This article provides an assessment of the health policy of the Canadian Conservative government under Brian Mulroney, 1984–1993. Underlying this assessment is the need to test the theory of the irreversibility of the welfare state in the light of its health component. The author argues that despite a political rhetoric that might have presaged a sharp rollback of Canada's Medicare, either through residualization or progressive com-modification, Canada emerged from this period of New Right federal government with its state-funded health care system still in place. This argument is substantiated through a consideration of the social policy model inherited by the Mulroney government and how it was affected by the government's fiscal policies between 1984 and 1993.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DwyerV.In search of unity. Maclean's, July 1, 1994, pp. 16–19.
2.
GreggA.A nation transformed. Maclean's, January 2, 1995, pp. 20–22.
ThollW. G.Health care spending in Canada: Skating faster on thinner ice. In Limits to Care: Reforming Canada's Health System in an Age of Restraint, edited by BlomqvistA.BrownD. L., pp. 53–90. C. D. Howe Institute, Toronto, 1994.
5.
EvansR. G.Canada: The real issues. J. Health Polit. Policy Law17: 739–762, 1992.
6.
EvansR. G.Health care reform: “The issue from hell.”Policy Options, July-August 1993, pp. 34–35.
7.
MhatreS. L.DeberR. B.From equal access to health care to equitable access to health: A review of Canadian provincial health commissions and reports. Int. J. Health Serv. 22: 645–668, 1992.
8.
The Nova Scotia Royal Commission on Health Care. The Report of the Nova Scotia Commission on Health Care: Towards a New Strategy. Halifax, 1989.
9.
Québec. A Reform Centred on the Citizen. Ministère de la Santé et des Services Sociaux, Québec, 1990.
10.
MillerA.Labour and the Keynesian state and the changing international political economy. In Political Economy and the Changing Global Order, edited by StubbsR.UnderhillG. R. D., pp. 60–74. Macmillan, London, 1994.
11.
Esping-AndersonG.The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Polity Press, London, 1994.
12.
MishraR.The Welfare State in Capitalist Society. Harvester-Wheatsheaf, London, 1990.
13.
ChandlerM. A.ChandlerW. M.Public Policy and Provincial Politics. McGraw-Hill, Montreal, 1979.
14.
TaylorM. G.Health Insurance and Canadian Policy: The Seven Decisions that Created the Canadian Health Insurance System and their Outcomes. Institute of Public Administration of Canada, Montreal, 1987.
15.
RoemerM. I.National Health Systems of the World, Vol. 1: The Countries. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1991.
16.
StevensonG.The division of powers. In Perspectives on Canadian Federalism, edited by OilingR. D.WestmacottM. W., Prentice-Hall, Toronto, 1988.
17.
Duclaud-WilliamsR.Health Politics and the Welfare State: Situating Health Politics and Provision within a Map of the Welfare State. Paper presented at the European Consortium for Political Research Joint Sessions, Madrid, April 1994.
18.
CrichtonA.Canada's Health System. Canadian Hospital Association Press, Ottawa, 1990.
19.
Canada. Federal Transfers to the Provinces. Department of Finance Canada, Ottawa, 1994.
20.
Canada. National Health Expenditures 1975–1993. Health Canada, Ottawa, 1994.
21.
GourevitchP.Politics in Hard Times. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1986.
22.
JacksonR.Politics in Canada. Prentice-Hall, Toronto, 1986.
23.
BercusonD.Sacred Trust: Brian Mulroney and the Conservative Party in Power. Doubleday, Toronto, 1986.
24.
BéginM.Medicare: Canada's Right to Health. Optimum, Montreal1984.
25.
PrinceM. J.Startling facts, sobering truths and sacred trust: Pension policy and the Tories. In How Ottawa Spends 1985: Sharing the Pie, edited by MasloveA. M., pp. 114–161. Methuen, Toronto, 1986.
26.
RiceJ. J.Restitching the safety net: Altering the national social security system. In How Ottawa Spends 1987–88: Restraining the State, edited by PrinceM. J., pp. 211–238. Methuen, Toronto, 1989.
27.
BootheP.JohnsonB.Stealing the Emperor's clothes: Deficit offloading and national standards in health. Commentary41: 1–12, 1993.
28.
ButlerM.The current predicament in fiscal federalism. Policy Options, December 1993, pp. 22–26.
29.
Canada. A New Direction for Canada: An Agenda for Economic Renewal. Department of Finance Canada, Ottawa, 1984.
30.
BantingK.The Canadian welfare state: Crisis and continuity. In Policy Choices, edited by BantingK., pp. 29–45. School of Public Policy, Queen's University, Kingston, Ont., 1991.
31.
WilsonM.Economic and Fiscal Statement. Department of Finance Canada, Ottawa, 1984.
32.
ThomsonA.Federal Support for Health Care: A Background Paper. Health Action Lobby, Ottawa, 1991.
33.
Canada, House of Commons. Debates, February 26, 1986.
34.
FréchetteJ.-D.Federal Transfer Payments to the Provinces for Health and Post-Secondary Education: New Trends. Library of Parliament Research Branch, Ottawa, 1994.
35.
Canada, House of Commons. Debates, February 26, 1991.
36.
Canada, House of Commons. Debates, February 25, 1992.
37.
BouchardB.Healthy Canada: Notes for an Address. Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa, May 11, 1993.
38.
MaychakM.Tories to protect medicare, MP says. Toronto Star, September 7, 1984, p. A3.
39.
CornellierM.Ottawa n'étend pas se retirer de la santé, prévient Beatty. La Presse, December 13, 1990, p. B4.
40.
Senior Officiai, Department of Finance Canada. Personal communication, August 1994.
41.
CourcheneT.Redistributing Money and Power: A Guide to the Canada Health and Social Transfer. C. D. Howe Institute, Toronto, 1995.
