Three experiments were conducted to examine the relative impact of lyrics vs. music on mood. In Experiment 1, the lyrics, music, or lyrics plus music of a sad song were presented to college students. While the music alone increased positive affect and decreased depression, the lyrics plus music had the opposite effect. In Experiment 2, the sad lyrics plus music also increased depression and decreased positive affect even when performed in an up-beat style. Experiment 3 showed that pairing the melody with the sad lyrics led subjects to rate the melody alone as less pleasant one week later. Lyrics, thus, appear to have greater power to direct mood change than music alone and can imbue a particular melody with affective qualities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HevnerK., Experimental Studies of the Elements of Expression in Music, American Journal of Psychology, 48, pp. 246–248, 1936.
2.
DainowE., Physical Effects and Motor Responses to Music, Journal of Research in Music Education, 25, pp. 211–221, 1977.
3.
ZimnyG. H. and WeidenfellerE. W., Effects of Music upon GSR and Heart-Rate, American Journal of Psychology, 76, pp. 311–314, 1963.
4.
ThompsonW. F. and RobitailleB., Can Composers Express Emotions through Music?, Empirical Studies of the Arts, 10, pp. 79–89, 1992.
5.
WalkerR., Musical Beliefs: Psychoacoustic, Mythical and Education Perspectives, New York Teachers College Press, New York, 1990.
6.
St. LawrenceJ. and JoynerD., The Effects of Sexually Violent Rock Music on Males' Acceptance of Violence against Women, Psychology of Women Quarterly, 15, pp. 49–63, 1991.
7.
IversonJ.ReesH., and RevlinR., The Effect of Music on the Personal Relevance of Lyrics, Psychology: A Journal of Human Behavior, 26, pp. 15–22, 1989.
8.
CrowderR.SerafineM. L., and ReppB., Physical Interaction and Association by Contiguity in Memory for the Words and Melodies of Songs, Memory and Cognition, 18, pp. 469–476, 1990.
9.
SerafineM. L.DavidsonJ.CrowderR., and ReppB., On the Nature of Melody-Text Integration in Memory for Songs, Journal of Memory and Language, 25, pp. 123–135, 1986.
10.
HymanI. E. and RubinD. C., Memorabeatlia: A Naturalistic Study of Long-Term Memory, Memory and Cognition, 18, pp. 205–214, 1990.
11.
YalchR. F., Memory in a Jingle Jungle: Music as a Mnemonic Device in Communicating Advertising Slogans, Journal of Applied Psychology, 76, pp. 268–275, 1991.
12.
GalizioM. and HendrickC., Effect of Musical Accompaniment on Attitude: The Guitar as a Prop for Persuasion, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2, pp. 350–359, 1972.
13.
GfellerK. and CoffmanD., An Investigation of Emotional Response of Trained Musicians to Verbal and Music Information, Psychomusiocology, 10, pp. 31–48, 1991.
14.
VeltenE., A Laboratory Task for Induction of Mood States, Behavior Research and Therapy, 6, pp. 473–482, 1968.
15.
StrattonV. N. and ZalanowskiA. H., The Effects of Music and Paintings on Mood, Journal of Music Therapy, 26, pp. 30–41, 1989.
16.
ZuckermanM. and LubinB., Manual for the Multiple Affect Adjective Check List, Revised, Educational and Industrial Testing Service, San Diego, California, 1985.
17.
StrattonV. N. and ZalanowskiA. H., The Effects of Music and Cognition on Mood, Psychology of Music, 19, pp. 121–127, 1991.
18.
MartinI. and LeveyA. B., Conditioning Evaluations and Cognitions: An Axis of Integration, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 23, pp. 167–175, 1985.
19.
GornG., The Effects of Music in Advertising on Choice Behavior: A Classical Conditioning Approach, Journal of Marketing, 46, pp. 94–101, 1982.
20.
BierleyC.McSweeneyF., and VannieuwkerkR., Classical Conditioning of Preferences for Stimuli, Journal of Consumer Research, 12, pp. 316–323, 1985.
21.
BlairM. E. and ShimpT. A., Consequences of an Unpleasant Experience with Music: A Second-Order Negative Conditioning Perspective, Journal of Advertising, 21, pp. 35–43, 1992.
