRWhittemoreRGreenM: Patient participation in a pediatric program. J Hlth Hum Behav1:183–91, 1960.
26.
LeventhalH: Fear communication in the acceptance of preventive health practices. Bull N Y Acad Med41:1144–68, 1965.
27.
LeyPSpelmanMS: Communication in an outpatient setting. Brit J Soc Clin Psychol4:114–16, 1965.
28.
MohlerDNWallinDGDreyfusEG: Studies in the home treatment of streptococcal disease. New Engl J Med252:1116–18, 1955.
29.
RileyCS: Patients' understanding of doctors' instructions. Med Care4:34–47, 1966.
30.
RobbinsGFConteAJLeachJE: Delay in diagnosis and treatment of cancer. JAMA143:346–48, 1950.
31.
UllmannADavisMS: Assessing the medical patient's motivation and ability to work. Soc Casewk46:195–202, 1965.
32.
WattsD: Health education: Getting people to accept modern medical service. Publ Hlth Rpt81:229–30, 1966.
33.
BalesRF: Interaction Process Analysis. Cambridge, Addison Wesley, 1951.
34.
BackK: Influence through social communication. J Abnorm Soc Psychol46:9–23, 1951.
35.
PrattLSelligmanAReaderG: Physicians view of the level of medical information among patients. Amer J Publ Hlth47:1277–83, 1959.
36.
TriandisHC: Cognitive similarity and communication in a dyad. Hum Rel13:175–83, 1960.
37.
GoldbergSC: Three situational determinants of conformity to social norms. J Abnorm Soc Psychol49:325–29, 1954.
38.
JennesA: The role of discussion in changing opinion regarding a matter of fact. J Abnorm Soc Psychol27:279–96, 1932.
39.
NewcombTM: An approach to the study of communicative acts. Psychol Rev60:393–404, 1953.
40.
DavisF: Uncertainty in medical prognosis, clinical and functional. Amer J Soc66:41–47, 1960.
41.
FisherSLubinA: Distance as a determinant of influence in a two-person serial interaction situation. J Abnorm Soc Psychol56:230–38, 1958.
42.
ParsonsT: Definitions of health and illness in the light of American values and social structure, Patients, Physicians and Illness. Edited by JacoE Gartly. Glencoe, Free Press, 1957.
43.
GoffmanE: Encounters: Two Studies in the Sociology of Interaction. Indianapolis, Bobbs-Merril, 1961.
44.
ZimbardoP: Involvement and communication discrepancy as determinants of opinion conformity. J Abnorm Soc Psychol60:86–94, 1960.
45.
TurgeonLLongD: A study of new patients in the general medical clinic. Paper presented at Comprehensive Care and Teaching Program, February 1965, Cornell Medical Center. Mimeographed.
46.
DavisMS: Dimensions of Compliant Doctor-Patient Relationships. U.S. Public Health Service Grant (MH08458-01).
47.
HendersonLJ: Physician and patient as a social system. New Engl J Med212:819–25, 1935.
48.
BloomSW: The Doctor and His Patient: A Sociological Interpretation. New York, Russell Sage Foundation, 1963.
49.
MaukschHOTagliacozzoDL: Patient's view of the patient role: I. Analysis of interview. Department of Patient Care Research, 1962, Presbyterian-St. Luke's Hospital, Chicago, Illinois. Mimeographed.
50.
HollanderEP: Conformity, status and idiosyncratic credit. Psychol Rev65:117–27, 1958.
51.
HomeyK: The Neurotic Personality of Our Time. London, Paul Kegan, 1937.
52.
MellingerGD: Interpersonal trust as a factor in communication. J Abnorm Soc Psychol304–9, 1956.
53.
FlandersNHSuloN: Group compliance to dominative teacher influence. Hum Rel13:67–82, 1960.
54.
GouldnerAW: The norm of reciprocity: A preliminary statement. Amer Soc Rev25:161–78, 1960.
55.
KellmanHC: Compliance, identification and internalization: Three processes of attitude change. J Conflict Resolution2:51–60, 1958.
56.
LevineJ: Conforming behavior of psychiatric and medical patients. J Abnorm Soc Psychol49:251–55, 1954.
57.
HollanderEP: Competence and conformity in the acceptance of influence. J Abnorm Soc Psychol61:365–69, 1960.
58.
ChooT: Communicator credibility and communication discrepancy as determinants of opinion change. J Soc Psychol64:65–76, 1964.
59.
HovlandCIWeissW: The influence of source credibility on communication effectiveness. Publ Opn Quart15:635–50, 1952.
60.
MausnerB: The effect of variation in one partner's prestige on the interaction of observer pairs. J Abnorm Soc Psychol49:557–60, 1954.
