To compare videonasendoscopy, lateral videofluoroscopy, and perceptual speech examination in the assessment of velopharyngeal dysfunction.
Design
Retrospective observational.
Setting
Multidisciplinary cleft palate team at a tertiary academic institution.
Patients, Participants
Patients who had undergone videonasendoscopy and lateral videofluoroscopy for suspected velopharyngeal dysfunction at our center were evaluated. Inclusion required that videonasendoscopy, lateral videofluoroscopy, and the perceptual speech exam were performed on the same day. A total of 88 patients were analyzed.
Main outcome Measure(s)
Primary outcome measures included percent closure on videonasendoscopy, percent closure on lateral videofluoroscopy, and quantitative scores for hypernasal resonance, nasal emission, and facial grimace. Additional outcome measures included linear and angular anatomic measurements obtained from lateral videofluoroscopy.
Results
Moderately strong correlation was found between closure estimates of videonasendoscopy and lateral videofluoroscopy (ρ = .583; p < .001). Lateral videofluoroscopy estimates of closure averaged 11.7% higher than videonasendoscopy. Closure correlated moderately with overall speech severity (ρ = .304; p = .005); whereas, a stronger correlation was seen with hypernasal resonance (ρ = –.479; p < .001). Patients exhibiting grimace had worse closure than those without (79.1% versus 70.7%; ρ = .035). Movement angle of the velum and change in genu angle correlated significantly with closure function (ρ = –.304; p = .034 and ρ = –.395; p < .001, respectively).
Conclusions
Videonasendoscopy and lateral videofluoroscopy closure estimates correlated moderately. Lateral videofluoroscopy tended to give smaller gap estimates. Hypernasal resonance and facial grimace are useful clinical indicators of large gap size. Velar movement angle and change in genu angle were identified as anatomical correlates of closure function.
American Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Association (ACPA). Parameters for evaluation and treatment of patients with cleft lip/palate or other craniofacial anomalies: summary of recommendations. Available at http://www.acpa-cpf.org/teamcare/. Accessed November 15, 2008.
2.
ArmourA., FischbachS., KlaimanP., FisherD.M.Does velopharyngeal closure pattern affect the success of pharyngeal flap pharyngoplasty?Plast Reconstr Surg.2005; 115: 45–52, discussion 53.
3.
BirchM.J., SommerladB.C., FennC., ButterworthM.A study of the measurement errors associated with the analysis of velar movements assessed from lateral videofluoroscopic investigations. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1999; 36: 499–507.
ConleyS.F., GosainA.K., MarksS.M., LarsonD.L.Identification and assessment of velopharyngeal inadequacy. Am J Otolaryngol.1997; 18: 38–46.
6.
D'AntonioL.L.Evaluation and management of velopharyngeal dysfunction: a speech pathologist's viewpoint. Probl Plast Reconstr Surg.1992; 2: 86–111.
7.
DalstonR.M., WarrenD.W., SmithL.R.The aerodynamic characteristics of speech produced by normal speakers and cleft palate speakers with adequate velopharyngeal function. Cleft Palate J.1990; 27: 393–399, discussion 400–401.
8.
DudasJ.R., DeleyiannisF.W., FordM.D., JiangS., LoseeJ.E.Diagnosis and treatment of velopharyngeal insufficiency: clinical utility of speech evaluation and videofluoroscopy. Ann Plast Surg.2006; 56: 511–517, discussion 517.
9.
Golding-KushnerK.J., ArgamasoR.V., CottonR.T., GramesL.M., HenningssonG., JonesD.L., KarnellM.P., KlaimanP.G., LewinM.L., MarshJ.L.. Standardization for the reporting of nasopharyngoscopy and multiview videofluoroscopy: a report from an international working group. Cleft Palate J.1990; 27: 337–347, discussion 347–348.
10.
HaS., KuehnD.P., CohenM., AlperinN.Magnetic resonance imaging of the levator veli palatini muscle in speakers with repaired cleft palate. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2007; 44: 494–505.
11.
HenningssonG., IsbergA.Comparison between multiview videofluoroscopy and nasendoscopy of velopharyngeal movements. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1991; 28: 413–417, discussion 417–418.
12.
KarnellM.P., IbukiK., MorrisH.L., Van DemarkD.R.Reliability of the nasopharyngeal fiberscope (NPF) for assessing velopharyngeal function: analysis by judgment. Cleft Palate J.1983; 20: 199–208.
13.
KirschnerR.E., RandallP., WangP., JawadA.F., DuranM., HuangK., SolotC., CohenM., LaRossaD.Cleft palate repair at 3 to 7 months of age. Plast Reconstr Surg.2000; 105: 2127–2132.
14.
KuehnD.P., EttemaS.L., GoldwasserM.S., BarkmeierJ.C.Magnetic resonance imaging of the levator veli palatini muscle before and after primary palatoplasty. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2004; 41: 584–592.
15.
KummerA.W., BillmireD.A., MyerCM3rd. Hypertrophic tonsils: the effect on resonance and velopharyngeal closure. Plast Reconstr Surg.1993; 91: 608–611.
16.
KummerA.W., BriggsM., LeeL.The relationship between the characteristics of speech and velopharyngeal gap size. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2003; 40: 590–596.
17.
KummerA.W., CurtisC., WiggsM., LeeL., StrifeJ.L.Comparison of velopharyngeal gap size in patients with hypernasality, hypernasality and nasal emission, or nasal turbulence (rustle) as the primary speech characteristic. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1992; 29: 152–156.
18.
KummerA.W., NealeH.W.Changes in articulation and resonance after tongue flap closure of palatal fistulas: case reports. Cleft Palate J.1989; 26: 51–55.
19.
LamD.J., StarrJ.R., PerkinsJ.A., LewisC.W., EblenL.E., DunlapJ., SieK.C.A comparison of nasendoscopy and multiview videofluoroscopy in assessing velopharyngeal insufficiency. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.2006; 134: 394–402.
20.
LamE., HundertS., WilkesG.H.Lateral pharyngeal wall and velar movement and tailoring velopharyngeal surgery: determinants of velopharyngeal incompetence resolution in patients with cleft palate. Plast Reconstr Surg.2007; 120: 495–505, discussion 506–507.
21.
LindmanR., PaulinG., StålP.S.Morphological characterization of the levator veli palatini muscle in children born with cleft palates. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.2001; 38: 438–448.
22.
LoskenA., WilliamsJ.K., BursteinF.D., MalickD.N., RiskiJ.E.Surgical correction of velopharyngeal insufficiency in children with velocardiofacial syndrome. Plast Reconstr Surg.2006; 117: 1493–1498.
23.
MarshJ.L.The evaluation and management of velopharyngeal dysfunction. Clin Plast Surg.2004; 31: 261–269.
24.
MarshJ.L.Management of velopharyngeal dysfunction: differential diagnosis for differential management. J Craniofac Surg.2003; 14: 621–628, discussion 629.
McWilliamsB.J., PhillipsB.J.Velopharyngeal Incompetence: Audio Seminars in Speech Pathology.Philadelphia: WB Saunders;1979.
27.
McWilliamsB.J., RandallP., LaRossaD., CohenS., YuJ., CohenM., SolotC.Speech characteristics associated with the Furlow palatoplasty as compared with other surgical techniques. Plast Reconstr Surg.1996; 98: 610–619, discussion 620–621.
28.
PigottR.W., MakepeaceA.P.Some characteristics of endoscopic and radiological systems used in elaboration of the diagnosis of velopharyngeal incompetence. Br J Plast Surg.1982; 35: 19–32.
29.
RudnickE.F., SieK.C.Velopharyngeal insufficiency: current concepts in diagnosis and management. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg.2008; 16: 530–535.
30.
ShprintzenR.J., Golding-KushnerK.J.Evaluation of velopharyngeal insufficiency. Otolaryngol Clin North Am.1989; 22: 519–536.
31.
ShprintzenR.J., LewinM.L., CroftC.B., DanillerA.I., ArgamasoR.V., ShipA.G., StrauchB.A comprehensive study of pharyngeal flap surgery: tailor-made flaps. Cleft Palate J.1979; 16: 46–55.
32.
SieK.C., ChenE.Y.Management of velopharyngeal insufficiency: development of a protocol and modifications of sphincter pharyngoplasty. Facial Plast Surg.2007; 23: 128–139.
33.
SinclairS.W., DaviesD.M., BrackaA.Comparative reliability of nasal pharyngoscopy and videofluorography in the assessment of velopharyngeal incompetence. Br J Plast Surg.1982; 35: 113–117.
SommerladB., RowlandN., HarlandK.Lateral videofluoroscopy: a modification to aid in velopharyngeal assessment and measurement. Cleft Palate Craniofac J.1994; 31: 134–135.
StringerD.A., WitzelM.A.Comparison of multi-view videofluoroscopy and nasopharyngoscopy in the assessment of velopharyngeal insufficiency. Cleft Palate J.1989; 26: 88–92.
38.
WarrenD.W.Compensatory speech behavior in cleft palate: a regulation/control phenomenon?Cleft Palate J.1981; 18: 193–203.
