Using the Dutch Oral Cleft Registration, which records the morphology and topography of common oral clefts, a new classification based on the (patho)embryology of the primary and secondary palates was tested.
Design
Prospective observational study.
Setting
The fifteen cleft palate teams in the Netherlands register patients to the national registry.
Patients
All unoperated patients with common oral clefts reported between 1997 and 2006 inclusive were included.
Main Outcome Measures
The classification is based on the pathoembryological events that ultimately result in various subphenotypes of common oral clefts. Patients within the three categories cleft lip/alveolus (CL/A), cleft lip/alveolus and palate (CL/AP), and cleft palate (CP) were divided into three subgroups: fusion defects, differentiation defects, and fusion and differentiation defects. A timetable was constructed to relate the type of clefting to the time of derailment during embryonic development.
Results
3512 patients were included. Patients with CL/A showed 22% fusion defects, 75% differentiation defects, and 3% fusion and differentiation defects. CL/AP patients and CP patients mostly showed fusion defects (70% and 89%, respectively). We were able to relate almost all (over 90%) cleft subphenotypes to specific weeks in embryonic development.
Conclusions
This classification provides new cleft subgroups that may be used for clinical and fundamental research. The subphenotypes of these subgroups originate from different time frames during embryonic development and different cell biological mechanisms, thereby enabling more accurate data for, e.g., gene identification and/or environmental factors.
BushJ.O., JiangR.Palatogenesis: morphogenetic and molecular mechanisms of secondary palate development. Development.2012; 139: 231–243.
2.
CanfieldM.A., HoneinM.A., YuskivN., XingJ., MaiC.T., CollinsJ.S., DevineO., PetriniJ., RamadhaniT.A., HobbsC.A.. National estimates and race/ethnic-specific variation of selected birth defects in the United States, 1999–2001. Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol.2006; 76: 747–756.
3.
CarinciF., ScapoliL., PalmieriA., ZollinoI., PezzettiF.Human genetic factors in nonsyndromic cleft lip and palate: an update. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol.2007; 71: 1509–1519.
4.
ChaiY., MaxsonR.E.Jr. Recent advances in craniofacial morphogenesis. Dev Dyn.2006; 235: 2353–2375.
5.
ChiquetB.T., BlantonS.H., BurtA., MaD., StalS., MullikenJ.B., HechtJ.T.Variation in WNT genes is associated with non-syndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate. Hum Mol Genet.2008; 17: 2212–2218.
6.
CornelM.C., SpreenJ.A., MeijerI., SpauwenP.H., DharB.K., ten KateL.P.Some epidemiological data on oral clefts in the northern Netherlands, 1981–1988 [published correction appears in J Craniomaxillofac Surg. 1992;20: 363]. J Craniomaxillofac Surg.1992; 20: 147–152.
7.
CoxT.C.Taking it to the max: the genetic and developmental mechanisms coordinating midfacial morphogenesis and dysmorphology. Clin Genet.2004; 65: 163–176.
8.
CuervoR., CovarrubiasL.Death is the major fate of medial edge epithelial cells and the cause of basal lamina degradation during palatogenesis. Development.2004; 131: 15–24.
9.
DixonM.J., MarazitaM.L., BeatyT.H., MurrayJ.C.Cleft lip and palate: understanding genetic and environmental influences. Nat Rev Genet.2011; 12: 167–178.
10.
DudasM., LiW.Y., KimJ., YangA., KaartinenV.Palatal fusion: where do the midline cells go? A review on cleft palate, a major human birth defect. Acta Histochem.2007; 109: 1–14.
11.
DuongT.D., EricksonC.A.MMP-2 plays an essential role in producing epithelial-mesenchymal transformations in the avian embryo. Dev Dyn.2004; 229: 42–53.
InoueH., KayanoS., AokiY., KureS., YamadaA., HataA., MatsubaraY., SuzukiY.Association of the GABRB3 gene with nonsyndromic oral clefts. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2008; 45: 261–266.
20.
IsekiS.Disintegration of the medial epithelial seam: is cell death important in palatogenesis?Dev Growth Differ.2011; 53: 259–268.
21.
JiangR., BushJ.O., LidralA.C.Development of the upper lip: morphogenetic and molecular mechanisms. Dev Dyn.2006; 235: 1152–1166.
22.
JinJ.Z., DingJ.Analysis of cell migration, transdifferentiation and apoptosis during mouse secondary palate fusion. Development.2006; 133: 3341–3347.
23.
JohnstonM.C., BronskyP.T.Prenatal craniofacial development: new insights on normal and abnormal mechanisms [corrected and republished in Crit Rev Oral Biol Med. 1; 6: 368–422]. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med.1995; 6: 25–79.
JuriloffD.M., HarrisM.J.Mouse genetic models of cleft lip with or without cleft palate. Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol.2008; 82: 63–77.
28.
KitamuraH.Evidence for cleft palate as a postfusion phenomenon. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1991; 28: 195–210.
29.
KrapelsI.P., Vermeij-KeersC., MullerM., de KleinA., Steegers-TheunissenR.P.Nutrition and genes in the development of orofacial clefting. Nutr Rev.2006; 64: 280–288.
30.
LavrinI.O., McLeanW., SeegmillerR.E., OlsenB.R., HayE.D.The mechanism of palatal clefting in the Col11a1 mutant mouse. Arch Oral Biol.2001; 46: 865–869.
LuijsterburgA.J.M., Vermeij-KeersC.Recording and classification common oral clefts. In: LiljaJ., ed. Transactions. The 9th International Congress on Cleft Palate and Related Craniofacial Anomalies.Götenborg: Erlanders Novum; 2001: 243–250.
33.
LuijsterburgA.J., Vermeij-KeersC.Ten years recording common oral clefts with a new descriptive system. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2011; 48: 173–182.
34.
LynchJ.B., LewisS.R., BlockerT.G.Jr. Cleft palate not explained by embryology. Plast Reconstr Surg.1966; 38: 552–554.
35.
Martinez-AlvarezC., BlancoM.J., PerezR., RabadanM.A., AparicioM., ReselE., MartinezT., NietoM.A.Snail family members and cell survival in physiological and pathological cleft palates. Dev Biol.2004; 265: 207–218.
36.
Martinez-AlvarezC., TudelaC., Perez-MiguelsanzJ., O'KaneS., PuertaJ., FergusonM.W.Medial edge epithelial cell fate during palatal fusion. Dev Biol.2000; 220: 343–357.
37.
Martinez-SanzE., Del RioA., BarrioC., MurilloJ., MaldonadoE., GarcillanB., AmorosM., FuerteT., FernandezA., TrinidadE.. Alteration of medial-edge epithelium cell adhesion in two Tgf-beta3 null mouse strains. Differentiation.2008; 76: 417–430.
38.
MengL., BianZ., TorensmaR., Von den HoffJ.W.Biological mechanisms in palatogenesis and cleft palate. J Dent Res.2009; 88: 22–33.
NogaiH., RosowskiM., GrunJ., RietzA., DebusN., SchmidtG., LausterC., JanitzM., VortkampA., LausterR.Follistatin antagonizes transforming growth factor-beta3-induced epithelial-mesenchymal transition in vitro: implications for murine palatal development supported by microarray analysis. Differentiation.2008; 76: 404–416.
41.
RayH.J., NiswanderL.Mechanisms of tissue fusion during development. Development.2012; 139: 1701–1711.
42.
RittlerM., Lopez-CameloJ.S., CastillaE.E., BermejoE., CocchiG., CorreaA., Csaky-SzunyoghM., DanderferR., De ViganC., De WalleH.. Preferential associations between oral clefts and other major congenital anomalies. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2008; 45: 525–532.
43.
RozendaalA.M., LuijsterburgA.J., MohangooA.D., OngkosuwitoE.M., AnthonyS., Vermeij-KeersC.Validation of the NVSCA Registry for Common Oral Clefts: study design and first results. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2010; 47: 534–543.
44.
RozendaalA.M., LuijsterburgA.J., MohangooA.D., OngkosuwitoE., De VriesE., Vermeij-KeersC.Validation of the Dutch Registry of Common Oral Clefts: quality of recording specific oral cleft features. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2012; 49: 609–617.
45.
RozendaalA.M., LuijsterburgA.J., OngkosuwitoE.M., van den BoogaardM.J., de VriesE., HoviusS.E., Vermeij-KeersC.Delayed diagnosis and underreporting of congenital anomalies associated with oral clefts in the Netherlands: a national validation study. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg.2012; 65: 780–790.
46.
RozendaalA.M., MohangooA.D., OngkosuwitoE.M., BuitendijkS.E., BakkerM.K., Vermeij-KeersC.Regional variation in prevalence of oral cleft live births in the Netherlands 1997–2007: time-trend analysis of data from three Dutch registries. Am J Med Genet A.2012; 158A: 66–74.
47.
SunD., BaurS., HayE.D.Epithelial-mesenchymal transformation is the mechanism for fusion of the craniofacial primordia involved in morphogenesis of the chicken lip. Dev Biol.2000; 228: 337–349.
48.
TaniguchiK., SatoN., UchiyamaY.Apoptosis and heterophagy of medial edge epithelial cells of the secondary palatine shelves during fusion. Arch Histol Cytol.1995; 58: 191–203.
49.
van den BoogaardM.J., de CostaD., KrapelsI.P., LiuF., van DuijnC., SinkeR.J., LindhoutD., Steegers-TheunissenR.P.The MSX1 allele 4 homozygous child exposed to smoking at periconception is most sensitive in developing nonsyndromic orofacial clefts. Hum Genet.2008; 124: 525–534.
50.
van den BoogaardM.J., DorlandM., BeemerF.A., van AmstelH.K.MSX1 mutation is associated with orofacial clefting and tooth agenesis in humans. Nat Genet.2000; 24: 342–343.
51.
Vaziri SaniF., HallbergK., HarfeB.D., McMahonA.P., LindeA., Gritli-LindeA.Fate-mapping of the epithelial seam during palatal fusion rules out epithelial-mesenchymal transformation. Dev Biol.2005; 285: 490–495.
52.
Vermeij-KeersC.Craniofacial embryology and morphogenesis: normal and abnormal. In: StrickerM., Van der MeulenJ.C., RaphaelB., MazzolaR., TolhurstD.E., MurrayJ.E., ed. Craniofacial Malformations.Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone; 1990: 27–60.
53.
Vermeij-KeersC., MazzolaR.F., Van der MeulenJ.C., StricklerM.Cerebro-craniofacial and craniofacial malformations: an embryo-logical analysis. Cleft Palate J.1983; 20: 128–145.
54.
VieiraA.R.Association between the transforming growth factor alpha gene and nonsyndromic oral clefts: a HuGE review. Am J Epidemiol.2006; 163: 790–810.
55.
VukojevicK., KeroD., NovakovicJ., Kalibovic GovorkoD., Saraga-BabicM.Cell proliferation and apoptosis in the fusion of human primary and secondary palates. Eur J Oral Sci.2012; 120: 283–291.
