Tax deductibility has been recognized as a motive for charitable donations. This article considers charitable donations as purchases that consumers make, and it examines the effects of changes in the tax deductibility (i.e., the price of donating) on charitable donations. The meta-analysis includes approximately four decades of estimates of the price elasticity of charitable giving. The authors discuss implications for policy makers and the marketers of charities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramsBurton and SchitzMark (1978), “The ‘Crowding-Out’ Effect of Governmental Transfers on Private Charitable Contributions,”Public Choice, 33 (1), 30–39.
2.
AbramsBurton and SchitzMark (1984), “The Crowding Out Effect of Governmental Transfers on Private Charitable Contributions: Cross-Section Evidence,”National Tax Journal, 37 (4), 563–68.
3.
AndersonDonna and BeierRuth (1999), “The Effect of a State Tax Credit on Giving to Community Foundations,”American Economist, 43 (2), 66–72.
4.
AndrewsRick L. and FrankeGeorge R. (1991), “The Determinants of Cigarette Consumption: A Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10 (Spring), 81–100.
5.
ApinunmahakulAmornrat and DevlinRose Anne (2004), “Charitable Giving and Charitable Gambling: An Empirical Investigation,”National Tax Journal, 57 (1), 67–88.
6.
AssmusGert, FarleyJohn, and LehmannDonald (1984), “How Advertising Affects Sales: Meta-Analysis of Econometric Results,”Journal of Marketing Research, 21 (February), 65–74.
7.
AutenGerald, CilkeJames, and RandolphWilliam (1992), “The Effects of Tax Reform on Charitable Contributions,”National Tax Journal, 45 (3), 267–90.
8.
AutenGerald, ClotfelterCharles, and SchmalbeckRichard (2002), “Taxes and Philanthropy Among the Wealthy,” in Does Atlas Shrug? The Economic Consequences of Taxing the Rich, Joel Slemrod, ed. New York: Russell Sage Foundation and Harvard University Press, 392–424.
9.
AutenGerald, and JoulfaianDavid (1996), “Charitable Contributions and Intergenerational Transfers,”Journal of Public Economics, 59 (1), 55–68.
10.
AutenGerald, and RudneyGabriel (1990), “The Variability of Charitable Giving in the U.S.,”Voluntas, 1 (2), 80–97.
11.
AutenGerald, and RudneyGabriel (1984), “Charitable Deductions and Tax Reform: New Evidence on Giving Behavior,” in Proceedings of the 77th Annual National Tax Association Conference, BowersStanley J., ed. Columbus, OH: National Tax Association–Tax Institute of America, 73–81.
12.
AutenGerald, SiegHolger, and ClotfelterCharles (2002), “Charitable Giving, Income and Taxes: An Analysis of Panel Data,”American Economic Review, 92 (1), 371–82.
13.
BakijaJon (2002), “Distinguishing Transitory and Permanent Price Elasticities of Charitable Giving with Pre-Announced Changes in Tax Law,” working paper, Department of Economics, Williams College.
14.
BakijaJon, GaleWilliam, and SlemrodJoel (2003), “Charitable Bequests and Taxes on Inheritances and Estates: Aggregate dence from Across States and Time,”American Economic Review, 93 (2), 366–83.
15.
BarrettKevin (1991), “Panel-Data Estimates of Charitable Giving: A Synthesis of Techniques,”National Tax Journal, 44 (3), 365–81.
16.
BarrettKevin, McGuirkAnya, and SteinbergRichard (1997), “Further Evidence on the Dynamic Impact of Taxes on Charitable Giving,”National Tax Journal, 50 (2), 321–34.
17.
BartholdThomas and PlotnickRobert (1984), “Estate Taxation and Other Determinants of Charitable Bequests,”National Tax Journal, 37 (2), 225–37.
18.
BednallDavid H.B., WalkerIan, CurlDavid, and Le RoyHeather (2001), “Business Support Approaches for Charities and Other Nonprofits,”International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 6 (2), 172–87.
19.
BeggColin B. (1994), “Publication Bias,” in Handbook of Research Synthesis, CooperHarris and HedgesLarry, eds. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 399–409.
20.
BendapudiNeeli, SinghSurendra, and BendapudiVenkat (1996), “Enhancing Helping Behavior: An Interactive Framework for Promotion Planning,”Journal of Marketing, 60 (July), 33–49.
21.
BittkerBoris (1972), “The Propriety and Vitality of a Federal Income Tax Deduction for Private Philanthropy,” in Tax Impacts of Philanthropy, AaronHenry, ed. Princeton, NJ: Tax Institute of America, 145–59.
22.
BoskinMichael (1976), “Estate Taxation and Charitable Bequests,”Journal of Public Economics, 5 (1), 27–56.
23.
BoskinMichael and FeldsteinMartin (1977), “Effects of the Charitable Deduction on Contributions by Low Income and Middle Income Households: Evidence from the National Survey of Philanthropy,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 59 (3), 351–54.
24.
BradleyRalph, HoldenSteven, and McClellandRobert (2000), “A Robust Estimation of the Effects of Taxation on Charitable Contributions,” paper presented at the Econometric Society 8th Annual World Congress, Seattle (August).
BromanAmy (1989), “Statutory Tax Rate Reform and Charitable Contributions,”Journal of the American Taxation Association, 10 (Fall), 7–20.
27.
BrooksArthur (2002), “Charitable Giving in Transition Economies: Evidence From Russia,”National Tax Journal, 55 (4), 743–53.
28.
BrooksArthur (2004), “The Effects of Public Policy on Private Charity,”Administration & Society, 36 (2), 166–85.
29.
BrownEleanor (1987), “Tax Incentives and Charitable Giving: Evidence from New Survey Data,”Public Finance Quarterly, 15 (4), 386–96.
30.
BrownEleanor and LankfordHamilton (1992), “Gifts of Money and Time: Estimating the Effects of Tax Prices and Available Time,”Journal of Public Economics, 47 (3), 321–41.
31.
CermakDianne, FileKaren Maru, and PrinceRuss Alan (1994), “A Benefit Segmentation of the Major Donor Market,”Journal of Business Research, 29 (2), 121–30.
32.
ChaneyIsabella and DolliNitha (2001), “Cause Related Marketing in New Zealand,”International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 6 (2), 156–63.
33.
ChoeYong and JeongJinook (1993), “Charitable Contributions by Low and Middle Income Taxpayers: Further Evidence with a New Method,”National Tax Journal, 46 (1), 33–39.
34.
ChristianCharles and BoatsmanJames (1990), “Cross-Sectional Price Elasticity Estimates of the Charitable Contributions Deduction,” in Advances in Taxation, JonesSally, ed. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, 15–66.
35.
ChristianCharles, BoatsmanJames and ReneauJ. Hal (1990), “The Interpretation of Econometric Estimates of the Tax Incentive to Engage in Philanthropy,”Journal of the American Taxation Association, 11 (1), 7–16.
36.
ChuaVincent and WongChung Ming (1999), “Tax Incentives, Individual Characteristics and Charitable Giving in Singapore,”International Journal of Social Economics, 26 (12), 1492–1504.
37.
ClotfelterCharles (1980), “Tax Incentives and Charitable Giving: Evidence from a Panel of Taxpayers,”Journal of Public Economics, 13 (3), 319–40.
38.
ClotfelterCharles (1983), “Tax Evasion and Tax Rates: An Analysis of Individual Returns,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 65 (3), 363–73.
39.
ClotfelterCharles (1985), Federal Tax Policy and Charitable Giving. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
40.
ClotfelterCharles (1990), “The Impact of Tex Reform on Charitable Giving: A 1989 Perspective,” in Do Taxes Matter? Joel Slemrod, ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 203–242.
41.
ClotfelterCharles and SteuerleEugene (1981), “Charitable Contributions,” in How Taxes Affect Economic Behavior, AaronHenry and PechmanJoseph, eds. Washington, DC: Brookings Institute, 403–446.
42.
ColomboJohn (2001), “The Marketing of Philanthropy and the Charitable Contributions Deduction,”Wake Forest Law Review, 36 (3), 657–703.
43.
CordesJoseph (2001), “The Cost of Giving: How Do Changes in Tax Deductions Affect Charitable Contributions?”Emerging Issues in Philanthropy, (accessed August 23, 2004), [available at www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/philanthropy_2.pdf].
DawsonScott (1988), “Four Motivations for Charitable Giving: Implications for Marketing Strategy to Attract Monetary Donations for Medical Research,”Journal of Health Care Marketing, 8 (2), 31–37.
46.
DunbarAmy and PhillipsJohn (1997), “The Effect of Tax Policy on Charitable Contributions: The Case of Nonitemizing Taxpayers,”Journal of the American Taxation Association, 19 (1), 1–20.
47.
DuquetteChristopher (1999), “Is Charitable Giving by Nonitemizers Responsive to Tax Incentives? New Evidence,”National Tax Journal, 52 (2), 195–206.
48.
DyeRichard (1978), “Personal Charitable Contributions: Tax Effects and Other Motives,” in Proceedings of the 71st National Annual Tax Association Conference, BowersStanley J., ed. Columbus, OH: National Tax Association–Tax Institute of America, 311–21.
49.
DyeRichard (1980), “Contributions of Volunteer Time: Some Evidence on Income Tax Effects,”National Tax Journal, 33 (1), 89–93.
50.
FeenbergDaniel (1987), “Are Tax Price Models Really Identified: The Case of Charitable Giving,”National Tax Journal, 40 (4), 629–33.
51.
FeigenbaumSusan (1980), “The Case of Income Redistribution: A Theory of Government and Private Provision of Collective Goods,”Public Finance Quarterly, 8 (2), 3–22.
52.
FeldsteinMartin (1975a), “The Income Tax and Charitable Contributions: Part I: Aggregate and Distributional Effects,”National Tax Journal, 28 (1), 81–100.
53.
FeldsteinMartin (1975b), “The Income Tax and Charitable Contributions: Part II: The Impact on Religious, Educational and Other Organizations,”National Tax Journal, 28 (2), 209–226.
54.
FeldsteinMartin and ClotfelterCharles (1976), “Tax Incentives and Charitable Organizations in the United States,”Journal of Public Economics, 5 (1–2), 1–26.
55.
FeldsteinMartin and TaylorAmy (1976), “The Income Tax and Charitable Contributions,”Econometrica, 44 (6), 1201–1222.
56.
FisherRobert (2000), “The Future of Social Desirability Bias Research in Marketing,”Psychology & Marketing, 17 (2), 73–77.
57.
FisherRobert and AckermanDavid (1998), “The Effects of Recognition and Group Need on Volunteerism: A Social Norm Perspective,”Journal of Consumer Research, 25 (3), 262–76.
58.
FisherRonald (1977), “The Combined State and Federal Income Tax Treatment of Charitable Contributions,” in Proceedings of the 70th Annual National Tax Association Conference, BowersStanley J., ed. Columbus, OH: National Tax Association–Tax Institute of America, 397–403.
59.
FosterMary and MeinhardAgnes (2002), “A Contingency View of the Responses of Voluntary Social Service Organizations to Ontario Government Cutbacks,”Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 19 (1), 27–41.
60.
GalletCraig and ListJohn (2003), “Cigarette Demand: A Meta-Analysis of Elasticities,”Health Economics, 12 (1), 821–35.
61.
GlendayGraham, GuptaAnil, and PawlakHenry (1986), “Tax Incentives for Personal Charitable Contributions,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 68 (4), 688–93.
62.
GreenePamela and McClellandRobert (2001), “Taxes and Charitable Giving,”National Tax Journal, 54 (3), 433–53.
63.
GreenwoodDaphne (1993), “Price and Income Elasticities of Charitable Giving,”Public Finance Quarterly, 21 (2), 196–209.
64.
HibbertSally and HorneSuzanne (1997), “Donation Dilemmas: A Consumer Behaviour Perspective,”Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 2 (3), 261–74.
65.
HoodR.D., MartinS.A., and OsbergL.S. (1977), “Economic Determinants of Individual Charitable Donations in Canada,”Canadian Journal of Economics, 10 (4), 653–69.
66.
HunterJack E. and SchmidtFrank L. (1990), Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting for Error and Bias in Research Findings Across Studies. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
67.
JonesAndrew and PosnettJohn (1991), “The Impact of Tax Deductability on Charitable Giving by Convenant in the UK,”Economic Journal, 101 (408), 1117–29.
68.
JonesP.R. (1983), “Aid to Charities,”International Journal of Social Economics, 10 (1), 4–11.
JoulfaianDavid (2000), “Estate Taxes and Charitable Bequests by the Wealthy,”National Tax Journal, 53 (3), 743–63.
71.
JoulfaianDavid and RiderMark (2004), “Errors-In Variables and Estimated Income and Price Elasticities of Charitable Giving,”National Tax Journal, 57 (1), 25–43.
72.
KingmaBruce Robert (1989), “An Accurate Measurement of the Crowd-Out Effect, Income Effect, and Price Effect for Charitable Contributions,”Journal of Political Economy, 97 (5), 1197–1207.
KottaszRita (2004), “How Should Charitable Organisations Motivate Young Professionals to Give Philanthropically?”International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 9 (1), 9–27.
75.
KremersHans, NijkampPeter, and RietveldPiet (2002), “A Meta-Analysis of Price Elasticities of Transport Demand in a General Equilibrium Framework,”Economic Modelling, 19 (1), 463–85.
76.
LankfordR. Hamilton and WyckoffJames (1991), “Modeling Charitable Giving Using a Box-Cox Standard Tobit Model,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 73 (3), 460–70.
LawrenceDavid and SaghafiMassoud (1984), “The Flat-Rate Income Tax, Tax Burden, and Charitable Contributions,”National Tax Journal, 37 (4), 569–74.
79.
LindahlWesley (1995), “The Major Gift Donor Relationship,”Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 5 (4), 411–32.
80.
LindahlWesley and ConleyAaron (2002), “Literature Review: Philanthropic Fundraising,”Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 13 (1), 91–112.
81.
LindseyLawrence (1987), “Estimating the Behavioral Responses of Taxpayers to Changes in Tax Rates,”Journal of Public Economics, 33 (1), 173–206.
82.
McClellandRobert (2004), “Charitable Bequests and the Repeal of the Estate Tax,” Technical Paper Series Document 2004-14274, Congressional Budget Office, Washington, DC.
MillerMatthew (1998), “Explaining California's ‘Mississippification’: A Dramatic Decline in Public Services,”U.S. News and World Report, (May 18), 32.
85.
NewsomeMichael, BlomquistGlenn, and RomainWendy (2001), “Taxes and Voluntary Contributions: Evidence from State Tax Check-Off Programs,”National Tax Journal, 54 (4), 725–40.
86.
OlabuenagaRuiz (2000), El Sector no Lucrative en Espana (Third Sector in Spain). Madrid: Fundacion BB.
87.
O'NeilCherie, SteinbergRichard, and ThompsonG. Rodney (1996), “Reassessing the Tax-Favored Status of the Charitable Deduction for Gifts of Appreciated Assets,”National Tax Journal, 49 (2), 215–33.
88.
OrwinRobert G. (1994), “Evaluating Coding Decisions,” in The Handbook of Research Synthesis, CooperH. and HedgesL.V., eds. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 139–62.
89.
PetersonRobert A. and BrownSteven P. (2005), “On the Use of Beta Coefficients in Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 90 (1), 175–81.
90.
PiliavinJane Allyn and CharngHong-Wen (1990), “Altruism: A Review of Recent Theory and Research,”Annual Review of Sociology, 16 (1), 27–65.
91.
RandolphWilliam (1995), “Dynamic Income, Progressive Taxes, and the Timing of Charitable Contributions,”Journal of Political Economy, 103 (4), 709–738.
92.
ReeceWilliam (1979), “Charitable Contributions: New Evidence on Household Behavior,”American Economic Review, 69 (1), 142–51.
93.
ReeceWilliam and ZieschangKimberly (1985), “Consistent Estimation of the Impact of Tax Deductibility on the Level of Charitable Contributions,”Econometrica, 53 (2), 271–94.
94.
ReeceWilliam and ZieschangKimberly (1989), “Evidence on Taxation and Charitable Giving from the 1983 U.S. Treasury Tax Model File,”Economic Letters, 31 (1), 49–52.
95.
RickettsRobert and WestfallPeter (1993), “New Evidence on the Price Elasticity of Charitable Contributions,”Journal of the American Taxation Association, 15 (2), 1–25.
96.
RobinsonJohn (1990), “Estimates of the Price Elasticity of Charitable Giving: A Reappraisal Using 1985 Itemizer and Nonitemizer Charitable Deduction Data,”Journal of the American Taxation Association, 12 (2), 39–59.
97.
RostenLeo (1972), Leo Rosten's Treasury of Jewish Quotations. New York: McGraw-Hill.
98.
RudneyGabriel (1985), “Charitable Deductions and Tax Reform: New Evidence on Giving Behavior,”Tax Notes, (January 28), 367–68.
99.
SchiffJerald (1985), “Does Government Spending Crowd Out Charitable Contributions?”National Tax Journal, 38 (4), 535–46.
100.
SchwartzRobert (1970), “Personal Philanthropic Contributions,”Journal of Political Economy, 78 (1), 1264–91.
101.
SlemrodJoel (1989), “Are Estimated Tax Elasticities Really Just Tax Evasion Elasticities? The Case of Charitable Contributions,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 71 (3), 517–52.
102.
SmithScott M. (1980), “Giving to Charitable Organizations: A Behavioral Review and a Framework for Increasing Commitment,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 7, OlsonJerry, ed. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 753–56.
103.
SteelPiers and Kammeyer-MuellerJ.D. (2002), “Comparing Meta-Analytic Moderator Estimation Techniques Under Realistic Conditions,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 87 (1), 96–111.
104.
SteelPiers and KönigCornelius J. (in press), “Integrating Theories of Motivation,”Academy of Management Review, forthcoming.
105.
SteinbergRichard (1985), “Empirical Relations Between Government Spending and Charitable Donations,”Journal of Voluntary Action Research, 14 (September), 54–65.
106.
SteinbergRichard (1990), “Taxes and Giving: New Findings,”Voluntas, 1 (2), 61–79.
107.
SullivanAline (2002), “Affair of the Heart,”Barron's, 82 (49), 28.
108.
TabachnickBarbara G. and FidellLinda S. (1989), Using Multivariate Statistics, 2d ed. New York: HarperCollins.
109.
TaussigMichael (1967), “Economic Aspects of the Personal Income Tax Treatment of Charitable Donations,”National Tax Journal, 20 (1), 1–19.
110.
TellisGerard (1988), “The Price Elasticity of Selective Demand: A Meta-Analysis of Econometric Models of Sales,”Journal of Marketing Research, 25 (November), 331–41.
111.
TiehenLaura (2001), “Tax Policy and Charitable Contributions of Money,”National Tax Journal, 54 (4), 707–723.
112.
U.S. Department of Treasury (1984), Tax Reform for Fairness, Simplicity, and Economic Growth. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Treasury.
113.
U.S. House (1985), Tax Reform Act of 1985, 99th Cong., 1st session, 99–426.
114.
WuJiang-Ming Johnny and RickettsRobert (1999), “The Price Elasticity of Charitable Giving: Additional Evidence from Panel Data via the EM Algorithm,” in Proceedings of the Survey Research Methods Section of the American Statistical Society, Vol. 11. Alexandria, VA: Statistical Association, 831–36.
