The Roundtop site located in the Upper Susquehanna River Valley of New York has long been held to contain the earliest evidence for maize-beans-squash agriculture in the Northeast. In his reports on this site, Ritchie linked charred maize, beans, and squash remains with a radiocarbon date of A.D. 1070 + 60 and pottery associated with the early Owasco Carpenter Brook phase. Recent AMS dating of the domesticates indicates that there is no evidence for maize, beans, and squash co-occurring at the site before A.D. 1300. The dates are supported by pottery collections and Ritchie's lab notes. These results emphasize that site descriptions in the literature are interpretations not observations. These interpretations need to be carefully assessed before their incorporation into new analyses and syntheses. This can only be done if collections of artifacts, botanical and zoological remains, and field and lab notes are maintained by museums.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BendremerJ. C. M. and DewarR. E.1994The Advent of Prehistoric Maize in New England, in Corn & Culture in the Prehistoric New World, JohannessenS. and HastorfC. A. (eds.), Westview Press, Boulder, pp. 369–393.
2.
BendremerJ. C. M.KelloggE. A., and LargyT.B.1991A Grass-Lined Maize Storage Pit and Early Maize Horticulture in Central Connecticut, North American Archaeologist, 12, pp. 325–349.
3.
BrownJ. A.1977Current Directions in Midwestern Archaeology, Annual Reviews in Anthropology, 6, pp. 161–179.
4.
CassedyD. and WebbP.1999New Data on the Chronology of Maize Horticulture in Eastern New York and Southern New England, in Current Northeast Paleoethnobotany, HartJ. P. (ed.), New York State Museum Bulletin 494, The University of the State of New York, Albany, pp. 85–100.
5.
CrawfordG. W.SmithD. G., and BowyerV. E.1997Dating the Entry of Corn (Zea mays) into the Lower Great Lakes Region, American Antiquity, 62, pp. 112–119.
6.
FordR. I.1985Patterns of Prehistoric Food Production in North America, in Prehistoric Food Production in North America, FordR. I. (ed.), Anthropological Papers No. 75, Museum of Anthropology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, pp. 309–364.
7.
FunkR. E.1993Archaeological Investigations in the Upper Susquehanna Valley, New York State, Persimmon Press, Buffalo.
8.
GeorgeR. I.1983The Gnagey Site and the Monongahela Occupation of the Somerset Plateau, Pennsylvania Archaeologist, 53:4, pp. 1–97.
9.
HartJ. P.1999Dating Roundtop's Domesticates: Implications for Northeast Late Prehistory, in Current Northeast Paleoethnobotany, HartJ. P. (ed.), pp. 47–68, New York State Museum Bulletin 494, The University of the State of New York, Albany.
10.
HartJ. P. and SidellN. Asch1996Prehistoric Agricultural Systems in the West Branch of the Susquehanna River Basin, A.D. 800 to A.D. 1350, Northeast Anthropology, 52, pp. 1–30.
11.
HartJ. P. and AschN. Sidell1997Additional Evidence for Early Cucurbit Use in the Northern Eastern Woodlands East of the Allegheny Front, American Antiquity, 62, pp. 523–537.
12.
HartJ. P. and ScarryC. M.1999The Age of Common Beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) in the Northeastern United States. American Antiquity, 64:4, pp. 653–658.
13.
HayC. A. and HamiltonC. E.1984The Bald Eagle Township Sewage Collection System Archaeological Project: Final Mitigation Research, The Pennsylvania State University, Department of Anthropology, Technical Report No. 2, University Park.
14.
HeckenbergerM. J.PetersonJ. B., and SidellN. Asch1992Early Evidence of Maize Agriculture in the Connecticut River Valley of Vermont, Archaeology of Eastern North America, 20, pp. 125–150.
15.
KaplanL.1971Phaseolus: Diffusion and Centers of Origin, in Man Across the Sea, RileyC. L.KellyJ. C.PenningtonC. W., and RandsR. C. (eds.), The University of Texas Press, Austin, pp. 416–427.
16.
KnappT.1996Stage 3 Data Recovery, Thomas Luckey Site (SUBi-888), Town of Ashland, Chemung County, New York, Public Archaeology Facility, Binghamton University, Binghamton, New York.
17.
LaccettiMichael F.1965The Roundtop Site: A Postulated Early Owasco Component, The Bulletin of the New York State Archaeological Association, 33, pp. 12–20.
18.
LaccettiMichael F.1966The Roundtop Site: A Pre-Iroquoian Farming Village in South-Central New York: Amateurs Uncover Early Indian Village in Southern Tier, The New York State Conservationist, 22:3, pp. 12–14.
19.
LaccettiMichael F.1974The Roundtop Site: An Early Owasco Horticultural Stage, The Bulletin of the New York State Archaeological Association, 62, pp. 4–26.
20.
McBrideKevin A. and DewarRobert E.1987Agriculture and Cultural Evolution: Causes and Effects in the Lower Connecticut River Valley, in Emergent Horticultural Economies of the Eastern Woodlands, KeeganWilliam F. (ed.), Southern Illinois University at Carbondale, Center for Archaeological Investigations, Occasional Paper No. 7, pp. 305–328.
21.
MoellerRoger W.1992Analyzing and Interpreting Late Woodland Features, Occasional Publications in Northeastern Anthropolgy, 12, Bethlehem, Connecticut.
22.
MunsonP. J.1973The Origins and Antiquity of Maize-Beans-Squash Agriculture: Some Linguistic Implications, in Variations in Anthropology, LathrapD. W. and DouglasJ. (eds.), Illinois Archaeological Survey, Urbana, Illinois, pp. 107–139.
23.
PetersonJ. B. and SidellN. Asch1996Mid-Holocene Evidence of Cucurbita sp. from Central Maine, American Antiquity, 61, pp. 685–698.
24.
PrezzanoS.C.1992Longhouse, Village, and Palisade: Community Patterns at the Iroquois Southern Door, University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, Michigan.
25.
RileyT. J.EdgingR., and RosenJ.1990Cultigens in Prehistoric Eastern North America: Changing Paradigms, Current Anthropology, 31, pp. 525–542.
26.
RitchieW. A.1969The Archaeology of New York State, Natural History Press, Garden City, New York.
27.
RitchieW. A.1973The Roundtop Site (Apl. 1), in Aboriginal Settlement Patterns in the Northeast, by RitchieW. A. and FunkR. E., Memoir 20, New York Museum & Science Service, The University of the State of New York, Albany, pp. 179–194.
28.
RitchieW. A. and FunkR. E.1973Aboriginal Settlement Patterns in the Northeast, Memoir 20, New York Museum & Science Service, The University of the State of New York, Albany.
29.
RitchieW. A. and MacNeishR.1949The Pre-Iroquoian Pottery of New York State, American Antiquity, 15:2, pp. 97–124.
30.
SnowD. R.1980The Archaeology of New England, Academic Press, New York.
31.
SnowD. R.1995Migration in Prehistory: The Northern Iroquoian Case, American Antiquity, 60, pp. 59–79.
32.
WinterJ.1971A Summary of Owasco and Iroquois Maize Remains, Pennsylvania Archaeologist, 41:3, pp. 1–11.
33.
YarnellR. A.1976Early Plant Husbandry in Eastern North America, in Cultural Change and Continuity: Essays in Honor of James Bennett Griffin, ClelandC. (ed.), Academic Press, New York, pp. 265–274.
