This conceptual article presents a critical review of gender-difference and gender-sameness theory and research. The focus is upon gender workplace communication, a topic often debated in the popular and organizational literature. A contextually-based integrated paradigm is proposed which represents a shift from a gender-difference foundation to a more integrated approach that includes the interaction of gender with Standpoint Theory, culture, organizational climate, and structure and task context. The network of shared meanings concept is introduced as having a major impact on gender communication orientation. Research using an example of communication to create a contextual meaning for social support is highlighted. Implications and conclusions for organizations, researchers, and educators are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BairdJ. E. and BradleyP. H., Styles of Management and Communication: A Comparative Study of Men and Women, Communication Monographs, 46, pp. 101–111, 1979.
2.
BrownD. J., Male Versus Female Leaders, Sex Roles, 5, pp. 595–609, 1979.
3.
Gomez-MejiaL. R., Sex Differences during Occupational Socialization, Academy of Management Journal, 26: 3, pp. 492–499, 1983.
4.
RosenerJ. B., Ways Women Lead, in Gendered Relationships, WoodJ. (ed.), Mayfield Publishing Company, Mountain View, California, p. 259, 1996.
5.
TannenD., That's Not What I Meant!William Morrow, New York, 1986.
6.
TannenD., You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation, William Morrow, New York, 1990.
7.
BurkeK., Androgny and Identity in Gender Communication, The Quarterly Journal of Speech, 80, pp. 482–497, November 1994.
8.
O'BarrW., Linguistic Evidence: Language, Power and Strategy in the Courtroom, in Gender as a Variable in Managerial Communication: An Annotated Bibliography of Empirical Research in the 1980s, BakerM. A. (ed.), The Bulletin of the Association for Business Communication, LII: 3, p. 81, 1990.
9.
StewartL. and Ting-ToomeyS., Communication, Gender, and Sex Roles in Diverse Interaction Contexts, Ablex Publishing, New Jersey, 1987.
10.
SmeltzerL. and WerbelJ., Gender Differences in Managerial Communication: Fact or Folk Linguistics?Journal of Business Communication, 23: 2, pp. 41–50, 1986.
11.
TurnerL. and SterkH., Differences That Make a Difference: Examining the Assumptions in Gender Research, Bergin & Garvey, Westport, Connecticut, 1994.
12.
BakerM., Gender as a Variable in Managerial Communication: An Annotated Bibliography of Empirical Research in the 1980s, The Bulletin of the Association for Business Communication, LII: 3, pp. 80–83, 1990.
13.
BakerM., Gender and Verbal Communication in Professional Settings: A Review of Research, Management Communication Quarterly, 5: 1, pp. 36–63, August 1991.
14.
CraganJ. and ShieldsD., Understanding Communication Theory, Allyn & Bacon, Boston, Massachusetts, 1998.
15.
MurphyB. and ZornT., Gender Interaction in Professional Relationships, in Gender Relationships, WoodJ. (ed.), Mayfield Publishing Company, Mountain View, California, pp. 213–232, 1996.
16.
NatalleE., Gender Issues in the Workplace, in Gender Relationships, WoodJ. (ed.), Mayfield Publishing Company, Mountain View, California, pp. 253–271, 1996.
17.
MacLeodL.ScrivenJ., and WayneF., Gender and Management Level Differences in the Oral Communication Patterns of Bank Managers, The Journal of Business Communication, 29: 4, pp. 343–361, 1992.
18.
WoodsN., Sex and Status as Determinants of Floor Apportionment in a Work Setting, in Women in Their Speech Communities, CoatesJ. and CameronD. (eds.), Longwood, London, pp. 141–157, 1988.
19.
NadlerL. and NadlerM., Communication, Gender and Interorganizational Negotiation Ability, in Advances in Gender and Communication Research, StewartL. and Ting-ToomeyS. (eds.), University Press, New York, pp. 119–131, 1987.
20.
WilkinsB. and AndersenP., Gender Differences and Similarities in Management Communication: A Meta-Analysis, Management Communication Quarterly, 5, pp. 6–31, August 1991.
21.
SmytheM. and MeyerJ., On the Origins of Gender-Linked Language Differences: Individual and Contextual Explanations, in Differences That Make a Difference: Examining the Assumptions in Gender Research, TurnerL. and SterkH. (eds.), Bergin & Garvey, Westport, Connecticut, pp. 51–60, 1994.
22.
HegelG., Phenomenology of Mind (1807), in Communication, Gender and Culture, WoodJ. (ed.), Wadsworth Publishing, Albany, New York, pp. 64–65, 1997.
23.
CollinsP., Learning from the Outsider Within, in Communication, Gender, and Culture, WoodJ. (ed.), Wadsworth Publishing, Albany, New York, p. 64, 1997.
24.
HardingS., Whose Science? Whose Knowledge? Thinking from Women's Lives, in Communication, Gender, and Culture, WoodJ. (ed.), Wadsworth Publishing, Albany, New York, p. 65, 1997.
25.
UchidaA., Bringing the ‘Culture’ Back In: A Culture Building Approach to Gender and Communication, Women and Language, 20, pp. 15–24, Fall 1997.
26.
WoodJ. (ed.), Communication, Gender, and Culture, Wadsworth Publishing, Albany, New York, 1997.
27.
Hare-MustinR. and MaracekJ., Gender and the Meaning of Difference: Postmodernism and Psychology, in Making a Difference: Psychology and the Construction of Gender, Hare-MustinR. and MaracekJ. (eds.), Yale University Press, New Haven, pp. 22–64, 1990.
28.
BarkerR. and CamarataM., The Role of Communication in Creating and Maintaining a Learning Organization: Preconditions, Indicators, and Disciplines, The Journal of Business Communication, 35: 4, pp. 443–467, October 1998.
TrentJ., Communication: Views From the Helm for the 21st Century, Allyn & Bacon, Boston, Massachusetts, 1998.
31.
BarkerR. T. and CamarataM. R., The Role of Communication in Creating and Maintaining a Learning Organization: Preconditions, Indicators, and Disciplines, The Journal of Business Communication, 35: 4, 1998.
32.
BarkerR. T.GilbreathG. H., and StoneW. S., The Interdisciplinary Needs of Organizations: Are New Employees Adequately Equipped?The Journal of Management Development, 17: 3, 1998.
33.
Beckett-CamarataE. J.CamarataM. R., and BarkerR. T., Integrating Internal and External Customer Relationships through Relationship Management: A Strategic Response to a Changing Global Environment, The Journal of Business Research, 41, 1998.
34.
BarkerR. T. and FranzakF., Team Building in the Classroom: Preparing Students for their Organizational Future, Journal of Technical Writing and Communication, 27: 3, 1997.
35.
TrumbleR. and ZifcakL., Compensation and Benefits: International Stock Option Use for Compensation, International Hr Journal, 7: 4, 1999.
