The authors use a series of meta-analyses to demonstrate the impact of warning labels across five dimensions of effectiveness: attention, reading and comprehension, recall, judgments, and behavioral compliance. Subsequent moderator analyses indicate that attention is moderated by vividness-enhancing characteristics, warning location, and familiarity but not by product type. None of the moderating variables affect either reading and comprehension or recall. Product type moderates judgments, and familiarity and cost of compliance moderate behavioral compliance. The authors discuss public policy implications and avenues for further research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsAustin S., and EdworthyJudy (1995), “Quantifying and Predicting the Effects of Basic Text Display Variables on the Perceived Urgency of Warning Labels: Tradeoffs Involving Font Size, Border Weight, and Color,”Ergonomics, 38 (11), 2221–37.
AndrewsCraig J., NetemeyerRichard G., and DurvasulaSrinvas (1993), “The Role of Cognitive Responses as Mediators of Alcohol Warning Label Effects,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12 (Spring), 57–74.
BarlowTodd, and WogalterMichael S. (1991), “Alcohol Beverage Warning Labels in Print Advertisements,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 451–55.
6.
BeattySharon, and SmithScott (1987), “External Search Effort: An Investigation Across Several Product Categories,”Journal of Consumer Research, (June), 83–95.
7.
BerlyneDaniel E. (1960), Conflict, Arousal and Curiosity.New York: McGraw-Hill.
8.
BhallaGaurav, and LactovickaJohn L. (1984), “The Impact of Changing Cigarette Warning Message Content and Format,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 29th Annual Meeting, AlluisiMary Jane, de GrootSybil, and AlluisiEarl A., eds. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 305–310.
9.
BorlandRon (1997), “Tobacco Health Warnings and Smoking-Related Cognitions and Behaviors,”Addiction, 92 (11), 1427–35.
10.
BraunCurt C., and Clayton SilverN. (1995), “Interaction of Signal Word and Color on Warning Labels: Differences in Perceived Hazard and Behavioral Compliance,”Ergonomics, 38 (11), 2207–20.
11.
BrelsfordJohn W., WogalterMichael S., and ScogginsJames A. (1994), “Enhancing Comprehension and Retention of Safety-Related Pictorials,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 38th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 836–40.
12.
CarverR.P. (1970), “Effect of ‘Chunked’ Typography on Reading Rate and Comprehension,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 54, 288–96.
13.
ChildersTerry, and HoustonMichael (1984), “Conditions for a Picture-Superiority Effect on Consumer Memory,”Journal of Consumer Research, 11 (September), 643–54.
14.
CohenJacob (1977), Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences.New York: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
15.
Comprehensive Smokeless Tobacco Health Education Act (1986), Public Law 99–252, 15 U.S.C. § 4401–08.
16.
CoxEli P.III, WogalterMichael S., StokesSara L., and Tipton MurffElizabeth J. (1997), “Do Product Warnings Increase Safe Behavior? A Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 16 (Fall), 195–204.
17.
CvetkovichGeorge, and EarleTimothy C. (1995), “Product Warnings and Information Processing: The Case of Alcohol Beverage Labels,”European Review of Applied Psychology, 45 (1), 17–20.
18.
D'AstousAlain, and DubucMarc (1986), “Retrieval Processes in Consumer Evaluative Judgment Making: The Role of Elaborative Processing,” in Advances in Consumer Research, LutzRichard, ed. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 132–37.
19.
DesaulniersDavid R. (1987), “Layout, Organization, and the Effectiveness of Consumer Product Warnings,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 31st Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 56–60.
20.
DingusThomas A., HunnBruce P., and WreggitSteven S. (1991), “Two Reasons for Providing Protective Equipment as Part of Hazardous Consumer Product Packaging,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 1039–42.
21.
DingusThomas A., WreggitSteven S., and HathawayJill A. (1993), “Warning Variables Affecting Personal Protective Equipment Use,”Safety Science, 16, 655–73.
22.
DorrisA.L., and PurswellJ.L. (1978), “Human Factors in the Design of Effective Product Warnings,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 22nd Annual Meeting, BaiseEdith J., and MillerJames M., eds. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 343–46.
23.
DywanJane, and JacobyLarry (1990), “Effects of Aging on Source Monitoring: Differences in Susceptibility to False Fame,”Psychology and Aging, 5 (3), 379–87.
24.
FarleyJohn U., and LehmannDonald R. (1986), Meta-Analysis in Marketing: Generalization of Response Models.Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
25.
Federal Cigarette Labeling Act (1965), 89–92, 79 Stat. 282.
FrankeGeorge R. (2001), “Applications of Meta-Analysis for Marketing and Public Policy: A Review,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 20 (Fall), 186–200.
28.
FrantzJ. Paul (1992), “Effect of Location, Procedural Explicitness, and Presentation Format on User Processing of and Compliance with Product Warnings and Instructions,” doctoral dissertation, Department of Industrial and Operations Engineering, University of Michigan.
29.
FrantzJ. Paul, and RhoadesTimothy P. (1993), “A Task-Analytic Approach to the Temporal and Spatial Placement of Product Warnings,”Human Factors, 35 (4), 719–30.
30.
FraseL.T., and SchwartzB.J. (1979), “Typographical Cues That Facilitate Comprehension,”Journal of Educational Psychology, 71 (5), 197–206.
31.
FriedmannKeyla (1987), “The Effect of Adding Symbols to Written Warning Labels on Used Behavior and Recall,” master's thesis, Department of Psychology, California State University, Northridge.
32.
FriedmannKeyla (1988), “The Effect of Adding Symbols to Written Warning Labels on User Behavior and Recall,”Human Factors, 30 (4), 507–515.
33.
Gardner-BonneauDaryle, KabbaraFawzi, HwangMinjohn, BeanHans, GanttMarilyn, HartshornKevin, HowellJennifer, and SpenceRahim (1989), “Cigarette Warnings: Recall of Content as a Function of Gender Message Content, Smoking Habits and Time,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 33rd Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 928–30.
34.
GodfreySandra S., and LaugheryKenneth R. (1984), “The Biasing Effects of Familiarity on Consumers’ Awareness of Hazard,”in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 28th Annual Meeting, AlluisiMary Jane, de GrootSybil, and AlluisiEarl A., eds. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 81–85.
35.
GodfreySandra S., RothsteinPamela R., and LaugheryKenneth R. (1985), “Warnings: Do They Make A Difference,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 29th Annual Meeting, SwezeyRobert W., ed. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 669–73.
36.
GoldhaberGerard M., and deTurckMark A. (1988a), “Effectiveness of Warning Signs: Familiarity Effects,”Forensic Reports, 1, 281–301.
37.
GoldhaberGerard M., and deTurckMark A. (1988b), “Effectiveness of Warning Signs: Gender and Familiarity Effects,”Journal of Products Liability, 11 (3), 271–284.
38.
GoldhaberGerard M., and deTurckMark A. (1988c), “Effects of Consumers’ Familiarity with a Product on Attention to and Compliance with Warnings,”Journal of Products Liability, 11 (1), 29–37.
39.
GoldhaberGerard M., and deTurckMark A. (1989), “The Developmental Analysis of Warning Signs: The Case of Familiarity and Gender,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 33rd Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 1019–23.
40.
GornGerald, LavackAnne M., PollackCraig G., and WeinbergCharles B. (1996), “An Experiment in Designing Effective Warning Labels,”Health Marketing Quarterly, 14 (2), 43–61.
41.
GrassoLaura (1998), “Cellular Telephones and the Potential Hazards of RF Radiation: Responses to the Fear and Controversy,”Virginia Journal of Law and Technology, 2 (Spring), 1522–1687.
42.
HankinJanet R., FirestoneIra J., SloanJames J., AgerJoel W. (1993), “The Impact of the Alcohol Warning Label on Drinking During Pregnancy,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12 (Spring), 10–23.
43.
HartleyJ. (1981), “Eighty Ways of Improving Instructional Text,”IEEE Transactions on Professional Communications, 25 (1), 17–27.
44.
HatemAida Therese (1993), “The Effect of Performance Level on Warning Compliance,” master's thesis, Department of Industrial Engineering, Purdue University.
45.
HawkinsDel I., BestRoger J., and ConeyKenneth A. (2001), Consumer Behavior: Building Marketing Strategy.New York: Irwin/McGraw-Hill.
46.
HunterJohn E., and SchmidtFrank L. (1990), Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error and Bias in Research Findings.Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
47.
JaynesLinda S., and BolesDavid B. (1990), “The Effect of Symbols on Warning Compliance,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 34th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 984–87.
48.
KahnemanDaniel (1973), Attention and Effort.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
49.
KalsherMichael J., ClarkeSteven W., and WogalterMichael S. (1991), “Posted Warning Placard: Effects on College Students Knowledge of Alcohol Facts and Hazards,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 35th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 456–60.
50.
KalsherMichael J., PucciShari, WogalterMichael S., and RacicotBernadette M. (1994), “Enhancing the Perceived Readability of Pharmaceutical Container Labels and Warnings: The Use of Alternative Designs and Pictorials,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 38th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 384–88.
51.
KarnesEdward W., and David LeonardS. (1986), “Consumer Product Warnings: Reception and Understanding of Warning Information by Final Users,” in Trends in Ergonomics/Human Factors III, KarwowskiW., ed. North Holland: Elsevier Science Publishers, 995–1003.
52.
KaskutasLee A. (1993), “Changes in Public Attitudes Toward Alcohol Control Policies Since the Warning Label Mandate of 1988,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12 (Spring), 30–42.
KotlerPhilip, ArmstrongGary, and CunninghamPeggy H. (2002), Principles of Marketing, 5th Canadian ed. Toronto: Prentice Hall.
55.
KozupJohn, BurtonScot, and CreyerElizabeth (2001), “A Comparison of Drinkers’ and Nondrinkers’ Responses to Health-Related Information Presented on Wine Beverage Labels,”Journal of Consumer Policy, 24 (2), 209–230.
56.
LaugheryKenneth R., VaubelKent P., YoungStephen L., BrelsfordJohn W.Jr., and RoweAnna L. (1993), “Explicitness of Consequence Information in Warnings,”Safety Science, 16 (5), 597–613.
57.
LawSharmistha, HawkinsScott, and CraikFergus (1998), “Repetition-Induced Belief in the Elderly: Rehabilitating Age-Related Memory Deficits,”Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (September), 91–107.
58.
LehtoMark, and MillerJames M. (1988), “The Effectiveness of Warning Labels,”Journal of Products Liability, 11 (3), 225–70.
59.
LynchJohn, and SrullThomas (1982), “Memory and Attention Factors in Consumer Choice: Concepts and Research Methods,”Journal of Consumer Research, 9 (June), 18–37.
60.
MacKenzieScott B. (1986), “The Role of Attention in Mediating the Effect of Ads on Attribute Importance,”Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (2), 174–95.
61.
MacKinnonDavid P., and FenaughtyAndrea M. (1993), “Substance Use and Memory for Health Warning Labels,”Health Psychology, 12 (2), 147–50.
62.
MacKinnonDavid P., NohreLiva, CheongJeewon, StacyAlan W., and PentzMary Ann (2002), “Longitudinal Relationship Between the Alcohol Warning and Alcohol Consumption,”Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 62 (2), 221–26.
63.
MacKinnonDavid P., NohreLiva, PentzMary Ann, and StacyAlan W. (2000), “The Alcohol Warning and Adolescents: 5-Year Effects,”American Journal of Public Health, 90 (10), 1589–94.
64.
MagurnoAmy Barlow, and WogalterMichael S. (1994), “Behavioral Compliance with Warnings: Effects of Stress and Placement,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 38th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 26–30.
65.
MalouffJohn, SchutteNicola, WienerKimara, BrancazioChristine, and FishDarla (1993), “Important Characteristics of Warning Displays on Alcohol Containers,”Journal of Studies on Alcohol, (July), 457–61.
66.
MazisMichael B., MorrisLouis A., and SwasyJohn L. (1991), “An Evaluation of the Alcohol Warning Label: Initial Survey Results,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10 (Spring), 229–41.
67.
McCarthyR.L., FinneganJ.P., Krumm-ScottS., and McCarthyG.E. (1984), “Product Information Presentation, User Behavior, and Safety,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 28th Annual Meeting, AlluisiMary Jane, de GrootSybil, and AlluisiEarl A., eds. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 81–85.
68.
McGuireWilliam J. (1980), “The Communication-Persuasion Model and Health-Risk Labeling,” in Banbury Report: Product Labeling and Health Risks, MorrisL.A., and MazisM.B., eds. Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, 99–122.
69.
MickDavid G. (1992), “Levels of Subjective Comprehension in Advertising Processing and Their Relations to Ad Perceptions, Attitudes and Memory,”Journal of Consumer Research, 18 (4), 411–24.
70.
MiyazakiAnthony D., BrumbaughAnne M., and SprottDavid E. (2001), “Promoting and Countering Consumer Misconceptions of Random Events: The Case of Perceived Control and State-Sponsored Lotteries,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 20 (Fall), 254–67.
MullenB., and RosenthalR. (1985), BASIC: Meta-Analysis Procedures and Programs.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
73.
OrrMadeleine, and HughesStanley T. (1988), “Effectiveness of Product Safety Warnings Over Time, and the Generalization of Warning Signs,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 28th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 897–900.
74.
OtsuboShirley M. (1988a), “Effectiveness of Warning Signs on Consumer Products,” master's thesis, Department of Psychology, California State University, Northridge.
75.
OtsuboShirley M. (1988b), “A Behavioral Study of Warning Labels for Consumer Products: Perceived Danger and Use of Pictographs,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 32nd Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 536–40.
76.
PalijPeter (2002), Personal correspondence with Moderator regarding “ELMAR Subscriber Information,” (May).
77.
PeterJ. Paul, and OlsonJerry (2002), Consumer Behavior and Marketing Strategy, 6th ed. Madison, WI: McGraw-Hill Higher Education.
PoonSimpson, and JosephMatthew (2000), “Product Characteristics and Internet Commerce Benefit Among Small Businesses,”The Journal of Product and Brand Management, 9 (1), 21–31.
80.
RethansArno, SwasyJohn, and MarksLawrence (1989), “Effects of Television Commercial Repetition, Receiver Knowledge and Commercial Length: A Test of the Two-Factor Model,”Journal of Marketing Research, 23 (February), 50–61.
81.
ScottDouglas R., and SolomonDebbie (1998), “What Is Wearout Anyway?”Journal of Advertising Research, 38 (5), 285–330.
82.
SlaterMichael D., KaranDavid, RoonerDonna, MurphyKevin, and BeauvaisFrederick (1998), “Developing and Assessing Alcohol Warning Content: Responses to Quantitative Information and Behavioral Recommendations in Warnings with Television Beer Advertisements,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 17 (Spring), 48–60.
83.
StewartDavid W., and MartinL.M. (1994), “Intended and Unintended Consequences of Warning Messages: A Review and Synthesis of Empirical Research,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 13 (Spring), 1–19.
84.
StrawbridgeJill Annette (1986a), “The Influence of Position, Highlighting, and Embedding on Warning Effectiveness,” master's thesis, Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, California State University, Northridge.
85.
StrawbridgeJill Annette (1986b), “The Influence of Position, Highlighting, and Embedding on Warning Effectiveness,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 30th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 716–20.
86.
WogalterMichael S., AllisonScott T., and McKennaNancy A. (1989), “Effects of Cost and Social Influence on Warning Compliance,”Human Factors, 31 (2), 133–40.
87.
WogalterMichael S., FontenelleGail A., and LaugheryKenneth R. (1985), “Behavioral Effectiveness of Warnings,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 29th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 679–83.
88.
WogalterMichael S., GodfreySandra S., FontenelleGail A., DesaulniersDavid R., RothsteinPamela R., and LaugheryKenneth R. (1987), “Effectiveness of Warnings,”Human Factors, 29 (5), 599–612.
89.
WogalterMichael S., KalsherMichael J., and RacicotBernadette M. (1992), “The Influence of Location and Pictorials on Behavioral Compliance to Warnings,” in Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 36th Annual Meeting.Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society, 1029–33.
90.
WogalterMichael S., KalsherMichael J., and RacicotBernadette M. (1993), “Behavioral Compliance with Warnings: Effects of Voice, Context, and Location,”Safety Science, 16 (5), 637–54.
91.
WogalterMichael S., and LaugheryKenneth R. (1996), “WARNING! Sign and Label Effectiveness,”Current Directions in Psychological Science, 5 (2), 33–37.
92.
WogalterMichael S., and SojournerRussell J. (1999), “Research on Pharmaceutical Labeling: An Information Processing Approach,” in Processing of Medical Information in Aging Patients: Cognitive and Human Factors Perspectives, ParkDenise C., MorrellRoger W., and ShifrenKim, eds. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
93.
WreggitSteven S. (1991), “The Effects of Cost of Compliance, Information, and Physical Interactivity on Consumer Product Warning Compliance,” master's thesis, Department of Psychology, University of Idaho.
94.
YoungStephen L, and WogalterMichael S. (1990), “Comprehension and Memory of Instruction Manual Warnings: Conspicuous Print and Pictorial Icons,”Human Factors, 32 (6), 637–49.
