During the past few years greater interest has been shown in ways in which the coverage of health services in developing countries might be increased. Frequently, it has been advocated that greater use be made of mobile health services, often using relatively sophisticated transport systems, including aircraft. The present article examines the uses to which mobility in health services has been put and the merits of different forms of transport, within the resource constraints and health “needs” of Third World countries. Our main conclusions are that for the majority of health service movement appropriate intermediate technology transport should be used (i.e. bicycle, animals, or motorcycles). The use of mechanical transport within health services with the highest benefit per unit cost is likely to be that employed in the regular supportive (not policing) visits to permanently staffed fixed basic care facilities by more highly skilled and scarce health personnel. Those clinics located closer to the regional base can usually be reached more cheaply by land transport, while those at a distance might justify the use of a light aircraft. Where aircraft are used in this supportive role, it is important they are integrated into the ongoing health services and tightly scheduled to lessen the risk of their diversion to less cost-effective activities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
KingM., editor. Medical Care in Developing Countries. Oxford University Press, Nairobi, 1966.
2.
BryantJ.Health & the Developing World, pp. 19–53. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1969.
3.
GishO.Planning the Health Sector. Croom Helm, London, 1975.
4.
CharltonL.MillsC.Flying doctor services. Horizon Roan Selection Trust8: 4–11, February 1966.
5.
DuncanJ.The flying doctor service of Africa. World Medical Journal13(iv): 102–123, 1966.
6.
Flying Doctor Services and Rural Development: Report of a Seminar Held at Birmingham University, 1969. Flying Doctor Development Services, Birmingham, England, 1969.
7.
VuturoA. F.JensenR. T.Considerations for planning and implementing a flying health service: Experiences in the Ryukyu Islands. Milit. Med.136: 736–739, 1971.
8.
WoodA. M.The use of modern forms of transport in community medicine. In Health and Disease in Africa: East African Medical Research Council Conference, Nairobi, 1970, edited by GouldG. C., pp. 33–41. East African Literature Bureau, Kampala, 1970.
9.
JackmanE.Flying doctor services in Zambia. In Medical Geography Techniques and Field Studies, edited by GlashanN. D., Ch. 7. Methuen, London, 1972.
10.
JollyA. R.The economy of a district hospital. In Medical Care in Developing Countries, edited by KingM., Ch. 12. Oxford University Press, Nairobi, 1966.
11.
BodenheimerT. S.Mobile units: A solution to the rural health problem?Med. Care7: 144–154, March-April, 1969.
12.
GodlundS.Population, regional hospitals, transport facilities and regions in Sweden. Lund Studies Series B, 1961.
13.
GishO.Resource allocation, equality of access and health. World Development1: 37–44, December 1973.
14.
HilleboeH. E.BarkhuusA.ThomasW. C.Jr.Approaches to National Health Planning. Public Health Paper No. 46. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1972.
15.
LoganR. F. L.Hospital Services for Angus: Towards a More Effective Pattern. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, 1973 (mimeographed).
16.
DewarM. A.McCollumJ. P.FloydM.Hospital topics: A year's experience with a mobile resusitation unit. Br. Med. J. (iii): 89–92, 1969.
17.
EdwardsC.Accident after care services. Practitioner209(1249): A65–A69, 1972.
18.
BrowningD.Accident department on wheels. Nurs. Times71(i): 32–34, 1975.
19.
CramptonR. S.The reduction of prehospital, ambulance and community death rates by the community-wide emergency cardiac care system. Am. J. Med.58: 151–165, February 1975.
20.
AndersonG. J.KnoebelS. B.FischC.Continuous prehospitalization monitoring of cardiac rhythm. Am. Heart J. 82: 642–646, 1971.
21.
HudsonH.Flynn's Flying Doctors. William Heineman, Melbourne, 1956.
22.
The Flying Doctor. Australian Information Service, Canberra, 1974.
23.
HaraldsonS. R. S.Mobile Populations and Public Health. A discussion meeting held at The Ciba Foundation, London, November 14, 1974.
24.
Annual Report for 1973. African Medical and Research Foundation, Nairobi, 1974.
25.
LearningD. B.SmithA. G.The Flying Surgeon Service of Queensland. Med. J. Aust.57: 387–390, 1970.
26.
BurkittW. R.The work of the Kenya Mobile Eye Unit. Br. J. Ophthalmol.52: 329–334, 1968.
27.
DuraiswamiP. K.Multipurpose role of mobile hospitals. J. R. Coll. Surg. Edinb.16: 185–187, 1971.
28.
SaxenaS.Editorial: Mobile paediatric service. Indian Pediatr. 9(ii): 641–642, 1972.
29.
RamboV. C.ChatterjeeA.The Curable Blind: A Guide for Establishing and Maintaining Eye Hospitals in Developing Countries. Rambo Committee, Philadelphia, 1974.
30.
ReichartA.The health care-a-van. Industrial Medicine40: 36–37, December 1971.
31.
CanvinR. W.Improving general practice facilities for rural patients—An experimental mobile surgery. R. Soc. Health J. 92: 141–145, 1972.
32.
SnyderL. A.SetterG. C.Mobile unit health care in rural Minnesota. Minn. Med.56: 97–101, 1973.
33.
BellB. D.Mobile medical care to the elderly: An evaluation. Gerontologist15: 100–103, April 1975.
34.
CachiaC. A.A mobile health unit amongst the Masai. East Afr. Med J. 37: 224–236, March 1960.
35.
BoltonJ. M.Medical services to the aborigines in West Malaysia. Br. Med. J. (ii): 818–823. June 1968.
36.
CoxP. S. V.The value of mobile medicine. East Afr. Med. J.46: 548–552, October 1969.
37.
RanaghyH. A.NasrK.Medical problems of developing countries: An attempt to bring medical care to rural communities in Iran. Br. Med. J. (i): 295–296, 1970.
38.
KimmanceK. J.Evaluation of the work of a mobile outpatient unit in Swaziland. J. Trop. Pediatr.16: 62–67, 1970.
39.
MwangemiP. M.Personal view. East Afr. Med. J.49: 23–31, February 1973.
40.
DennyK. M.A Review of Alternative Approaches to Health Care Delivery in Developing Countries: Mobile Health Teams. Management Sciences for Health, Cambridge, Mass., 1974 (draft mimeograph).
41.
LongE. C.Health problems of Central America. Trop. Doct.2: 89–93, 1972.
42.
PaddockW.PaddockE., editors. Mobile health clinics become a shell game. In We Don't Know How, an Independent Audit of What They Call Success in Foreign Assistance, Ch. 4. Iowa State University Press, Ames, 1973.
43.
GishO.WalkerG. J. A.Mobile Health Services: A Study in Cost-Effectiveness. Tri-med, London, 1977.
44.
MakeneteM. T., Administrator, Lesotho Flying Doctor Service. Personal communication, 1975.
45.
Special Report 1965–1973. Zambia Flying Doctor Service, Ndola, Zambia, 1974.
46.
CochraneA. L.World health problems. Can. J. Public Health66(iv): 280–287, 1975.
47.
The Place of Hospitals in Public Health Services and Their Role in African Communities: Report on a Seminar, Table 6, p. 65. (AFR/PHA/132), WHO Regional Office for Africa, Brazzaville, 1974.
48.
Ministry of Health, Maseru, Lesotho. Personal communication, 1975.
49.
FrankenbergR.LeesonJ.The sociology of health dilemmas in the post-colonial world: Intermediate technology and medical care in Zambia, Zaire and China. In Sociology and Development, edited by de KadtE.WilliamsG., Tavistock Publications, London, 1974.
50.
GonzalezC. L.Mass Campaigns and General Health Services. Public Health Papers No. 29. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1965.
51.
Study Group on the Integration of Mass Campaigns Against Specific Diseases into General Health Services. WHO Tech. Rep. Ser. No. 294. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1965.
52.
SoperF. L.The Relation of the Mass Campaigns for the Prevention of Specific Disease to the General Health Services. (WHO/PHA/Mass Campaigns/5), World Health Organization, Geneva, 1969 (mimeographed).
53.
Joint Study on Alternative Approaches to Meeting Basic Health Needs of Populations in Developing Countries. (JC/UNICEF-WHO/75.2), WHO/UNICEF, 1974 (mimeographed).
54.
HowellC.Working Paper No. One: Mobile Units. International Planned Parenthood Federation, London, 1969.
55.
MunroeG. S.JonesG. W.Reports on Population/Family Planning No. Ten, Mobile Units in Family Planning. Population Council, New York, 1971.
56.
CookR., editor. Recent experience in maternal and child health in East Africa. J. Trop. Pediatr. MonographNo. 2, 12: 77–78, 1966.
57.
WilkinsonJ. L.SmithH.SmithO. I.The organisation and economics of a mobile child welfare team in Sierra Leone. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.70: 14–18, 1967.
58.
MoffatM.Mobile Young Child Clinics in Rural Uganda: A Report of the Ankole Pre-School Protection Programme 1967–69. Makerere University, 1969 (mimeographed).
59.
Van der MeiJ.BelcherD. W.Comparing under-five programmes in a hospital-based clinic and in satellite mobile clinics. Trop. Geogr. Med.26: 449–456, December 1974.
60.
KorteR.PatelP. M.Operational aspects of mobile and stationary young child clinics in Lushoto, Tanzania. J. Trop. Pediatr.20: 90–105, April 1974.
61.
WatsfordS. D.Medical services to natives in the Northern Territory. Health Canberra8–10, 1970.
62.
ImperatoP. J.Nomads of the West African Sahel and the delivery of health services to them. Soc. Sci. Med.8: 443–457, 1974.
63.
HaraldsonS. R. S.Socio-medical problems of nomad peoples. In The Theory and Practice of Public Health, Ed. 4, edited by HobsonW., Oxford University Press, London, 1975.
64.
LahaN. M.Transport organisation: An important component in comprehensive health care—Its nationalisation. Indian J. Public Health15: 150–151, October 1971.
65.
HideH.The Kenya Road Transport Cost Study: Research on Vehicle Operating Costs. Transport and Road Research Laboratory, Department of the Environment, Crowthorne, 1975.
66.
BunceJ. A.TresidderJ. O.Characteristics of Rural Roads in Jamaica as They Affect Traffic Speeds and Vehicle Operating Costs. Conference on Civil Engineering Problems Overseas, pp. 207–233. Institution of Civil Engineers, London, 1966.
67.
BennettF. J.LutwanaJ. S. W.Assessing the problems at a rural dispensary. Cent. Afr. J. Med.10: 424–426, November 1964.
68.
FendallN. R. E.The medical assistant in Africa. J. Trop. Med. Hyg.71: 83–95, 1968.
69.
RoemerM. I.Organized ambulatory health service in international perspective. Int. J. Health Serv. 1: 18–27, 1971.
70.
SaiF. T.A rural health model: Danfa, Ghana. In Health Care for Remote Areas, edited by HughesJ. P., Kaiser Foundation International, Oakland, Cal., 1972.
