The resonance between scientific theory and ideology is starkly revealed by the medical debate on slavery, alleged black inferiority, and racial differences in disease: opposing doctors invoked the same science, but relied on contrary assumptions, to reach antagonistic conclusions. Reductionist, biological determinist, and ahistorical premises underlay the dominant belief that innate racial differences led to black bondage and racial disparities in health; an anti-reductionist and historical approach supported the minority view that social factors rooted in the planters' need for cheap labor explained both. From 1830 to 1850, doctors debated the accuracy, validity, and interpretation of their findings. In the 1850s, “apolitical” doctors sought to purge medicine of politics to regain scientific objectivity, yet the first generation of black physicians argued that politics inevitably affected medical inquiry. The Civil War and Emancipation spurred studies relating the health of blacks and poor whites to social conditions, while the destruction of Reconstruction led to the resurgence of racist medicine. Comprehending how politics set the terms and tempo of this polemic can provide insight into current controversies on racial differences in disease.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FonerP. S.History of Black Americans: From the Emergence of the Cotton Kingdom to the Eve of the Compromise of 1850, vol. II.Greenwood Press, Westport, Conn., 1983.
2.
MarxK.Capital, vol. I, pp. 751, 759–760. International Publishers, New York, 1974.
3.
FonerP. S.History of Black Americans: From Africa to the Emergence of the Cotton Kingdom, vol. I.Greenwood Press, Westport, Conn., 1975.
4.
WilliamsE.Capitalism and Slavery, pp. 98–102. Capricorn Books, New York, 1944.
5.
StantonW.The Leopard's Spots: Scientific Attitudes toward Race in America, 1815–1859. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1960.
6.
FisherW.Physicians and slavery in the antebellum Southern Medical Journal. J. Hist. Med. Allied Sci. 23 (1): 36–49, 1968.
7.
StarrP.The Transformation of American Medicine, Basic Books, Inc., New York, 1982.
8.
GrobG.Edward Jarvis and the federal census. Bull. Hist. Med.50: 4–27, 1976.
9.
PendletonE. M.Statistics of diseases of Hancock County. South. Med. Surg. J. n.s. 5: 647–654, 1849.
10.
EmersonG.Medical statistics; consisting of estimates relating to the population of Philadelphia. Am. J. Med. Sci.9: 3–46, 1831.
11.
CoatesB.On the effect of secluded and gloomy imprisonment on individuals of the African variety of mankind. N. Y. J. Med.4: 91–95, 1844.
12.
Caucasian and negro races. Boston Med. Surg. J.30: 244–245, 1844.
13.
CaldwellC.An essay on the nature and sources of the malaria or noxious miasma. Am. J. Med. Sci.16: 249–340, 1831.
14.
SimmonsT. Y.Remarks on the climate of the lower country of South Carolina. Am. J. Med. Sci.9: 256–257, 1831.
15.
MonnetJ. W.Epidemic yellow fever of Washington, Miss. Am. J. Med. Sci.1: 243–245, 1831.
16.
RossignolH.Statistics of the mortality in Augusta, Georgia from 1839 to 1840. South. Med. Surg. J. n.s. 4: 658–663, 1848.
17.
DrakeD.Diseases of the Negro populations. South. Med. Surg. J.1: 341–342, 1845.
18.
SwadosF.Negro health on the antebellum plantations. Bull. Hist. Med.10 (3): 460–472, 1941.
19.
SavittT. L.Medicine and Slavery: The Diseases and Health Care of Blacks in Antebellum Virginia. University of Illinois Free Press, Urbana, Ill., 1978.
20.
AckerknechtE. H.Anticontagionism between 1821 and 1867. Bull. Hist. Med.22 (5): 562–593, 1948.
21.
NottJ. C.The mulatto a hybrid—probable extermination of the two races if the whites and blacks are allowed to intermarry. Boston Med. Surg. J.26 (2): 29–32, 1843.
22.
DeutschA.The first U.S. census of the insane (1840) and its use as pro-slavery propaganda. Bull. Hist. Med.15: 469–482, 1944.
23.
ForryS.Vital statistics by the sixth census of the United States, bearing upon the question of the unity of the human race. N. Y. J. Med.1: 151–167, 1843.
24.
ForryS.On the relative proportion of centenarians, of deaf and dumb, of blind, and of insane, in the races of European and African origin, as shown by the census of the United States. N. Y. J. Med.2: 310–320, 1844.
25.
JarvisE.Insanity among the coloured population of the free states. Am. J. Med. Sci.7 (14): 71–83, 1844.
26.
CartwrightS. A.The diseases and physical peculiarities of the Negro race. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.8: 187–194, 1851.
27.
FonerP. S.History of Black Americans: From the Compromise of 1850 to the End of the Civil War, vol. III.Greenwood Press, Westport, Conn., 1983.
28.
CartwrightS. A.Report on the diseases and physical peculiarities of the Negro race. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.7: 691–715, 1850.
29.
SmithJ. T.Review of Dr. Cartwright's report on the diseases and physical peculiarities of the Negro race. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.8: 228–237, 1851.
30.
Charleston Med. J.6: 829–843, 1851.
31.
Charleston Med. J.7: 89–98, 1852.
32.
CartwrightS. A.Alcohol and the Ethiopian: Or, the moral and physical effects of ardent spirits on the Negro race, and some accounts of the peculiarities of that people. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.10: 150–165, 1853.
33.
CartwrightS. A.Ethnology of the Negro or prognathous race—A lecture delivered November 30, 1857, before the New Orleans Academy of Science. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.15: 149–163, 1858.
34.
CartwrightS. A.Remarks on dysentery among Negroes. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.11: 145–163, 1855.
35.
WootenH. S.Dysentery among Negroes. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.11: 448–456, 1855.
36.
GrierS. L.The Negro and his diseases. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.9: 752–763, 1853.
37.
KingJ. W.Review of J. C. Nott's “Geographical Distribution of Animals and the Races of Men.”South. J. Med. Physical Sci. 1: 366–370, 1853.
38.
RamseyH. A.Letter to Dr. James Bryon on the Southern Negro. South. J. Med. Physical Sci. 1: 301–302, 1853.
39.
NottJ. C.Acclimation; or, the comparative influence of climate, endemic and epidemic diseases, on the races of men. In Indigenous Races of the Earth: Or New Chapters of Ethnological Enquiry, edited by NottJ. C.GliddonG., pp. 353–401. J. B. Lippincott & Co., Philadelphia, 1857.
40.
Editors. Indigenous races of the earth. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.14: 138–142, 1857.
41.
Editors. Indigenous races of the earth. Charleston Med. J.12: 650–653, 1857.
42.
H. H. (Editors). Indigenous races of the earth. Am. J. Med. Sci.34 (68): 468–470, 1857.
43.
LevesqueG. A.Boston's black Brahmin: Dr. John S. Rock. Civil War Hist. 54 (4): 326–346, 1980.
44.
LinkE. P.The civil rights activities of three great Negro physicians (1840–1940). J. Negro Hist. 52 (3): 169–184, 1967.
45.
SmithJ. M.On the fourteenth query of Thomas Jefferson's notes on Virginia. The Anglo-African Magazine1 (8): 225–238, 1859.
46.
MarxK.Die Presse, November 7, 1861. In The Civil War in the United States, by MarxK.EngelsF. p. 81. International Publishers, New York City, 1971.
47.
ZinnH.A People's History of the United States. Harper Colophon Books, New York, 1980.
48.
GibbG.The larynx of the Negro. Chicago Med. Examiner6: 183–185, 1865.
49.
BryonJ.Negro regiments—Department of Tennessee. Boston Med. Surg. J.69 (1): 43–44, 1863.
50.
ReyburnR.Remarks concerning some of the diseases prevailing among the freedpeople in the District of Columbia (Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen and Abandoned Lands). Am. J. Med. Sci. n.s.51(102): 364–369, 1866.
51.
Half-Yearly Abstract. Am. J. Med. Sci. n.s. 50: 560, 1865.
52.
HoweS. G.The colored population—mulattoes, etc. Chicago Med. J.20: 478–479, 1863.
53.
NottJ. C.Instincts of the races. New Orleans Med. Surg. J.19: 1–16; 148–156, 1866.
54.
HallerJ. S.The physician versus the Negro: Medical and anthropological concepts of race in the late nineteenth century. Bull. Hist. Med.44 (2): 154–167, 1970.
55.
KuperL.Introduction. In Race, Science and Society, edited by KuperL., pp. 14–28. The UNESCO Press, Paris, 1975.
56.
United States Department of Health and Human Services. Report of the Secretary's Task Force on Black and Minority Health, vol. I: Executive Summary (1985 0-487-637 (QL 3)). U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1985.
