Freidson's concept of medical dominance is compared to the alternative conceptions of neo-Marxist writers. Dominance is then examined in historical perspective, using medicine in Canada (mainly Ontario) as a case study. Medicine emerged as the dominant health occupation in Canada in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, consolidating its power between World War I and the Saskatchewan doctors' strike of 1962. The authors argue that medical dominance has declined since that time due to such factors as the involvement of the state in health insurance, the rise of other health occupations, increasing public or at least elite skepticism, and possible internal fragmentation. The underlying social explanation for this historical process is sought in changes in the Canadian class structure, specifically the spread of the capitalist mode of production, the decline of the petite bourgeoisie, and the rise of the state. It is suggested that Freidson's specific accounts of the history of medicine must be incorporated for explanatory purposes within the broader neo-Marxist view of medicine as an intermediary rather than an ultimately determining institution.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FreidsonE.Professional Dominance. Atherton Press, New York, 1970.
2.
FreidsonE.Profession of Medicine. Dodd, Mead and Co., New York, 1970.
3.
LarsonM. S.The Rise of Professionalism. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1977.
4.
BrownE. R.Rockefeller Medicine Men: Medicine and Capitalism in America. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1979.
5.
McKinlayJ. B.The business of good doctoring or doctoring as good business: Reflections on Freidson's view of the medical game. Int. J. Health Serv. 7(1): 459–483, 1977.
6.
NavarroV.Medicine Under Capitalism. Prodist, New York, 1976.
7.
BerlantJ. L.Profession and Monopoly. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1975.
BlishenB. R.Doctors and Doctrines: The Ideology of Medical Care in Canada. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1969.
10.
TaylorM. G.Health Insurance and Canadian Public Policy. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1978.
11.
SwartzD.The politics of reform: Conflict and accommodation in Canadian health policy. In The Canadian State: Political Economy and Political Power, edited by PanitchL., University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977.
12.
CharlesC. A.The medical profession and health insurance: An Ontario case study. Soc. Sci. Med.10: 33–38, 1976.
13.
BadgleyR. F.CharlesC.TorranceG.National Health Insurance in Canada. Department of Behavioural Science, University of Toronto, 1975 (mimeo).
14.
GidneyR. D.MillarW. P. J.The origins of organized medicine in Ontario, 1850–1869. Department of Education, University of Western Ontario, London, 1982 (mimeo).
15.
MacNabE.A Legal History of Health Professions in Ontario. Committee on the Healing Arts. Queen's Printer, Toronto, 1970.
16.
KettJ. F.American and Canadian medical institutions 1800–1870. J. Hist. Med.22: 343–356, 1967.
17.
Commission on Pharmaceutical Services. Pharmacy in a New Age. Canadian Pharmaceutical Association, Toronto, 1971.
18.
BiggsL. C.The Case of the Missing Midwives: A Sociological Study of Midwifery in Ontario 1788–1905. Department of Behavioural Science, University of Toronto, 1981 (mimeo).
19.
CoburnM.“I see and am silent:” A short history of nursing in Ontario. In Women at Work, Ontario 1850–1930, edited by ActonJ.GoldsmithP.ShepardB., Canadian Women's Educational Press, Toronto, 1974.
20.
StevensonA.Physicians' Panel on Canadian Medical History. Shering Corp., Toronto, 1967.
21.
FeinR.The Doctor Shortage. The Brookings Institute. Washington, D.C., 1967.
22.
McFarlaneJ. A.Medical Education in Canada. Queen's Printer, Ottawa, 1964.
23.
MacDermotH. E.One Hundred Years of Medicine in Canada: 1867–1967. McClelland and Stewart Ltd., Toronto, 1967.
24.
BatorP. A.“Saving Lives on the Wholesale Plan:” Public Health Reform in Toronto, 1900–1930. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of History, University of Toronto, 1979.
25.
TaylorM. G.The role of the medical profession in the formulation and execution of public policy. Can. J. Economy Polit. Sci.25(1): 108–127, 1960.
26.
AlfordR. R.Health Care Politics. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1975.
27.
CharlesC. A.The medical profession and health insurance: An Ontario case study. Soc. Sci. Med.10: 33–38, 1976.
28.
CoburnD.A new deal in health care: Patients' rights. The Canadian Forum, May 1980, pp. 14–18.
29.
RenaudM.Reform or illusion: An analysis of the Quebec state intervention in health. In Health and Canadian Society: Sociological Perspectives, edited by CoburnD.D'ArcyC.NewP.TorranceG., Fitzhenry and Whiteside, Toronto, 1981.
30.
HaugM. R.The erosion of professional authority: A cross-cultural inquiry. Milbank Mem. Fund Q., Winter 1976, pp. 83–106.
31.
IllichI.Medical Nemesis. Calder and Byars, London, 1975.
32.
McKeownT.The Role of Medicine: Dream, Mirage, or Nemesis. Nuffield Provincial Hospital Trust, London, 1976.
33.
LaLondeM.A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians. Information Canada, Cat. No. H31-1374, Ottawa, 1975.
34.
MarsdenL. R.Power within a profession: Medicine in Ontario. Soc. Work Occup. 4(1): 3–26, 1977.
35.
GrayC.Women in medicine. Can. Med. Assoc. J.123(8): 798–804, 1980.
36.
LoveR. L.Women in Medicine: Will it make a difference?Healthsharing (Toronto), Sept. 1981.
37.
Association of Canadian Medical Colleges. Canadian Medical Education Statistics, 1979–1980. Research Division, Ottawa, 1980.
38.
SchneiderJ. W.ConradP.The medical control of deviance. In Research in the Sociology of Health Care, Vol. 2, edited by RothJ. A., J. A. I. Press Inc., Greenwich, Connecticut, 1982.
39.
KelnerM.HallO.CoulterI.Chiropractors: Do They Help?Fitzhenry and Whiteside, Toronto, 1980.
40.
JohnsonL. A.The political economy of Ontario women in the nineteenth century. In Women at Work, Ontario 1850–1930, edited by ActonJ.GoldsmithP.ShepardB., Canadian Women's Educational Press, Toronto, 1974.
JohnsonL. A.The development of class in Canada in the twentieth century. In Capitalism and the National Question in Canada, edited by TeepleG., University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1972.
43.
LoweG. S.The Administrative Revolution: The Growth of Clerical Occupations and the Development of the Modern Office in Canada, 1911–1931. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Toronto, 1979.
44.
TorranceG.Hospitals as health factories. In Health and Canadian Society: Sociological Perspectives, edited by CoburnD.D'ArcyC.NewP.TorranceG., Fitzhenry and Whiteside, Toronto, 1981.
45.
WrightE. O.Class, Crisis and the State. Verso, London, 1979.
46.
WhittakerR.Images of the state in Canada. In The Canadian State, edited by PanitchL., University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977.
47.
SwartzD.The politics of reform: Conflict and accommodation in Canadian health policy. In The Canadian State, edited by PanitchL., University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977.
48.
WaltersV.State, capital and labour: The introduction of federal-provincial insurance for physician care in Canada. Can. Rev. Anthro. Sociol.19(2): 157–172, 1982.
49.
BirdR. M.BucovetskyM. W.FootD. K.The Growth of Public Employment in Canada. Institute for Research on Social Policy. Butterworth and Co., Toronto, 1979.
50.
ArmstrongD.The decline of medical hegemony; A review of government reports during the N.H.S. Soc. Sci. Med.10: 157–163, 1976.
51.
BaerH. A.The organizational rejuvenation of osteopathy: A reflection of the decline of professional dominance in medicine. Soc. Sci. Med.15A: 701–711, 1981.
52.
HaugM. R.LavinB.Public challenge of physician authority. Med. Care17(8): 844–858, 1979.
53.
StarrP.Medicine and the waning of professional sovereignty. Daedalus107(2): 175–193, 1978.
54.
YarmolinskyA.What future for the professional in American society?Daedalus107(2): 159–174, 1978.
55.
WellerG. R.From “pressure group politics” to “medical-industrial complex:” The development of approaches to the politics of health. J. Health Politics Policy Law1(4): 444–470, 1977.
