Since factitious disorders entered the official psychiatric nomenclature in DSM-III and DSM-III-R, there has been a proliferation of reports and commentary about this unusual disorder. We present an update of the recent literature.
Method:
The psychiatric and medical literature was searched. Clinical reports and critical/theoretical papers were reviewed; eighty-five are summarized here.
Results:
Available data is descriptive and anecdotal. Reports focus on the following four topics, which are discussed here: 1) diagnostic issues, 2) the newly proposed DSM-IV category of factitious disorder by proxy, 3) epidemiology and course, 4) new developments in treatment and management.
Conclusions:
Factitious disorders are uncommon but serious illnesses that present diagnostic and management dilemmas. Deriving systematic information about these illnesses is a major challenge.
American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C., pp. 285–290, 1980.
3.
American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition, Revised, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C., pp. 315–320, 1987.
4.
RogersR.BagbyR. M.RectorN.Diagnostic Legitimacy of Factitious Disorder with Psychological Symptoms, American Journal of Psychiatry, 146:1312–1314, 1989.
5.
RogersR.BagbyR. M.Dr. Rogers and Dr. Bagby Reply, American Journal of Psychiatry, 147:681, 1990.
6.
JonasJ. M.PopeH. G.The Dissimulating Disorders: A Single Diagnostic Entity?Comprehensive Psychiatry, 26:58–62, 1985.
7.
OverholserJ. C.Differential Diagnosis of Malingering and Factitious Disorder with Physical Symptoms, Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 8:55–65, 1990.
8.
HoffmanB. F.Legitimacy of Factitious Disorder Diagnoses, American Journal of Psychiatry, 147:680, 1990.
9.
PankratzL.LezakM. D.Cerebral Dysfunction in the Munchausen Syndrome, Hillside Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 9:195–206, 1987.
10.
SussmanN.BorodJ. C.CancelmoJ. A.BrownD.Munchausen's Syndrome: A Reconceptualization of the Disorder, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 175: 692–695, 1987.
11.
DrobS. L.BergerR. H., The Determination of Malingering: A Comprehensive Clinical-Forensic Approach, Journal of Psychiatry and Law, pp. 519–538, Winter, 1987.
12.
CramerB.GershbergM. R.SternM.Munchausen Syndrome: Its Relationship to Malingering, Hysteria and the Physician-Patient Relationship, Archives of General Psychiatry, 24:573–578, 1971.
13.
NadelsonT.The Munchausen Spectrum: Borderline Character Features, General Hospital Psychiatry, 1:11–17, 1979.
14.
DworkinR. H.CaligorE.Psychiatric Diagnosis and Chronic Pain: DSM-III-R and Beyond, Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 3:87–98, 1988.
15.
NadelsonT.False Patients/Real Patients: A Spectrum of Disease Presentation, Psychotherapy Psychosomatics, 44:75–184, 1985.
16.
LondonM.GhaffariK.Munchausen's Syndrome and Drug Dependence, British Journal of Psychiatry, 149:651–654, 1986.
17.
RiesR. K.DSM-III Differential Diagnosis of Munchausen's Syndrome, Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 168:629–632, 1980.
18.
American Psychiatric Association Task Force on DSM-IV, DSM-IV Options Boole-Work in Progress, American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C., pp. J:1–J:2, 1991.
19.
CocoresJ. A.SantaW. G.PatelM. D.The Ganser Syndrome: Evidence Suggesting Its Classification as a Dissociative Disorder, International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 14:47–56, 1984.
20.
TothE. L.BaggaleyA.Coexistence of Munchausen's Syndrome and Multiple Personality Disorder: Detailed Report of a Case and Theoretical Discussion, Psychiatry, 54:176–183, 1991.
21.
SteinbergM.Commentary on Toth and Baggaley, Psychiatry, 54:184–186.
22.
GoodwinJ.Munchausen Syndrome as a Dissociative Disorder, Dissociation, 1:54–60, 1988.
23.
HylerS. E.SussmanN.Chronic Factitious Disorder with Physical Symptoms (The Munchausen Syndrome), Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 4:365–377, 1981.
24.
MeadowR., Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy: The Hinterland of Child Abuse, Lancet, pp. 343–345, 1977.
25.
MeadowR.LennertT.Munchausen by Proxy or Polle syndrome: Which Term is Correct?, Pediatrics, 74:554–556, 1984.
26.
McGuireT. L.FeldmanK. W.Psychologic Morbidity of Children Subjected to Munchausen by Proxy, Pediatrics, 83:289–292, 1989.
27.
KrenerP.AdelmanR.Parent Salvage and Parent Sabotage in the Care of Chronically Ill Children, American Journal of Diseases of Children, 142:945–951, 1988.
28.
RosenbergD. A.Web of Deceit: A Literature Review of Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy, Child Abuse and Neglect, 2:547–563, 1987.
29.
GriffithJ. L.SlovikL. S.Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy and Sleep Disorders Medicine, Sleep, 12:178–183, 1989.
30.
MeadowR.Munchausen by Proxy and Brain Damage, Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology, 26:672–674, 1984.
31.
MillsR. W.BurkeS., Gastrointestinal Bleeding in a 15 Month Old Male A Presentation of Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy, Clinical Pediatrics, 29:474–477, 1990.
32.
CroftR. D.JervisM.Munchausen's Syndrome in a 4 Year Old, Archives of Disease in Childhood, 63:740–741, 1989.
33.
GriffithJ. L.The Family Systems of Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy, Family Process, 27:423–437, 1988.
34.
SigalM.GelkopfM.MeadowR. S.Munchausen by Proxy Syndrome: The Triad of Abuse, Self Abuse and Deception, Comprehensive Psychiatry, 30:527–533, 1989.
35.
MoneyJ.AnnecilloC.HutchisonJ. W.Forensic and Family Psychiatry in Abuse Dwarfism: Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy, Atonement, and Addiction to Abuse, Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy, 11:30–40, 1985.
36.
MehlA. L.CobleL.JohnsonS.Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy: A Family Affair, Child Abuse and Neglect, 14:577–585, 1990.
37.
MastersonJ.DunworthR.WilliamsN.Extreme Illness Exaggeration in Pediatric Patients: A Variant of Munchausen's by Proxy?, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 58:188–195, 1988.
38.
MoneyJ.Paleodigms and Paleodigmatics: A New Theoretical Construct Applicable to Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy, Child-Abuse Dwarfism, Paraphilias, Anorexia Nervosa and Other Syndromes, American Journal of Psychotherapy, 43: 15–24, 1989.
39.
KaufmanK. L.CouryD.PickrelE.McCleeryJ.Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy: A Survey of Professionals Knowledge, Child Abuse and Neglect, 13:141–147, 1989.
40.
YorkerB. C.KahanB. B.Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy as a Form of Child Abuse, Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 4:313–318, 1990.
41.
MantheiD. J.PierceR. L.RothbaumR. J.MantheiU.KeatingJ. P.Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy: Covert Child Abuse, Journal of Family Violence, 3:131–140, 1980.
AbeK.ShinozimaK.OkunoA.Munchausen's Syndrome in Children: Bizarre Clinical and Laboratory Findings, Acta Paediatrica Japonica, 26:539–543, 1984.
44.
SapiraJ.Munchausen's Syndrome and the Technologic Imperative, Southern Medical Journal, 74:193–196, 1981.
45.
ZitelliB. J.SeltmanM. F.ShannonR. M.Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy and Its Professional Participants, American Journal of Diseases of Children, 141:1099–1101, 1987.
46.
FrostJ. D.GlazeD. G.RosenC. L.Munchausen's Syndrome by Proxy and Video Surveillance, American Journal of Diseases of Children, 142:917–918, 1988.
47.
ZitelliB. J.SeltmanM. F.ShannonR. M.In Reply (letter), American Journal of Diseases of Children, 142:918, 1988.
48.
KassF. C.Identification of Persons with Munchausen's Syndrome: Ethical Problems, General Hospital Psychiatry, 7:195–200, 1985.
49.
MerepolN.FordC.ZanerR.Factitious Illness: An Exploration in Ethics, Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 28:269–281, 1985.
50.
SadlerJ. Z.Ethical and Management Considerations in Factitious Illness: One and the Same, General Hospital Psychiatry, 9:31–36, 1987.
51.
FordC. V.ZanerR. M.Response to the Article: “Ethical and Management Considerations in Factitious Illness: One and the Same,” by John Z. Sadler, General Hospital Psychiatry, 9:37, 1987.
52.
SutherlandA. J.RodinG. M.Factitious Disorders in a General Hospital Setting: Clinical Features and a Review of the Literature, Psychosomatics, 31:392–399, 1990.
53.
ReichP.GottfriedL. A.Factitious Disorders in a Teaching Hospital, Annals of Internal Medicine, 99:240–247, 1983.
54.
AduanR. P.FauciA. S.DaleD. C.Factitious Fever and Self Induced Infection, Annals of Internal Medicine, 90:340–342, 1979.
55.
SogiC.WarthonD.MezzichJ.Comparative Distributions of DSM-III Diagnoses in North and South American Clinical Samples, British Journal of Psychiatry, 154(suppl.4):91–95, 1989.
56.
FinkP.JensenJ.Clinical Characteristics of the Munchausen Syndrome: A Review and New Case Histories, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 52:164–171, 1989.
57.
GrunbergerG.WeinerJ. L.SilvermanR.Factitious Hypoglycemia Due to Surreptitious Administration of Insulin, Annals of Internal Medicine, 108:240–247, 1988.
58.
SavardG.AndermannF.TeitelbaumJ.LehmannH.Epileptic Munchausen's Syndrome: A Form of Pseudoseizures Distinct from Hysteria and Malingering, Neurology, 38:1628–1629, 1988.
59.
BurstenB.On Munchausen's Syndrome, Archives of General Psychiatry, 13:261–268, 1965.
60.
NadelsonT.The Munchausen Spectrum, General Hospital Psychiatry, 1:11–17, 1979.
61.
EisendrathS., Factitious Physical Disorders: Treatment Without Confrontation, Psychosomatics, pp. 383–387, 1989.
62.
McFarlandB. H.ResnickM.BloomJ. D.Ensuring Continuity of Care for a Munchausen Patient Through a Public Guardian, Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 34:65–67, 1983.
63.
SchlesingerR. D.DanielD. G.RabinP.JackR.Factitious Disorder with Physical Manifestations: Pitfalls of Diagnosis and Management, Southern Medical Journal, 82:210–214, 1989.
64.
SolyomC.SolyomL.A Treatment Program for Functional Paraplegia/Munchausen Syndrome, Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 21:225–230, 1990.
65.
KlonoffE.YoungerS. J.MooreD. J.HersheyL. A.Chronic Factitious Illness: A Behavioral Approach, International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 13:173–183, 1983.
66.
BhugraD.Psychiatric Munchausen's Syndrome: Literature Review with Case Reports, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavia, 77:497–503, 1988.
67.
CocoresJ. A.SchlesingerL.GoldM. S.A Review of the EEG Literature on Ganser's Syndrome, International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine, 16:59–65, 1986.
68.
FenelonG.MahieuxF.RoulletE.GuillardA., Munchausen's Syndrome and Abnormalities on Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Brain, BMJ, 302:996–997, 1991.
69.
SmithN. J.ArdernM. H.‘More in Sickness Than in Health’: A Case Study of Munchausen by Proxy in the Elderly, Journal of Family Therapy, 11:321–334, 1989.
70.
MillerF.WeidenP.SacksM.WozniakJ.Two Cases of Factitious AIDS (letter), American Journal of Psychiatry, 143:1483, 1986.
71.
BaerJ. W.Case Report: Munchausen's/AIDS, General Hospital Psychiatry, 9:75–76, 1987.
72.
RobinsonE. N.LathamR. H.A Factitious Case of Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome, Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 14:54–57, 1987.
