A case study of the process of foreign intervention in medical education in the developing world is presented. Material collected from the Rockefeller Foundation Archives on a Foundation program in Thailand is used to analyze the conditions under which foreign agencies and their personnel intervene in the development of medical professionals in the Third World and to study the problems that may occur as a result of such intervention. The importance of value consensus and the competitive advantage foreigners have in the marketing of professional models are highlighted as reasons for the diffusion of Western models of medical education throughout the developing world.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Eleventh Compendium of Technical Assistance to Thailand. Development Assistance Group for Thailand, Bangkok, 1974.
2.
EversH. D.ReganD.Specialization and Involvement: The Modernizing Role of Doctors in Malaysia and Indonesia. Working Paper No. 16, Department of Sociology, University of Singapore, 1973.
3.
BryantJ.Health & the Developing World. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1969.
4.
LathemW.Introduction in Community Medicine: Teaching, Research and Health Care, edited by LathemW.NewberryA., p. 5. Appleton-Century-Crofts, New York, 1970.
5.
WilliamsG.The Plague Killers. Charles Scribner's Sons, New York, 1969.
6.
FosdickR.The Story of the Rockefeller Foundation. Harper and Brothers, New York, 1952.
7.
Public Health in Thailand, p. 25. Ministry of Public Health, Bangkok, 1971.
8.
LordD. C.Mo Bradley and Thailand, pp. 85–90. W. B. Eerdmans Company, Grand Rapids, Mich., 1969.
9.
MendelsonR. W.I Lost a King, p. 139. Vantage Press, New York, 1964.
10.
GrahamW. A.Siam, Vol. 1, p. 254. Alexander Morning Ltd., The De La Mare Press, London, 1924.
11.
The Country's Public Health Problems, Especially in Personnel and Proposals for a Development Policy to Solve Public Health Problems, p. 5. Unpublished paper, Ministry of Public Health, Bangkok, 1973.
12.
RichW.Smaller Families Through Social and Economic Progress, pp. 25–26. Monograph No. 7, Overseas Development Council, Washington, D. C., 1973.
13.
AriyapruchyaS.Sources of Aid and International Relations of Thailand, pp. 3–4. Paper presented at a seminar on Foreign Aid to Thailand in the 1980s, Chiengmai, Thailand, June 1974.
14.
BarnesM. E. Letter to W. Rose, August 3, 1921. Rockefeller Foundation Archives, Record Group 1, Series 617A, Chulalongkorn University (hereafter cited as RF617A).
15.
EllisA. G.The service to medicine in Siam rendered by H. R. H. Prince Mahidol of Songkla, M.D. In Chumnum Phraniphont le Botkhawan Charlem Phrakiat, Somdej Prarachabida Chao Fa Mahidol Adulyadet, Krom Luang Songkla Nakharin, pp. 330–331. Prabida Haeng Karnphaet Phaen Bachuban Khong Thai, Khana Phaetsart le Siriraj Phayabal, 1965 (B.E. 2508).
16.
PearceR. M.Report on Medical Education in Siam, pp. 45–46. RF617A, November 1921.
17.
BarnesM. E.Confidential Report on Medical Education. RF617A, September 30, 1921.
18.
CarthewM.A Plea for the Registration of Medical Practitioners in Siam. Included as Exhibit 2 in Pearce, R. M. Report on Medical Education in Siam. RF617A, November 1921.
19.
PearceR. M.Diary Notes. Meeting with Prince Mahidol Songkla; luncheon conference with GEV [George E. Vincent] and RSG [Roger S. Greene]. RF617A, March 24, 1927.
20.
MontriD. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, August 16, 1922.
21.
PearceR. M. Letter to D. Montri. RF617A, January 23, 1922.
22.
PearceR. M. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, December 8, 1923.
23.
CarterW. S.Report on the Medical School in Bangkok, Based upon a Visit, May 1–4, 1923. RF617A, 1923.
24.
CarterW. S. Diary Notes. RF617A, August 18–19, 1931.
25.
EllisA. G.Chronological Review of Events in Bangkok. RF617A, 1923.
26.
SongklaM. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, August 12, 1923.
27.
SongklaM. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, December 10, 1923.
28.
CarterW. S. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, October 3, 1926.
29.
CarterW. S. Memorandum of Conference on January 25, 1928, between H. E. Phya Baisal, Under-Secretary, Phya Bhaiata, Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Dr. A. G. Ellis, and W. S. Carter. RF617A, January 25, 1928.
30.
BatsonB.Siam's Political Future: Documents from the End of the Absolute Monarchy, p. 3. Data Paper No. 96, Cornell University, Southeast Asia Program, Department of Asian Studies, July 1974.
31.
ChakrabongseC.Lords of Life: A History of the Kings of Thailand, pp. 268–317. Alvin Redman, London, 1960.
32.
Memo to FFR [Frederick F. Russell], interview of GEV [George E. Vincent], SMG [Selskar M. Gunn], and Prince Sakol of Siam, in Paris, July 8, 1928. RF617A, 1928.
33.
VaravamS. [Prince Sakol]. Public Health and Medical Service in Siam: General and Medical Features, pp. 185–244. Far Eastern Association of Tropical Medicine, Executive Committee of the Eighth Congress, editors. Bangkok Times Press, Bangkok, 1930.
34.
EllisA. G. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, April 18, 1929.
35.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, September 15, 1930.
36.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, October 16, 1930.
37.
EllisA. G. Letter to S. Varavam. RF617A, March 30, 1931.
38.
EllisA. G.Medical Education and Practice, p. 14. Bangkok Times Press, Bangkok, 1932.
39.
ZimmermanC.Siam: Rural Economic Survey, 1930–31, pp. 239–242. Bangkok Times Press, Bangkok, 1931.
40.
O'ConnorF. W. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, September 9, 1931.
41.
HeiserV. G.Letter to M. E. Barnes. Record Group 5, Series 617, International Health Board, February 1, 1924.
42.
FFR [Frederick F. Russell]. Memo to VGH [Victor G. Heiser]. RF617A, April 24, 1931.
43.
HeiserV. G.Memorandum on Medical Sciences Conference on Siam. RF617A, September 10, 1931.
44.
Vejnisit B.E. 2482. Karn Pim Thai, Bangkok, 1941 (B.E. 2484).
45.
CarterW. S. Diary Notes. RF617A, September 10, 1931.
46.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, January 27, 1932.
47.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis, RF617A, May 9, 1932.
48.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, September 8, 1932.
49.
The Siam Observer, September 5, 1932.
50.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, September 12, 1932.
51.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, October 26, 1932.
52.
The Daily Mail, October 21–25, 1932.
53.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, December 6, 1932.
54.
CortE. C. Suggested Scheme for Providing Medical Care for the Rural Population of Siam. Version available in Rockefeller Foundation Archives.
55.
SchapiroL. Letter to V. G. Heiser. RF617A, October 8, 1931.
56.
CarterW. S. Memo to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, April 19, 1933.
57.
EllisA. G. Letter to W. S. Carter. RF617A, October 16, 1933.
58.
EllisA. G. Letter to E. C. Cort. RF617A, undated (around September 1933).
59.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, March 5, 1934.
60.
GrantJ. B.Diary Notes on Trip to Philippines, Java, Malay, Singapore, Siam and India. Record Group 9, Series 600, pp. 141–142. Rockefeller Foundation Archives, 1933.
61.
The Bangkok Times, January 16, 1934.
62.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis, RF617A, April 30, 1934.
63.
Personal communication from Charas Yamarat, 1975.
64.
LandonK. P.Siam in Transition, pp. 128–129. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1939.
65.
Ministry of Public Health. Commemoration of the Fifteenth Anniversary of the Ministry of Public Health: 1942–1957, pp. 303–305. Udom Press, Bangkok, 1957.
66.
Penal Code of Thailand, Section 306, 1936 (B.E. 2499).
67.
China Medical Commission of the Rockefeller Foundation. Medicine in China, p. 81. Rockefeller Foundation, New York, 1914.
68.
EbertR. H.The medical school. In Life and Death in Medicine, p. 105. W. H. Freeman, San Francisco, 1973.
69.
NielsonW. A.The Big Foundations, p. 61. Columbia University Press, New York, 1972.
70.
KingM., editor. Medical Care in Developing Countries. Oxford University Press, London, 1966.
71.
Training and Utilization of Village Health Workers. Working Document HMD/74.5. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1974.
72.
Report to Thailand on Health Services, Health Personnel, and Health Education. Rockefeller Foundation, New York, 1965.
73.
BarnesM. E.Letter to V. G. Heiser. Record Group 5, Series 617. International Health Board, August 3, 1921.
74.
GreggA.The work of the Rockefeller Foundation in medical education and the medical sciences, 1920 to 1929 inclusive, under the direction of Richard Mills Pearce, M.D. The Rockefeller Foundation Quarterly Bulletin, Vol. 5, No. 2, 1931.
75.
PearceR. M. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, June 18, 1924.
76.
HeiserV. G.Letter to F. F. Russell. Record Group 5, Series 617. International Health Board, January 26, 1926.
77.
CarterW. S. Memo to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, August 26, 1923.
78.
FlexnerA.Medical Education in the United States and Canada. Bulletin No. 4, The Carnegie Foundation, New York, 1910.
79.
PenfieldW.The Difficult Art of Giving: The Epic of Alan Gregg, p. 143. Little Brown, Boston, 1967.
80.
KunitzS. J.Professionalism and social control in the Progressive Era: The case of the Flexner Report. Social Problems22 (1): 25, October 1974.
81.
SkinnerG. W.Chinese Society in Thailand: An Analytical History. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, N.Y., 1957.
82.
NumnondaT.The first American advisers in Thailand. Journal of the Siam Society62: 2, July 1974.
83.
SongklaM. Letter to R. M. Pearce. RF617A, May 14, 1927.
84.
CarterW. S. Letter to A. G. Ellis. RF617A, January 18, 1930.
85.
HeiserV. G. Letter to M. E. Barnes. Record Group 5, Series 617. International Health Board, August 12, 1923.
86.
McGavranE.SongklaM.Diphyllobothrium latum in Massachusetts. JAMA90: 1607–1608, May 19, 1928.
87.
EllisA. G. Diary Notes. RF617A, January 26 and March 31, 1924.
88.
HanksL. M.Another Vietnam? American aid is damaging Thai society. In America and the Asian Revolutions, edited by LiftonR. J., p. 129. Aldine Publishing Company, Chicago, 1970.
89.
Minutes of a Cabinet Meeting on July 9, 1929. National Archives of Thailand, Seventh Reign, Ministry of Foreign Affairs 35/21.
90.
SaibuaS.Foreign Aid to Thailand, pp. 13–14. Paper presented at a seminar on Foreign Aid to Thailand in the 1980s, Chiengmai, Thailand, June 1974.
91.
Public Health Statistics, p. 168. Ministry of Public Health, Division of Vital Statistics, Bangkok, 1971.
92.
RileyJ. N.SermsriS.The Variegated Thai Medical System as a Context for Birth Control Services. Working Paper No. 6, Institute for Population and Social Research, Mahidol University, Bangkok, June 1974.
93.
EversH. D.Group conflict and class formation in South-East Asia. In Modernization in South-East Asia, edited by EversH. D., p. 113. Oxford University Press, London, 1973.
94.
EversH. D.The Role of Professionals in Social and Political Change, pp. 20–22. Working Paper No. 24, Department of Sociology, University of Singapore, 1974.
95.
RiggsF. W.Thailand: The Modernization of a Bureaucratic Policy, p. 349. East West Center Press, Honolulu, 1966.
96.
NairnR.International Aid to Thailand: The New Colonialism?, p. 101. Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn., 1966.
97.
DinningJ. S.University development in Thailand: A program in the life sciences. J. Med. Educ.49: 767, August 1974.
98.
BenchakarnV.Teaching Population and Family Planning in a School of Health Professions, p. 3. Paper prepared for a symposium, Southeast Addresses Its Health Problems, Bangkok, October 28-November 1, 1974.
99.
HarinasutaC.The need for clinical assistants in Thailand. Lancet pp. 1298–1300, June 9, 1973.
100.
SteinbergD.WyattD. K.SmallJ. R. W.WoodsideA.RoffW. R.ChandlerD. P.In Search of Southeast Asia: A Modern History, p. 313. Oxford University Press, Kuala Lumpur, 1971.
