No body of literature exists related specifically to the occupational health of airport check-in workers. The problems encountered by airport check-in workers are typical of other service-sector occupations with similar work-related health hazards, particularly those characterized by a high level of demand with low worker control, performed predominantly by women. The knowledge gap could be narrowed by broadening the scope in both traditional occupational health and ergonomics studies to take into equal consideration jobs performed by women. In an attempt to reduce the knowledge gap specific to airport check-in workers, literature was reviewed on several other worker populations whose job characteristics include elements similar to airport check-in work: computer clerical workers, supermarket check-in workers, and airport baggage handlers. This cross-population review identified the major elements that have been studied in the comparison groups, compared with the factors examined in a study of check-in workers. The review demonstrates that jobs that may appear completely different from the outside, might, upon closer examination, have numerous common exposures from a variety of sources. Thus, knowledge about one job may be useful for another that has not been investigated. The literature review reveals that it would be useful to extend to airport check-in workers recommendations from studies of the three comparison populations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
RosskamE., Working at the Check-in: Consequences for Worker Health and Management Practices, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, 2003.
2.
BoydC. and BainP., A Summary of the Findings from the Cabin Crew Health and Working Environment Survey, University of Strathclyde, United Kingdom, in collaboration with Transport and General Workers Union and BASSA, 1999.
3.
KarasekR. and TheorellT., Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity and the Reconstruction of Working Life, Basic Books, New York, 1991.
4.
KarasekR., Control in the Workplace and Its Health-Related Aspects, in Job Control and Worker Health, SauterS. L.HurrellJ. J., and CooperC. (eds.), John Wiley and Sons, Chichester, pp. 129–159, 1989.
5.
World Health Organization, Work with Visual Display Terminals: Psychosocial Aspects and Health, Journal of Occupational Medicine, 31, pp. 957–968, 1989.
6.
World Health Organization, Visual Display Terminals and Workers Health, in WHO Offset Publication No. 99, Geneva, 1987.
7.
KarlqvistL., A Process for the Development, Specification and Evaluation of VDU Work Tables, Applied Ergonomics, 29(6), pp. 423–432, 1998.
8.
BettendorfR. F.HoffmanM. S.AdamsE.McLooneH., and PurvisC. J., The OERC Framework for Understanding Upper-Extremity Musculoskeletal Disorders Research, Theory and Management, paper presented at The National Ergonomics Conference and Exhibition, New York, May 1998.
9.
SmithM., Psychosocial Aspects of Working with Video Display Terminals (VDTs) and Employee Physical and Mental Health, Ergonomics, 40(10), pp. 1002–1015, 1997.
10.
CarayonP.YangC.-L., and LimS.-Y., Examining the Relationship Between Job Design and Worker Strain Over Time in a Sample of Office Workers, Ergonomics, 38(6), pp. 1199–1211, 1995.
11.
WestlanderG., The Full-Time VDT Operator as a Working Person: Musculoskeletal Work Discomfort and Life Situation, International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 6(4), pp. 339–364, 1994.
12.
CarayonP., Job Design and Job Stress in Office Workers, Ergonomics, 36(5), pp. 463–477, 1993.
13.
Carayon-SainfortP., The Use of Computers in Offices: Impact on Task Characteristics and Worker Stress, International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction, 4(3), pp. 245–261, 1992.
14.
SauterS. L.SchleiferL. M., and KnutsonS. J., Work Posture, Workstation Design, and Musculoskeletal Discomfort in a VDT Data Entry Task, Human Factors, 33(2), pp. 151–167, 1991.
15.
StathamA. and BravoE., The Introduction of New Technology: Health Implications for Workers, Women and Health, 16(2), pp. 105–129, 1990.
16.
SainfortP., Job Design Predictors of Stress in Automated Offices, Behaviour and Information Technology, 9(1), pp. 3–16, 1990.
17.
SauterS.DainoffM., and SmithM. (eds.), Promoting Health and Productivity in the Computerized Office, Taylor and Francis, London, 1990.
18.
SauterS. L.GottliebM. S.JonesK. C.DodsonV. N., and RohrerK. M., Job and Health Implications of VDT Use: Initial Results of the Wisconsin-NIOSH Study, Human Aspects of Computing, 26(4), pp. 284–294, 1983.
19.
SmithM. J.CohenB. G. F., and StammerjohnL. W.Jr., An Investigation of Health Complaints and Job Stress in Video Display Operations, Human Factors, 23(4), pp. 387–400, 1981.
20.
OngC-N.ChiaS-E.JeyaratnamJ., and TanK-C., Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Operators of Visual Display Terminals, Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 21, pp. 60–64, 1995.
21.
FaucettJ. and RempelD., VDT-Related Musculoskeletal Symptoms: Interactions Between Work Posture and Psychosocial Work Factors, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 26, pp. 597–612, 1994.
22.
MatiasA. C.SalvendyG., and KuczekT., Predictive Models of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Causation Among VDT Operators in Ergonomics, 41(2), pp. 213–226, 1998.
23.
ShahnavazH.AbeysekeraJ., and JohanssonA., Solving Multi-Factorial Work Environment Problems Through Participation: Case Study: VDT Operators, in The Ergonomics of Manual Work, MarrasW.KarwowskiW.SmithJ., and PacholskiL. (eds.), Taylor and Francis, London, pp. 499–502, 1993.
24.
MessingK. (ed.), Integrating Gender in Ergonomic Analysis: Strategies for Transforming Women's Work, European Trade Union Technical Bureau for Health and Safety, Brussels, 1999.
25.
MessingK., One-Eyed Science: Occupational Health and Women Workers, Temple University Press, Philadelphia, 1998.
26.
MessingK.ChatignyC., and CourvilleJ., Light and Heavy Work in the Housekeeping Service of a Hospital, Applied Ergonomics, 29(6), pp. 451–459, 1998.
27.
HauflerA. J.FeuersteinM., and HuangG. D., Job Stress, Upper Extremity Pain and Functional Limitations in Symptomatic Computer Users, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 38, pp. 507–515, 2000.
28.
YuI. T. S. and WongT. W., Musculoskeletal Problems Among VDU Workers in a Hong Kong Bank, Occupational Medicine, 46(4), pp. 275–280, 1996.
29.
OngC. N.ChiaS. E.JeyaratnamJ., and TanK. C., Technological Change and Work-Related Musculoskeletal Disorders: A Study of VDU Operators in Towards Human Work: Solutions to Problems in Occupational Health and Safety, KumashiroM. and MegawE. (eds.), Taylor and Francis, London, pp. 333–339, 1991.
30.
HochschildA., The Managed Heart: Commercialization of Human Feeling, University of California Press, San Francisco, 1983.
31.
HalesT. R.SauterS. L.PetersonM. R.FineL. J.Putz-AndersonV.SchleiferL. R.OchsT. T., and BernardB. P., Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Visual Display Terminal Users in a Telecommunication Company, Ergonomics, 37(10), pp. 1603–1621, 1994.
32.
SmithM. J. and SainfortP. C., A Balance Theory of Job Design for Stress Reduction, International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 4, pp. 67–79, 1989.
33.
JohanssonA.JohanssonG.LundqvistP.AkessonI.OdenrickP., and AkselssonR., Evaluation of a Workplace Redesign of a Grocery Checkout System, Applied Ergonomics, 29(4), pp. 261–266, 1998.
34.
DasB. and SenguptaA., Industrial Workstation Design: A Systematic Ergonomics Approach, Applied Ergonomics, 27(3), pp. 157–163, 1996.
35.
CarrascoC.ColemanN.HealeyS., and LustedM., Packing Products for Customers: An Ergonomics Evaluation of Three Supermarket Checkouts, Applied Ergonomics, 26(2), pp. 101–108, 1995.
36.
GrantK.HabesD. J., and BaronS. L., An Ergonomics Evaluation of Cashier Work Activities at Checker-Unload Workstations, Applied Ergonomics, 25(5), pp. 310–318, 1994.
37.
HinnenU.LaubliT.GuggenbuhlU., and KruegerH., Design of Check-Out Systems Including Laser Scanners for Sitting Work Posture, Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 18(3), pp. 186–194, 1992.
38.
NiedhammerI.LandreM. F.LeClercA.BourgeoisF.FranchiP.ChastangJ. F.MarignacG.MereauP.QuintonD.Du NoyerC. R.SchmausA., and VallayerC., Shoulder Disorders Related to Work Organization and Other Occupational Factors Among Supermarket Cashiers, International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health, 4(3), pp. 168–178, 1998.
39.
VézinaM.GeoffrionL.ChatignyC., and MessingK., A Manual Materials Handling Job: Symptoms and Working Conditions Among Supermarket Cashiers, Chronic Diseases in Canada, 15(1), pp. 17–22, 1994.
40.
ToonS., Service Industries Say Safety Plays Key Role in Putting Customer First, Occupational Health and Safety, 62(11), pp. 61–69, 1993.
41.
OrgelD.MillironM., and FrederickL., Musculoskeletal Discomfort in Grocery Express Checkstand Workers: An Ergonomic Intervention Study, Journal of Occupational Medicine, 34(8), pp. 815–818, 1992.
42.
HarberP.BloswickD.LuoJ.BeckJ.GreerD., and PenaL. F., Work-Related Symptoms and Checkstand Configuration: An Experimental Study, American Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 54(7), pp. 371–376, 1993.
GrantK. and HabesD., An Analysis of Scanning Postures Among Grocery Cashiers and Its Relationship to Checkstand Design, Ergonomics, 38(10), pp. 2078–2090, 1995.
45.
RandleI. and NicholsonA., Cashier Workstation Audit and Re-Design for Halifax PLC, The Safety and Health Practitioner, 17(7), pp. 50–52, 1999.
46.
BohrP. C.EvanoffB. A., and WolfL. D., Implementing Participatory Ergonomics Teams Among Health Care Workers, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 32, pp. 190–196, 1997.
47.
FredrikssonK.AlfredssonL.ThorbjornssonC. B.PunnettL.ToomingasA.TorgenM., and KilbomA., Risk Factors for Neck and Shoulder Disorders: A Nested Case-Control Study Covering a 24-Year Period, American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 38, pp. 516–528, 2000.
48.
SynnermanJ. E. and ClaridgeN., The Work Environment Conditions of Civil Aviation Ground Staff, Ergo Management AB, Stockholm, p. 238, 1984.
49.
RibakJ.ClineB., and FroomP., Common Accidents Among Airport Ground Personnel, Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 66(12), pp. 1188–1190, 1995.
50.
Air Transport Association of America, Report of the Air Transport Association Facility Planning Guidelines: Baggage Handling, Passenger Loading Bridges, Preconditioned Air Systems, Ground Power Systems, BNP Associates, Inc., Ct. USA, September 1998.
51.
BuckleP. W.StubbsD. A.RandleI. P. M., and NicholsonA. S., Limitations in the Application of Materials Handling Guidelines, Ergonomics, 35(9), pp. 955–964, 1992.
52.
ReddellC. R.CongletonJ. J.HuchingsonR. D., and MontgomeryJ. F., An Evaluation of a Weightlifting Belt and Back Injury Prevention Training Class for Airline Baggage Handlers, Applied Ergonomics, 23(5), pp. 319–329, 1992.
53.
RuckertA.RohmertW., and PresselG., Ergonomic Research Study on Aircraft Luggage Handling, Ergonomics, 35(9), pp. 997–1012, 1992.
54.
ScheierR., Airlines Confront a Ground-Level Safety Problem, Safety and Health, 144(1), pp. 64–68, 1991.
55.
UndeutschK.KupperR.LowenthalI.GartnerK. H.LuopajarviT.RauterbergK.KarvonenM. J., and RutenfranzJ., Occupational Health Studies on Airport Transport Workers—III. Musculoskeletal Complaints and Orthopedic Disorders of Airport Transport Workers, International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 50(1), pp. 59–75, 1982.
56.
UndeutschK.GartnerK. H.LuopajarviT.KupperR.KarvonenM. J.LowenthalI., and RutenfranzJ., Back Complaints and Findings in Transport Workers Performing Physically Heavy Work, Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment Health, 8(1), pp. 92–96, 1982.
57.
KarvonenM. J.MainzerJ.RohmertW.LowenthalI.UndeutschK.KupperR.GartnerK. H., and RutenfranzJ., Occupational Health Studies on Airport Transport Workers—II. Muscle Strength of Airport Transport Workers, International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health, 47(3), pp. 233–244, 1980.
58.
DiebschlagW.HeidingerF.KurzB.LowenthalI.RohmertW., and RuckertA., Measurement of Actual Forces During Luggage and Pallet Handling at a Large Airport in Arbeitsmedizin-Sozialmedizin-Praventivmedizin, 24(5), pp. 98–105, 1989.
59.
FroomP.ClineB., and RibakJ., Disease Evaluated on Return-to-Work Examinations: Aviation Ground Personnel Compared to Other Workers, Clinical Medicine, 67(4), pp. 361–363, 1996.
60.
RuckertA. and RohmertW., Evaluation of Manual Load Handling in Confined Spaces, Arbeitsmedizin-Sozialmedizin-Praventivmedizin, 26(2), pp. 58–63, 1991.
61.
RohmertW.LowenthalI., and RuckertA., Workload and Physiological Strain Caused by Baggage Handling at a Large Airport, Arbeitsmedizin-Sozialmedizin-Praventivmedizin, 24(3), pp. 47–52, 1989.
62.
ChanlatJ. F., Nouveaux modes de gestion, stress professionnel et santé au travail, in L'homme à l'echine plié [New methods of management, occupational stress and occupational health, in “The man with the bent spine”], BrunsteinI. (ed.), Desclee de Brouwer, pp. 29–60, 2000.
63.
The United States National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Cumulative Trauma Disorders in the Workplace, NIOSH, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, NIOSH Publication No. 95–119, 1995.
64.
ChappellD. and Di MartinoV., Violence at Work, International Labour Office, Geneva, 2000.
65.
ChenierE., The Workplace: A Battleground for Violence, Public Personnel Management, 27(4), pp. 557–568, 1998.
66.
ManuabaA., Appropriate Technology Approach with Its “Built-in” Ergonomics Aspect is a Must in Technology Transfer to Attain Sustainable Development in Industrially Developing Countries, in Global Ergonomics, ScottP. A.BridgerR. S., and CharterisJ. (eds.), Elsevier, Oxford, pp. 57–62, 1998.
67.
KogiK. and SenR. N., Third World Ergonomics, International Reviews of Ergonomics, 1, pp. 77–118, 1987.
68.
SenR. N., Application of Ergonomics to Industrially Developing Countries, Ergonomics, 27(10), pp. 1021–1032, 1984.
69.
International Transport Workers' Federation, Air Rage: The Prevention and Management of Disruptive Passenger Behaviour, Safety in Practice, 1, London, May 2000.
70.
HagbergM. and WegmanD., Prevalence Rates and Odds Ratios of Shoulder-Neck Diseases in Different Occupational Groups, British Journal of Industrial Medicine, 44, pp. 602–610, 1987.
71.
EkbergK.BjorkqvistB.MalmP.Bjerre-KielyB.KarlssonM., and AxelsonO., Case-Control Study of Risk Factors for Disease in the Neck and Shoulder Area, Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 51, pp. 262–266, 1994.
