In explanations offered for fear of crime, two different paradigms can be distinguished. The first considers fear of crime as a rational reaction to crime and victimization; the other views such fear as a representation of more general feelings of malaise. The paradigms suggest different research strategies and offer different explanations for the same empirical observations. The choice of paradigm therefore determines the meaning of the empirical findings and hence the policy implications that can be drawn from them. In this article, the authors describe the paradigms, illustrate the way in which they offer different explanations for the same observations, and try to empirically discriminate between them on the basis of crucial tests. The tests are performed on data for the Flemish (Belgian) population aged nineteen to thirty-six. The results support the view that fear of crime or feelings of insecurity should be seen mainly as a consequence of, on one hand, general feelings of malaise, vulnerability, and helplessness that can have many origins and, on the other hand, exposure to processes of communication that highlight crime and the risk of victimization.
AdamsRichard E.SerpeRichard T., 2000. “Social Integration, Fear of Crime, and Life Satisfaction.”Sociological Perspectives43:605–29.
2.
AltheideDavid L., 1997. “The News Media, the Problem Frame, and the Production of Fear.”The Sociological Quarterly38:647–68.
3.
AnselmeMichel. 1993. “Le lien Sécuritaire: Mettre en Ordre le Désordre Quotidien” [The Security Connection: Put the Daily Disorder in Order]. Revue Internationale d'Action Communautaire30:29–38.
4.
BennettRichard R.FlavinJeanne M., 1994. “Determinants of Fear of Crime: The Effect of Cultural Setting.”Justice Quarterly11:357–81.
5.
WolfgangBilskyPfeifferChristinaWetzelsPeter. 1993. Fear of Crime and Criminal Victimization. Stuttgart, Germany: Enke.
6.
CarcachCarlosFramptonPetaThomasKayeCranichMathew. 1995. “Explaining Fear of Crime in Queensland.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology11:271–87.
7.
ChiricosTedEschholzSarahGertzMarc. 1997. “Crime, News and Fear of Crime: Toward an Identification of Audience Effects.”Social Problems44:342–57.
8.
ChiricosTedPadgettKathyGertzMarc. 2000. “Fear, TV News, and the Reality of Crime.”Criminology38:755–85.
9.
CovingtonJeanetteTaylorRalph B., 1991. “Fear of Crime in Urban Residential Neighborhoods: Implications of Between- and Within-Neighborhood Sources for Current Models.”Sociological Quarterly32:231–49.
10.
DammertLuciaMaloneMary Fran T., 2003. “Fear of Crime or Fear of Life? Public Insecurities in Chile.”Bulletin of Latin American Research22:79–101.
11.
DayKristen. 2001. “Constructing Masculinity and Women's Fear in Public Space in Irvine, California.”Gender, Place & Culture8:109–27.
12.
De BensElsPaulussenSteve. 2004. Hoe Anders is de VRT? De “Performantie” van de Vlaamse Publieke Omroep en Vergelijkende Analyse van het Nieuws van TV1 en VTM [How Different is the VRT? The “Performance” of the Flemish Public Television Channel and Comparative News Analysis of TV1 and VTM]. Universiteit Gent, Belgium: Vakgroep Communicatiewetenschappen.
13.
De GroofSaskia. 2006. “Het (On)grijpbare Onveiligheidsgevoel. Een Exploratie van de Structuur binnen het Onveiligheidsconcept van Mannen en Vrouwen” [The (Un)graspable Feeling of Insecurity. An Exploration of the Structures in the Fear of Crime Concept of Men and Women]. Tijdschrift voor Criminologie48:19–34.
14.
De GroofSaskia. 2008. “And my Mama Said … The (Relative) Parental Influence on Fear of Crime among Adolescent Girls and Boys.”Youth & Society39 (3): 267–93.
15.
de VausDavidWiseSarah. 1996. “The Fear of Attack: Parents' Concerns for the Safety of their Children.”Family Matters43:34–38.
16.
DittonJasonChadeeDerekFarrallStephenGilchristElizabethBannisterJon. 2004. From imitation to intimidation. A note on the curious and changing relationship between the media, crime and fear of crime. British Journal of Criminology44:595–610.
17.
DittonJasonFarrallStephen. 2000. The Fear of Crime. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
18.
ElchardusMarkDe GroofSaskiaSmitsWendy. 2005. “Rationele Angst of Collectieve Voorstelling van Onbehagen. Een Vergelijking van Twee Paradigma's ter Verklaring van Onveiligheidsgevoelens” [Rational Fear or Collective Representation of Malaise. A Comparison of Two Paradigms Explaining Fear of Crime]. Mens & Maatschappij80:48–68.
19.
ElchardusMarkSmitsWendy. 2003. “Bedreigd, Kwetsbaar en Hulpeloos: Onveiligheidsgevoel in Vlaanderen, 1998–2002” [Threatened, Vulnerable and Helpless: Fear of Crime in Flanders, 1998–2002]. Pp. 99–136 in Vlaanderen Gepeild!, edited by van de Vlaamse GemeenschapMinisterie. Brussel, Belgium: Ministerie van de Vlaamse Gemeenschap, Administratie Planning en Statistiek.
20.
FarrallStephenBannisterJonDittonJasonGilchristElizabeth. 1997. “Questioning the Measurement of the ‘Fear of Crime’. Findings from a Major Methodological Study.”British Journal of Criminology37:658–79.
21.
FattahEzzat A., 1993. “Research on Fear of Crime: Some Common Conceptual and Measurement Problems.” Pp. 45–70 in Fear of Crime and Criminal Victimization, edited by BilskyW.PfeifferC.WetzelsP., Stuttgart, Germany: Enke.
22.
FerraroKenneth F.1995. Fear of Crime. Interpreting Victimization RiskAlbany: State University of New York Press.
23.
FerraroKenneth F.LaGrangeRandy L., 1987. “The Measurement of Fear of Crime.”Sociological Inquiry57:70–101.
24.
GabrielUteGreveWerner. 2003. “The Psychology of Fear of Crime. Conceptual and Methodological Perspectives.”British Journal of Criminology43:600–14.
25.
RandyGainey R.SeyfritCarole L., 2001. “Fear of Crime among Rural Youth: Testing the Generality of Urban Models to Rural Areas.”Sociological Focus34:269–86.
26.
GebotysRobert J.RobertsJulian V.DasGuptaBikram. 1988. “News Media Use and Public Perception of Crime.”Canadian Journal of Criminology30:3–16.
27.
GerbnerGeorgeGrossLarry. 1976. “Living with Television: The Violence Profile.”Journal of Communication26:173–99.
28.
GiddensAnthony. 1990. The Consequences of Modernity. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
29.
GilchristElizabethBannisterJonDittonJasonFarrallStephen. 1998. “Women and the ‘Fear of Crime’: Challenging the Accepted Stereotype.”British Journal of Criminology38:283–99.
30.
GilliamFranklin D.IyengarShanto. 2000. “Prime Suspects: The Influence of Local Television News on the Viewing Public.”American Journal of Political Science44:560–73.
31.
JoGoodey. 1997. “Boys Don't Cry. Masculinities, Fear of Crime and Fearlessness.”British Journal of Criminology37:401–18.
32.
HaleChris. 1996. “Fear of Crime: A Review of the Literature.”International Review of Victimology4:79–150.
33.
HeathLindaGilbertKevin. 1996. “Mass Media and Fear of Crime.”American Behavioral Scientist39:379–86.
34.
HirschPaul M., 1981. “On not Learning from One's Own Mistakes. A Reanalysis of Gerbner et al.'s Findings on Cultivation Analysis.”Communication Research8:3–37.
35.
HollanderJocelyn A., 2001. “Vulnerability and Dangerousness: The Construction of Gender through Conversation about Violence.”Gender and Society15:83–109.
36.
WendyHollwayJeffersonTony. 1997. “The Risk Society in an Age of Anxiety: Situating Fear of Crime.”British Journal of Sociology48:255–66.
37.
JensenKlaus B., 1990. “Television Futures: A Social Action Methodology for Studying Interpretative Communities.”Critical Studies in Mass Communication7:129–46.
38.
KananJames W.PruittMatthew V., 2002. “Modelling Fear of Crime and Perceived Victimization Risk: The (In)significance of Neighborhood Integration.”Sociological Inquiry72:527–48.
39.
KellyLiz. 1996. “It's Everywhere: Sexual Violence as a Continuum.” Pp. 191–206 in Feminism & Sexuality: A Reader, edited by JacksonS.ScottS., Edinburgh, UK: Edinburgh University Press.
40.
KilliasMartin. 1990. “Vulnerability: Towards a Better Understanding of a Key Variable in the Genesis of Fear of Crime.”Violence and Victims5:97–108.
41.
KellyLizClericiChristian. 2000. “Different Measures of Vulnerability in their Relation to Different Dimensions of Fear of Crime.”British Journal of Criminology40:437–50.
42.
HelmutKuryFerdinandTheodore. 1998. “The Victim's Experience and Fear of Crime.”International Review of Victimology5:93–140.
43.
KuryHelmutObergfell-FuchsJoachimFerdinandTheodore. 2001. “Aging and the Fear of Crime: Recent Results from East and West Germany.”International Review of Victimology8:75–112.
44.
LagrangeHugues. 1993. “La Pacification des Mœurs à l'Épreuve” [The Pacification of Morality Put to the Test]. Déviance et Société17:279–289.
45.
LiskaAllen E.BaccagliniWilliam. 1990. “Feeling Safe by Comparison: Crime in the Newspapers.”Social Problems37:360–74.
46.
DennisT. LowryNioJosephine T. C.LeitnerDennis W., 2003. “Setting the Public Fear Agenda: A Longitudinal Analysis of Network TV Crime Reporting, Public Perceptions of Crime, and FBI Crime Statistics.”Journal of Communication53:61–73.
47.
LuptonDeborahTullochJohn. 1999. “Theorizing Fear of Crime: Beyond the Rational/Irrational Opposition.”British Journal of Sociology50:507–23.
48.
MayDavid C., 2001. “The Effect of Fear of Sexual Victimization on Adolescent Fear of Crime.”Sociological Spectrum21:141–74.
49.
MayDavid C.DunawayGregory R., 2000. “Predictors of Fear of Criminal Victimization at School among Adolescents.”Sociological Spectrum20:149–68.
50.
MayDavid C.VartanianLesa RaeVirgoKeri. 2002. “The Impact of Parental Attachment and Supervision on Fear of Crime among Adolescent Males.”Adolescence37:267–87.
51.
McCoyH. VirginiaWooldredgeJohn D.CullenFrancis T.DubeckPaula J.BrowningSandra L., 1996. “Lifestyles of the Old and not so Fearful: Life Situation and Older Persons' Fear of Crime.”Journal of Criminal Justice24:191–205.
52.
MeschGustavo S., 2000a. “Women's Fear of Crime: The Role of Fear for the Well-Being of Significant Others.”Violence and Victims15:323–36.
53.
MeschGustavo S., 2000b. “Perceptions of Risk, Lifestyle Activities, and Fear of Crime.”Deviant Behavior21:47–62.
54.
O'ConnellMichael. 1999. “Is Irish Public Opinion towards Crime Distorted by Media Bias?”European Journal of Communication14:191–212.
55.
OhlssonStellan. 2000. “Falsifications, Anomalies and the Naturalistic Approach to Cognitive Change.”Science and Education9:173–86.
56.
PainRachel H., 1995. “Elderly Women and Fear of Violent Crime: The Least Likely Victims? A Reconsideration of the Extent and Nature of Risk.”British Journal of Criminology35:584–98.
57.
PainRachel H., 2001. “Gender, Race, Age and Fear in the City.”Urban Studies38:899–913.
58.
ParkerKeith D.RayMelvin C., 1990. “Fear of Crime: An Assessment of Related Factors.”Sociological Spectrum10:29–40.
59.
PleysierStefaanVervaekeGeertGoethalsJohan. 2001. “Veiligheid: Enkele Theoretische en (Macro)Sociologische Beschouwingen” [Security: Some Theoretical and (Macro)Sociological Reflections]. Pp. 15–34 in Veiligheid, een Illusie? Theorie, Onderzoek en Praktijk, edited by CasselmanJ.GoethalsJ.GoossensFHutsebautFVervaekeG.WalgraveL., Brussel, Belgium: Uitgeverij Politeia nv.
60.
PleysierStefaanVervaekeGeertGoethalsJohan. 2004. “Cross-Cultural Invariance and Gender Bias when Measuring ‘Fear of Crime’.”International Review of Victimology10:245–60.
61.
RomerDanielJamiesonKathleen H.AdaySean2003. “Television News and the Cultivation of Fear of Crime.”Journal of Communication53:88–104.
62.
RountreePamela W., 1998. “A Reexamination of the Crime-Fear Linkage.”Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency35:341–72.
63.
RountreePamela W.LandKenneth C., 1996. “Perceived Risk versus Fear of Crime: Empirical Evidence of Conceptually Distinct Reactions in Survey Data.”Social Forces74:1353–76.
64.
ScottHannah. 2003. “Stranger Danger: Explaining Women's Fear of Crime.”Western Criminology Review4:203–14.
65.
SkoganWesley G., 1993. “The Various Meanings of Fear.” Pp. 131–40 in Fear of Crime and Criminal Victimization, edited by BilskyW.PfeifferC.WetzelsP., Stuttgart, Germany: Enke.
66.
SkoganWesley G.MaxfieldMichael G., 1981. Coping with Crime. Individual and Neighborhood Reactions. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
67.
StankoElizabeth A., 1988. “Fear of Crime and the Myth of the Safe Home: A Feminist Critique of Criminology.” Pp. 75–88 in Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse, edited by YlloK.BogradM., Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
68.
SuttonRobbie M.FarrallStephen. 2005. “Gender, Socially Desirable Responding and the Fear of Crime.”British Journal of Criminology45 (2): 212–24.
69.
TaylorRalph B.HaleMargaret. 1986. “Testing Alternative Models of Fear of Crime.”The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology77:151–89.
70.
TullochMarian. 1998. “Quantitative Review.” Pp. 7–28 in Fear of Crime—Volume 1: Audit of the Literature and Community Programs, edited by Centre for Cultural Risk Research. Canberra, Australia: National Crime Prevention Program.
71.
TullochMarian. 2000. “The Meaning of Age Differences in the Fear of Crime: Combining Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches.”British Journal of Criminology40:451–67.
72.
WalgraveS.De SwertK., 2002. “Does News Content Matter? The Contribution of the News Media in the Making of the Issues of the Vlaams Blok.”Ethical Perspectives9:249–74.
73.
WarrMark. 1984. “Fear of Victimization: Why are Women and the Elderly more Afraid?”Social Science Quarterly65:681–702.
74.
WarrMark. 1987. “Fear of Victimization and Sensitivity to Risk.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology3:29–46.
75.
WarrMarkEllisonChristopher G., 2000. “Rethinking Social Reactions to Crime: Personal and Altruistic Fear in Family Households.”American Journal of Sociology106:551–78.
76.
WilliamsFrank P.McShaneMarilyn D.AkersRonald L., 2000. “Worry about Victimization: An Alternative and Reliable Measure for Fear of Crime.”Western Criminology Review2. Retrieved December 1, 2005, from http://wcr.sonoma.edu/v2n2/williams.html.
77.
WilliamsPaulDickinsonJulie. 1993. “Fear of Crime: Read All about It? The Relationship between Newspaper Crime Reporting and Fear of Crime.”British Journal of Criminology33:33–56.
