To determine if demographic differences exist in patients with depressive symptoms as the principal reason for visits to primary care physicians (PCP) versus psychiatrists. To estimate the likelihood of these patients receiving a range of mental health services from each provider group.
Methods:
Review and analysis of all outpatient visits made by patients with depressive symptoms using the National Ambulatory Medical Care Surveys (NAMCS) conducted in 1995 and 1996.
Results:
A significantly greater proportion of visits by persons with depressive symptoms as the principal reason for visit were made to psychiatrists than to primary care physicians (T = −3.56, p = .000). However, men, African-Americans, other Non-White persons, and persons aged 65 to 74 and 75 years and over were proportionately more likely to visit a PCP than a psychiatrist. Women, whites, and persons aged 45 to 64 were proportionately more likely to make a visit to a psychiatrist than to a PCP. The overall intensity of care delivered by PCPs for patients with depressive symptoms was significantly lower than that provided by psychiatrists (t = −2.03, p = .02). Analysis of individual services also revealed significant differences in service provision.
Conclusions:
Demographic differences among the patient caseloads of these physician groups have implications for mental health service delivery because of known distinctions in prevalence rates, symptom presentation, and functionality among depressed patient subgroups.
MarrowWReigerDARaeDSManderschiedRWLockeBZ. Use of services by persons with mental and addictive disorders: Findings from the NIMH epidemiological catchment area study. Archives of General Psychiatry1993; 50: 95–107.
2.
StaffordRSSaglamDCausinoNStarfieldBCulpepperLMarderWDBlumenthalD. Trends in adult visits to primary care physicians in the United States. Archives of Family Medicine1999; 8: 26–32.
3.
SchappertS. National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. 1995 Summary: Advance data from vital and health statistics. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics, 1995.
4.
SchappertS. National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. 1996 Summary: Advance data from vital and health statistics. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics, 1996.
5.
CameronO. G.Presentations of depression. New York: John Wily & Sons, 1987.
6.
WhybrowPCAkiskalHSMcKinneyWTJr. Mood disorders: Toward a new psychobiology. New York: Plenum Press, 1984.
7.
Schad-SomersSP. On mood swings: The psychobiology of elation and depression. New York: Insight Books, 1990.
8.
ClarkDABeckAT. Scientific foundations of cognitive theory and therapy of depression. New York: John Wily, 1999.
9.
SteinRE. Psychoanalytic theories of affect. New York: Praeger, 1991.
10.
WellsKBStewartAHaysRDBurnamMARogersWDanielsMBerrySGreenfieldSWareJ. The functioning and well being of depressed patients: Results for the medical outcomes study. Journal of the American Medical Association1989; 262: 914–919.
11.
RuppA. The economic consequences of not treating depression. British Journal of Psychiatry1995; 166: 29–35.
12.
ElkinISheaMTWatkinsJTImberSDSotskySJCollinsJFGlassDRPilkonisPALeberWRDohertyJPFiesterSJParloffMB. National Institute of mental health treatment of depression collaborative research program: General effectiveness of treatments. Archives of General Psychiatry1989; 46: 971–982.
13.
Public Health Service Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. Depression in primary care: Treatment of major depression. Rockville, MD: US Dept. of Health and Human Services; 1993; 2 AHCPR publication 93–051.
14.
Von KorffMShapiroSBurkeJDTeitelbaumMSkinnerEAGermanPTurnerRWKleinLBurnsB. Anxiety and depression in a primary care clinic. Archives of General Psychiatry1987; 44: 152–156.
15.
AndersenSMHarthornBH. The recognition, diagnosis, and treatment of mental disorders by primary care physicians. Medical Care1989; 27: 869–886.
16.
WilliamsJWRostKDietrichAJCiottiMCZyzanskiSJCornellJ. Primary care physicians' approach to depressive disorders. Archives of Family Medicine1999; 8: 58–67.
17.
PincusHAZarinDATanielanTLJohnsonJLWestJCPettitARMarcusSCKesslerRCMcIntyreJS. Psychiatric patients and treatments in 1997. Archives of General Psychiatry1999; 56: 441–449.
18.
SchulbergHC. Mental disorders in the primary care setting. General and Hospital Psychiatry1991; 13: 156–164.
19.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders, 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1994.
20.
RogersWWellsKBMeredithLSSturnRBurnamA. Outcomes for adult outpatients with depression under prepaid or fee-for-service financing. Archives of General Psychiatry1993; 50: 517–525.
21.
OlfsonMKlermanGL. The treatment of depression: Prescribing practices of primary care physicians and psychiatrists. Journal of Family Practice1992; 35: 627–635.
22.
JohnstoneAGoldbergD. Psychiatric screening in general practice: A controlled experiment. Lancet1976; 1: 605–608.
23.
SeligmanMEP. The effectiveness of psychotherapy: The consumer reports study. American Psychologist1995; 50: 965–974.
24.
KatonWVon KorffMLinEWalkerESimonGEBushTRobinsonPRussoJ. Collaborative management to achieve treatment guideline: Impact of depression in primary care. Journal of the American Medical Association1995; 273: 1026–1031.
25.
McDanielSH. Collaboration between psychologists and family physicians: Implementing the biopsychosocial model. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice1995; 26: 117–122.
26.
RubensteinLVJackson-TricheMUnutzerJMirandaJMinimumKPearsonMLWellsKB. Evidence-based care for depression in managed primary care practices. Health Affairs1999;Sept/Oct:89–105.
27.
AntonucciDODantonWGDeNelskyGY. Psychotherapy versus medication for depression: Challenging the conventional wisdom with data. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice1995; 26: 574–585.
28.
SeemanM. Gender and psychopathology. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 1995.
29.
BrownCSchulbergHCMadoniaMJ. Clinical presentations of major depression by African-Americans and whites in primary medical care practice. Journal of Affective Disorders1996; 41: 181–191.
30.
McGrathEKeitaGPStricklandBRRussoNF. Women and depression: Risk factors and treatment issues. Final Report of the American Psychological Association National Task Force on Women and Depression. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, 1990.
31.
KatonWSchulbergH. Epidemiology of depression in primary care. General and Hospital Psychiatry1992; 14: 237–247.
32.
DuffyM. Handbook of counseling and psychotherapy with older adults. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1999.
33.
RussSWOllendickTH, editors. Handbook of psychotherapies with children and families. New York: Plenum, 1996.
34.
RudorferMVRobinsE. Amitriptyline overdose: Clinical effects on tricyclic antidepressant plasma levels. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry1982; 43: 457–460.
35.
BrownCSchulbergHCSacoDPerelJMHouckPR. Effectiveness of treatments for major depression in primary medical care practice: A post hoc analysis of outcomes for African-American and white patients. Journal of Affective Disorders1999; 53: 185–192.
36.
RichardsonLAKellerAMSelby-HarringtonMLParrishR. Identification and treatment of children's mental health problems by primary care providers: A critical review of research. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing1996; 10: 293–303.
37.
AreanPAHuTSatreD. Depression. In: HersenMVan HasseltVB, editors. Handbook of clinical geropsychology. New York: Plenum Press, 1998: 195–212.
38.
Cooper-PatrickLCCrumRMFordDE. Characteristics of patients with major depression that required care in general and specialty health settings. Medical Care1994; 32: 15–34.
39.
ICD-9-CM; International Classification of Diseases, 9th revision; Clinical Modification. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association, 1995.
40.
RogersWHWellsKBMeredithLSSturmRBurnamMA. Outcomes for adult outpatients with depression under prepaid or fee-for-service financing. Archives of General Psychiatry1993; 50: 517–525.
41.
LevensteinJHMcCrackenECMcWhinneyJR. The patient-centered clinical method. I: A model for the doctor-patient interaction in family medicine. Family Practice1986; 3: 24–30.
42.
ClearyP. The need and demand for mental health services. In: TaubeCMechanicDHohmannA, editors. The future of mental health services research. Washington, DC: Dept. of Health and Human Services. 1989: 161–183.
43.
Stata Corporation. STATA Statistical Software. 6.0 edition. College Station, TX: Stata Press, 1999.
44.
AnthonyJCAborayaA. Epidemiology of selected disorders. In SloaneRBCohenGD, editors. Handbook of mental health and aging. 2nd ed.New York: Academic Press, 1989.
45.
CochranSVRabinowitzFE. Men and depression: Clinical and empirical perspectives. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, 2000.
46.
KlinkmanM. Competing demands in psychosocial care: A model for the identification and treatment of depressive disorders in primary care. General and Hospital Psychiatry1997; 19: 98–111.
47.
American Medical Association. Gender disparities and clinical decision making. Journal of the American Medical Association1991; 266: 559–562.
48.
HuestonWJWerthJManiousAG. Personality disorder traits: Prevalence and effects on health status in primary care patients. International Journal of Psychiatry in Medicine1999; 29: 63–74.
49.
LonglettJKruseJ. Behavioral science education in family medicine: A survey of behavior science educators and family physicians. Family Medicine1992; 24: 28–35.
50.
RollandJS. Families, illness, and disability: An integrative treatment model. New York: Basic Books, 1994.
51.
HenaoSGosseN. Principles of family systems in family medicine. New York: Brunner/Mazel, 1985.
52.
Christie-SeelyJ. Working with families in primary care. New York: Praeger Publishers, 1984.
53.
Author. Parity in financing mental health services: Managed care effects on cost, access & quality. Bethesda, MD: National Institute of Mental Health, 1998.
54.
BrentDAHolderDKolkoDBirmaherBBaugherMRothCIyengarSJohnsonBA. A clinical psychology trial for adolescent depression comparing cognitive, family, and supportive therapy. Archives of General Psychiatry1997; 54: 877–885.
55.
ZitoJSaferDJdosReisSGardnerJFBolesMLynchF. Trends in prescribing psychotrophic medications to preschoolers. Journal of the American Medical Association2000; 283: 1025–1030.
56.
VitelloBJensenPS. Medication development and testing in children and adolescents. Archives of General Psychiatry1997; 54: 871–876.
57.
DrebingCVan ForpWGStuckAEMitrushinaMBeckJ. Early detection of cognitive decline in higher functioning older adults: Sensitivity and specificity of a neuropsychological screening battery. Neuropsychology1994; 8: 31–37.
58.
KorffMSimonG. Methodologic perspective: Getting answers to the most important questions. In: MirandaDHohmannAAtkissonCCLarsonD, editors. Mental disorders in primary care. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, 1994.
59.
DeTittaMRobinowitzCBMoreWW. The future of psychiatry: Psychiatrists of the future. American Journal of Psychiatry1991; 148: 853–858.
60.
SelbyJGrumbachKQuisenberryJSchmittdielJATrumanAF. Differences in resource use and costs of primary care in a large HMO according to physician specialty. Health Services Research1999; 34: 503–518.
61.
St PeterRFReedMCKemperPBlumenthalD. Changes in the scope of care provided by primary care physicians. New England Journal of Medicine1999; 23: 1980–1985.
