This essay explores the place of electoral politics within Marxist political theory through the lens of a critique of August Nimtz's two-volume study of Lenin's electoral politics. The problem of how the Marxist left should relate to electoral politics has come to the fore in recent years in, for instance, Egypt, Greece, Spain, the UK and the USA. The debates occasioned by these movements would do well to be informed by a clearer understanding of the history of the revolutionary left's approach to electoral politics. For this reason, Nimtz's study of Lenin's practical and theoretical engagement with this subject is a welcome and timely intervention. However, Nimtz's interpretation of the relationship between strategy and tactics in Lenin's thought and the position of elections therein can be challenged, and this paper does so through a discussion of Lenin's notebooks on Clausewitz. Understood through the lens of these notebooks, Lenin can be shown to have held a much more rigorous and flexible approach to electoral strategy than Nimtz supposes.
AronRaymond. 1985. Clausewitz: Philosopher of War.Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
2.
BadayevA. Y.1987. Bolsheviks in the Tsarist Duma.London: Bookmarks.
3.
BalibarÉtienne. 2007. “The Philosophical Moment in Politics Determined by War: Lenin 1914-1916.” Pp. 207–222 in SebastianBudgen, , eds., Lenin Reloaded.London: Duke University Press.
4.
BensaïdDaniel. 2007. “Leaps! Leaps! Leaps!” Pp. 148–163 in SebastianBudgen, , eds., Lenin Reloaded.London: Duke University Press.
5.
BernsteinEduard. 1993. The Preconditions of Socialism.Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
6.
BlackledgePaul. 2006. “What Was Done?” International Socialism, 2:111, 111–126.
7.
BlackledgePaul, ed. 2010. “Symposium on Lars Lih's Lenin Rediscovered.”Historical Materialism, 18:3, 25–174.
8.
BlackledgePaul. 2011. “Labourism and Socialism: Ralph Miliband's Marxism.” International Socialism, 2:129, 67–96. Revised version of “On Moving On from ‘Moving On’: Miliband, Marxism and Politics.” Pp. 64–83 in ClydeBarrow, , eds., Class, Power and State in Capitalist Society: Essays on Ralph Miliband. London: Palgrave.
9.
BlackledgePaul. 2012. Marxism and Ethics.Albany, New York: SUNY Press.
10.
BlackledgePaul. 2013a. “Left Reformism, the State and the Problem of Socialist Politics Today.” International Socialism, 2:139, 25–56.
11.
BlackledgePaul. 2013b. “Thinking about (New) Social Movements: Some Insights from the British Marxist Historians.” Pp. 259–275 in ColinBarker, , eds., Marxism and Social Movements.Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
12.
BlackledgePaul. 2014a. “Once More on Left Reformism.” International Socialism, 2:141, 189–204.
13.
BlackledgePaul. 2014b. “The Great Schism: Socialism and War in 1914.”International Socialism, 2:143, 85–110. Revised version of “The Split in the International and the Origins of War.” Pp. 31–56 In ShannonBrincat, ed., Communism in the Twenty-First Century. Volume 2: Whither Communism? Santa Barbara, California: Praeger.
14.
BlackledgePaul. 2017. “Soviet Democracy in 1917.” Pp. 129–136 In XavierMarquez, ed., Democratic Moments. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
15.
BlackledgePaul. 2018. “Hegemony and Intervention.” Science & Society, 82:4, 479–499.
16.
BlackledgePaul. 2019a. “War and Revolution: Friedrich Engels as a Military Thinker.” War and Society, 38 (May).
17.
BlackledgePaul. 2019b. “Engels's Politics: Strategy and Tactics after 1848.”Socialism and Democracy (March).
18.
BlackledgePaul. 2019c. Friedrich Engels.Albany, New York: SUNY Press.
EngelsFrederick. 1976. “Preface to the English Edition.” Pp. 109–113 in KarlMarx, Capital. London: Penguin.
27.
EngelsFrederick. 1979. “Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany.” Pp. 1–98 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 11. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
28.
EngelsFrederick. 1987. “The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State.” Pp. 129–276 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 25. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
29.
EngelsFrederick. 1990a. “A Critique of the Draft Social-Democratic Programme of 1891.” Pp. 217–230 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol 27.London: Lawrence and Wishart.
30.
EngelsFrederick. 1990b. “Socialism in Germany.” Pp. 237–250 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol 27. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
31.
EngelsFrederick. 1990c. “Reply to the Honourable Giovanni Bovio.” Pp. 270–272 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol 27. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
32.
EngelsFrederick. 1990d. “The Future Italian Revolution and the Socialist Party.” Pp. 437–40 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol 27. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
33.
EngelsFrederick. 1990e. “Introduction to Karl Marx's The Class Struggle in France.” Pp. 506–524 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol 27.London: Lawrence and Wishart.
34.
EngelsFrederick. 1995. “Letter to Friedrich Adolph Sorge, 29 November 1886.” Pp. 531–534 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 47. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
35.
EngelsFrederick. 2001a. “Letter to Hermann Schlüter, March 1887.” Pp. 39–40 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 48. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
36.
EngelsFrederick. 2001b. “Letter to Paul Lafargue, December 1887.” Pp. 129–131 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 48. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
37.
EngelsFrederick. 2001c. “Letter to Gerson Trier, 18 December 1889.” Pp. 423–425 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 48. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
38.
EngelsFrederick. 2001d. “Letter to Karl Kautsky, 4 September 1892.” Pp. 514–517 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 49. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
39.
EngelsFrederick. 2004. “Letter to Paul Lafargue, 25 February 1893.” Pp. 112–115 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 50. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
40.
FernbachDavid. 1974. “Introduction.” Pp. 9–72 In DavidFernbach, ed., Karl Marx: The First International and After. London: Penguin.
41.
HardingNeil. 1983. Lenin's Political Thought. London: Macmillan.
42.
HahlwegWerner. 1960. “Clausewitz, Lenin and Communist Military Attitudes Today.” Royal United Services Institution Journal, 105:618, 221–225.
HowardMichael. 2002. Clausewitz. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
45.
JohnsonCarol. 1980. “The Problem of Reformism and Marx's Theory of Fetishism.” New Left Review, 1/119, 70–96.
46.
KippJacob W1985. “Lenin and Clausewitz: The Militarization of Marxism, 1914-1921.”Military Affairs (October), 184–191.
47.
KrauszTamás. 2015. Reconstructing Lenin. New York: Monthly Review Press.
48.
LeBlancPaul. 1990. Lenin and the Revolutionary Party. Atlantic Highlands, New Jersey: Humanities Press.
49.
LeninV. I.1961. “Prosecutors of Zemstvo and Hannibals of Liberalism.” Pp. 35–80 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 5. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
50.
LeninV. I.1962. “The Boycott of the Bulgin Duma, and Insurrection.” Pp. 179–187 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 9. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
51.
LeninV. I.1963a. “Meeting of the International Socialist Bureau.” Pp. 231–246 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 15. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
52.
LeninV. I.1963b. “Two Letters.” Pp. 286–302 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 15. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
53.
LeninV. I.1963c. “August Bebel.” Pp. 294–301 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 19. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
54.
LeninV. I.1963d. “Kautsky's Unpardonable Error.” Pp. 546–547 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 19. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
55.
LeninV. I.1964a. “Letters on Tactics.” Pp. 42–54 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 24. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
56.
LeninV. I.1964b. “On Compromises.” Pp. 305–310 in LeninV. I., Collected Works. Vol. 25. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
57.
LeninV. I.1968. “The State and Revolution.” Pp. 263–348 in LeninV. I., Selected Works. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
58.
LeninV. I.1977. “Lenin's Notebook on Clausewitz.” Edited, translated and introduced by DavisDonald E. and KohnWalter S. G. Pp. 188–229 in JonesDavid R., ed., Soviet Armed Forces Review Annual, Vol.1. Gulf Breeze, Florida: Academic International Press.https://www.clausewitz.com/bibl/DavisKohn-LeninsNotebookOnClausewitz.pdf#zoom=100
59.
LeninV. I.1993. “Left-Wing” Communism: An Infantile Disorder. London: Bookmarks. Liebman, Marcel. 1975. Leninism under Lenin. London: Jonathan Cape.
60.
LihLars. 2006. Lenin Rediscovered. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
LukácsGeorg. 1970. Lenin: A Study in the Unity of His Thought. London: New Left Books.
64.
LuxemburgRosa. 1986. The Mass Strike. London: Bookmarks.
65.
MarxKarl. 1973. “The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte.” Pp. 143–249 in KarlMarx, Surveys from Exile. London: Penguin.
66.
MarxKarl. 1975. “Letter to Ruge, September 1843.” Pp. 206–209 in KarlMarx, Early Writings. London: Penguin.
67.
MarxKarl. 1986. “Record of Marx's Speech on the Political Action of the Working Class.” Pp. 616–617 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 22. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
68.
MarxKarl, and FrederickEngels. 1974. “1879 Circular Letter.” Pp. 360–379 in New Left Review, ed., Karl Marx: The First International and After. London: Penguin.
69.
MarxKarl, and FrederickEngels. 1976. “The German Ideology.” Pp. 20–539 in MarxKarl and FrederickEngels, Collected Works.Vol. 5. London: Lawrence and Wishart.
70.
MilibandRalph. 1976. “Moving On.” Pp. 128–140 in Socialist Register. London: Merlin.
71.
MilibandRalph. 1977. Marxism and Politics. London: Merlin.
72.
MolyneuxJohn. 1978. Marxism and the Party. London: Pluto Press.
73.
MolyneuxJohn. 2017. Lenin For Today. London: Bookmarks.
74.
NegriAntonio. 2014. Factory of Strategy: 33 Lessons on Lenin. New York: Columbia University Press.
75.
NimtzAugust. 2014a. Lenin's Electoral Strategy from Marx and Engels Through the Revolustion of 1905. London: Palgrave.
76.
NimtzAugust. 2014b. Lenin's Electoral Strategy from 1907 to the October Revolution of 1917. London: Palgrave.
77.
PostCharles. 2010. “Exploring Working-Class Consciousness: A Critique of the Theory of the ‘Labour Aristocracy’.” Historical Materialism, 18:4, 3–38.
78.
RiddellJohn, ed. 1991. Workers of the World and Oppressed, Peoples, Unite! Volume 1. New York: Pathfinder.
79.
RueschemeyerDietrich, StephensEvelyn and JohnStephens. 1992. Capitalist Development and Democracy. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press.
80.
SalvadoriMassimo. 1979. Karl Kautsky and the Socialist Revolution. London: Verso.
81.
SchorskeCarl. 1983. German Social Democracy, 1905-.1917Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
82.
ShandroAlan. 2014. Lenin and the Logic of Hegemony. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
83.
ThompsonEdward. 1960. “The Point of Production.” New Left Review, 1, 68–70.
84.
TrotskyLeon. 1947. Stalin. London: Hollis and Carter.
85.
TrotskyLeon. 1973. Their Morals and Ours. New York: Pathfinder.
