Instrumental and Expressive Learning: Some Comparisons

Abstract

Preferences for and learning activity in instrumental (basic or skill mastery) and expressive (enjoyment or self-fulfillment) education are examined. Interviews with 256 Nebraskans, fifty-five or older, provided information to examine hypotheses of 1) greater preference for instrumental learning (supported), 2) no preference differences according to age, sex, and location groupings (partially supported), 3) predicted preference for expressive learning by white collar workers and college graduates (not supported), and 4) no preference differences according to race, marital status, and social class groupings (partially supported). Comparisons with earlier (1972) data are included; an increased overall preference for instrumental education was found.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hiemstra

R. P.

, Educational Planning for Older Adults: A Survey of Expressive Vs. Instrumental Preferences, International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 4, pp. 147–156, 1973.

Whatley

L. F.

, Expressive and Instrumental Educational Interests of Older Adults as Perceived by Adult Educators, Gerontologists, and Older Adults, unpublished masters thesis, University of Georgia, 1974.

Goodrow

B. A.

, The Perceived Learning Needs and Interests of the Elderly in Knox County, Tennessee, doctoral dissertation, University of Tennessee, University Microfilms, Ann Arbor, Mich., No. 75–11, p. 169, 1975.

Marcus

E. E.

, Effects of Age, Sex, and Socioeconomic Status on Adult Education Participants' Perception of the Utility of their Participation, unpublished doctoral, dissertation, University of Chicago, in press. Personal communications with the author provided a status report, June 27, 1975.

Tough

, The Adult's Learning Projects, Research in education series no. 1, The Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, Ontario, 1971.

Hiemstra

, The Older Adult and Learning, Department of Adult and Continuing Education, 105 Henzlik Hall, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Lincoln, Nebraska, 1975.