Effects of Counselor Smoking Status,Experience Level,and Treatment Modality on the Credibility of Smoking Cessation Programs

Abstract

One hundred and seventeen smokers were presented with descriptions of a smoking control program and a smoking counselor and were then asked to rate program and counselor effectiveness and counselor empathy. The descriptions varied along three dimensions constituting a 3 × 2 × 2 factorial design: counselor smoking status—ex-smoker, current smoker, never smoker; experience level; and group or individual treatment. Counselor smoking status yielded highly significant main effects on all three dependent measures. There were no other significant main effects. Experience level tended to moderate the effects of smoking status though the interaction was significant only for program effectiveness. Responses to direct preference questions confirmed the counselor smoking status findings and indicated a preference for group over individual treatment.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Engelhard

B. E.

, Measured Levels of Facilitative Core Conditions and Attitudes of Alcohol Counselors with Differing Alcohol and Academic Backgrounds (Doctoral dissertation, University of Arizona, 1977), Dissertation Abstracts International, 38B, University Microfilms No. 7732269, pp. 3630–3631, 1977.

Lloyd

, Therapist Variables in the Treatment of Alcoholism: The Relevance of Professional Training and a Previous Drinking Problem (Doctoral dissertation, University of Arizona, 1977), Dissertation Abstracts International, 38B, University Microfilms No. 7732264), pp. 3892–3893, 1977.

Brown

B. S.

and Thompson

R. F.

, The Effectiveness of Formerly Addicted and Nonaddicted Counselors on Client Functioning, Drug Forum, 5: 2, pp. 123–129, 1976.

LeClair

S. W.

and Roberts

R. R.

, Characteristics of Drug Abuse Counselors and Their Relationship to Treatment Process and Outcome, Journal of Drug Education, 10: 2, pp. 153–158, 1980.

Poussaint

A. F.

Bergman

S. H.

, and Lichtenstein

, The Effect of the Physician's Smoking on the Treatment of Smokers, Diseases of the Nervous System, 27, pp. 539–543, 1966.

Lichtenstein

Poussaint

A. F.

Bergman

S. H.

Jurney

, and Shapiro

, A Further Report on the Effects of the Physician's Treating of Smoking by Placebo, Diseases of the Nervous System; 28, pp. 754–755, 1967.

Borkovec

T. D.

and Nau

, Credibility of Analogue Therapy Rationales, Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 3, pp. 257–260, 1976.

Hynd

G. W.

Stratton

T. T.

and Severson

H. H.

, Smoking Treatment Strategies, Expectancy Outcomes, and Credibility in Attention-Placebo Control Conditions, Journal of Clinical Psychology, 34, pp. 182–186, 1978.

Kazdin

A. E.

and Wilcoxon

L. A.

, Systematic Desensitization and Nonspecific Treatment Effects: A Methodological Evaluation, Psychological Bulletin, 83, pp. 729–758, 1976.

10.

Federal Trade Comission, Report of “Tar” and Nicotine Content of the Smoke of 176 Varieties of Cigarettes, December, 1979.

11.

Kirk

R. E.

, Experimental Design: Procedures for the Behavioral Sciences, Brooks/Cole Publishing Co., Belmont, California, pp. 90–91, 1968.