This longitudinal study examined the effect of an urban Area Health Education Center (AHEC) program on choice of primary care as a medical specialty by comparing three groups of medical students. The first group was not exposed to any AHEC clinical training. All other students were variously exposed: one group received AHEC training only in required ambulatory/primary care clerkships, whereas the other group voluntarily took one or more AHEC-sponsored clinical électives. Applying chi-square analysis and the Z-score test for correlated data, no meaningful program effect was found at the end of the fourth year of medical school or seven years after graduation. These results are discussed in the context of program implementation and contemporary medical education in the United States.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
MiikeL. H.RossR. J.Area health education centers: What are they and where are they going?J. Med. Educ.50: 242–251, 1975.
2.
ZwickD. I.A report on the national AHEC program. Public Health Rep. 92:108–120, 1977.
3.
GessertC. E.SmithD. R.The national AHEC program: Review of its progress and consideration for the 1980s. Public Health Rep. 96:116–120, 1981.
4.
RettieL. L.Affecting health personnel distribution through AHECs. J. Allied Health10: 114–119, 1981.
5.
Carnegie Commission on Higher Education. Higher Education and the Nation's Health: Policies for Medical and Dental Education. McGraw-Hill, Heightstown, 1970.
6.
EvashwickC.BaconT. J.MayerE. S.The effect of decentralized clinical education on the career choices of medical students. Health Professions Educ. Bull., Winter 1979, pp. 9–15.
7.
The Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare. An Assessment of the National Area Health Education Center Program. DHEW Pub. No. (HRA) 80–33. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Washington, D.C., 1980.
8.
GessertC.JonesC.Urban AHECs: A comparison with rural AHECs. Public Health Rep. 101: 637–643, 1986.
9.
CrowderJ. E.SchnepperJ. E.GessertC.A statewide approach to health care personnel maldistribution. West. J. Med.140: 798–802, 1984.
10.
94th Congress. Health Professions Educational Assistance Act of 1976 (Public Law 94-484). U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1976.
11.
LoetherH. J.McTavishD. G.Inferential Statistics for Sociologists, An Introduction, pp. 238–255. Allyn and Bacon, Boston, 1974.
12.
American Medical Association. American Medical Directory: Physicians in the United States, Ed. 31. Chicago, 1988.
13.
AikenL. H.The contribution of specialists to the delivery of primary care: A new perspective, tf. Engl. J. Med.300:1363–1370, 1979.
14.
Institute of Medicine. A Manpower Policy for Primary Health Care. IOM Pub. No. 78-02. National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D.C., 1978.
15.
FinklesteinR.Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the AHEC Primary/Ambulatory Care Clerkships: Student and Preceptor Perspectives. Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, 1984.
16.
BabbottD.The stability of early specialty preferences among U.S. medical school graduates in 1983. JAMA259:1970–1975, 1988.
17.
DialT. H.ElliottP. R.Relationships of scholarships and indebtedness to medical students' career plans. J. Med. Educ.62: 316–324, 1987.
18.
TudorC.Career plans and debt levels of graduating U.S. medical students, 1981–1986. J. Med. Educ.63: 271–275, 1988.
19.
TaggartM. P.WartmanS. A.WessenA. F.Influences on the choice of primary care: Today's gatekeepers to the medical care delivery system. Med. Care25: 671–674, 1987.
20.
DonovanJ. C.SalzmanL. F.AllenP. Z.Studies in medical education: Career choice consistency of medical students. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol.112: 519–523, 1972.
21.
LangwellK. M.Career paths of first-year resident physicians: A seven-year study. J. Med. Educ.55: 897–905, 1980.
22.
GlasserM.SarnowskiA. A.ShethB.Career choices from medical school to practice: Findings from a regional clinical education site. J. Med. Educ.57: 442–448, 1982.
23.
TardiffK.Selection and change of specialties by medical school graduates. J. Med. Educ.61: 790–796, 1986.
24.
SchroederS. A.Western European responses to physician oversupply: Lessons for the United States. JAMA252: 373–384, 1984.
25.
Project Panel of the General Professional Education of the Physician. Physicians for the twenty-first century. J. Med. Educ.59(11, Pt. 2): 1–208, 1984.
