There has been a lacuna in previous studies of medicine and health care of concepts or structures relating changes in health care with their contextualizing social structures. That is, there is a need to more adequately account for health care and social structure in terms of dynamic rather than static concepts. This article reports the application of a general schema outlining the transformation of capitalism through the phases of entrepreneurial, monopoly, and global capitalism, first presented by Ross and Trachte, to help understand both the changing role of medicine in Canada and the historical trajectory of the development of health insurance. These related events are shown to be partly reflective of the transformed class dynamics involved in a changing capitalist mode of production. The recent history of challenges to medicare in Canada as well as evidence of the declining power of medicine are both related directly and indirectly to the increased power of business and the decline in the relative autonomy of the state accompanying globalization. The application of the phases of capitalism sequence does roughly fit the Canadian instance although some modifications will be required to account for the specifics of the Canadian case. The schema also helps resolve two previously competing class arguments about the rise of health insurance in Canada.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
FreidsonE.Profession of Medicine. Harper & Row, New York, 1970.
2.
FreidsonE.Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of Medical Care. Atherton Press, New York, 1970.
3.
McKinlayJ. B., The business of good doctoring or doctoring as good business: Reflections on Freidson's views of the medical game. Int. J. Health Serv. 7: 459–483, 1977.
4.
McKinlayJ.B., and ArchesJ., Towards the proletarianization of physicians. Int. J. Health Serv. 15: 161–195, 1985.
5.
NavarroV.Medicine under Capitalism. Prodist, New York, 1976.
6.
NavarroV., Professional dominance or proletarianization?Neither. Milbank Q.66(Suppl. 2), 57–75, 1988.
7.
WillisE.Medical Dominance: The Division of Labour in Australian Health Care, Ed. 2. George Allen and Unwin, Sydney, 1989.
8.
HaffertyF. W., and McKinlayJ. B. (eds.). The Changing Medical Profession. Oxford University Press, New York, 1993.
9.
CoburnD.TorranceG., and KaufertJ., Medical Dominance in Canada in historical perspective: The rise and fall of medicine. Int. J. Health Serv. 13: 407–432, 1983.
10.
CoburnD.Professional powers in decline: Medicine in a changing Canada. In The Changing Medical Profession, edited by HaffertyF. W. and McKinlayJ. B.. Oxford University Press, New York, 1993.
11.
NaylorC. D.Private Practice, Public Payment: Canadian Medicine and the Politics of Health Insurance, 1911–1966. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1986.
12.
TaylorM. G.Health Insurance and Canadian Public Policy: The Seven Decisions that Created the Canadian Health Insurance System. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1978.
13.
SwartzD.The politics of reform: Conflict and accommodation in Canadian health policy. In The Canadian State, edited by PanitchL.. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977.
14.
UseemM.The Inner Circle: Large Corporations and the Rise of Business Political Activity in the United States and the U.K.Oxford University Press, New York, 1984.
15.
ColemanW. D.Business and Politics: A Study of Collective Action. McGill-Queen's University Press, Kingston and Montreal, 1988.
16.
BantingK. (ed.). The State and Economic Interests. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1986.
17.
McQuaigL.Canada's Social Programs: Under Attack. Atkinson Charitable Foundation, Toronto, 1992.
18.
McQuaigL.Shooting the Hippo: Death by Deficit and Other Canadian Myths. Viking, Toronto, 1995.
19.
RappoltS.Globalization, Politics and Health Policy in Ontario. Paper presented at the Canadian Sociology and Anthropology Association Annual Meeting, Brock University, 1996.
20.
RossR. J. S., and TrachteK. C.Global Capitalism: The New Leviathan. State University of New York, Albany, 1990.
21.
WaltersV., State, capital and labour: The introduction of federal-provincial insurance for physician care in Canada. Can. Rev. Sociol. Anthropol.19(2): 157–172, 1982.
22.
Esping-AndersenG.The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J., 1990.
23.
Esping-AndersenG., Three political economies of the welfare state. Can. Rev. Sociol. Anthropol.26: 1, 1989.
24.
O'ConnorJ.The Fiscal Crisis of the State. St. Martin's Press, New York, 1973.
25.
BrownE. R.Rockefeller Medicine Men: Medicine and Capitalism in America. University of California Press, Berkeley, 1975.
26.
ShorttS. E. D., Physicians, science, and status: Issues in the professionalization of Anglo-American medicine in the 19th Century. Med. Hist.27(1): 51–68, 1983.
27.
EdwardsR. K.Ideology and Canadian Medicine, 1880–1920. Masters thesis, Department of Environmental Studies, York University, 1986.
28.
TorranceG.Historical introduction. In Health and Canadian Society: Sociological Perspectives, Ed. 2, edited by CoburnD.. Fitzhenry and Whiteside, Toronto, 1987.
29.
BarerM. L., Evans, R. G., and Labelle, R. J. Fee controls as cost controls: Tales from the frozen north. Milbank Q.66: 1–64, 1988.
30.
ShorttS. E. D. (ed.). Medicine in Canadian Society: Historical Perspectives. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal, 1984.
31.
RolandC. C. (ed.). Health, Disease and Medicine: Essays in Canadian History. Hannah Institute for the History of Medicine, Toronto, 1984.
32.
ConnorJ. T. H.Minority Medicine in Ontario, 1795–1903: A Study of Medical Pluralism and Its Decline. Dissertation, Department of History, University of Waterloo, 1987.
33.
GidneyR. D., and MillarW. P. J.Professional Gentlemen: The Professions in Nineteenth Century Ontario. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1994.
34.
GidneyR. D., and MillarW. P. J.The origins of organized medicine in Ontario, 1850–1869. In Health, Disease and Medicine: Essays in Canadian History, edited by RolandC. G.. Hannah Institute for the History of Medicine, Toronto, 1984.
35.
WolfeD. A.The rise and demise of the Keynesian era in Canada: Economic policy, 1930–1982. In Modern Canada, 1930–1980s, edited by CrossM. S. and KealeyG. S.. McClelland and Stewart, Toronto, 1984.
36.
WolfeD., The Canadian state in comparative perspective. Can. Rev. Sociol. Anthropol.26(1): 95–126, 1989.
37.
StubbsR., and UnderhillG. R. D. (eds.). Political Economy and the Changing Global Order. McClelland and Stewart, Toronto, 1994.
38.
TeepleG.Globalization and the Decline of Social Reform. Garamond Press, Toronto, 1995.
39.
DracheD., and GertlerM. S.The New Era of Global Competition: State Policy and Market Power. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal and Kingston, 1991.
McQuaigL.The Quick and the Dead: Brain Mulroney, Big Business and the Seduction of Canada. Viking, Toronto, 1991.
42.
RossR. J. S.The relative decline of relative autonomy: Global capitalism and the political economy of state change. In Changes in the State: Causes and Consequences, edited by GreenbergE. S. and MayerT. F.. Sage, Newbury Park, Calif., 1990.
43.
JohnsonA. F.McBrideS., and SmithP. J. (eds.). Continuities and Discontinuities: The Political Economy of Social Welfare and Labour Market Policy in Canada. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1994.
44.
MoscovitchA., and DroverG.Social expenditures and the welfare state: The Canadian experience in historical perspective. In The Benevolent State: The Growth of Welfare in Canada, edited by MoscovitchA. and AlbertJ.. Garamond Press, Toronto, 1987.
45.
O'ConnorJ., Welfare expenditures and policy orientation in Canada in comparative perspective. Can. Rev. Sociol. Anthropol.26(1): 127–150, 1989.
46.
CoburnD., and FynesM.Changing Forces in Health Care in Canada: An Exploration of the Role of Business. Paper presented at the Canadian Sociology and Anthropology Association Annual Meeting, Montreal, 1995.
47.
AlfordR. R.Health Care Politics. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 1975.
48.
CoburnD.RappoltS., and BourgeaultI., Decline vs. retention of medical power through restratification: The Ontario case. Sociol. Health Ill. 19(1): 1–22, 1997.
49.
BergtholdL. A.Purchasing Power in Health: Business, the State and Health Care Politics. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, N.J., 1990.
50.
BrownL. D., Dogmatic Slumbers: American business and health policy. J. Health Polit. Policy Law18(2): 339–357, 1993.
51.
MartinC. J., Together again: Business, government, and the quest for cost control. J. Health Polit. Policy Law18(2): 359–393, 1993.
52.
SalmonJ. W. (ed.). The Corporate Transformation of Health Care: Part 1. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 1990.
53.
SalmonJ. W. (ed.). The Corporate Transformation of Health Care: Part II. Baywood, Amityville, N.Y., 1994.
54.
LaxerG.Open for Business: The Roots of Foreign Ownership in Canada. Oxford University Press, Toronto, 1989.
55.
KorpiW., Power politics and state autonomy in the development of social citizenship: Social rights during sickness in eighteen OECD countries since 1930. Am. Sociol. Rev.54: 309–328, 1989.
56.
KorpiW.The Democratic Class Struggle. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1983.
57.
NavarroV., Why some countries have national health insurance, others have national health services, and the U.S. has neither. Soc. Sci. Med.28(9): 887–898, 1989.
58.
Morales-GomezD., and TorresM. A. (eds.). Social Policy in a Global Society: Parallels and Lessons from the Canada—Latin America Experience. International Development and Research Centre, Ottawa, 1995.
59.
NefJ.Human Security and Mutual Vulnerability: An Exploration into the Global Political Economy of Development and Underdevelopment. International Development and Research Centre, Ottawa, 1995.
60.
BantingK.Social policy challenges in a global society. In Social Policy in a Global Society, edited by Morales-GomezD. and TorresA. M.. International Development and Research Centre, Ottawa, 1995.
61.
HicksP.Establishing an effective social policy agenda with constrained resources. In Social Policy in a Global Society, edited by Morales-GomezD. and TorresA. M.. International Development and Research Centre, Ottawa, 1995.
62.
BerryA.Social policy reform in Canada under regional economic integration. In Social Policy in a Global Society, edited by Morales-GomezD. and TorresA. M.. International Development and Research Centre, Ottawa, 1995.
