Impact of Software and Hardware Technologies on Occupational Health and Safety Policies in Saudi Arabian Oil Refineries

Abstract

This article seeks to examine the impact of technology importation on occupational health and safety in both Saudi Arabian and U.S. oil refining industries. Technologies imported to the Saudi oil industry take two forms: hardware (sophisticated equipment to run oil facilities) and software (policies and regulations pertaining to workers' health and safety, and employment rights installed by Aramco's founding multinational companies).

This study utilizes qualitative, historically oriented, cross-national case studies to compare and assess workers' health, safety, and rights in Saudi Aramco with its U.S. counterpart, Motiva Enterprises. Two facilities were chosen to conduct field research: the Saudi Aramco oil refinery at Jeddah and Motiva's refinery at Port Arthur, Texas. The Jeddah refinery is fully owned by Saudi Aramco, thus, representing Aramco's health and safety policies and regulations. The Port Arthur refinery serves as a reference case study for U.S. oil refining facilities. The aspects of occupational health and safety in Saudi Aramco—ExxonMobil's joint ventures SAMREF and LUBREF—also are discussed to examine workers' health policies in both companies.

The American oil industry made a significant contribution in establishing the Saudi oil industry, with the cooperation of the Saudi government. Despite having outstanding employment benefits schemes in Saudi Aramco, the presence of an organized work force better serves employee participation in Motiva than in Aramco. Safety systems such as Process Safety Management (PSM)—applied in Motiva—partially exist in Aramco to operate hardware technologies safely. Motiva training systems are better through PACE's Triangle of Prevention (TOP). Both companies follow the same pattern of handling occupational injuries and diseases; however, Saudi government agencies (GOSI) are responsible for compensating and treating injured workers. Saudi workers expressed conditional support for the worker committee program proposed by the Ministry of Labor. American and Saudi workers are concerned about the quality and sufficiency of health and safety training, employment promotion, work pressure, and job uncertainty due to continuous downsizing.

This article recommends that Saudi social actors increase safety and health awareness in the work environment by providing intensive occupational safety training to the employees (as demanded by Saudi and American workers), improve labor-management relations through establishing strong cooperative contacts with regional and international trade unions, and establish uniform and standard occupational health and safety regulations for Saudi Aramco and its subsidiaries in order to provide an equal level of protection for Saudi workers.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Siqueira

and Levenstein

. Dependent Convergence: The Importation of Technological Hazards by Semiperipheral Countries. International Journal of Health Services. 30(4): 681–697, 2000.

Castleman

. Multinational Corporations, Environmental, and The Third World: Business Matters, Pearson

(editor). North Carolina: World Resources Institute, Duke University Press, Durham, pp. 149–172, 1987.

Castleman

. The Export of Hazards—Transnational corporations and environmental control issues, Ives

(editor). Routledge & Kegan Paul, pp. 60–89, 1985.

Chapman

. Government Policies and Internationalization. The International Petrochemical Industry; Blackwell Ltd., pp. 144–168, 1991.

Lunde

Maby

, and Sabini

. 1995. Oil and Saudi Aramco. Saudi Aramco and Its World—Arabia and the Middle East. In: Clark

Mandaville

Tracy

, and Grutz

(editors). Saudi Aramco Publications, Saudi Arabian Oil Company—Dhahran. Revised edition, pp. 175–268.

Lunde

Maby

, and Sabini

. 1995. Saudi Aramco and Its People—A History of Training. Editors: Clark

Mandaville

Tracy

, and Grutz

. Saudi Aramco Publications, Saudi Arabian Oil Company—Dhahran. Revised edition, pp. 1–243.

International Labor Organization (ILO). Saudi Arabia; Social Insurance System of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. International Social Security Review, 50(3): 67–75, 1997.

Noweir

. Occupational Health in Saudi Arabia. World Health Organization—Regional office for the Eastern Mediterranean. Project No. EM/OCH/75/E/R/10.94/22, 11 January—9 February 1994.

Razavi

. Occupational Health in the Oil Industry. Occupational Health Newsletter: 1(1), page 2, First Quarter 1999.

10.

Al-Buqami

and Al-Fadili

. Implementing new labor law gradually. Al-Eqtisadiyah (Saudi newspaper in Arabic), issue no. 3156, January 6, 2002.

11.

International Labor Organization (ILO). The promotion of good industrial relations in oil and gas production and oil refining industrial relations—Report for discussion at the tripartite meeting on the promotion of good industrial relations in oil and gas production and oil refining. Sectoral Activities Program, Geneva, 2002.

12.

Idreis

H. M.

. Impact of Hardware and Software Technologies on Occupational Health and Safety in Saudi Arabian Oil Refineries. Doctorate of Science dissertation, University of Massachusetts Lowell, 2004.

13.

Hashem

. The effects of work climate on process innovation in the Saudi Arabian petrochemical industry. University of Michigan, 1999.

14.

Badre

and Siksek

. Labor Resources: Recruitment and Commitment. Manpower and oil in Arab countries. Hyperion Press, Inc., Westport, CT, pp. 42–54, 1981.

15.

Alkahtany

. Organizational commitment; cross-national comparison of Arab and non-Arab employees in Saudi petrochemical companies. College of Business Administration, Robert B. Toulouse School of Graduate Studies, May 1998.

16.

Aldhiyab

. The impact of providing health, safety, and security tools in work environment on workers behavior and productivity—study on Saudi Aramco refineries in Jeddah and Riyadh. Ministry of Interior—High Commission for Industrial Security, Secretariat General. The Eleventh Industrial Security Symposium, November 1998.

17.

Noweir

Al-Idrisi

, and Al-Jiffry

. Appraisal of work hazards and safety in the industrial estate of Jeddah. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 27: 35–68, 1993.

18.

Ministerial Council of Ministers of Labor and Social Affairs—Executive Bureau. Tools for developing occupational health and safety in light of current challenges. Series of Social and Labor Studies, no. 33, first edition, 1997.

19.

Agreement Between Motiva Enterprises, LLC and PACE (Local No. 4-23, affiliated with the AFL-CIO), (Company document), 2002–2006.

20.

Saudi Aramco: General Internal Rules for the Organization of Work and Workmen. 2003. (Company document).

21.

Karasek

and Theorell

. Healthy Work: Stress, Productivity, and the Reconstruction of Working Life. Basic Books, New York, pp. 161–199, 1990.

22.

Campbell

and Pepper

. Organizational downsizing: Implications for the health of survivors, New Solutions, 12(2): 177–194, 2002.

23.

Saudi Labor Committees. November 15, 2002 (Muharram 27, 1426 H.). Rules for Regulations and Procedures for Implementation, Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs. (Government Document.)