This article examines the transition of the private medical sector in Britain from a mere appendage to the National Health Service to a significant business sector involving multinational enterprise. The author argues that private medicine continues to be in a state of flux because its degree of independence is limited by its links to the dominant public sector, particularly with regard to staffing, and is still vulnerable to attacks from the opposition parties. Private medicine, despite rapid growth in the late 1970s, is beset by mounting costs and intense competition.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Association of Independent Hospitals. Nursing Homes Beds. London, November 1985.
2.
McPhersonK.CoulterA.StrattonI.Increasing use of private practice by patients in Oxford requiring common elective surgical operations. Br. Med. J.291: 797–799, 1985.
3.
GrantC.Private Health Care in the UK: A Review. Economist Intelligence Unit, London, 1985.
4.
AndersonJ. R.Business opportunities for construction companies. Speech at the Financial Times Conference on Private Health Care, March 1985.
5.
HildrewP.Fowler orders check on hospital queues. The Guardian, July 22, 1986.
6.
College of Health. Guide to Hospital Waiting Lists, 1985. London, November 1985.
7.
NichollJ. P.Contribution of the private sector to elective surgery in England and Wales. Lancet, July 14, 1984, pp. 89–92.
8.
Office of Population, Census and Surveys. General Household Survey 1982. London, June 1984.
9.
Public versus private provision: What people think. Public Money, December 1984, pp. 63–66.
10.
International Federation of Voluntary Health Service Funds. Conference Proceedings, September 4–8, 1972. London, 1972.
11.
PitcherG.A matter of life and luxury. Observer, April 27, 1986, p. 39.
12.
LarsonJ. G.The role of private enterprise in providing health care: Lessons of the American experience. National Westminster Bank Rev., November 1980, pp. 58–65.
13.
GoodmanJ. C.National Health Care in Great Britain: Lessons for the U.S.A.Fisher Institute, Dallas, Texas, 1980.
14.
LindsayC. M.National Health Issues: The British Experience. Hoffman La Roche Inc., 1980.
15.
SeldonA. (ed.) The Litmus Papers: A National Health Disservice. Centre for Policy Studies, London, 1980.
16.
Adam Smith Institute. Health and the Public Sector: A Report to the Minister of Health. London, 1981.
17.
BuchananJ. M.The Inconsistencies of the NHS. Institute of Economic Affairs, London, 1964.
18.
JewkesJ.JewkesS.The Genesis of the British National Health Service. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1962.
19.
LeesD. S.Health Through Choice. Institute of Economic Affairs, London, 1961.
20.
SeldonA.After the NHS. Institute of Economic Affairs, London, 1968.
21.
Adam Smith Institute. Privatisation Worldwide. London, 1986.
22.
Royal Commission on the National Health Service. Report (Cmnd 7615). Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, July 1977.
23.
Thatcher's think tank takes aim at the Welfare State. Economist, September 18, 1982, pp. 25–26.
24.
Hansard, March 21, 1984.
25.
Department of Health and Social Security. Health Service Development, Health Service Act 1980: Private Medical Practice in Health Service Hospitals and Control of Private Hospital Beds, DHSS HC (80)10. London, 1980.
26.
Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General on the Accounts. National Health Service Accounts. London, 1986.
27.
Press release from Frank Dobson, MP, July 24, 1986.
28.
Department of Health and Social Security. Management of Private Practice in Health Service Hospitals. London, 1986.
29.
GreenD.Which Doctor?: A Critical Analysis of the Professional Barriers to Competition in Health Care, Institute of Economic Affairs, London, 1985.
30.
Co-operation between the NHS and the private sector at district level. The Health Services, June 3, 1983, p. 5.
31.
WilliamsB. T.Will the NHS and private sector collaborate?Br. Med. J. July 5, 1982.
32.
LoshakD.Healing partnership with the NHS. Financial Times, June 7, 1985, p. 16.
33.
WestP. A.Sharing the costs of high technology: The economics of public and private cooperation. Hospital Health Serv. Rev., January 1986, pp. 15–17.
34.
AndersonF.Private management for St. Mary's. Health Soc. Serv. J., January 23, 1986, p. 95.
35.
BirchS.Policy implications of contracting out care: The case of total hip replacements. Hospital Health Serv. Rev.81(/): 281–284, 1985.
36.
RathwellT.SicsA.WilliamsS.Towards a New Understanding. Nuffield Centre for Health Services Research, Leeds, 1985.
37.
Hansard, June 10, 1985.
38.
Hansard, June 23, 1986.
39.
MinfordP.State expenditure: A study in waste. Economic Affairs (Supplement)4(3): i–xix, 1984.
40.
DavisD.Public Hospitals: Private Management. Adam Smith Institute, London, 1985.
41.
No Turning Back: A Radical Political Agenda from a Group of Conservative MPs. Conservative Political Centre, London, 1985.
42.
ElwellH.NHS lessons Norman Fowler has yet to hammer home. Daily Telegraph, October 26, 1983.
43.
BurtonJ.Why No Cuts? An Inquiry into the Fiscal Anarchy of Uncontrolled Government Expenditure, Hobart Paper No. 104. Institute for Economic Affairs, London, 1985.
44.
EnthovenA.Reflections on the Management of the National Health Service. Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, Oxford, 1985.
45.
EnthovenA.National Health Service: Some reforms that might be politically feasible. Economist, June 22, 1985, pp. 19–22.
46.
EnthovenA.Health Plan: The Only Practical Solution to the Soaring Cost of Medical Care. Addison Wesley Publishing, Reading, Mass., 1983.
47.
BosanquetN.GPs as firms: Creating an internal market for primary care. In. Health Care UK 1986, edited by HarrisonA.GrettonJ., pp. 65–68. Hermitage, Berks, 1986.
48.
MaynardA.Reassessing the NHS: Evaluation could be a blooming success. Health Soc. Serv. J., December 13, 1984, pp. 1467–1468.
49.
RichardsT.Medicine American style and the growth of HMOs. Br. Med. J.292: 330–332, 1986.
50.
RichardsT.HMOs: America today, Britain tomorrow. Br. Med. J.292: 392–394, 1986.
51.
Department of Health and Social Security. Primary Health Care: An Agenda for Discussion. Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1986.
52.
JohnsonP.Early exit for NHS's “Managing Director.”Br. Med. J.292: 1609, 1986.
53.
CulyerA. J.The NHS and the market: Images and realities. In The Public/Private Mix for Health, edited by MaynardA.McLachlanG., London Provincial Hospitals Trust, London, 1982.
54.
JohnsonP.Government condemned by its own statistics. Br. Med. J.293: 86, 1986.
55.
Social Democratic Party. Health and Associated Social Services. London, 1983.
56.
MeacherM. Speech at the Financial Times Conference on Private Health Care, March 1985.
57.
HenckeD.Labour vows to axe Health Service deals. The Guardian, April 18, 1986.
58.
Income Data Services. Private Health Insurance. London, June 1985.
59.
WoodL.Containment of costs is the main problem. Financial Times, January 22, 1986.
60.
KleberL.Corporate health care: Why a time bomb is fizzing in the U.S. Financial Times, June 2, 1986.
61.
VeitchA.Test tube babies “only for the rich.”The Guardian, April 24, 1986.
62.
TimminsN.Private health insurer to ban drug abuse and alcoholism patients. The Times (London), December 5, 1985.
63.
VeitchA.Hospitals told to stop kidney deals or close. The Guardian, June 11, 1986.
64.
PauleyR.Plea for a wider market. Financial Times, January 22, 1986, p. 17.
65.
MencherS.Private Practice in Britain: The Relationship of Private Medical Care to the National Health Service, Occasional Papers in Social Administration. G. Bell and Sons, London, 1967.
66.
House of Commons Employment and Social Services Sub-Committee of the Expenditure Committee. National Health Facilities for Private Patients, London, 1972.
67.
RaynerG.Pay-beds. Public Money, December 1984.
68.
Parliamentary Questions, February 4, 1985.
69.
Independent Medical Care, February/March 1984.
70.
DodsworthT.For-profit hospitals feel the pinch. Financial Times, January 22, 1986.
71.
SandisonC. R.Using the stock market to fund private hospital projects. Br. J. Hospital Med. 23 (4): 400, 1980.
72.
HallW.AMI sees loss after $175 million write-off. Financial Times, March 15, 1986.
73.
British United Provident Association. Private Medicine: The Facts. London, October 1983.
74.
Department of Environment. Circular22/80. London, 1980.
75.
Department of Environment. Circular2/81. London, 1981.
76.
Hansard, April 4, 1985.
77.
GoldsmithJ. C., Can Hospitals Survive? The New Competitive Health Care Market. Dow Jones-Irwin, Homewood, Ill., 1981.
78.
SchwartzW. B.AaronH. J.Rationing health care: Lessons from Britain. N. Engl. J. Med.310: 52–56, 1984.
79.
Economic Models Ltd. The British Health Care System. American Medical Association, Chicago, Ill., 1976.
