This study documents and contrasts the development of knowledge about asbestos-related disease (ARD) in South Africa and the United Kingdom. It also contributes to the globalization debate by exploring corporate decision-making in a multinational industry. Between the 1930s and 1960s, the leading U.K. asbestos companies developed a sophisticated knowledge of ARD, though in South Africa, where the leading companies such as Turner & Newall and Cape Asbestos owned mines, there was little attempt to apply this knowledge. Asbestos mines (and their environments) in South Africa were uniquely dusty and ARD was rife. Social and political factors in South Africa, especially apartheid, allowed these companies to apply double standards, even after 1960 when the much more serious hazard of mesothelioma was identified. This shows the need for greater regulation of multinationals. Because of the lack of such regulation in the early 1960s, an opportunity was lost to prevent the current high morbidity and mortality of ARD both in South Africa and worldwide.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BrodeurP.Outrageous Misconduct. Pantheon Book, New York, 1985.
2.
CastlemanB. I.Asbestos: Medical and Legal Aspects, Ed. 4. Aspen Law and Business, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1996.
3.
FlynnL.Studded with Diamonds and Paved with Gold: Miners, Mining Companies and Human Rights in Southern Africa. Bloomsbury, London, 1992.
4.
McCullochJ.Asbestos Blues: Labour, Capital, Physicians and the State in South Africa. James Currey, Oxford, 2002.
5.
WikeleyN.Compensation for Industrial Disease. Dartmouth Publishing, Aldershot, U.K., 1993.
6.
TweedaleG.Magic Mineral to Killer Dust: Turner & Newall and the Asbestos Hazard. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2000.
7.
JohnstonR.McIvorA.Lethal Work: A History of the Asbestos Tragedy in Scotland. Tuckwell, Glasgow, 2000.
8.
HertzN.The Silent Takeover: Global Capitalism and the Death of Democracy. Free Press, New York, 2001.
9.
Cape Asbestos Company Ltd., Diamond Jubilee. Asbestos, July 1953, pp. 7–8.
10.
Deposition of Geoffrey Higham: In re: Asbestos personal injury cases, Arrington lead No. 93-9-114 Civil Action no. 93-9-1114: 167–8. London, October 24, 1996.
11.
Chief Inspector of Factories. Annual Report … for the Year 1898, Part 2, p. 171. HMSO, London, 1899.
12.
GreenbergM.Cape Asbestos, Barking, health and environment: 1928–1946. Am. J. Ind. Med.43: 109–119, 2003.
13.
MerewetherE. R. A.PriceC. W.Report on Effects of Asbestos Dust on the Lungs and Dust Suppression in the Asbestos Industry. HMSO, London, 1930.
14.
TweedaleG.Asbestos and its lethal legacy. Nature Rev. Cancer2: 311–315, 2002.
15.
WyersH.That Legislative Measures Have Proved Generally Effective in the Control of Asbestosis, pp. 89–90. M.D. thesis, Glasgow University, 1946.
16.
DollR.Mortality from lung cancer in asbestos workers. Br. J. Ind. Med.12: 81–86, 1955.
17.
MorganW. K. C.SeatonA.Occupational Lung Diseases, Ed. 3, p. 1. W. B. Saunders, Philadelphia, 1975.
18.
SimsonF. W.Pulmonary asbestosis in South Africa. BMJ1: 885, May 26, 1928.
19.
Investigations of the asbestos mines. In Report of the Commission to Study Silicosis and Other Industrial Pneumoconiosis, p. 85. Government Printer, Salisbury, S.A., 1938.
20.
Department of Labour. Memo: Chief Inspector of Factories to the Secretary for Mines and Industries, 15/9/1928. In Chief Inspector of Factories ARB CF 16/10/3, vol. 912. National Archives of South Africa, Pretoria.
21.
Department of Labour. Report: L. G. Irvine, Chair Miners' Phthisis Medical Bureau to Chief Inspector of Factories, 9/11/1928. In Chief Inspector of Factories ARB CF 16/10/3, vol. 912. National Archives of South Africa, Pretoria.
22.
Department of Labour. Memo: K. Leinberger, Deputy Inspector of Mines to Inspector of Mines, Johannesburg, 11/1/1929. In Chief Inspector of Factories ARB CF 16/10/3, vol. 912. National Archives of South Africa, Pretoria.
23.
SladeG. F.The Incidence of Respiratory Disability in Workers Employed in Asbestos Mining with Special Reference to the Type of Disability Caused by the Inhalation of Asbestos Dust. M.D. thesis, University of Witwatersrand, 1930.
24.
FelixM. A.LegerJ.-P.EhrlichR. I.Three minerals, three epidemics—Asbestos mining and disease in South Africa. In Advances in Modern Environmental Toxicology, Vol. 22: The Identification and Control of Environmental and Occupational Diseases: Asbestos and Cancers, ed. MehlmanM. A.UptonA., pp. 265–286. Princeton Scientific, Princeton, 1994.
25.
Department of Mines and Industries. Annual Report for the Year Ending 31 December 1968. Government Printing and Stationery Office, Pretoria, 1969.
26.
TweedaleG.Sources in the history of occupational health: The Turner & Newall archive. Soc. Hist. Med.13: 515–534, 2000.
27.
SchepersG. W. H.Comments on G. K. Sluis-Cremer, Asbestosis in South Africa— Certain geological and environmental considerations. In Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.132(1): 246–247, December 1965.
28.
SchepersG. W. H.Adventures in Toxicology, pp. 256–257. Typescript memoir, n.d.
29.
PeacockG. B.Report on Health Conditions at Asbestos Mines to Pietersburg … assistant health officer, June 1952. NTS 2258 695/280 Vol. 1. South African National Archives, Pretoria.
30.
WedlerH.-W.Uber den lungenkrebs bei asbestose [asbestosis in lung cancer patients]. Archiv fur Klinische Medizin191: 189–209, 1943.
31.
WyersH.Asbestosis. Postgrad. Med. J.25: 631–638, December 1949.
32.
Chief Inspector of Factories. Annual Report … for the Year 1947. HMSO, London, 1949.
33.
BonserG. M.FauldsJ. S.StewartM. J.Occupational cancer of the urinary bladder in dyestuffs operatives and of the lung in asbestos textile workers and iron-ore miners. Am. J. Clin. Pathol.25: 126–134, 1955.
34.
WagnerC.Interview with J. McCulloch, Weymouth, Dorset, March 22, 1998.
35.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. Visit to head offices of Cape Blue Asbestos company, Johannesburg, J. C. Wagner, 30/9/1958, General Arrangements, The MS Survey Files 1201/1. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
36.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. The Pneumoconiosis Research Unit annual report for the year 1 April 1957 to 31 March 1958. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
37.
WagnerJ. C.Some pathological aspects of asbestosis. In Proceedings of the Pneumoconiosis Conference, Held at the University of the Witwatersrand, Johanneshurg, 9–24 February 1959, ed. OrensteinA. J., pp. 373–382. J. A. Churchill, London, 1960.
38.
WagnerJ. C.SleggsC. A.MarchandP.Diffuse pleural mesothelioma and asbestos exposure in the north west Cape Province. Br. J. Ind. Med.17: 260–265, 1960.
39.
BrammfonteinI. W.Interview with J. McCulloch, Johannesburg, December 4, 1997.
40.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. PRU Field Survey in the North West Cape and at Penge in the Transvaal (Asbestosis and Mesothelioma). PRU report no. 1/64, p. 3. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, 1964. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
41.
MackeurtanJ.Deposition of Justin Mackeurtan 19/11/1996, Johannesburg, in re: Asbestos personal injury cases, Arrington lead no. 93-9-114 Civil Action no. 93-9-1114, p. 234.
42.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. Report on the progress of mesothelioma survey as at 30 April 1962, pp. 2–3. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
43.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. PRU 5th annual report for year ending 31 March 1963. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
44.
Pneumoconiosis Research Unit. PRU 4th annual report for year ending 31 March 1962. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
45.
WaltersI. G. Covering letter 23 June 1964. Field survey in the North West Cape and at Penge in the Transvaal. Asbestosis and Mesothelioma Pneumoconiosis Research Unit report no. 1/64. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
46.
HarrisonB.Interview with J. McCulloch, Killara, Sydney, October 15, 1999.
47.
TalentJ.Interview with J. McCulloch, Fish Hoek, South Africa, December 16, 1999.
48.
EnticknapJ. B.SmitherW. J.Peritoneal tumours in asbestosis. Br. J. Ind. Med.21: 20–31, 1964.
49.
TweedaleG.Science or public relations? The inside story of the Asbestosis Research Council. Am. J. Ind. Med.38: 723–734, 2000.
50.
SmitherW.Visit to South Africa, 1962. Barking, August. National Centre for Occupational Health Papers, Johannesburg.
51.
Minutes of 19th Meeting of Research Committee of ARC, Cambridge, 12 July 1962. Chase Manhattan Bank microfilm of T&N archive (in possession of G.T.), reel 81, frames 1830–35.
52.
NewhouseM. L.ThompsonH.Mesothelioma of pleura and peritoneum following exposure to asbestos in the London area. Br. J. Ind. Med.22: 261–269, 1965.
53.
McDermottM.Lung function and radiographic change in chrysotile workers in Swaziland. Br. J. Ind. Med.39: 338–343, 1982.
54.
BothaJ. L.IrwigL. M.StrebelP. M.Excess mortality from stomach cancer, lung cancer and asbestosis and/or mesothelioma in crocidolite mining districts in South Africa. Am. J. Epidemiol.123(1): 30–40, 1986.
55.
BattyA.South African asbestos workers (letter). Times (London), July 26, 1971.
56.
House of Commons Expenditure Committee. Fifth Report … on Wages and Conditions of African Workers Employed by British Firms in South Africa. HC 116, 78–9; Memoranda HC 21-IV, pp. 754–63, 1973–4. London.
57.
World in Action. Dust to Dust. Transcript, November 16, 1981. Chase Manhattan Bank microfilm, reel 30, frame 1712.
