The single known instance of transmission of HIV from a health care provider to a patient raised issues concerning the responsibility of clinicians to their patients, and sparked debate over policies to prevent the spread of HIV in health care facilities. The intensity and politicization of the debate were reflected in revision of the Centers for Disease Control guidelines to control the spread of infection at health care facilities, and in legislation proposed in Congress. The guidelines and proposed legislation provoked responses by public health and medical organizations, several of which considered the measures to be unnecessarily restrictive and too costly in terms of potential benefits. This article describes the events and responses that took place during 1991–1992 after the public was made aware of the case involving transmission from provider to patient. The author examines the situation in the context of public health efforts to control the spread of HIV.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
PalcaJ.CDC closes the case of the Florida dentist. Science256: 1130–1131, 1992.
2.
Centers for Disease Control. Recommendations for prevention of HIV transmission in health-care settings. MMWR Morb. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 36(Suppl. 2S): 1S–19S, 1987.
3.
AltaianL. K.Study sees no new transmissions of H.I.V. by health-care workers. New York Times, May 15, 1992.
4.
Centers for Disease Control. Recommendations for preventing transmission of human immunodeficiency virus and hepatitis B virus to patients during exposure-prone invasive procedures. MMWR Morb. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 40(No. RR-8): 1–9, 1991.
5.
Modified Leadership Amendment Act, Section 003, Public Law 102-141, 1991.
6.
RoperW. L., Director, Department of Health and Human Services. Letter to State Health Officers. Atlanta, June 18, 1992.
7.
National Commission on AIDS. Preventing HTV Transmission in Health Care Settings. Washington, D.C., July 1993.
8.
DanielsN.HIV-infected health care professionals: Public threat or public sacrifice?Milbank Q. 70(1): 3–42, 1992.
9.
DanielsN.HIV-infected professionals, patient rights, and the “switching dilemma.”JAMA267(10): 1368–1371, 1992.
10.
St. LouisM. E.Seroprevalence rates of human immunodeficiency virus infection at sentinel hospitals in the United States. N. Engl. J. Med.323: 213–218, 1990.
11.
Dentist dies of AIDS, and patients are offered test. New York Times, March 18, 1991.
12.
Surgeons rebuff U.S. AIDS request. New York Times, October 25, 1991.
13.
American Public Health Association. Written Testimony for the Centers for Disease Control. Presented at the Open Meeting on the Risk of Transmission of Bloodborne Pathogens to Patients During Invasive Procedures, Washington, D.C., March 1991.
14.
Centers for Disease Control. Revised Recommendations for Preventing Transmission of Human Immunodeficiency Virus and Hepatitis B Virus to Patients During Invasive Procedures. Draft memo. November 27, 1991.
15.
IfillG.Panel in Congress drops AIDS disclosure plan. New York Times, September 28, 1991.
16.
New York State Department of Health. Policy Statement and Guidelines to Prevent Transmission of HIV and Hepatitis B Through Medical/Dental Procedures. Albany, NY., 1992.
17.
ACLU AIDS Project. ACLU Information Packet: HIV Testing of Health Care Workers. New York, March 1991.
18.
NavarroM.New definition for AIDS arrives, bringing new Concerns. New York Times, January 6, 1993.
19.
BlendonR.KarenD.KnoxR.Public opinion and AIDS. JAMA267: 981–986, 1992.
20.
LedbetterC.JohnsonD.AIDS: Reading analysis of Understanding AIDS. AIDS and Public Policy4(3): 168–170, 1989.
21.
AltmanL. K.Cost of treating AIDS patient is soaring. New York Times, July 23, 1992.
22.
ColombotosJ.Physicians, Nurses and AIDS: Preliminary Findings from a National Survey. Publication 91-0024. Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, Washington, D.C., 1991.
23.
KantrowitzB.Doctors with AIDS: The Right to Know. Newsweek July 1, 1991, pp. 48–57.
24.
Centers for Disease Control. Update: Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome and human immunodeficiency virus infection among health care workers. MMWR Morb. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 37: 229–234, 239, 1988.
25.
Presidential Commission on AIDS. Report of the Presidential Commission on the Human Immunodeficiency Virus Epidemic. GPO publication no. 0-214-701:QL3. Washington, D.C., June 24, 1988.
26.
RogersD.Testimony at Public Hearing: The Impact of Regulatory Guidelines and Legislative Proposals Which Recommend HIV Testing, Disclosure and/or Workplace Restrictions for HCWs. Department of Health, New York City, September 11–13, 1991.
27.
The Americans with Disabilities Act (1990). Pub. L. 101-336, 104 Stat. 327, 1990.
28.
GostinL.The AIDS Litigation Project: A National Review of Court and Human Rights Commission Decisions, Part 1: The Social Impact of AIDS, Vol. 263, pp. 1961–1971, 1990.
29.
HeagartyM.AbramsE.Caring for HIV-infected women and children. N. Engl. J. Med.326(13): 887–888, 1992.
30.
Centers for Disease Control. Draft Guidelines for HIV Testing Services for Inpatients and Outpatients in Acute-Care Hospital Settings. Atlanta, September 1991.
31.
GuttmacherS.The limits of the medical model—ethics and preventive medicine: The case of borderline hypertension. Hastings Center Rep. 11(1): 12–20, 1981.
32.
SlovicP.Perception of risk. Science236: 280–285, 1987.
33.
GlantzL.MarinerW. K.AnnasG.Risky business: Setting public health policy for HIV-infected health care professionals. Milbank Q. 70(1): 43–79, 1992.
34.
Surgeons denying care to AIDS patients stirs ethical debate. AIDS Alert2: 153–158, 1987.
