The comparison of nations' health systems requires some way of categorizing them. As distinct from the typologies of Roemer, Maxwell, and others, which offer no apparent theoretical derivation, the schema suggested here derives from theory of the capitalist political economic world-system as put forth by Wallerstein and others. With the worldwide division of labor entailed in this perspective (core, semi-periphery, and periphery), combined with the strengths of workers' movements, five types of nations' health systems are identified, and illustrative comparisons are made using the contrasting case studies method. The author also discusses seeming exceptions to the general rule of capitalist dependencies with weak workers' movements having inequitous inadequate health systems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
World Health Organization. Alma-Ata 1978, Primary Health Care, Geneva, 1978.
2.
KleczkowskiB. M.EllingR. H.SmithD. L.Health System Support for Primary Health Care. Public Health Monograph Series, No. 80. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1984.
3.
McKeownT.An historical appraisal of the medical task. In Medical History and Medical Care, edited by McLachlanG.McKeownT., pp. 29–57. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1971.
4.
HornJ. S.Away with All Pests: An English Surgeon in People's China. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1969.
5.
SidelV. W.SidelR.Serve the People: Observations on Medicine in the People's Republic of China. Josiah Macy, Jr. Foundation, New York, 1974.
6.
NavarroV.A critique of the ideological and political positions of the Willy Brandt Report and the WHO Alma-Ata Declaration. Soc. Sci. Med.18: 467–474, 1984.
7.
StarkR.Non-professional primary care workers: Sociopolitical issues in utilization. In Third World Medicine and Social Change, edited by MorganJ. H., pp. 229–239. Washington Press of America, Lanham, Md., 1983.
8.
ReedJ.Guatemalans try to escape “Mayan Gulag.”Guardian (New York, April 22, 1992, p. 13.
9.
HeggenhougenH. K.Will primary care be allowed to succeed?Soc. Sci. Med.19: 217–224, 1984.
10.
SigeristH. E.From Bismark to Beveridge: Developments and trends in social security legislation. Bull. Hist. Med.13: 365–388, April 1, 1943.
11.
MaxwellR.Health Care, The Growing Dilemma: Needs Versus Resources in Western Europe, the U.S., and the U.S.S.R.McKinsey and Co., New York, 1974.
12.
RoemerM. I.Comparative National Policies on Health Care. Marcel Dekker, New York, 1977.
13.
RoemerM. I. with KleczkowskiB. M.Van De WerffS.National Health Systems and their Reorientation Towards Health for All. Public Health Papers Series, No. 77. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1984.
14.
RoemerM. I.Analysis of health services systems—A general approach. In Reorienting Health Services, edited by PennenborgC. O.Plenum, New York, 1984.
15.
TerrisM.The three world systems of medical care: Trends and prospects. Am. J. Public Health68: 1125–1131, 1978.
16.
FulcherD.Medical Care Systems: Public and Private Health Coverage in Selected Industrialized Countries. International Labor Organization, Geneva, 1974.
17.
SimanisJ. G.National Health Systems in Eight Countries. DHEW Publication No. (SSA) 75-11924. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1975.
18.
MohanJ.WoodsK. J.Restructuring health care: The social geography of public and private health care under the British Conservative Government. Int. J. Health Serv. 15: 197–215, 1985.
19.
EstesC. L.Austerity and aging in the United States: 1980 and beyond. Int. J. Health Serv. 12: 573–584, 1982.
20.
RoemerM. I.National Health Systems of the World (two volumes). Oxford University Press, New York, 1991.
21.
RoemerM. I.National Strategies for Health Care Organizations: A World Overview. Health Administration Press, Ann Arbor, Mich., 1985.
22.
NavarroV.Social Security and Medicine in the U.S.S.R.: A Marxist Critique. Lexington Books, Lexington, Mass., 1977.
23.
EllingR. H.Cross-National Study of Health Systems, Political Economies and Health Care. Transaction Books, New Brunswick, N.J., 1980.
24.
FuchsV.Who Shall Live: Health, Economics and Social Choice. Basic Books, New York, 1974.
25.
FieldM. G.Soviet Socialized Medicine. Free Press, New York, 1967.
26.
MechanicD.Ideology, medical technology, and health care organization in modern nations. Am. J. Public Health65: 241–247, 1975.
27.
RaffelM. W. (ed.). Comparative Health Systems: Descriptive Analyses of Fourteen National Health Systems. Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, Pa., 1984.
28.
FryJ.FarndaleW. A. V. (eds.). International Medical Care. Washington Square East Publishers, Wallingford, Pa., 1972.
29.
Douglas-WilsonI.MacLachlandG. (eds.). Health Service Prospects: An International Survey. Little Brown, Boston, 1973.
30.
AndersonO. W.Health Care: Can There Be Equity? The United States, Sweden and England. Wiley, New York, 1972.
31.
SidelV. W.SidelR.A Healthy State, revised and updated edition. Pantheon, New York, 1983.
32.
PflanzM.Social structure and health: Methodological and substantive problems without solutions. In Health, Medicine and Society, Part III, edited by SokolowskaM.D. Reidel, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, and PWN-Polish Scientific Publishers, Warsaw, 1976.
33.
SilverG. A.Virchow, the heroic model in medicine: Health policy by accolade. Am. J. Public Health77: 82–88, 1987.
34.
MarxK.EngelsF.The Communist Manifesto. International Publishers, New York, 1960 [1849].
35.
PivenF. F.ClowardR. A.Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Relief. Pantheon, New York, 1971.
36.
CeresetoS.WaitzkinH.Capitalism, socialism, and the physical quality of life. Int. J. Health Serv. 16: 643–658, 1986.
37.
BravemanP.SiegelD.Nicaragua: A health system developing under conditions of war. Int. J. Health Serv. 17: 169–178, 1987.
38.
de BrunS.EllingR. H.Cuba and the Philippines: Contrasting cases in world-system analysis. Int. J. Health Serv. 17: 681–701, 1987.
39.
DixonM.Dual power: The rise of the transnational corporation and the nation state; Conceptual explanations to meet popular demand. Contemporary Marxism5: 129–146, 1982.
40.
EllingR. H.The capitalist world-system and international health. Int. J. Health Serv. 11: 21–52, 1981.
41.
WallersteinI.The Modern World-System I: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century. Academic Press, New York, 1974.
42.
WallersteinI.The Modern World-System II: Mercantilism and the Consolidation of the European World-Economy, 1600–1750. Academic Press, New York, 1980.
43.
WallersteinI.The Modern World-System III: The Second Era of Great Expansion of the Capitalist World-Economy, 1730–1840s. Academic Press, New York, 1989.
44.
FrankA. G.The development of under-development. In Dependence and Underdevelopment, edited by Cockroft, pp. 3–17. Doubleday, New York, 1972.
45.
O'BrienJ., with assistance from el ShazaliS. E.The Political Economy of Development and Underdevelopment, An Introduction. Development Studies and Research Centre, University of Khartoum, Khartoum, 1979.
46.
CardosoF.FalettoE.Dependency and Development in Latin America. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1979.
47.
BellD.Coming of Post Industrial Society: A Venture in Social Forecasting. Basic Books, New York, 1976.
48.
BellD.Talk presented at Sociological Visions, A Celebration of 115 Years of Sociology at Yale. Whitney Humanities Center, Yale University, New Haven, April 5, 1992.
49.
NavarroV.The limits of the world-systems theory in defining capitalist and socialist formations. Sci. Soc.46: 77–90, 1982.
50.
SimsB.Workers of the World Undermined. South End Press, Boston, 1992.
51.
JaleeP.The Pillage of the Third World. Monthly Review Press, New York, 1968.
52.
NavarroV.The economic and political determinants of human (including health) rights. Int. J. Health Serv. 8: 145–168, 1978.
53.
SklarH.Trilateralism: The Trilateral Commission and Elite Planning for World Management. South End Press, Boston, 1980.
54.
GreenhouseS.I.M.F. is found to spur growth at social cost. New York Times, March 10, 1992.
55.
GramsciA.The modern prince. In Prison Notebook, edited by HoareQ.NorwellG., Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1972 [circa 1922].
56.
SassoonA. S.Gramsci's Politics. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, 1987.
57.
WaitzkinH.The micropolitics of medicine: A contextual analysis. Int. J. Health Serv. 14: 339–378, 1984.
58.
WaitzkinH.BrittT.Changing the structure of medical discourse: Implications of cross-national comparisons. J. Health Soc. Behav.30: 436–449, 1989.
59.
BarnetR. J.MullerR. E.Global Reach: The Power of the Multinational Corporations. Simon & Schuster, New York, 1974.
60.
EllingR. H.The Struggle for Workers' Health, A Study of Six Industrialized Countries. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 1986.
61.
KorpiW.ShalevM.Strikes, industrial relations and class conflict in capitalist societies. Br. J. Soc.30: 164–187, 1979.
62.
ShalevM.KorpiW.Working class modernization and American exceptionalizm. Econ. Ind. Democracy.1: 31–61, 1980.
63.
AronowitzS.Working Class Hero: A New Strategy for Labor. Pilgrim Press, New York, 1983.
64.
GreenJ.The World of the Workers: Labor in Twentieth-Century America. Hill and Wang, New York, 1980.
65.
SchatzR.The Electrical Workers: A History of Labor at General Electric and Westinghouse, 1923–1960. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, Ill., 1984.
66.
ReichR.FrumkinH.An overview of Japanese occupational health. Am. J. Public Health78: 809–813, 1988.
67.
HalberstamD.The Reckoning. Avon, New York, 1987.
68.
SonodaK.Health and Illness in Changing Japanese Society. University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 1988.
69.
PowellM.AnesakiM.Health Care in Japan. Routledge, New York, 1990.
70.
Chase-DunnK. (ed.). Socialist States in the World-System. Sage, Beverly Hills, Calif., 1982.
71.
NagiM. H.The health care system in Kuwait: A social welfare perspective. In Third World Medicine and Social Change, edited by MorganJ. H., pp. 157–171. University Press of America, Lanham, Md., 1983.
72.
ZayedM.Contrasting Case Studies of National Health Systems in Arab Countries. Required student research paper, University of Connecticut Medical School, Farmington, Conn., 1977.
73.
United Nations Children's Fund. The State of the World's Children. Oxford University Press, Oxford, England, 1992.
74.
HallidayF.Arabia Without Sultans. Penguin, Baltimore, Md., 1974.
75.
WheenF. (eds.). World View 1982. South End Press, Boston, 1982.
76.
TissierP.South Korea: An oppressed people, a “model” in crisis. In World View 1982, pp. 144–146. South End Press, Boston, 1982.
77.
SivardR.World Military and Social Expenditures, 1987–1988. World Priorities, Washington, D.C., 1988.
78.
CareyG. W.FischmanJ.Costa Rica. In Volume Library, pp. 2135–2136. Southwestern Co., Nashville, 1974.
79.
MorganL. M.Health without wealth? Costa Rica's health system under economic crisis. J. Public Health Policy8: 86–105, 1987.
80.
EllingR. H.Political influences on research methods. In Cross-National Sociomedical Research: Concepts, Methods, Practice, edited by PflanzM.SchachE., pp. 144–155; 170–172. Thieme, Stuttgart, 1976.
81.
MaxwellR.Health and Wealth—An International Study of Health Spending. Lexington Books, Lexington, Mass., 1981.
82.
BlackD.Inequalities in Health (The Black Report). Penguin, Harmondsworth, England, 1982.
83.
NewmanB.Socialized care: Frugal medical service keeps Britain healthy and patiently waiting. Wall Street J., February 9, 1983, pp. 1, 27.
84.
TomassonR.The mortality of Swedish and U.S. white males: A comparison of experience, 1969–1971. Am. J. Public Health66: 968–974, 1976.
85.
BerfenstamR.EllingR. H.Regional planning in Sweden: A social and medical problem. In Health: A Major Issue, edited by AskeyD. E., special issue of Scandinavian Rev. 63: 40–52, 1975.
86.
SivardR.World Military and Social Expenditures, 1974. WMSE Publications, Leesburg, Va., 1974.
87.
RatcliffeJ.Social justice and the demographic transition: Lessons from India's Kerala State. Int. J. Health Serv. 8: 123–144, 1978.
88.
PanikarP. G. K.SomanC. R.Health Status of Kerala: The Paradox of Economic Backwardness and Health Development. Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum, India, 1984.
89.
RoemerM. I.Primary health care and hospitalization: California and Cuba. Am. J. Public Health83: 317–318, 1993.
90.
WoodC. H.Infant mortality trends and capitalist development in Brazil: The case of Sao Paulo and Belo Horizonte. Latin Am. Perspect.4: 56–65, Fall 1977.
91.
LenaH. F.LondonB.The political and economic determinants of health outcomes: A cross-national analysis. Int. J. Health Serv. 23(3): 585–602, 1993.
