A Simulation Approach to the Measurement of Change in Ceramic Frequency Seriation

Abstract

This paper examines the problems encountered by users of ceramic frequency seriation in distinguishing chronologically meaningful trends from the background stochastic “noise” inherent in all ceramic assemblages. Aspects of manufacture, breakage and discard behavior are found to be important in the creation of “noise” in the archaeological record. A computerized model (POTS), which simulates both chronological changes and background “noise” in the ceramic assemblages of hypothetical villages, is used to evaluate the effects of sample size on the chronological accuracy of seriated sherd deposits. It is concluded that in order to maximize the utility of frequency seriation as a chronological ordering device, users should be concerned with the statistical adequacy of their sherd samples and that additional experimentation is needed with artificial data sets generated under ethnographically controlled conditions.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brainerd

George W.

1951 The Place of Chronological Ordering in Archaeological Analysis, American Antiquity, 16, pp. 303–313.

Cowgill

George L.

1972 Models, Methods, and Techniques for Seriation, in Models in Archaeology, Clarke

D. L.

(ed.). Methuen, London, pp. 381–424.

Craytor

William B.

and Johnson

Leroy

Jr. 1968 Refinements in Computerized Item Seriation, University of Oregon, Museum of Natural History, Bulletin No. 10.

David

Nicholas

1972 On the Life Span of Pottery, Type Frequencies, and Archaeological Inference, American Antiquity, 37, pp. 141–142.

David

Nicholas

and Hennig

Hilke

1972 The Ethnography of Pottery: A Fulani Case Seen in Archaeological Perspective, Addison-Wesley Modular Publications, McCaleb Module 21.

De Barros

Philip L. F.

1983 The Effects of Variable Site Occupation Span on the Results of Frequency Seriation, American Antiquity, 47, pp. 291–315.

Deboer

Warren R.

1974 Ceramic Longevity and Archaeological Interpretation: An Example from the Upper Ucayali, Peru, American Antiquity, 39, pp. 335–343.

Deboer

Warren R.

and Lathrap

Donald W.

1979 The Making and Breaking of Shipibo-Conido Ceramics, in Ethnoarchaeology: Implications of Ethnography for Archaeology, Kramer

(ed.). Columbia University, New York, pp. 102–138.

Dunnell

Robert C.

1970 Seriation Method and Its Evaluation, American Antiquity, 35, pp. 305–319.

10.

Dyke

Bennett

and MacCluer

Jean W.

1973 Computer Simulation in Human Population Studies. Academic Press, New York.

11.

Ford

James A.

1962 A Quantitative Method for Deriving Cultural Chronology, Technical Manual 1, Pan American Union General Secretariat, Organization of American States, Washington, D.C.

12.

Foster

George M.

1960 Life-Expectancy of Utilitarian Pottery in Tzintzuntzan, Michoacán, Mexico, American Antiquity, 25, pp. 606–609.

13.

Hatch

James W.

1976 “Change” versus “Noise” in Ceramic Frequency Seriation, paper presented at the Forty-First Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, St. Louis.

14.

Hatch

James W.

1977 Measuring the Effects of Sampling Error in Ceramic Frequency Seriation, paper presented at the Forty-Second Annual Meeting of the Society for American Archaeology, New Orleans.

15.

Johnson

Leroy

Jr.

1972 Introduction to Imaginary Models for Archaeological Scaling and Clustering, in Models in Archaeology, Clarke

D. L.

(ed.). Methuen, London, pp. 309–379.

16.

Longacre

William A.

1974 Kalinga Pottery Making: The Evolution of a Research Design, in Frontiers in Anthropology, Leaf

(ed.). Van Nostrand, New York.

17.

Marquardt

William H.

1978 Advances in Archaeological Seriation, in Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, Volume 1, Schiffer

M. B.

(ed.). Academic Press, New York, pp. 257–314.

18.

Michels

Joseph W.

1973 Dating Methods in Archaeology. Seminar Press, New York.

19.

Robinson

W.S.

1951 A Method for Chronologically Ordering Archaeological Deposits, American Antiquity, 16, pp. 239–301.

20.

Rouse

Irving B.

1967 Seriation in Archaeology, in American Historical Anthropology: Essays in Honor of Leslie Spier, Riley

C. L.

and Taylor

W. W.

(eds.). Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale, pp. 153–195.

21.

Rowe

John H.

1961 Stratigraphy and Seriation, American Antiquity, 26, pp. 324–330.

22.

Schiffer

Michael B.

1972 Archaeological Context and Systemic Context, American Antiquity, 37, pp. 156–165.

23.

Snedecor

George W.

and Cochran

William G.

1967 Statistical Methods. Iowa State University Press, Ames.

24.

Tsokos

Chris P.

1972 Probability Distributions: An Introduction to Probability Theory with Applications. Duxbury Press, Belmont.