Our hypothesis was that patient-doctor relationship experienced positively by the patient is associated with adequate compliance behavior and thus to the long-term metabolic control of diabetes.
Method:
Cross-sectional study of 100 consecutive adult patients with Type 1 diabetes treated in a diabetes out-patient department. From a questionnaire, four scores (direct estimate of physician, satisfaction with the place of treatment, self-esteem score, security with the patient-doctor relationship) determining the patient-doctor relationship were formed. In score 3 (self-esteem score) the impact of the patient-doctor relationship to the patients' self-esteem was indirectly estimated. The anonymous data taken from diabetes register including information about treatment of diabetes, metabolic control and end-organ complications were returned together with the questionnaire. On the basis of GHbA1c diabetic patients were divided into two groups: with adequate metabolic control (GHbA1c ⩽ 8.0%) or with poor/moderate control (GHbA1c > 8.0%).
Results:
In univariate analyses the score 3 associated with metabolic control (p < 0.001). In logistic regression analyses the nephropathy (t = 2.80, p < 0.05) and score 3 (t = 3.98, p < 0.001) were associated with metabolic control.
Conclusion:
Patient's positively-experienced patient-doctor relationship was associated with good metabolic control of diabetes.
HinkleL. E.ChristensonW.KaneF.An Investigation of the Relationship Between Life Experience, Personality Characteristics, and General Susceptibility to Illness, Psychosomatic Medicine, 2: 278–295, 1958.
2.
DorowskiT. S.Emotional Stress as a Cause of Diabetes Mellitus, Diabetes, 12: 183–184, 1963.
3.
SlawsonP. F.FlynnW. R., and KollorE. J.Psychological Factors Associated with the Onset of Diabetes Mellitus, Journal of the American Medical Association, 185: 166–170, 1963.
4.
KischE. S.Stressful Events and the Onset of Noninsulin Dependent Diabetes, Israel Journal of Medicine Science, 22: 466–467, 1986.
5.
RobinsonN. and FullerJ. H.Role of Life Events and Difficulties in the Onset of Diabetes Mellitus, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 29: 583–591, 1985.
6.
WilkinsonG.The Influence of Psychiatric, Psychological and Social Factors on the Control of Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus, Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 31: 277–286, 1987.
7.
SchwartzL. S.CoulsonL. R.ToovyD.LyonsJ. S., and FlahertyJ. A.A Biopsychosocial Treatment Approach to the Management of Diabetes Mellitus, General Hospital Psychiatry, 13: 19–26, 1991.
8.
BarglowP.HatcherR.EdivinD. V., and Sloan-RossiterD.Stress and Metabolic Control in Diabetes: Psychosomatic Evidence and Evaluation of Methods, Psychosomatic Medicine, 46: 127–144, 1984.
9.
TähkäV., The Patient-Doctor Relationship, Adis Health Press, Sydney, 1984.
10.
TähkäV.ViinamäkiH., and KoskelaK.Interaction in Health Education, International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 36: 99–110, 1990.
11.
LipsittL. P.A Self-Concept Scale for Children and Its Relation to the Children's Form of the Manifest Anxiety, Child Development, 29: 463–472, 1958.
12.
SimondsJ.GoldsteinD.WalkerB., and RawlingsS.The Relationship Between Psychological Factors and Blood Glucose Regulation in Insulin-Dependent Diabetic Adolescents, Diabetes Care, 4: 610–615, 1981.
13.
OrrD. P.GoldenM. P.MyersG., and MarreroD. G.Characteristics of Adolescents with Poorly Controlled Diabetes Referred to a Tertiary Care Center, Diabetes Care, 6: 170–175, 1983.
14.
CloseH.DaviesA. G.PriceD. A., and GoodyearI. M.Emotional Difficulties in Diabetes Mellitus, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 61: 337–340, 1986.
15.
FinestoneD. H. and WeinweR. D.Effects of ECT on Diabetes Mellitus, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 70: 321–326, 1984.
16.
FakhriO.FadhliA. A., and el RaiviR. M.Effect of Electroconvulsive Therapy on Diabetes Mellitus, Lancet, 2: 775–777, 1980.
17.
YudofsyS. C. and RosenthalN. E.ECT in a Depressed Patient with Adult Onset Diabetes Mellitus, American Journal of Psychiatry, 137: 100–101, 1980.
18.
MazzeR. S. and LucidoD.Psychological and Social Correlates of Glycemic Control, Diabetes Care, 7: 360–366, 1984.
19.
LustmanP. J.GriffthL. S.ClouseR. E., and CryerP. E.Psychiatric Illness in Diabetes: Relationship to Symptoms and Glucose Control, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 174: 736–742, 1986.
20.
DupuisA.JonesR. L., and PetersonC. M.Psychological Effects of Blood Glucose Self-Monitoring in Diabetic Patients, Psychosomatics, 21: 581–591, 1980.
21.
WinokurA.MaislinG.PhillipsJ. L., and AmsterdamJ. D.Insulin Resistance After Oral Glucose Tolerance Testing in Patients with Major Depression, American Journal of Psychiatry, 145: 325–330, 1988.
22.
McCowanP. K. and QuastelJ. H.Blood Sugar Studies in Abnormal Mental States, Journal of Mental Science, 77: 525–548, 1931.
23.
PryceI. G.The Relationship Between Glucose Tolerance, Body Weight, and Clinical State, Journal of Mental Science, 104: 1079–1092, 1958.
24.
van PraagH. M. and LeijnseB., Depression, Glucose Tolerance, Peripheral Glucose Uptake and Their Alterations Under the Influence of Anti-Depressive Drugs of the Hydrazine Type, Psychopharmacologia (Berlin), 8: 67–78, 1965.
25.
MuellerP. S.HeningerG. R., and McDonaldR. K.Intravenous Glucose Tolerance Test in Depression, Archives of General Psychiatry, 21: 470–477, 1969.
26.
WilkinsonD. G.Psychiatric Aspects of Diabetes Mellitus, British Journal of Psychiatry, 138: 1–9, 1981.
27.
MuellerP. S.HeningerG. R., and McDonaldR. K., Studies on Glucose Utilization and Insulin Sensitivity in Affective Disorders, in Proceedings of the NIMH Workshop on Recent Advances in the Psychobiology of the Depressive Illnesses, WilliamsT. A. (ed.), National Institute of Mental Health, Washington, D.C., pp. 235–248, 1969.
28.
MuellerP. S.HeningerG. R., and McDonaldR. K.Insulin Tolerance Test in Depression, Archives of General Psychiatry, 22: 587–594, 1969.
29.
SacharE. J.FrantzA. G.AltmanA.Growth Hormone and Prolactin in Unipolar and Bipolar Depressed Patients: Responses to Hypoglycemia and L-dopa, American Journal of Psychiatry, 130: 1362–1367, 1973.
30.
GruenP. H.SacharE. J.AltmanN.Growth Hormone Responses to Hypoglycemia in Postmenopausal Depressed Women, Archives of General Psychiatry, 32: 31–33, 1975.
31.
GregoireF.BraumanH.de BuckR.Hormone Release in Depressed Patients Before and After Recovery, Psychoneuroendocrinology, 2: 303–312, 1977.
32.
BrambillaF.SmeraldiE.SacchettiE.Deranged Anterior Pituitary Responsiveness to Hypothalamic Hormones in Depressed Patients, Archives of General Psychiatry, 35: 1231–1238, 1978.
33.
WrightJ. H.GocisinJ. J.RodinN. S.Glucose Metabolism in Unipolar Depression, British Journal of Psychiatry, 132: 386–393, 1978.
34.
LewisD. A.KatholR. G.ShermanB. M.Differentiation of Depressive Subtypes by Insulin Insensitivity in the Recovered Phase, Archives of General Psychiatry, 40: 167–170, 1983.
35.
FreemanH.Resistance to Insulin in Mentally Disturbed Soldiers, Archives of Neurology and Psychiatry, 56: 74–78, 1946.
36.
KoslowS. H.StokesP. E.MendelsJ.Insulin Tolerance Test: Human Growth Hormone, Response and Insulin Resistance in Primary Unipolar Depressed, Bipolar Depressed, and Control Subjects, Psychological Medicine, 12: 45–55, 1982.
37.
RaskinP.PietriA. O.UngerR., and ShannonW. A.Jr.The Effect of Diabetic Control on the Width of Skeletal-Muscle Capillary Basement Membrane in Patients with Type I Diabetes Mellitus, New England Journal of Medicine, 309: 1546–1556, 1983.
38.
KleinR.KleinB. E. K.MossS. E.DavisM. D., and DeMetsD. L.Glycosylated Hemoglobin Predicts the Incidence and Progression of Diabetic Retinopathy, Journal of the American Medical Association, 260: 2864–2871, 1988.
39.
MakitaZ.RadoffS.RayfieldE. J.Advanced Glycosylation End Products in Patients with Diabetic Nephropathy, New England Journal of Medicine, 325: 836–842, 1991.
40.
BerglundP. R. B.BritzA.CarsI.NilssenB. Y., and RosenqvistV.Intensified Conventional Insulin Treatment retards the Microvascular Complications of Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus (IDDM): Stockholm Diabetes Intervention Study (SDIS) at the 5 Years, Journal of Internal Medicine, 230: 101–108, 1991.
41.
American College of PhysiciansGlycosylated Hemoglobin Assays in the Management and Diagnosis of Diabetes Mellitus, Annals of Internal Medicine, 8: 516–517, 1985.
42.
ViinamäkiH.TähkäV.KoskelaK., and PuskaP.Psychodynamic Approach and Health Education, Nordic Journal of Psychiatry, 44: 17–23, 1990.
43.
GillespieC. R. and BradleyC.Causal Attributions of Doctor and Patients in a Diabetes Clinic, British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 27: 67–76, 1988.
44.
ViinamäkiH. and NiskanenL.Psychotherapy in Patients with Poorly Controlled Type 1 (Insulin-Dependent) Diabetes, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 56: 24–29, 1991.
