SPECIAL SECTION: Comparison of Self-Reporting of Deficiencies in Airway Management with Video Analyses of Actual Performance

Abstract

We compared the performance deficiencies of airway management captured by three types of self-reports with those identified through video analysis. The three types of self-reports were the anesthesia record (a patient record constructed during the course of treatment), the anesthesia quality assurance (AQA) report (a retrospective report as a part of the trauma center's quality assurance process), and a posttrauma treatment questionnaire (PTQ), which was completed immediately after the case for the purposes of this research. Video analysis of 48 patient encounters identified 28 performance deficiencies related to airway management in 11 cases (23%). The performance deficiencies took the form of task omissions or practices that lessened the margin of patient safety. In comparison, AQA reports identified none of these performance deficiencies, the anesthesia records identified 2 (of 28), and the PTQs suggested contributory factors and corrective measures for 5 deficiencies. Furthermore, video analysis provided information about the context of and factors contributing to the identified performance deficiencies, such as failures in adherence to standard operating procedures and in communications.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brennan, T. A. , Leape, L. L. , Laird, N. , Herbert, L. , Localio, A. A. R. , Lawthers, A. G. , Newhouse, J. P. , Weiler, P. C. , & Hiatt, H. H. (1991). Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients: Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study I. New England Journal of Medicine, 324, 370–376.

Caplan, R. A. , Posner, K. L. , & Cheney, F. W. (1991). Effect of outcome on physician judgments of appropriateness of care. Journal of the American Medical Association, 265, 1951–196.

Caplan, R. A. , Posner, K. L. , Ward, R. J. , & Cheney, F. W. (1990). Adverse respiratory events in anesthesia: A closed claims analysis. Anesthesiology, 72, 828–83.

Cheney, F. W. , Posner, K. L. , & Caplan, R. A. (1991). Adverse respiratory events infrequently leading to malpractice suits. Anesthesiology, 75, 932–93.

Cooper, J. B. , Newbower, R. S. , & Kitz, R. J. (1984). An analysis of major errors and equipment failures in anesthesia management: Considerations for prevention and detection Anesthesiology, 60, 34–4.

Cooper, J. B. , Newbower, R. S. , Long, C. D. , & McPeek, B. (1978). Preventable anesthesia mishaps: A study of human factors. Anesthesiology, 49, 399–40.

Edsall, D. W. , Jones, B. R. , & Smith, N. T. (1992). The anesthesia database, the automated record, and the quality assurance process. International Anesthesiology Clinics, 30, 71–9.

Gaba, D. M. , Fish, K. J. , & Howard, S. K. (1994). Crisis management in anesthesiology. New York: Churchill Livingstone

Green, T. G. , O'Connor. P. , Sparks, D. D. , & Eddlemon, C. L. (1983). Improving clinical teaching by videotaping performance. Journal of Dental Education, 47, 118–11.

10.

Harper, B. , Mackenzie, C. F. , & Norman, K. L. (1995). Quantitative measures in the ergonomic examination of the trauma resuscitation units anesthesia workspace. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 39th Annual Meeting (pp. 723–777). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.

11.

Helmreich, R. L. (1984). Cockpit management altitudes. Human Factors, 26, 583–589.

12.

Hoyt, D. B. , Shackford, S. R. , Fridland, P. H. , Mackersie, R. C. , Hansborough, J. F. , Wachtel, T. L. , & Fortune, J. B. (1988) Video recording trauma resuscitations: An effective teaching technique. Journal of Trauma, 28, 435–440

13.

Jeppesen Sanderson, Inc. (1995). Federal aviation regulations: Part 13S–Air taxi operators and commercial operators; 135: 100–Flight crewmember duties. Englewood, CO: Author.

14.

Leape, L. L. (1994). The preventability of medical injury. In M. S. Bogner (Ed.), Human error in medicine (pp. 13–25) Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum

15.

Mackenzie, C. F. , Martin, P. , Xiao, Y. , & the LOTAS Group (1996). Video analysis of prolonged uncorrected esophageal intubation. Anesthesiology, 84, 1494–150.

16.

Reason, J. T. (1994). Foreword. In M. S. Bogner , (Ed.), Human error in medicine (pp. vii–xv). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

17.

Runciman, W. B. , Sellen, A. , Webb, R. K. , Williamson, J. A. , Currie, M. , Morgan, c. , & Russell, W.J. (1993). Errors, incidents and accidents in anaesthetic practice. Anaesthesia Intensive Care, 21, 506–51.

18.

Small, S. , Cullen, D. J. , Bates, D. , Cooper, J. B. , and Leape, L. (1994). The incident reporting system lacks validity as the basis for a quality assurance program [abstract]. Anesthesiology, 91, A1226.

19.

Webb, R. K. , Currie, M. , Morgan, C. A. , Williamson, J. A. , Mackay, P. , Russell, W. J. , & Runciman, W. B. (1993). The Australian Incident Monitoring Study: An analysis of 2000 incident reports. Anaesthesia Intensive Care, 21, 520–52.

20.

Xiao, Y. , Hunter A. , Mackenzie, C. F. , Jefferies, N. J. , Horst R. , & the LOTAS Group (1996). Task complexity in emergency medical care and its implications for team coordination. Human Factors, 38, 636–645.