Analogical Reasoning and Computer Programming

Abstract

Investigations of the cognitive demands of programming can inform teaching and validate claims that important cognitive skills are inherent in programming. Given reports of experts' use of analogical problem solving in programming, the study reported here related analogical reasoning to Logo programming mastery among high school students. Correlational analyses related pretests of analogical reasoning to posttests of programming mastery. As predicted, a significant correlation was found between analogical reasoning and the ability to write subprocedures which can be reused for several different programs. This sophisticated programming skill requires recognition of structural similarities among distinct programming tasks. A final, general discussion considers analogical reasoning skill as a cognitive demand and consequence of programming.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Papert

, Mindstorms, Basic Books, New York, 1980.

Nickerson

R. S.

, Computer Programming as a Vehicle for Teaching Thinking Skills, Thinking: The Journal of Philosophy for Children, 4, pp. 42–48, 1982.

Pea

R. D.

Kurland

D. M.

, On the Cognitive Prerequisites of Learning Computer Programming, (Technical Report No. 18), Center for Children and Technology, Bank Street College of Education, New York, 1983.

Kurland

D. M.

Clement

Mawby

Pea

R. D.

, Mapping the Cognitive Demands of Learning to Program, in Thinking: Progress in Research and Teaching, Bishop

Lochhead

Perkins

(eds.), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, New Jersey, in press.

Polya

, How to Solve It, Doubleday-Anchor, New York, 1957.

Gentner

, A Structure Mapping Approach to Analogy and Metaphor, Reprint from the Proceedings of the International Conference on Cybernetics and Society, 1982.

Winston

P. H.

, Learning New Principles From Precedents and Exercises, Artificial Intelligence, 19, pp. 321–350, 1982.

Carbonell

, Metaphor and Common-Sense Reasoning, (Technical Report No. 83-110), Carnegie-Mellon University, 1983.

Holyoak

K. J.

, Analogical Thinking and Human Intelligence, (Technical Report No. 18), University of Michigan, 1982.

10.

Gentner

D. R.

, Flowing Waters or Teeming Crowds: Mental Models of Electricity, in Mental Models, Gentner

Stevens

A. L.

(eds.), Erlbaum, Hillsdale, New Jersey, 1982.

11.

Gick

M. L.

Holyoak

K. J.

, Schema Induction and Analogical Transfer, Cognitive Psychology, 15, pp. 1–39, 1982.

12.

Schustack

M. W.

Anderson

J. R.

, Effects of Analogy to Prior Knowledge on Memory for New Information, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 18, pp. 565–583, 1979.

13.

Reed

S. K.

Ernst

G. W.

Banerji

, The Role of Analogy in Transfer Between Similar Problem States, Cognitive Psychology, 6, pp. 436–450, 1974.

14.

Brooks

R. E.

, Toward a Theory of the Cognitive Processes in Computer Programming, International Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 9, pp. 737–751, 1977.

15.

Pennington

, Cognitive Components of Expertise in Computer Programming: A Review of the Literature, (Technical Report No. 46), University of Michigan Center for Cognitive Science, Ann Arbor, 1982.

16.

Jeffries

Turner

A. A.

Poison

P. G.

Atwood

M. E.

, The Processes Involved in Designing Software, in Cognitive Skills and Their Acquisition, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, New Jersey, 1981.

17.

Shneiderman

, Software Psychology, Winthrop Publishers, Inc., Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1980.

18.

Sternberg

R. J.

Rifkin

, The Development of Analogical Reasoning Processes, Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 27, pp. 195–232, 1979.

19.

Mawby

, Determining Students' Understanding of Programming Concepts, paper presented at the meetings of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, 1984.

20.

Resnick

L. B.

, A Developmental Theory of Number Understanding, in The Development of Mathematical Thinking, Ginsburg

(ed.), Academic Press, New York, 1984.