Lay Evaluation of Medicine and Medical Practice: Report of a Pilot Study

Abstract

Sociologists appear to differ in the way they portray the public's ideas about modern medicine. Some argue that the public accepts that modern medicine is effective, and others say that as a whole the public is skeptical about its value. There is a dearth of empirical evidence about what the public thinks of modern medicine; this pilot study attempts to fill this gap. Tape-recorded interviews were carried out with small samples of women from Social Classes I and II and Classes IV and V to find out what they felt about the value of modern medicine and to identify the criteria that they used to assess a “good” and “bad” medical practitioner. The results showed that there is some degree of skepticism about the value of modern medicine, particularly amongst working-class people. However, the criteria for assessing the performance of a medical practitioner were only rarely seen to be tied up with the criteria used to assess the value of modern medicine.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Parsons

The Social System. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1951.

Illich

Medical Nemesis: The Expropriation of Health. Calder and Boyar, London, 1975.

Navarro

Class Struggle, the State and Medicine. Martin Robertson, Oxford, 1977.

Waitzkin

Medicine, superstructure and micropolitics. Soc. Sci. Med. 13A: 601–619, 1979.

Calnan

Clinical uncertainty: Is it a problem in the doctor-patient relationship?

Sociol. Health Illness 6(1): 74–85, 1954.

Shryock

The Development of Modern Medicine. University of Wisconsin Press, Wisconsin, 1979.

Starr

The Social Transformation of American Medicine. Basic Books, New York, 1982.

Larson

M. S.

The Rise of Professionalism, a Sociological Analysis. Californian University Press, Los Angeles, 1978.

Strong

P. M.

Sociological imperialism and the profession of medicine. Soc. Sci. Med. 13A: 199–227, 1979.

10.

West

The physician and the management of childhood epilepsy. In Studies in Everyday Medical Life, edited by Wadsworth

Robinson

, pp. 13–31. Martin Robertson, Oxford, 1976.

11.

Stimson

Webb

Going to See the Doctor: The Consultation Process in General Practice. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1975.

12.

Strong

P. M.

The Ceremonial Order of the Clinic. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1978.

13.

Cartwright

Anderson

Doctors and Patients Revisited. Tavistock, London, 1981.

14.

Reid

M. E.

Review article: A feminist sociological imagination? Reading Ann Oakley. Sociol. Health Illness 5: 183–194, 1983.

15.

Calnan

Women and medicalisation: An empirical examination of the extent of women's dependence on medical technology in the early detection of breast cancer. Soc. Sci. Med. 18(7): 561–570, 1984.

16.

Stimson

Obeying doctor's orders-view from the other side. Soc. Sci. Med. 8: 97–105, 1974.

17.

Stimson

General practitioners and types of trouble. In Sociology of the NHS, Sociol. Rev. [Monogr.] 22, edited by Stacey

, pp. 43–60, 1976.

18.

Askham

Professional criteria for accepting people as patients. Soc. Sci. Med. 16: 2083–2084, 1982.

19.

Townsend

Davidson

Inequalities in Health. Penguin, London, 1982.

20.

Cartwright

O'Brien

M. C.

Social class variations in health care. In The Sociology of the NHS, Sociol. Rev. [Monogr.] 22, edited by Stacey

, pp. 77–98, 1976.

21.

Pendelton

Bochner

The communication of medical information in general practice consultations as a function of patients' social class. Soc. Sci. Med. 14A: 669–673, 1980.

22.

Blaxter

Equity and consultation rates in general practice. Br. Med. J. 288: 1963–1966, 1984.

23.

Office of Population and Censuses. Classification of Occupations. Government Statistical Service, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London, 1980.

24.

Nicholls

Social class: Official, sociological and Marxist. In Demystifying Social Statistics, edited by Irvine

Miles

Evans

, pp. 152–171. Pluto, London, 1979.

25.

Delphy

Women in stratification studies. In Doing Feminist Research, edited by Roberts

, pp. 114–128. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1981.

26.

Graham

Women, Health and the Family. Wheatsheaf Books, Sussex, 1984.

27.

Macfarlane

Official statistics and women's health and illness. In EOC Research Bulletin no. 4, pp. 45–47. Equal Opportunities Commission, London, 1980.

28.

Dale

Gilbert

G. N.

Arber

Integrating women into class theory. Sociology 19(3): 384–408, 1985.

29.

Gabe

Lipshitz-Phillips

Tranquillisers as social control. Sociol. Rev. 32(3): 524–546, 1984.

30.

Calnan

Health and Illness; The Lay Perspectives. Tavistock, London, 1987.

31.

Friedson

The Profession of Medicine, Dodd-Mead Co., New York, 1970.

32.

Abercrombie

Hill

Turner

B. S.

The Dominant Ideology Thesis. George Allen and Unwin, London, 1980.

33.

Prendergast

Prout

What will I do …? Teenage girls and the construction of motherhood. Sociol. Rev. 3: 517–536, 1980.

34.

Cornwell

Hard-earned Lives. Tavistock, London, 1984.