The provision of choice in terms of how people use goods and services has been proposed as a vehicle of improvement of social welfare. This article highlights some of the costs and benefits of creating choice, and it discusses how much choice policy makers and other agents (e.g., employers, retailers) should ideally grant and in what form they should grant it.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AggarwalPankaj, and BottiSimona (2006), “Do I Like It if You Choose for Me? The Influence of Relationship Norms on Satisfaction with Consumer- Versus Marketer-Chosen Outcomes,” working paper, Rotman School of Management, Marketing Department, University of Toronto.
2.
AmirOn, and ArielyDan (2005), “Liberating Limitations: Regret and Indecision in Consumer Choice,” working paper, Rady School of Management, Marketing Department, University of California, San Diego.
3.
BeattieJane, BaronJonathan, JohnC. Hershey, and MarkD. Spranca (1994), “Psychological Determinants of Decision Attitude,”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 7 (2), 129–44.
4.
BemDaryl J. (1967), “Self-Perception: An Alternative Interpretation of Cognitive Dissonance Phenomena,”Psychological Review, 74 (3), 183–200.
5.
BenartziShlomo, and RichardH. Thaler (2002), “How Much Is Investor Autonomy Worth?”Journal of Finance, 57 (4), 1593–1616.
6.
BiehalGabriel, and ChakravartiDipankar (1986), “Consumers’ Use of Memory and External Information in Choice: Macro and Micro Perspectives”Journal of Consumer Research, 12 (March), 382–405.
7.
BottiSimona, and SheenaS. Iyengar (2004), “The Psychological Pleasure and Pain of Choosing: When People Prefer Choosing at the Cost of Subsequent Satisfaction,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 87 (3), 312–26.
8.
BottiSimona, SheenaS., and OrfaliKristina (2006), “Avoiding Pain: Choice Preferences and Emotional Responses in Medical Decision Contexts,” working paper, S.C. Johnson Graduate School of Management, Marketing Department, Cornell University.
9.
BottiSimona, SheenaS., and AnnL. McGill (2006), “When Choosing Is Not Deciding: The Effect of Perceived Responsibility on Satisfaction,”Journal of Consumer Research, 33, forthcoming.
10.
BrennerLyle, RottenstreichYuval, and SoodSanjay (1999), “Comparison, Grouping, and Preference,”Psychological Science, 10 (3), 225–29.
11.
BroniarczykSusan (2006), “Product Assortment,” in Handbook of Consumer Psychology, HaugtvedtCurt, and HerrPaul, eds. Marwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, forthcoming.
12.
BrynjolfssonErik, HuYu, and MichaelD. Smith (2003), “Consumer Surplus in the Digital Economy: Estimating the Value of Increased Product Variety at Online Booksellers,”Management Science, 49 (11), 1580–96.
13.
BushGeorge W., and HughesKaren (1999), A Charge to Keep.New York: William Morrow.
14.
CarmonZiv, WertenbrochKlaus, and ZeelenbergMarcel (2003), “Option Attachment: When Deliberating Makes Choosing Feel Like Losing,”Journal of Consumer Research, 30 (June), 15–29.
15.
ChernevAlexander (2003), “When More Is Less and Less Is More: The Role of Ideal Point Availability and Assortment in Consumer Choice,”Journal of Consumer Research, 30 (September), 170–83.
16.
Cialdini RobertB., MelanieR. Trost, and JasonT. Newsom (1995), “Preference for Consistency: The Development of a Valid Measure and the Discovery of Surprising Behavioral Implications,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69 (2), 318–28.
17.
CordovaDiana I., and MarkR. Lepper (1996), “Intrinsic Motivation and the Process of Learning: Beneficial Effects of Contextualization, Personalization, and Choice,”Journal of Educational Psychology, 88 (4), 715–30.
18.
CullenJulie B., BrianA. Jacob, and LevittSteven (2003), “The Effect of School Choice on Student Outcomes: Evidence from Randomized Lotteries,” working paper, National Bureau of Economic Research.
19.
DeCharmsRichard (1968), Personal Causation.New York: Academic Press.
20.
DeciEdward L. (1975), Intrinsic Motivation.New York: Plenum.
21.
DeciEdward L., and RichardM. Ryan (1985), Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior.New York: Plenum.
22.
DegnerLesley F., and JeffreyA. Sloan (1992), “Decision Making During Serious Illness: What Role Do Patients Really Want to Play?”Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 45 (9), 941–50.
23.
DharRavi (1997), “Consumer Preference for an Imposed-Choice Option,”Journal of Consumer Research, 24 (September), 215–31.
24.
DiehlKristin (2005), “When Two Rights Make a Wrong: Searching Too Much in Ordered Environments,”Journal of Marketing Research, 42 (August), 313–22.
25.
DiehlKristin, LauraJ. Kornish, and JohnG. LynchJr. (2003), “Smart Agents: When Lower Search Costs for Quality Information Increase Price Sensitivity,”Journal of Consumer Research, 30 (June), 56–71.
26.
EndeJack, KazisLewis, AshArlene, and MarkA. Moskowitz (1989), “Measuring Patients’ Desire for Autonomy: Decision Making and Information-Seeking Preferences Among Medical Patients,”General Internal Medicine, 4 (1), 23–30.
27.
FeldmanJack M., and JohnG. LynchJr. (1988), “Self-Generated Validity and Other Effects of Measurement on Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 73 (August), 421–35.
28.
FestingerLeon (1957), A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance.Evanston, IL: Row, Peterson.
29.
FrommErich (1941), Escape from Freedom.New York: Henry Holt.
30.
GawandeAtul (2002), Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science.New York: Picador.
31.
GreenleafEric A., and DonaldR. Lehmann (1995), “Reasons for Substantial Delay in Consumer Decision Making,”Journal of Consumer Research, 22 (September), 186–99.
32.
HarrisElizabeth (2003), “Investing; In These 401(k)'s, Workers Do Less to Save More,”The New York Times, (August 31), Section 3, 6.
33.
HäublGerald, and TriftsValerie (2000), “Consumer Decision Making in Online Shopping Environments: The Effects of Interactive Decision Aids,”Marketing Science, 19 (1), 4–21.
34.
HauserJohn R., and WernerfeltBirger (1990), “An Evaluation Cost Model of Consideration Sets,”Journal of Consumer Research, 16 (March), 393–408.
35.
HochSteven J., EricT. Bradlow, and WansinkBrian (1999), “The Variety of an Assortment,”Marketing Science, 18 (4), 527–46.
36.
HoefflerSteve (2003), “Measuring Preferences for Really New Products,”Journal of Marketing Research, 40 (November), 406–420.
37.
HoefflerSteve, and ArielyDan (1999), “Constructing Stable Preferences: A Look into Dimensions of Experience and Their Impact on Preference Stability,”Journal of Consumer Psychology, 8 (2), 113–39.
38.
HoldenSarah, and VanDerheiJack (2003), “401(k) Plan Asset Allocation, Account Balances, and Loan Activity in 2001,” EBRI Issue Brief No. 255, (March).
39.
HuffmanCynthia, and BarbaraE. Kahn (1998), “Variety for Sale: Mass Customization or Mass Confusion?”Journal of Retailing, 74 (4), 491–513.
40.
IyengarSheena S., RachelF. Elwork, and SchwartzBarry (2006), “Doing Better But Feeling Worse: Looking for the ‘Best’ Job Undermines Satisfaction,”Psychological Science, 17 (2), 143–50.
41.
IyengarSheena S., JiangWei, and HubermanGur (2004), “How Much Choice Is Too Much: Determinants of Individual Contributions in 401K Retirement Plans,” in Pension Design and Structure: New Lessons from Behavioral Finance, OliviaS. Mitchell, and UtkusSteve, eds. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 83–97.
42.
IyengarSheena S., JiangWei, and KamenicaEmir (2006), “The Psychological Costs of Ever Increasing Choice: A Fallback to the Sure Bet,” working paper, Graduate School of Business, Management Department, Columbia University.
43.
IyengarSheena S., JiangWei, and MarkR. Lepper (1999), “Rethinking the Value of Choice: A Cultural Perspective on Intrinsic Motivation,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76 (3), 349–66.
44.
IyengarSheena S., JiangWei, and MarkR. Lepper (2000), “When Choice Is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 79 (6), 995–1006.
45.
IyengarSheena S., JiangWei, and MogilnerCatherine (2005), “When More Choice Motivates: Considering the Benefits of Perceived Versus Actual Choice on Outcome Satisfaction,” working paper, Graduate School of Business, Management Department, Columbia University.
46.
JohnsonEric J., and DanielG. Goldstein (2003), “Do Defaults Save Lives?”Science, 302 (5649), 1338–39.
47.
JohnsonEric J., and RobertJ. Meyer (1984), “Compensatory Choice Models of Noncompensatory Processes: The Effect of Varying Context,”Journal of Consumer Research, 11 (June), 528–41.
48.
JohnsonEric J., SteffelMary, and DanielG. Goldstein (2005), “Making Better Decisions: From Measuring to Constructing Preferences,”Health Psychology, 24 (4), S17–S22.
49.
KahnBarbara E., and BaronJonathan (1995), “An Exploratory Study of Choice Rules Favored for High-Stakes Decisions,”Journal of Consumer Psychology, 4 (4), 305–328.
50.
KahnemanDaniel (2000), “Experienced Utility and Objective Happiness: A Moment-Based Approach,” in Choices, Values, and Frames, KahnemanDaniel, and TverskyAmos, eds. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 673–92.
51.
KahnemanDaniel, and JackieS. Snell (1992), “Predicting a Changing Taste: Do People Know What They Will Like?”Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 5 (3), 187–200.
52.
LangerEllen J. (1975), “The Illusion of Control,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32 (2), 311–28.
53.
LangerEllen J., and RodinJudith (1976), “The Effects of Choice and Enhanced Personal Responsibility for the Aged: A Field Experiment in an Institutional Setting,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34 (2), 191–98.
54.
LauricellaTom (2004), “A Lesson for Social Security: Many Mismanage Their 401(k)s,”The Wall Street Journal, (December 1), A1, A4.
55.
LefcourtHerbert M. (1973), “The Function of the Illusion of Control and Freedom,”American Psychologist, 28 (5), 417–25.
56.
LelandJohn (2004), “73 Options for Medicare Plan Fuel Chaos, Not Prescriptions,”The New York Times, (May 12), Section 1, 1.
57.
LewinKurt (1951), Field Theory in Social Science.Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
58.
LidzCharles W., MeiselAlan, OsterweisMarain, JaneL. Holden, JohnH. Marx, and MarkR. Munetz (1983), “Barriers to Informed Consent,”Annals of Internal Medicine, 99 (4), 539–43.
59.
LuceMary Frances (1998), “Choosing to Avoid: Coping with Negatively Emotion-Laden Consumer Decisions,”Journal of Consumer Research, 24 (March), 409–433.
60.
LuceMary Frances, JohnW. Payne, and JamesR. Bettman (1999), “Emotional Trade-Off Difficulty and Choice,”Journal of Marketing Research, 36 (May), 143–59.
61.
MadrianBrigitte C., and DennisF. Shea (2001), “The Power of Suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) Participation and Savings Behavior,”Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116 (4), 1149–87.
62.
MalhotraNaresh K. (1982), “Information Load and Consumer Decision Making,”Journal of Consumer Research, 8 (4), 419–30.
63.
MarkusHazel R., and KitayamaShinobu (1991), “Culture and the Self: Implications for Cognition, Emotion, and Motivation,”Psychological Review, 98 (2), 224–53.
64.
MillerNeal E. (1944), “Experimental Studies in Conflict,” in Personality and the Behavior Disorder, Vol. 1, HuntJoseph McVicker, ed. New York: Ronald, 431–65.
65.
MillerSuzanne M., DavidS. Brody, and SummertonJeffrey (1988), “Styles of Coping with Threat: Implications for Health,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 54 (1), 142–48.
66.
MoorthySridhar, RatchfordBrian, and TalukdarDebabrata (1997), “Consumer Information Search Revisited: Theory and Empirical Analysis,”Journal of Consumer Research, 23 (March), 263–77.
67.
MussaMichael, and RosenSherwin (1978), “Monopoly and Product Quality,”Journal of Economic Theory, 18 (2), 301–317.
68.
OrdóňezLisa D., and ConnollyTerry (2000), “Regret and Responsibility: A Reply to Zeelenberg et al. (1998),”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 81 (1), 132–42.
69.
OrfaliKristina, and ElisaJ. Gordon (2004), “Autonomy Gone Awry: A Cross-Cultural Study of Parents’ Experiences in Neonatal Intensive Care Units,”Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 25 (4), 329–65.
70.
Payne JohnJ., JamesR. Bettman, and EricJ. Johnson (1993), The Adaptive Decision Maker.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
71.
PearRobert (2005), “Confusion Is Rife About Drug Plan as SignUp Nears,”The New York Times, (November 13), Section 1, 1.
72.
PearRobert, and FreudenheimMilt (2006), “As New Drug Plan Begins, Stores Predict Bumps,”The New York Times, (January 1), Section 1, 1.
73.
PerlmuterLawrence C., and RichardA. Monty (1977), “The Importance of Perceived Control: Fact of Fantasy?”American Scientist, 65 (6), 759–65.
74.
RedelmeierDonald A., and ShafirEldar (1995), “Medical Decision Making in Situations That Offer Multiple Alternatives,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 273 (4), 302–305.
75.
RitovIlana, and BaronJonathan (1992), “Status-Quo and Omission Biases,”Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 5 (1), 49–61.
76.
RotterJulian B. (1966), “Generalized Expectancies for Internal Vs. External Control of Reinforcement,”Psychological Monographs (General and Applied), 80 (1), 1–28.
77.
RussoJ. Edward, MargaretG. Meloy, and VictoriaH. Medvec (1998), “Predecisional Distortion of Product Information,”Journal of Marketing Research, 35 (November), 438–52.
78.
SalopSteven C. (1979), “Monopolistic Competition with Outside Goods,”The Bell Journal of Economics, 10 (1), 141–56.
79.
SamuelsonWilliam, and ZeckhauserRichard (1988), “Status Quo Bias in Decision Making,”Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1 (1), 7–59.
80.
SchkadeDaniel, and KahnemanDaniel (1998), “Does Living in California Make People Happy? A Focusing Illusion in Judgments of Life Satisfaction,”Psychological Science, 9 (5), 340–46.
81.
SchneiderCarl (1998), The Practice of Autonomy: Patients, Doctors, and Medical Decision.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
82.
SchulzRichard, and BarbaraH. Hanusa (1978), “Long-Term Effects of Control and Predictability-Enhancing Interventions: Findings and Ethical Issues,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36 (11), 1194–1201.
83.
SeligmanMartin E. (1975), Helplessness: On Depression, Development, and Death.San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
84.
ShafirEldar, SimonsonItamar, and TverskyAmos (1993), “Reason-Based Choice,”Cognition, 49 (1-2), 11–36.
85.
ShuganSteven M. (1980), “The Cost of Thinking,”Journal of Consumer Research, 7 (2), 99–111.
86.
SimonHerbert A. (1957), Models of Man: Social and Rational.Oxford: John Wiley & Sons.
87.
SimonsonItamar (1992), “The Influence of Anticipating Regret and Responsibility on Purchase Decisions,”Journal of Consumer Research, 19 (June), 105–118.
88.
StiglerGeorge J. (1961), “The Economics of Information,”Journal of Political Economy, 69 (3), 213–25.
89.
StrullWilliam M., LoBernard, and CharlesGerald (1984), “Do Patients Want to Participate in Medical Decision Making?”Journal of the American Medical Association, 252 (21), 2990–94.
90.
SutherlandHeather J., HilaryA. Llewellyn-Thomas, GinaA. Lockwood, DavidL. Tritchler, and JamesE. Till (1989), “Cancer Patients: Their Desire for Information and Participation in Treatment Decisions,”Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 82 (5), 260–63.
91.
TaylorShelley E. (1979), “Hospital Patient Behavior: Reactance, Helplessness, or Control?”Journal of Social Issues, 35 (1), 156–84.
92.
TaylorShelley E., and JonathonD. Brown (1988), “Illusion and Well Being: A Social Psychological Perspective on Mental Health,”Psychological Bulletin, 103 (2), 193–210.
93.
TaylorShelley E., RosemaryR. Lichtman, and JoanneV. Wood (1984), “Attributions, Beliefs About Control, and Adjustment to Breast Cancer,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 46 (3), 489–502.
94.
VertinskyIlan B., WilliamA. Thompson, and UyenoDean (1974), “Measuring Consumer Desire for Participation in Clinical Decision Making,”Health Services Research, 9 (2), 121–34.
95.
ZeelenbergMarcel, van DijkWilco W., and AntonyS.R. Manstead (2000), “Regret and Responsibility Resolved? Evaluating Ordóňez and Connolly's (2000) Conclusions,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 81 (1), 143–54.
96.
ZuckermanMiron, PoracJoseph, LatinDrew, SmithRaymond, and EdwardL. Deci (1978), “On the Importance of Self- Determination for Intrinsically Motivated Behavior,”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 4 (3), 443–46.
