The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of ventilation tube (VT) placement on long-term hearing outcomes in children with cleft palate.
Study Design
Case series with chart review.
Setting
Genetic and dysmorphology database at Rady Children's Hospital–San Diego (RCHSD).
Patients
Children with cleft palate diagnosis who underwent surgery at RCHSD between 1995 and 2002.
Main Outcome Measure
The primary outcome studied was hearing acuity at 10 years of age. Independent variables studied included gender, age at palate repair and first VT placement, total number of VTs, number of complications, and presence of tympanic membrane perforation.
Results
An increased number of tubes was associated with a greater incidence of hearing loss at age 10, even after adjusting for total number of otologic complications. The timing of initial tube placement did not have a significant effect on long-term hearing outcome in this study.
Conclusions
While children with worse middle ear disease are more likely to receive more tubes and have long-term conductive hearing loss as a result of ear disease, the results of this study suggest that multiple tube placements may not contribute to improved long-term hearing outcomes. Further research focusing on long-term outcomes is needed to establish patient-centered criteria guiding decision making for ventilation tube placement in children with cleft palate.
de BeerB.A., SchilderA.G., IngelsK., SnikA.F., ZielhuisG.A., GraamansK.Hearing loss in young adults who had ventilation tube insertion in childhood.Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol.2004; 113: 438–444.
4.
DhillonR.S.The middle ear in cleft palate children pre and post palatal closure.J R Soc Med.1988; 81: 710–713.
5.
DoyleW.J., ReillyJ.S., JardiniL., RovnakS.Effect of palatoplasty on the function of the eustachian tube in children with cleft palate.Cleft Palate J.1986; 23: 63–68.
6.
FlynnT., LohmanderA., MollerC., MagnussonL.A longitudinal study of hearing and middle ear status in adolescents with cleft lip and palate.Laryngoscope.2013; 123: 1374–1380.
7.
GoudyS., LottD., CanadyJ., SmithR.J.Conductive hearing loss and otopathology in cleft palate patients.Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.2006; 134: 946–948.
8.
GouldH.J.Hearing loss and cleft palate: the perspective of time.Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1990; 27: 36–39.
9.
Handžic-CukJ., CukV., GluhinicM., RišaviR., Štajner-KatušicS.Tympanometric findings in cleft palate patients: influence of age and cleft type.J Laryngol Otol.2001; 115: 91–96.
10.
HongH.R., KimT.S., ChungJ.W.Long-term follow-up of otitis media with effusion in children: comparisons between a ventilation tube group and a non-ventilation tube group.Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.2014; 78: 938–943.
11.
JonesM.Etiology of facial clefts: prospective evaluation of 428 patients.Cleft Palate J.1988; 25: 16–20.
12.
KlockarsT., RautioJ.Early placement of ventilation tubes in cleft lip and palate patients: does palatal closure affect tube occlusion and short term outcome?Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.2012; 76: 1481–1484.
13.
KuoC.L., TsaoY.H., ShiaoA.S.Critical reassessment of the probability of receiving additional ventilation tube insertion for recurrent otitis media with effusion in children with cleft palate.Acta Otolaryngol.2015; 135: 519–520.
14.
MarrinanE.M., LaBrieR.A., MullikenJ.B.Velopharyngeal function in nonsyndromic cleft palate: relevance of surgical technique, age at repair, and cleft type.Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1998; 35: 95–100.
15.
MerrickG.D., KunjurJ., WattsR., MarkusA.F.The effect of early insertion of grommets on the development of speech in children with cleft palates.Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg.2007; 45: 527–533.
16.
MurrayJ.Gene/environment causes of cleft lip and/or palate.Clin Genet.2002; 61: 248–256.
17.
ParadiseJ.L., BluestoneC.D., FelderH.The universality of otitis media in 50 infants with cleft palate.Pediatrics.1969; 44: 35–42.
18.
PonduriS., BradleyR., EllisP.E., BrookesS.T., SandyJ.R., NessA.R.The management of otitis media with early routine insertion of grommets in children with cleft palate—a systematic review.Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2009; 46: 30–38.
19.
ReiterR., HaaseS., BroschS.Repaired cleft palate and ventilation tubes and their associations with cholesteatoma in children and adults.Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2009; 46: 598–602.
20.
RobinsonP.J., LodgeS., JonesB.M., WalkerC.C., GrantH.R.The effect of palate repair on otitis media with effusion.Plast Reconstr Surg.1992; 89: 640–645.
21.
RosenfeldR.M., SchwartzS.R., PynnonenM.A., TunkelD.E., HusseyH.M., FicheraJ.S., GrimesA.M., HackellJ.M., HarrisonM.F., HaskellH.Clinical practice guideline: tympanostomy tubes in children.Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.2013; 149(IS): S1–S35.
22.
ShawR., RichardsonD., McMahonS.Conservative management of otitis media in cleft palate.J Craniomaxillofac Surg.2003; 31: 316–320.
23.
SheahanP., BlayneyA.W., SheahanJ.N., EarleyM.J.Sequelae of otitis media with effusion among children with cleft lip and/or cleft palate.Clin Otolaryngol.2002; 27: 494–500.
24.
SheahanP., MillerI., SheahanJ.N., EarleyM.J., BlayneyA.W.Incidence and outcome of middle ear disease in cleft lip and/or cleft palate.Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.2003; 67: 785–793.
25.
SmithT.L., DiRuggieroD.C., JonesK.R.Recovery of Eustachian tube function and hearing outcome in patients with cleft palate.Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.1994; 111: 423–429.
26.
SzaboC., LangevinK., SchoemS., MabryK.Treatment of persistent middle ear effusion in cleft palate patients.Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.2010; 74: 874–877.
27.
TimmermansK., Vander PoortenV., DesloovereC., DebruyneF.The middle ear of cleft palate patients in their early teens: a literature study and preliminary file study.B-ENT.2006; 2(suppl 4): 95–101.
28.
TimmonsM., WyattR., MurphyT.Speech after repair of isolated cleft palate and cleft lip and palate.Br J Plast Surg.2001; 54: 377–384.
29.
TuncbilekG., OzgurF., BelginE.Audiologic and tympanometric findings in children with cleft lip and palate.Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2003; 40: 304–309.
30.
ValtonenH., DietzA., QvarnbergY.Long-term clinical, audiologic, and radiologic outcomes in palate cleft children treated with early tympanostomy for otitis media with effusion: a controlled prospective study.Laryngoscope.2005; 115: 1512–1516.
