New Patterns in Health Sector Aid to India

Abstract

Criticisms of health aid have largely been derived from African and Latin American experiences. It is suggested that such analyses, while valuable, cannot be applied wholesale to India without detailed examination of the patterns of health sector aid which have actually characterized the period since 1947. This article brings together material on the scale and form that this assistance has taken, and demonstrates that its focus has been preventive in emphasis and oriented towards the primary care sector. In some periods it has contributed a substantial share of total public sector expenditures, and in some spheres, it has played a major role, particularly the control of communicable diseases. However, the impact of less substantial sums going to prestige medical colleges or to population control programs should not be ignored; and several of the aid categories have been of dubious origin (PL-480 counterpart funds and U.S. food surpluses as the prime examples). However, the “new” health aid programs do not deserve the ready dismissal they have received in some quarters.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Banerji

Book review. Economic and Political Weekly 16: 129, January 26, 1981.

Kocher

J. E.

Population Policy in India. Pop. Dev. Rev. 6(4): 299–310, 1980.

Block

Beyond relative autonomy. Socialist Register, pp. 227–242, 1980.

Harris

The state and the economy. Socialist Register, pp. 243–262, 1980.

Cole-King

Health Sector Aid from Voluntary Agencies: The British Case Study. Discussion paper 97, Institute of Development Studies, Brighton, UK, 1976.

White

British Official Aid in the Health Sector. Discussion Paper 107. Institute of Development Studies, Brighton, UK, 1977.

Gish

Doctor Migration and World Health. Bell, London, 1971.

Gish

Medical brain drain revisited. Int. J. Health Serv. 6(2): 175–189, 1976.

Jeffery

Recognizing India's doctors: The establishment of medical dependency, 1918–1939. Modern Asian Studies 13(2): 301–326, 1979.

10.

Doyal

The Political Economy of Health, pp. 266–273, Merlin Press, London, 1979.

11.

Cleaver

Malaria, the politics of public health and the international crisis. Review of Radical Political Economy 9(1): 81–103, 1977.

12.

Roxborough

Theories of Underdevelopment. Macmillan, London, 1979.

13.

Warren

Imperialism. New Left Books, London, 1980.

14.

Foster-Carter

The modes of production controversy. New Left Review 107: 95–120, 1978.

15.

Worsley

One world or three. Socialist Register, pp. 298–338, 1980.

16.

Alavi

India and the colonial mode of production. Socialist Register, pp. 273–302, 1975.

17.

Alavi

Structures of colonial formation. Economic and Political Weekly, 16: 475–486, 1981.

18.

Frankenberg

Allopathic medicine, profession and capitalist ideology in India. Soc. Sci. Med. 13(1): 75–84, 1981.

19.

Jeffery

The state and primary health care in India. Paper presented at the IXth Congress of the International Sociological Association, Uppsala, July, 1978.

20.

Briscoe

Are voluntary agencies helping to improve health in Bangladesh?

Int. J. Health Serv. 10(1): 47–69, 1980.

21.

Banerji

Health as a lever for another development. Development Dialogue, pp. 19–25, 1978.

22.

Chowdhury

The paramedics of Savar: An experiment in community health in Bangladesh. Development Dialogue 1978(1): 41–50, 1978.

23.

Bryant

Health and the Developing World. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York, 1969.

24.

Newell

(ed.). Health by the People. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1975.

25.

Sinha

N. P.

Malaria eradication: What went wrong?

Economic and Political Weekly 11: 946–947, 1976.

26.

Agarwal

Malaria makes a comeback. New Scientist, p. 274, February 2, 1978.

27.

Banerji

Family Planning in India, People's Publishing House, New Delhi, 1971.

28.

Demerath

N. J.

Birth Control and Foreign Policy. Random House, New York, 1976.

29.

Illich

Medical Nemesis. Marion Calder, London, 1976.

30.

Piotrow

P. T.

World Population Crisis: The U.S. Response. Praeger, New York, 1973.

31.

Singer

H. W.

External aid: For plans or projects?

Economic Journal, 299: 539–545, 1965.

32.

Shenoy

B. R.

PL-480 Aid and India's Food Problem. Concept, New Delhi, 1974.

33.

Directory and Year Book. Times of India, New Delhi, 1948–49 to 1979–80.

34.

Bhatt

R. V.

Migration of Baroda medical graduates, 1949–72. Medical Education 1: 239–242, 1976.

35.

Meyer

M. L.

A comparative analysis of the Indian government's relationships with WHO, UNESCO, and ECAFE. Ph.D. thesis, University of Pennsylvania, 1967.

36.

Medical Aid. Overseas Development Administration, Foreign and Commonwealth Office, London, 1971.

37.

Review of British Health Aid to Developing Countries 1974–76. Overseas Development Ministry, London, 1978.

38.

Colombo Plan Annual Report. Cmnd 9016. London, 1969.

39.

Directory of Fellowships and Scholarships 1917–70. The Rockefeller Foundation, New York, 1972.

40.

Personal communication, January 14, 1981.

41.

India Program: Annual Public Summary of Activities. Catholic Relief Services, New York, 1979.

42.

Country Program Profile: India (mimeo). CARE, New York, 1980.

43.

Minkler

Consultants or colleagues: The role of US population advisers in India. Pop. Dev. Rev. 3(4): 403–419, 1977.

44.

Hanson

A. H.

The Process of Planning. Royal Institute of International Affairs, London, 1964.

45.

Cassen

India: Population, Economy, Society. Macmillan, London, 1978.

46.

Health Sector Policy Paper. World Bank, Washington, DC, 1975.

47.

More Aid for the Poorest. HMSO, London, 1975.

48.

Draft Five Year Plan. Planning Commission, Government of India, New Delhi, 1977.