The allocation of health care resources has always been and will remain a contentious issue. Classically, the arguments have been posed in terms of the “need” for health care and/or the “right” to treatment. More recently, there have been attempts to shape the debate in consequentialist terms, by introducing a composite outcome measure. In the United Kingdom, the QALY (Quality Adjusted Life Year) has been promoted enthusiastically. But, like many other such proposals, it is a dodo, and one that is potentially politically dangerous.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeveridgeW.National Health Service. Cmnd. 6502. Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1944.
2.
AiachP.Les débats scientifique et politique sur les inégalités de santé en France. In Les Inégalités Sociales de Santé en France et en Grande Bretagne, edited by AiachP., pp. 143–158. INSERM, La Documentation Francçaise, Paris, 1987.
3.
Department of Health and Social Security. Sharing Resources for Health in England. Report of the Resources Allocation Working Party. DHSS, London, 1976.
4.
MaysN.BevanG.Resource Allocation and the Health Services. Occasional Papers in Social Administration, No. 81. Bedford Square Press, London, 1987.
5.
Department of Health. Working for Patients. Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1989.
WeinsteinM. C.StasonW. B.Foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis for health and medical practices. N. Engl. J. Med.303: 717–721, 1977.
8.
DrummondM. F.Resource Allocation Decisions in Health Care. Discussion Paper 21. Health Services Management Centre, University of Birmingham, 1986.
9.
HollandsworthJ. G.Evaluating the impact of medical treatment on the quality of life: A 5-year update. Soc. Sci. Med.26: 425–434, 1988.
10.
AndrewsF.WitheyS. B.Social Indicators of Well Being. Plenum Press, New York, 1976.
11.
SenA. K.Choice, Welfare and Measurement. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1982.
12.
SenA.Poverty and Famines: An Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1981.
13.
CulyerA. J.Measuring Health: Lessons form Ontario. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1978.
14.
Carr-HillR. A.Indicators of Health and of Inequalities in Health. Report presented to the Social Affairs Committee of the Social Sciences Research Council. London, November 1983.
15.
StourmanK.FalkI. S.Healthy indices: A study of objective indices of health in relation to environment and sanitation. League of Nations Quarterly Bulletin of the Health Organization. Geneva, 1936.
16.
CartwrightA.Health Surveys in Practice and Potential. Oxford University Press for Kings Fund, London, 1983.
17.
GudexC.KindP.The QALY Toolkit. Discussion Paper 38. Centre for Health Economics, University of York, 1988.
GudexC.QALYs and Their Use by the Health Service. Discussion Paper 20. Centre for Health Economics, University of York, 1986.
20.
Carr-HillR. A.Assumptions of the QALY procedure. Soc. Sci. Med.28: 469–477, 1989.
21.
Carr-HillR. A.Pressures for spending. In Health Care U.K. 1988, Policy Journals. London, 1988.
22.
WestP. A.What is Wrong with QALYs. Paper presented to the Health Economists Study Group, December 1985.
23.
LoomesG.McKenzieL.The use of QALYs in health care decision making. Soc. Sci. Med.28: 299–308, 1989.
24.
FestingerL.A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stamford University Press, Stamford, Calif., 1957.
25.
AvoornJ.Benefit and cost analysis in geriatric care: Turning age discrimination into health policy. N. Engl. J. Med.310: 1294–1301, 1984.
26.
MulkayM.AshmoreM.PinchJ.Measuring the quality of life: A sociological intervention concerning the application of economics to health care. Sociol. Health Illness21: 541–564, 1988.
27.
Carr-HillR. A.Social indicators for basic needs: Who benefits from which numbers. In Models, Planning and Basic Needs edited by ColeS.LucasH., Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1982.
28.
EnglertR. M.MeanM. H.ScribnerJ. D.Politics of programme evaluation in large city school districts. Educ. Urban Districts9: 429–449, 1977.
29.
PollitC.Case study: Inequalities in health care. In Open University Social Science: Third Level Courses, Social Policy and Social Welfare. Open University Publishing, Milton Keynes, 1984.
30.
WilliamsA.Measuring quality of life: A comment. Soc. Health Illness21: 565–566, 1987.
31.
SmithA.Qualms about QALYs. Lancet1: 1134–1136, 1987.
32.
WeberM.The Theory of Economic and Social Organisation. Routledge, London, 1964.
33.
PopperK.The Open Society and Its Enemies. Routledge, London, 1956.
34.
BellD.The End of Ideology. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1953.
DonaldsonC.Should QALYs be programme specific?J. Health Econ. 7: 239–257, 1988.
37.
SeersD.The political economy of national accounting. In Employment, Income Distribution and Development Strategy, edited by CameronA.PuriM., Macmillan, London, 1975.
