The owners of capital in the United States have successfully transferred most of the costs of industrial casualties onto the working class and the public at large. This has been accomplished by the creation of the privately owned workers' compensation insurance system and the corporate-dominated safety establishment.
This “compensation-safety establishment” has been able to take over most of the federal apparatus created by the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970. Nevertheless, workers and unions and their allies have begun to challenge the establishment's hegemony over job health and safety policy for the first time in seventy years.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Analysis of Workers' Compensation Laws. U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Washington, D.C., 1976.
2.
First Annual McGraw-Hill Survey of Investment in Employee Safety and Health, May 25, 1973.
3.
Insurance Expense Exhibit (Countrywide), for the year ending December 31, 1966. Compiled by the National Council on Compensation Insurance, 1967. Reprinted in 1968 Senate hearings, p. 820.
4.
WirtzW. W., Secretary of Labor. Testimony, 1968 Senate hearings, p. 204.
5.
MallinoD.A Policy Handbook on Occupational Safety and Health Standards, p. 6. Government Research Center, Washington, D.C., January 1973.
6.
GordonJ.Testimony, 1968 Senate hearings, p. 557.
7.
TraskoV. M.Silicosis, a continuing problem. Public Health Rep., September 1958.
8.
SkolnikA. M.HobsonJ. W.Workmen's compensation payments and costs, 1965. Social Security Bulletin, pp. 29–36, January 1967.
9.
SkolnikA. M.PriceD. N.Workmen's compensation payments and costs, 1972. Social Security Bulletin, pp. 30–34, January 1974.
10.
AshfordN. A.Crisis in the Workplace: Occupational Disease and Injury (A Report to the Ford Foundation). MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1976.
11.
PriceD. N.Workers' compensation: Coverage, payments, and costs, 1974. Social Security Bulletin, pp. 38–42, January 1976.
12.
Labor Letter. Wall Street Journal, p. 1. October 12, 1976.
13.
WirtzW. W.Testimony with Esther Peterson, Assistant Secretary of Labor for Labor Standards, and Charles Donahue, Solicitor, Department of Labor, 1968 Senate hearings, pp. 60–204.
14.
NaderR.GordonJ. B.Testimony, 1968 Senate hearings, pp. 509–634.
15.
ClaymanJ., Administrative Director, Industrial Union Department AFL-CIO. Testimony, 1970 Senate hearings, pp. 422–437.
16.
BermanD. M.Occupational Diseases and Public Policy: The Case of Industrial Lead Poisoning in Missouri, photocopy.
17.
MazzocchiA.Legislative-Citizenship Director, Oil, Chemical, and Atomic Workers. Testimony, 1968 House hearings, pp. 381–395.
18.
HannanD. W., President, United Steelworkers Local 1557. Testimony, 1970 Senate hearings, pp. 923–941.
19.
Coroner's verdict on the death of Claudie B. Douglas, January 11, 1970. Reproduced in 1970 Senate hearings, p. 1587.
20.
The Enforcement of Occupational Safety and Health Laws in Massachusetts: A Critique. Urban Planning Aid, Inc., Cambridge, Mass., 1971 (mimeographed).
21.
Interview with George Flexsenhar by Daniel M. Berman, Herculaneum, Missouri, February 1970.
22.
BamakoF. K., Manager, Compensation and Safety Division, Bethlehem Steel Corporation. Testimony, 1968 Senate hearings, pp. 399–442.
23.
PageJ. A.O'BrienM-W.Bitter Wages (Ralph Nader's Study Group Report on Disease and Injury on the Job). Grossman, New York, 1973.
24.
“Safety Activities of Compensation Insurance Companies,” apparently submitted as part of an exhibit by Andrew Kalmykow from an unidentified source (perhaps a publication of the New York State Department of Labor, judging from the type); in 1968 Senate hearings, p. 839.
25.
Van SchaakD.The part of the casualty insurance company in accident prevention. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, pp. 36–40, January 1926.
26.
DeegF. W., safety engineer, American Mutual Insurance Alliance. Testimony, 1968 House hearings, p. 438.
27.
Case against S.F. Bankers Ruled. San Francisco Chronicle, September 1976.
28.
Disclosure of Corporate Ownership, prepared by the Subcommittee on Intergovernmental Relations of the Committee on Governmental Operation, U.S. Senate, March 4, 1974.
MenshikovS.Millionaires and Managers. Progress Publishers, Moscow, 1969.
31.
Best's Aggregates and Averages (Property-Liability), 1975 edition.
32.
Property and Casualty Insurance Companies—Their Role as Financial Intermediaries. Monograph prepared for the Commission on Money and Credit, the American Mutual Insurance Alliance, Association of Casualty and Surety Companies, and National Board of Fire Underwriters.
33.
KellerM.The Life Insurance Enterprise, 1885–1910. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1963.
34.
SerberD.Regulating reform: The social organization of insurance regulation. The Insurgent Sociologist, pp. 83–105, Spring 1975.
35.
McCahanD.State Insurance in the United States. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, 1929.
36.
Compendium on Workmen's Compensation. National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws, Washington, D.C., 1973.
37.
“Get Mine” in Ohio. Time, August 23, 1976.
38.
WilliamsG. A.Insurance Arrangements under Workmen's Compensation. U.S. Department of Labor Bulletin No. 317, 1969.
39.
RoseJ. C., Deputy Attorney General, Anti-trust Division, U.S. Department of Justice. “Should Competition Be National Policy?” (address to the Institute on Regulation of the Insurance Industry, American Bar Association, New Orleans). Text in The National Underwriter, Property and Division, June 18, 1976.
40.
Annual Report. National Council on Compensation Insurance, March 4, 1976.
41.
Telephone conversation with Miles R. Drobisch, Assistant Actuary, California Inspection Rating Bureau, September 16, 1976.
42.
LeslieW.Workmen's compensation insurance. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, pp. 98–104, May 1932.
43.
OrrenK.Corporate and Social Change: The Politics of the Life Insurance Industry. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Md., 1974.
44.
GinnoldR. E.A Follow-up Study of Permanent Disability under Wisconsin Workers' Compensation. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin-Madison, August 1976.
45.
Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970, Parts 1 and 2. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Washington, D.C., 1975.
46.
LansburghR. H. ForwardThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, p. viii, January 1926.
47.
Report of the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws, Washington, D.C., 1972.
48.
State Workers' Compensation Laws Compared with Essential Recommendations of the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws as of January 1, 1976. American Insurance Association, New York.
49.
KalisD. B.Workmen's comp: Will Uncle Sam deal himself in?Occupational Hazards, pp. 35–38, December 1975.
50.
PoyerB.Summary and Analysis of the Key Provisions of S.2018: National Workers' Compensation Act of 1975. Labor Occupational Health Program, Institute of Industrial Relations, University of California, Berkeley, 1975.
51.
AdamsS. W.JaffeA. J.Too little and too late. Supplemental Studies for the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws2: 13–66, 1973.
52.
Countrywide Workmen's Compensation Experience Including Certain Competitive State Funds. National Council on Compensation Insurance, New York, 1975.
53.
BerkowitzM.Workmen's compensation income benefits: Their adequacy and equity. Supplemental Studies for the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws, pp. 189–274, 1973.
54.
Conversation between Daniel M. Berman and representatives of Accountants for the Public Interest, San Francisco.
55.
KinderW. F., Director, McKinsey & Company, Los Angeles. A look at the leaders: Time for the turnaround?Best's Review, p. 18, July 1976.
56.
PriceD. N.Workers' compensation: Coverage, payments, and costs. Social Security Bulletin, pp. 38–42, January 1976.
57.
CheitE. F.Injury and Recovery in the Course of Injury. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1963.
58.
Personal informants.
59.
Litigation in Workers' Compensation—A Report to the Industry. California Workers' Compensation Institute, San Francisco, 1974.
60.
Evaluating Disability under the Wisconsin Workmen's Compensation Act. Employers' Mutual of Wausau, 1971. As cited in Ginnold, R. E., A Follow-up Study of Permanent Disability under Wisconsin Workers' Compensation. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin-Madison, August 1976.
61.
Letter to Daniel M. Berman, from Mary Quartiano, November 21, 1975.
62.
Interview with Robert A. Fowler by Daniel M. Berman, April 1975.
63.
MarcusB.Advocating the rights of the injured. In Occupational Disability and Public Policy, edited by CheitE. F.GordonM. S., pp. 77–90. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1963.
64.
DaltonM.The role of supervision. In Industrial Conflict, by KornhauserA., McGraw-Hill, New York, 1954.
65.
RussellL. B.Compromise and release settlements. Supplemental Studies for the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws3: 179–215, 1973.
66.
Report on the National Workers' Compensation Standards Act, with reactions from insurance carriers and corporate sources. Current Developments Section, Daily Labor Report, pp. 9–14. Bureau of National Affairs, December 28, 1973.
67.
Employers organize to fight federal standards for workers' compensation. Current Developments Section, Daily Labor Report, pp. 1–3. Bureau of National Affairs, February 2, 1974.
68.
AdamsR. R., Director of Unemployment and Workers' Compensation, General Motors, and Chairman of the Task Force on Workmen's Compensation of the National Association of Manufacturers. Speech to NAM conference on workmen's compensation legislation. Full text printed in Daily Labor Report, Bureau of National Affairs, February 20, 1974.
69.
BerkowitzM.Sources of information about workmen's compensation recipients. Supplemental Studies for the National Commission on State Workmen's Compensation Laws2: 109–162.
70.
WodkaS. H.Pesticides since silent spring. In The Environmental Handbook, edited by de BellG., pp. 76–79. Ballantine, New York, 1970.
71.
KahnE.Pesticide related illness in California farm workers. Journal of Occupational Medicine, pp. 693–696, October 1976.
72.
KerrL. E.Coal workers and pneumoconiosis. Archives of Environmental Health, April 1968. Reprinted in 1968 Senate hearings, pp. 797, 798.
73.
RandallW. S.SolomonS. D.Building 6, The Tragedy at Bridesburgh. Little, Brown and Company, Boston, 1977.
74.
BrodeurP.Expendable Americans. Viking Press, New York, 1974.
75.
Simple test may establish carcinogenicity. Chemical and Engineering News, pp. 19, 20, December 22, 1975.
76.
SwartzJ.The fight for legal protection. World Magazine, pp. 3, 6, July 31, 1976.
77.
BuderN.BillingsL.Legislation to control toxic substances. Sierra Club Bulletin, pp. 26–31, November/December 1975.
78.
President signs law to control toxic substances. San Francisco Chronicle, p. 7, October 13, 1976.
79.
KalmykowA., Assistant General Counsel, American Insurance Association. Testimony, 1970 Senate hearings, pp. 346–359.
80.
Telephone conversation between Andrew Kalmykow and Daniel M. Berman, August 12, 1976.
81.
HolmesL., Counsel, American Mutual Insurance Alliance. Testimony, 1970 Senate hearings, pp. 359–373.
82.
Safety Subjects. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Standards, Washington, D.C., Bulletin No. 67, revised 1956.
83.
Pure Premium Review Sheet, 1977. Proposed rates for 1977, from the California Compensation Rating Bureau, San Francisco, 1976.
84.
LemkeG. B., Vice-President, Safety and Health Services, Employers' Mutual of Wausau, Wausau, Wisconsin. Loss Cost Analysis and Control, speech delivered at the American Society of Safety Engineers Conference, Tampa, Florida, June 28, 1971 (mimeographed).
85.
KalmykowA.Letter to Robert A. Harris, Counsel, Subcommittee on Labor, U.S. Senate Committee on Labor and Public Welfare, July 11, 1968. Reprinted in 1968 Senate hearings, pp. 812–815.
86.
RostenK. S.Manager of Technical Programs, American Pulpwood Association. Testimony, 1972House Oversight hearings, p. 389.
87.
Interview with John F. Burton by Daniel M. Berman, School of Business, University of Chicago, Chicago, March 13, 1973.
88.
KalmykowA., Assistant General Counsel, American Insurance Association. Testimony on S. 2018, The National Workers' Compensation Act of 1975, February 2, 1976. Available from the American Insurance Association.
89.
Firemen's Fund American Companies 1975 Annual Report.
90.
EisenstatS.SchultzeC. L.LanceB.Memorandum to the President, May 27, 1977. Reprinted in UAW Washington Report, p. 2, July 18, 1977.
91.
Illinois workers' comp law—What next?CACOSH Health and Safety News, p. 2, July 1977.
92.
Cumulative Injury—The Problem Can Be Solved (Industrial Indemnity). Crum and Forster Insurance Company, San Francisco, 1977.
93.
TaylorG., staff economist, Standing Committee on Health and Safety, AFL-CIO, Washington, D.C. Telephone conversation with Daniel M. Berman, July 25, 1977.
94.
CACOSH Health and Safety News, May 1976.
95.
CACOSH Health and Safety News, July 1977.
96.
Brown lung unit members protest. Greenville News, Greenville, South Carolina, April 28, 1977.
97.
Federalizing workmen's comp. Business Week, p. 85, February 16, 1974.
98.
FisherM. J.Carter sees “operational” role for insurers under NHI plan. The National Underwriter (Property and Casualty Insurance Edition), p. 1, July 16, 1976.
99.
FaltenmeyerE.Ever increasing affluence is less of a sure thing. Fortune, p. 62, April 1975.
100.
SchultzeC. L., Chairman, Council of Economic Advisors. The public use of private interest. Harper's, pp. 43–62, May 29, 1977.
101.
FraserD. A., President, International Union, United Auto Workers. Letter to Secretary of Labor Ray Marshal, inUAW Washington Report, July 18, 1977.
