Using field data from Mexican Spiritualist healing, this article focuses on the relationship between treatment outcomes at the individual and social levels. Two issues are explored 1) to what degree do persons treated by Spiritualist healing techniques fit into the wider society of which they are part, and 2) what effects does a given healing system exert on socioeconomic and political arrangements? The discussion brings into bold relief the contradictions embedded in Spiritualist healing techniques and rituals when studied from micro and macro perspectives. Using physiological and social analysis, the author addresses the reasons why individuals participate in Spiritualist healing and rituals, despite the resultant reproduction of socioeconomic and political forms that are contrary to the participants' concerns and interests and that may also be illness producing. By way of conclusion, it is suggested that, on a macro level, healing systems of the Spiritualist kind tend to perpetuate the socioeconomic and political systems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DubosR.Mirage of Health. Harper & Row, New York, 1959
2.
McKeownT.The Role of Medicine. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J., 1979
3.
PowlesJ.On the limitations of modern medicine. Soc. Sci. Med.1: 1–30, 1973
4.
ComaroffJ.MaguireP.Ambiguity and the search for meaning: Childhood leukaemia in the modern clinical context. Soc. Sci. Med.15B: 115–123, 1981
5.
PloughA.Medical technology and the crises of experience: The costs of clinical legitimization. Soc. Sci. Med.15F: 89–101, 1981
6.
KaneR.The Challenges of Community Medicine, pp. 135–136. Springer, New York, 1974
7.
IllichI.Medical Nemesis, The Expropriation of Health. Random House, New York, 1976
8.
TurnerV. W.An Ndembu doctor in practice. In Magic, Faith and Healing, edited by KievA., pp. 230–263. The Free Press, New York, 1974
9.
ComaroffJ.Healing and cultural transformation: The Tswana of Southern Africa. Soc. Sci. Med.15B: 367–378, 1981
10.
FoxR.Witchcraft and clanship in Cochiti therapy. In Magic, Faith, and Healing, edited by KievA., pp. 174–202. The Free Press, New York, 1974
11.
KatzR.Boiling Energy. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1982
12.
CicourelA. V.Notes on the integration of micro- and macro-levels of analysis. In Advances in Social Theory and Methodology, edited by Knorr-CetinaK.CicourelA. V., pp. 51–80. Routledge and Kegan Paul, Boston, 1981
13.
CicourelA. B.Hearing is not believing: Language and the structure of belief in medical communication. In The Social Organization of Doctor-Patient Communications, edited by FisherS.ToddA. Dundas, pp. 221–239. Center for Applied Statistics, Washington, D.C., 1983
14.
GiddensA.Central Problems in Social Theory: Action Structure and Contradiction in Social Analysis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1979
15.
GiddensA.Agency, institution and time-space analysis. In Advances in Social Theory and Methodology, edited by Knorr-CetinaK.CicourelA. V., pp. 161–174. Routledge and Kegan Paul, Boston, 1981
16.
FinklerK.Spiritualist Healers in Mexico: Successes and Failures of Alternative Therapeutics. Praeger, New York, and Bergin & Garvey, South Hadley, 1985
17.
FinklerK.Dissident sectarian movements, the Catholic church and social class in Mexico. Comp. Stud. Soc. Hist.25: 277–305, 1983
18.
WaitzkinH.Medicine, superstructure and micropolitics. Soc. Sci. Med.13A: 601–609, 1979
19.
OrtizS. Personal communication, 1985
20.
FinklerK.Symptomatological differences between the sexes in rural Mexico. Cult. Med. Psychiatry9: 27–57, 1985
21.
TurnerV.The Ritual Process. Structures and Anti-Structures, p. 127. Aldine Publishing Co., Chicago, 1969
22.
FabregaH.SilverD.Illness and Shamanistic Curing in Zinacantan. Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1973
23.
KleinmanA.Patients and Healers in the Context of Culture. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1980
SilvermanJ.Shamans and acute schizophrenia. Am. Anthropol.69: 21–31, 1967
26.
WallaceA. F. C.Religion. Random House, New York, 1966
27.
FabregaH.Jr.Disease and Social Behavior: An Interdisciplinary Perspective. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Mass., 1974
28.
GarrisonV.Doctor, espiritista or psychiatrist: Health-seeking behavior in a Puerto Rican neighborhood of New York City. Med. Anthropol.1: 65–180, 1977
29.
NessR. C.The impact of indigenous healing activity: An empirical study of two fundamentalist churches. Soc. Sci. Med.14B: 147–180, 1980
30.
FinklerK.Dissident religious movements in the service of women's power. Sex Roles J. Res.7: 481–495, 1981
31.
GarrisonV.Sectarianism and psychosocial adjustment: A controlled comparison of Puerto Rican pentecostals and catholics. In Religious Movements in Contemporary America, edited by ZaretskyI. I.LeoneM. P., pp. 298–329. Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1974
32.
MacklinJ.Belief, ritual and healing: New England Spiritualism and Mexican-American Spiritualism compared. In Religious Movements in Contemporary America, edited by ZaretskyI. I.LeoneM. P., pp. 383–417. Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1974
33.
RobertsB.Protestant groups and coping with urban life in Guatemala City. Am. J. Sociol.73: 753–767, 1968
34.
BourguignonE.Religion, Altered States of Consciousness, and Social Change. Ohio State University, Columbus, 1973
35.
FinklerK.Land scarcity and economic development. When is a landlord a client and a sharecropper a patron? In Agricultural Decision-Making, edited by BarlettPeggy, pp. 265–288. New York, Academic Press, 1979
36.
FinklerK.From sharecropper to entrepreneurs: Peasant household production strategies under the Ejido system of Mexico. Economic Development and Cultural Change27: 103–120, 1978
37.
NeherA.Physiological explanation of unusual behavior in ceremonies involving drums. Hum. Biol.34: 151–161, 1962
38.
JilekW.“Brainwashing” as therapeutic technique in contemporary Canadian Indian spirit dancing: A case of theory building. In Anthropology and Mental Health, edited by Wester-MeyerJ., Mouton, The Hague
39.
PrinceR.Can the EEG be used in the study of possession states? In Trance and Possession States, edited by PrinceR., pp. 121–137. J. M. Bucke Memorial Society, Montreal, 1968
40.
BensonH.Historical and clinical considerations of the relaxation response. Am. Scientist65: 441–445, 1976
41.
LexB. W.Physiological aspects of ritual trance. J. Altered States of Consciousness2: 109–122, 1976
42.
LexB. W.Neurological bases of revitalization. Zygon13 (4): 276–312, 1978
43.
StavenhagenR.Las relaciones entre la estratificacion social y la dinamica de classes. In Social Structure, Stratification and Mobility, edited by LeedsA., pp. 126–151. Pan American Union, Washington, 1967
44.
KleinmanA.Somatization. Referential J. Psychiatry (People's Republic of China)11(2): 65–68, 1984
45.
KatonW.Depression and somatization: A review Part I. Am. J. Med.72: 127–135, 1982
46.
KatonW.Depression and somatization: A review Part II. Am. J. Med.72: 241–247, 1982
47.
LaurellA. C.Disease and rural development. A sociological analysis of morbidity in two Mexican villages. Int. J. Health Serv. 7: 401–423, 1977
48.
WeissmanM.The efficacy of drugs and psychotherapy. Am. J. Psychotherapy136(4B): 555–558, 1979
