The thesis of this article is that in general where most other workers were quickly and easily proletarianized, physicians—through the use of a variety of tactics at the disposal of some elite groups—have, until now, been able to postpone or minimize this process in their own case. Now, as a result of the bureaucratization which is being forced on medical practice as a consequence of the logic of capitalist expansion, physicians are slowly being reduced to a proletarian function, and their formerly self-interested activities subordinated to the broader requirements of the capitalist control of highly profitable medical production.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
McKinlayJ. B.On the professional regulation of change. Professionalization and Social Change, edited by HalmosPaul, pp. 61–84, The Sociological Review Monograph No. 20, Keele, 1973.
2.
McKinlayJ. B.Clients and organizations. In Processing People: Cases in Organizational Behavior, edited by McKinlayJ. B., pp. 339–378, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, London, 1975.
3.
CoserR. L.Insulation from observability and types of social conformity. Am. Soc. Rev., 26: 28–39, 1961.
4.
MarxK. (1867) Capital, three volumes. International Publishers, New York, 1967.
5.
WeberM.The Theory of Social and Economic Organization, translated by HendersonA. M., Oxford University Press, New York, 1947.
6.
LarsonM. S.Notes on technocracy: Some problems of theory, ideology and power. Berkeley Journal of Sociology17: 1–34, 1972–73.
7.
DurkheimE.The Division of Labor in Society, translated by SimpsonGeorge. Free Press, Glencoe, IL1947.
8.
MarglinS. A.What Do Bosses Do? The Origins and Functions of Hierarchy in Capitalist Production. Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, unpublished manuscript, 1971.
9.
EdwardsR.Contested Terrain. Basic Books, New York, 1979.
10.
WoolhandlerS.HimmelsteinD.Terms of endowment. Health PAC15: 13–16, 1984.
11.
Polk's Medical and Surgical Register of the United States and Canada, 6th revised ed.R. L. Polk and Co., Detroit, 1900.
12.
American Medical Association. Physician Licensure and Distribution: 1982.
13.
StarrP.The Social Transformation of Medicine. Basic Books, New York, 1982.
14.
SloanF.SchwartzW.More doctors: What will they cost?J.A.M.A.249: 766–769, 1983.
15.
OppenheimerM.The proletarianization of the professional. In Professionalization and Social Change, edited by HalmosP., University of Keele, Staffordshire, 1973.
16.
GlenE.FeldbergR.Degraded and deskilled: The proletarianization of clerical work. Social Problems, 25: 52–64, 1977.
17.
WagnerD.The proletarianization of nursing in the United States, 1932–1942. International Journal of Health Services, 10: 271–290, 1980.
18.
DerberC.Professionals as Workers: Mental Labor in Advanced Capitalism. R. K. Hall, Boston, 1982.
19.
PaxtonH.Group practice jobs: Suddenly it's a buyer's market. Medical Economics56, November 26, 1979.
20.
RobackG. A.Distribution of Physicians in the U.S., 1973. Center for Health Services Research and Development, American Medical Association, Chicago, 1974.
21.
TheodoreC. N.Reclassification of Physicians, 1968. Center for Health Services and Research and Development, American Medical Association, Chicago, 1971.
22.
RobackG. A.Distribution of Physicians in the U.S., 1973. Center for Health Services Research and Development, American Medical Association, Chicago, 1974.
23.
WarnerJ.AherneP.Profile of Medical Practice 1974. American Medical Association, Chicago, 1974.
24.
HarshamP.Inside the A.M.A. members retirement plan. Medical Economics, pp. 100–109, April 13, 1970.
25.
MarshallT. H.The recent history of professionalism in relation to social structure and social policy. Canadian Journal of Economics and Political ScienceV: 325–340, August 1939.
26.
O'ConnorJ.The Fiscal Crisis of the State. St. Martin's Press, New York, 1973.
27.
Doctors are joining services to avoid malpractice insurance costs, New York Times, March 22, 1975.
28.
ThorneB.Professional education in medicine. Education for the Professional Education of Medicine, Law, Theology, and Social Welfare, pp. 17–99. McGraw Hill, New York, 1973.
29.
MertonR. K.The Student Physician. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1957.
30.
KelmanS.Toward the political economy of medical care. Inquiry8(3): 30–38, 1971.
31.
EisenbergB. S.AherneP.Socioeconomic Issues of Health. American Medical Association, Chicago, 1974.
32.
U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. The Supply of Health Manpower—1970 Profiles and Projections to 1990. DHEW Publication No. (HRA) 75–38: 38–55, 1974.
33.
GaldstonI.The Birth and Death of Specialties. J.A.M.A.167:2056–2061, August 23, 1959.
34.
GaldstonI.The national history of specialism in medicine. J.A.M.A.170: 294–298, 1959.
35.
Why physicians leave—or fail to leave—private practice. Medical World News65: January 25, 1974.
36.
StreitchS.Internal revenue service policy on medical practice groups. Public Health Reports85(5):451–457, May 1970.
37.
ToddC.McNamaraM. E.Medical Groups in the U.S., 1969. Center for Health Services Research and Development, American Medical Association, Chicago, 1971.
38.
LewisR. C.What future for incorporated physicians?Medical Economics50: 178–185, November 26, 1973.
39.
ZalutskyM. H.An analysis of the post ERISA advantages of incorporation for the professional. The Journal of Taxation42: 240–247, April 1975.
40.
U.S. Internal Revenue Service. Statistics of Income, 1970—Business Income Tax Returns. Internal Revenue Service, Publication 438. October, 1973.
41.
ParkinF.Class Inequality and Political Order. Praeger Publishers, New York, 1971.
42.
More physicians joining group, rural practices. Family Practice News12(17), 1982.
43.
BaranP.SweezyP.Monopoly Capital. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1966.
44.
SmithA.The Wealth of Nations. London, 1970.
45.
MarxK. (1875). Critique of the Gotha Program. Marx and Engels, Basic Writing on Politics and Philosophy, edited by FeuerL. S., Doubleday, Garden City, NY, 1959.
46.
MandelE.Marxist Economic Theory, Vol. I.Monthly Review Press, New York, 1968.
47.
BravermanH.Labor and Monopoly Capital. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1974.
48.
BucherR.StraussA.Professions in process. Am. J. of Sociol. 65: 325–334, January 1961.
49.
WilenskyH.The professionalization of everyone. Am. J. Sociol.70: 137–158, September 1964.
50.
FreidsonE.Profession of Medicine. Dodd Mead and Company, New York, 1970a.
51.
FriedsonE.Professional Dominance. Atherton Press, New York, 1970b.
52.
MaxmenJ. S.GoodbyeWelbyDr.. Social Policy3, 4, and 5: 97–106, 1972 and 1973.
53.
SchwartzW. B.Medicine and the computer: The promise and problems of change. New Eng. J. of Med. 283: 1257–1264, December 3, 1970.
54.
AntleyP. M.AntleyM. A.Automation: Its impact on the delivery of health care. Computers and Automation22: 11–14, April 1973.
55.
HaugM. R.The deprofessionalization of everyone?Sociological Focus8(3): 197–213, August 1975a.
56.
HaugM. R.Deprofessionalization: An alternative hypothesis for the future. In Professionalization and Social Change, edited by HalmosPaul. pp. 195–211. The Sociological Review Monograph, No. 20. Keele, 1973.
57.
HaugM.Computer technology and obsolescence of the concept of profession. In Work and Technology, edited by HaugM.DofnyJ., pp. 195–214. Sage Press, Beverly Hills, 1977.
58.
LarsonM. S.Proletarianization and educated labor. Theory and Society9: 131–175, 1980.
59.
RothmanR.Deprofessionalization: The case of law in America. Work and Occupation11: 183–206, 1984.
60.
BerstrandC.Big profits in private hospitals. Social Policy, Fall: 49–54, 1982.
61.
FriedsonE.Professionals and the occupational principle. In The Professions and Their Prospects, edited by FriedsonE., Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, 1973b.
62.
BerlantJ.Profession and Monopoly. University of California Press, Los Angeles, 1974.
63.
PerrowC.Complex Organizations: A Critical Essay. Scott, Foresman and Company, Glencoe, IL, 1972.
64.
FieldingA. G.PortwoodD.Professions and the state-towards a typology of bureaucratic professions. Sociological Review28: 23–53, 1980.
65.
FalkW.GrimesM.LordG.IIIProfessionalism and conflict in a bureaucratic setting: The case of a teacher's strike. Social Problems29: 551–560, 1982.
66.
BucherR.StellingJ.Characteristics of professional organizations. J. Heal. Soc. Beh.10(1): 3–15, March 1969.
67.
RothJ. A.Professional: The sociologist's decoy. Sociology of Work and Occupations1: 6–23, February, 1974.
68.
KornhauserW.Scientists in Industry. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1963.
69.
BoxS.CotgroveS.Scientific identity, occupational selection and role strain. British Journal of Sociology17(1): 20–28, 1966.
70.
WagnerD.CohenM.Social service workers, class and professionalism. Catalyst1: 25–55, 1978.
71.
KaplanN.Professional scientists in industry: An essay review. Social Problems13(1): 88–97, Summer, 1965.
72.
GodnerF.RittiR. R.Professionalization as career immobility. Am. J. Sociol.72: 489–502, March 1967.
73.
HallR. H.Professionalization and bureaucratization. Am. Soc. Rev.33(1): 92–104, February 1968.
74.
FreidsonE.Review essay: Health factories, the new industrial sociology. Social Problems14(4): 493–500, Spring 1967.
75.
FuchsV.Who Shall Live?Basic Books, New York, 1974.
76.
FriedsonE.Prepaid group practice and the new demanding patient. Milbank Mem. Fund Q. (Health and Society). Fall: 473–488, 1973a.
77.
FriedsonE.Doctoring Together. Elsevier, New York, 1975.
78.
SommersH. M.SomersA. R.Doctors, Patients and Health Insurance. The Brookings Institute, Washington, DC, 1961.
79.
BadgleyR. F.WolfeS., Doctors Strike. Atherton Press, New York, 1967.
80.
Statistical Abstracts of the United States: 1984. Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C.
81.
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Directory of National Unions and Employee Associations, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1972.
82.
ChamotD.Scientists and unions: The new reality. American Federationist81: 8–12, September, 1974.
83.
LipsetS. M.Faculty unions and collegiality. Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning7(2): 39–41, March 1975.
84.
HopkinsG. E.The Airline Pilots. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1971.
85.
NeumannK.Doctors tagged with union labels?American Druggist Merchandizing169: 10 and 53, June 1, 1974.
86.
TuckJ. N.The question for the A.M.A.: When is a strike not a strike?Modern Health Care4(2): 16m–16o, August 1975.
87.
BognannoM. F.DworkinJ. B.FashoyinO.Physicians' and dentists' bargaining organizations: A preliminary look. Monthly Labor Review, pp. 33–35, June 1975.
88.
Physicians move to form union. New York Times. October 12, 1975.
89.
Doctors hit the streets with a new strike law. Business Week. March 31, pp. 19–20, 1975.
90.
WolfeS.Addendum. Int. J. Heal. Serv.5(1): 41, 1975.
91.
OppenheimerM.The unionization of the professional. Social Policy5(5): 34f, January/February, 1975.
92.
MarcusS. A.The purposes of unionization in the medical profession: The unionized profession's perspective in the United States. Int. J. Heal. Serv.5(1): 37–42, 1975.
93.
ParsonsT.The professions and social structure. Essays in Sociological Theory, Free Press, Glencoe, 34–49, 1954.
94.
MartinsonR.The age of treatment: Some implications of the custody-treatment dimension. Issues in Criminology2: 275–293, Fall, 1966.
95.
KunitzS. J.Professionalism and social control in the progressive era: The case of the Flexner Report. Social Problems22(1): 16–27, October 1974.
96.
SeeleyJ. R.Social values, the mental health movement and mental health. Mental Health and Mental Disorders: A Sociological Approach, pp. 599–612, Norton Pub., N.Y., 1955.
97.
DavisK.Mental hygiene and the class structure. Psychiatry1: 55–65, 1938.
98.
WilenskyH.LebeauxC. N.Industrial Society and Social Welfare. Free Press, New York, 1965.
99.
ZolaI. K.Medicine as an institution of social control. The Sociological Review20(4): 487–504, November 1972.
100.
ZolaI. K.In the name of health and illness: On some socio-political consequences of medical influence. Social Science and Medicine9(2): 83–87, February 1975.
101.
EhrenreichB.EhrenreichJ.Health care and social control. Social Policy4(6): 26–40, May/June 1975.
102.
IllichI.Medical Nemesis. Calder and Boyars, London, 1975.
103.
NavarroV.The industrialization of fetishism or the fetishism of industrialization: A critique of Ivan Illich. Int. J. Heal. Serv.5(3): 351–371, 1975b.
104.
Webster's New Twentieth Century Dictionary. The World Publishing Company, New York, 1953.
105.
McKinlayJ. B.The business of good doctoring or doctoring as good business: Reflections on Friedson's view of the medical game. Int. J. Heal. Serv.8(3): 459–488, 1977.
106.
BidwellC. E.Students and schools: Some observations on client trust in client-serving organizations. In Organizations and Clients, edited by RosengrenW. R.LeftonM., pp. 37–69, C. E. Merrill, Columbus, Ohio, 1970.
107.
HaugM. R.The erosion of professional autonomy and the revolt of the client. Social Problems17: 153–161, Fall 1969.
108.
Boston Women's Health Book Collective. Our Bodies, Ourselves. Simon and Schuster, New York, 1973.
109.
AnnasG. J.The Rights of Hospital Patients: The Basic ACLU Guide to a Hospital Patient's Rights. Avon Books, New York, 1975.
110.
Consumer Reports. The Medicine Show. Consumers Union, Mt. Vernon, NY, 1974.
111.
A.M.A. hires a firm to fight FTC suit. New York Times. January 6, 1976.
112.
Drug ads dropped over Times series. New York Times, Feburary 10, 1976.
113.
LazonickW.Karl Marx and enclosures in england. Review of Radical Political Economics6(2): 1–59, Summer 1974.
