The authors present a six-stage model of the policymaking process and evaluate the extent to which survey research has played a role at each stage. The authors identify areas in which additional research would be helpful in the development and evaluation of public policymaking. In addition, the authors explore three case studies—patient package inserts, direct-to-consumer advertising, and environmental marketing guides—to illustrate the role consumer research has played and could have played in the policy-development process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsCharles (2001), “FDA Plans to Review Policy Allowing Direct-to-Consumer Drug Ads for TV,”Wall Street Journal, (March 29).
2.
Advertising Age (1992), poll conducted by Yankelovich Clancy Schulman, special section, 4.
3.
AltekruseS.F., StreetDebra A., FeinSara B., and LevyAlan S. (1996), “Consumer Knowledge of Food-Borne Microbial Hazards and Food-Handling Practices,”Journal of Food Protection, 59(3), 287–94.
4.
AndrewsJ. Craig (2001), “The Use of Marketing Knowledge in Formulating and Enforcing Consumer Protection Policy,” in Handbook of Marketing and Society, PaulN. Bloom, and GundlachGregory T., eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 1–33.
5.
AndrewsJ. Craig, and MaronickThomas J. (1995), “Advertising Research Issues from FTC Versus Stouffer Foods Corporation,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 14(2), 301–27.
6.
AndrewsJ. Craig, and NetemeyerRichard G. (1996), “Alcohol Warning Label Effects: Socialization, Addiction, and Public Policy Issues,” in Marketing and Consumer Research in the Public Interest, HillRonald Paul, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 152–75.
BelkinLisa (2001), “Prime Time Pushers,”Mother Jones, 26(March/April), 30–37.
9.
BernhardtKenneth L., KinnearThomas C., and MazisMichael B. (1986), “A Field Study of Corrective Advertising Effectiveness,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 5, 146–62.
10.
BernsteinJoan Z. (1996), “Federal Trade Commission Solicits Consumer Research,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 23, KimP. Corfman, and LynchJohn G.Jr., eds. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 313–15.
11.
BloomPaul N., EdellJulie, and StaelinRichard (2001), “Criteria for Assessing the Public Policy Relevance of Research,” in Handbook of Marketing and Society, PaulN. Bloom, and GundlachGregory, eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 51–79.
12.
BogaertMichael, Vander SticheleR., KaufmanJohn, and LefebvreRobert (1989), Patient Package Insert as a Source of Drug Information.Amsterdam: Excerpta Medica.
13.
BushmanBrad J. (1996), “Forbidden Fruit Versus Tainted Fruit: Effects of Warning Labels on Attraction to Television Violence,”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2(3), 207–26.
14.
CalfeeJohn E. (2000), “The Historical Significance of Joe Camel,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 19(2), 168–82.
15.
CochranCharles L., and MaloneEloise F. (1995), Public Policy— Perspectives and Choices.New York: McGraw-Hill.
16.
CochranClarke E., MayerLawrence C., CarrT.R., and Joseph CayerN. (1993), American Public Policy: An Introduction, 4th ed.New York: St. Martin's Press.
17.
CohenJoel B. (2000), “Playing to Win: Marketing and Public Policy at Odds over Joe Camel,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 19(2), 155–67.
18.
Council on Plastics and Packaging in the Environment (1990), The Environmental Report, survey conducted by Environmental Research Associates.Washington, DC: Council on Plastics and Packaging in the Environment.
19.
CudeBrenda J. (1993), “Consumer Perceptions of Environmental Marketing Claims: An Exploratory Investigation,”Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics, 17(4), 207–25.
20.
CudeBrenda J., and MayerRobert N. (1995), “Comments on the Federal Trade Commission's Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims,” unpublished document, (September 27).
21.
DerbyBrenda M., and LevyAlan S. (2001), “Do Food Labels Work?” in Handbook of Marketing and Society, PaulN. Bloom, and GundlachGregory T., eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 372–98.
22.
DiFranzaJoseph D., RichardsJohn W., FreemanPaul M., Wolf-GillespieNancy, FletcherChristopher, JaffeRobert D., and MurrayDavid (1991), “RJR Nabisco's Cartoon Camel Promotes Camel Cigarettes to Children,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 266(December 11), 3149–53.
23.
DyerRobert F., and MaronickThomas J. (1988), “An Evaluation of Consumer Awareness and Use of Energy Labels in the Purchase of Major Appliances: A Longitudinal Analysis,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 7, 83–97.
Federal Trade Commission (1998a), Generic Copy Test of Food Health Claims in Advertising.Washington, DC: Federal Trade Commission.
32.
Federal Trade Commission (1998b), “Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims; Final Rule,”Federal Register, 63, 84 (May 1), 24239–51.
33.
Federal Trade Commission (2000), “Marketing Violent Entertainment to Children: A Review of Self-Regulated and Industry Practices in the Motion Picture, Music Recording and Electronic Game Industries,” Federal Trade Commission report, (September).
34.
FeinSara B., TungChung, LinJ., and LevyAlan S. (1995), “Food Borne Illness: Perceptions, Experience, and Preventative Behaviors in the United States,”Journal of Food Protection, 58(12), 1405–11.
35.
FischerPaul M., RichardsJohn W.Jr., BermanEarl J., and KrugmanDean M. (1989), “Recall and Eye Tracking Study of Adolescents Viewing Tobacco Advertisements,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 261(1), 84–89.
36.
FischerPaul M., SchwartzMeyer P., RichardsJohn W.Jr., GoldsteinAdam O., and RojasTina H. (1991), “Brand Logo Recognition by Children Aged 3 to 6 Years,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 266(December 11), 3145–48.
37.
Food and Drug Administration (1993), “Food Labeling; General Provisions … Final Rules,” 21 CFR, Part 1, (January 6), 2302–964.
38.
Food and Drug Administration (1997), Warning Letters and Untitled Letters to Pharmaceutical Companies 1997, (accessed July 23, 2001) [available at http://www.fda.gov/cder/warn/warn1997.htm].
39.
Food and Drug Administration (1999a), Attitudes and Behaviors Associated with Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) Promotion of Prescription Drugs: Preliminary Survey Results, (accessed July 23, 2001) [available at http://www.fda.gov/cder/ddmac/dtctitle.htm].
40.
Food and Drug Administration (1999b), Evaluation of Written Prescription Information Provided in Community Pharmacies: An 8-State Study, (accessed July 23, 2001) [available at http://www.fda.gov/cder/calendar/meeting/rx2000/report1.htm].
FordGary T., HastakManoj, MitraAnusree, and RingoldDebra Jones (1996), “Can Consumers Interpret Nutrition Information in the Presence of a Health Claim? A Laboratory Investigation,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 15(1), 16–27.
43.
FTC v. Kraft Inc. (1991), Commission Decision, 114 FTC 40–46, 116–51; aff'd, Kraft Inc. v. FTC (1992), 970 F2d 311 (7th Cir.), 311-28; cert. denied (1993), 113 S.Cct., 1254.
FTC v. Thompson Medical Company Inc. (1984), 104 FTC 648.
48.
FTC v. Trans Union Corporation (2000), FTC Docket No. 9255, Commission Opinion (February 10).
49.
Good Housekeeping Institute Report (1990), Concerns Women Have for the Environment, Consumer Research Department (August).Washington, DC: Good Housekeeping Institute.
50.
GravesKaren L. (1993), “An Evaluation of the Alcohol Warning Label: A Comparison of the United States and Ontario, Canada in 1990 and 1991,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12(1), 19–29.
51.
GrierSonya A. (2001), “The Federal Trade Commission's Report on the Marketing of Violent Entertainment to Youths: Developing Policy-Tuned Research,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 20(1), 123–32.
52.
GuessGeorge M., and FarnhamPaul G. (1989), Cases in Public Policy Analysis.New York: Longman.
53.
HankinJanet R., FirestoneIra J., SloanJames J., AgerJoel W., GoodmanAllen, SokolRobert, and MartierSusan S. (1993), “The Impact of the Alcohol Warning Label on Women During Pregnancy,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12(1), 10–18.
54.
HankinJanet R., SloanJames J., and SokolRobert J. (1998), “The Modest Impact of the Alcohol Beverage Warning Label on Drinking During Pregnancy Among a Sample of African-American Women,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 17(1), 61–69.
55.
HastakManoj (1998), “Report On a Telephone Survey of the Customers of National Talent Associates,” unpublished report submitted to the U.S. Department of Justice, Washington, DC.
56.
HastakManoj, HorstRomana, and MazisMichael B. (1992), “Summary and Analysis of Consumer Surveys on Environmental Claims in Advertising and Labeling,” report submitted to the Federal Trade Commission, Washington, DC.
57.
HastakManoj, HorstRomana, and MazisMichael B. (1994), “Consumer Perceptions About and Comprehension of Environmental Terms: Evidence from Survey Research Studies,” in Proceedings of the 1994 Marketing and Public Policy Conference, DebraJ. Ringold, ed. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 94–105.
58.
HastakManoj, MaronickThomas J., and MazisMichael B. (1996), “Consumers’ Interpretation of Alternative Environmental Claims,” report submitted to the Federal Trade Commission, Washington, DC.
59.
HastakManoj, and MazisMichael B. (1997), “Consumers’ Interpretation of ‘Recyclable’ and ‘Please Recycle’ Claims on Product Packages,” report submitted to the Federal Trade Commission, Washington, DC.
60.
HeimbachJames T. (1985), “Cardiovascular Disease and Diet: The Public View,”Public Health Reports, 100(1), 5–11.
61.
HolakSusan L., and ReddySrinivas K. (1986), “Effects of a Television and Radio Advertising Ban: A Study of the Cigarette Industry,”Journal of Marketing, 50(October), 219–27.
62.
HoustonMichael J., and RothschildMichael L. (1980), “Policy-Related Experiments on Information Provision: A Normative Model and Explication,”Journal of Marketing Research, 17(November), 432–49.
63.
Institute of Medicine (2000), To Err Is Human.Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
64.
Walter ThompsonJ. (1991), “The Meaning of Green,”JWT Green-watch, 3(Spring/Summer).
65.
JacobyJacob, and SzybilloGeorge J. (1995), “Consumer Research in FTC Versus Kraft (1991): A Case of Heads We Win, Tails You Lose?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 14(1), 1–14.
66.
JaffeHelene D. (1994), “Use of Consumer Surveys in Lanham Act Cases,”Antitrust, 8(Summer), 30–35.
67.
KlontzKarl C., TimboBabgaleh, FeinSara B., and LevyAlan S. (1995), “Prevalence of Selected Food Consumption and Preparation Behaviors Associated with Increased Risks of Food-Borne Disease,”Journal of Food Protection, 58(8), 927–30.
68.
KrumskeWilliam (1993), “When Medical Doctors Conduct Marketing Research: JAMA and Old Joe, the Camel,” in AMA Winter Educators’ Conference Proceedings: Marketing Theory & Applications, VaradarajanRajan, JaworskiBernard, GordonPeter J., and KellermanBert J., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 405–10.
69.
LackoJames M., McKernanSigne-Mary, and HastakManoj (2000), Survey of Rent-to-Own Customers, Bureau of Economics Staff Report. Washington, DC: Federal Trade Commission.
70.
LaugheryKenneth R., YoungStephen L., VaubelKent P., and BrelsfordJohn W.Jr. (1993), “The Noticeability of Warnings on Alcoholic Beverage Containers,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 12(1), 38–56.
71.
LeeJinkook, and HogarthJeanne M. (1999), “The Price of Money: Consumers’ Understanding of APRs and Contract Interest Rates,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 18(1), 66–76.
72.
LevyAlan S., FeinSara B., and SchuckerRaymond E. (1996), “Performance Characteristics of Seven Nutrition Label Formats,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 15(1), 1–15.
73.
LevyAlan S., FeinSara B., and StephensonMarilyn (1993), “Nutrition Knowledge Levels About Dietary Fats and Cholesterol,”Journal of Nutrition Education, 25(2), 60–66.
74.
LevyAlan S., and HeatonA.W. (1995a), “Iron Warning Labels Focus Groups: Summary of Findings,” Consumer Studies Branch, Division of Market Studies, Food and Drug Administration (April).
75.
LevyAlan S., and HeatonA.W. (1995b), “Summary Report on Six Vibrio vulnificus Education Focus Groups,” Consumer Studies Branch, Division of Market Studies, Food and Drug Administration (August).
76.
LevyAlan S., and HeatonA.W. (1997), “Summary Report on Consumer Advisory Focus Groups,” Consumer Studies Branch, Division of Market Studies, Food and Drug Administration (January).
77.
LevyAlan S., and HeatonA.W. (1998a), “Summary Report on Focus Group Testing on Warning Statements on Juice Products Not Pasteurized or Otherwise Specifically Treated to Eliminate Harmful Bacteria,” Consumer Studies Branch, Division of Market Studies, Food and Drug Administration (February).
78.
LevyAlan S., and HeatonA.W. (1998b), “Summary Report on Focus Group Testing of Safe Handling Statements on Shell Eggs,” Consumer Studies Branch, Division of Market Studies, Food and Drug Administration (March).
79.
MaronickThomas J. (1990), “Current Role of Research at the Federal Trade Commission,” in Marketing and Advertising Regulation: The Federal Trade Commission in the 1990's, PatrickE. Murphy, and WilkieWilliam L., eds. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 345–55.
80.
MaronickThomas J. (1991), “Copy Tests in FTC Deception Cases: Guidelines for Researchers,”Journal of Advertising Research, 31(6), 9–17.
81.
MaronickThomas J., and Craig AndrewsJ. (1999), “The Role of Qualifying Language on Consumer Perceptions of Environmental Claims,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 33(2), 297–320.
82.
MayerRobert N., CudeBrenda J., Gray-LeeJason, and ScammonDebra L. (1995), “Trends in Environmental Marketing Claims Since the FTC Guides: Two-Year Auditing Results,” in Consumer Interests Annual: Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the American Council on Consumer Interests, KarenF. Fox, ed. Columbia, MO: American Council on Consumer Interests, 161–66.
83.
MayerRobert N., LewisLinda A., and ScammonDebra L. (2001), “The Effectiveness of Environmental Marketing Claims: The Roles of Consumers, Competitors, and Policy Makers,” in Handbook of Marketing and Society, PaulN. Bloom, and GundlachGregory T., eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 399–420.
84.
MayerRobert N., ScammonDebra L., and ZickCathleen D. (1992), “Turning the Competition Green: The Regulation of Environmental Claims,” in Proceedings of the 1992 Marketing and Public Policy Conference, PaulN. Bloom, and StarrRichard G., eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 152–65.
85.
MazisMichael B. (1996), “Copy-Testing Issues in FTC Advertising Cases,” in Marketing and Public Policy Conference Proceedings, Vol. 6, HillRonald Paul, and TaylorCharles Ray, eds. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 122–30.
86.
MazisMichael B. (2001), “FTC v. Novartis: The Return of Corrective Advertising?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 21(1), 114–22.
87.
MazisMichael B., McNeillDennis L., and BernhardtKenneth L. (1983), “Day-After Recall of Listerine Corrective Commercials,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 2, 29–37.
88.
MazisMichael B., MorrisLouis A., and SwasyJohn L. (1991), “An Evaluation of the Alcohol Waning Label: Initial Survey Results,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10(1), 229–41.
89.
MazisMichael B., MorrisLouis A., and SwasyJohn L. (1996), “Longitudinal Study of Awareness, Recall, and Acceptance of Alcohol Warning Labels,”Applied Behavioral Science Review, 4(2), 111–20.
90.
McNeillDennis L., and WilkieWilliam L. (1979), “Public Policy and Consumer Information: Impact of the New Energy Labels,”Journal of Consumer Research, 6(1), 1–11.
91.
MitraAnusree, HastakManoj, FordGary T., and RingoldDebra Jones (1999), “Can the Educationally Disadvantaged Interpret the FDA-Mandated Nutrition Facts Panel in the Presence of an Implied Health Claim?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 18(1), 106–17.
92.
MizerskiRichard (1995), “The Relationship Between Cartoon Trade Character Recognition and Attitude Toward Product Category in Young Children,”Journal of Marketing, 59(4), 58–70.
93.
MoormanChristine (1996), “A Quasi Experiment to Assess the Consumer and Informational Determinants of Nutrition Information Processing Activities: The Case of the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 15(1), 28–44.
94.
MorrisLouis A., and GroftSteven (1982), “Patient Package Inserts: A Research Perspective,” in Drug Therapeutics; Concepts for Physicians, MelmonK., ed. New York: Elsevier, 191–217.
95.
MorrisLouis A., and HalperinJerome A. (1979), “Effects of Written Drug Information on Patient Knowledge and Compliance: A Literature Review,”American Journal of Public Health, 69(1), 47–52.
96.
MorrisLouis A., HastakManoj, and MazisMichael B. (1995), “Consumer Comprehension of Environmental Advertising and Labeling Claims,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 29(2), 328–50.
97.
MorrisLouis A., and KanouseDavid E. (1982), “Informing Patients About Drug Side Effects,”Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 5(3), 363–73.
98.
MorrisLouis A., and KlimbergRonald (1986), “A Survey of Aspirin Use and Reye's Syndrome Awareness Among Parents,”American Journal of Public Health, 76(12), 1422–24.
99.
MorrisLouis A., MazisMichael B., and BrinbergDavid (1989), “Risk Disclosures in Televised Prescription Drug Advertising to Consumers,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 8(1), 64–80.
100.
MorrisLouis A., MazisMichael B., and GordonEvelyn (1977), “A Survey of the Effects of Oral Contraceptive Patient Information,”Journal of the American Medical Association, (December 5), 2504–508.
101.
MorrisLouis A., TabakEllen, and GondekKathleen (1997), “Counseling Patients About Prescription Medication: Twelve-Year Trends,”Medical Care, 35(10), 996–1007.
102.
National Association of Attorneys General (1990), The Green Report: Findings and Preliminary Recommendations for Responsible Environmental Advertising.Washington, DC: National Association of Attorneys General.
103.
National Association of Attorneys General (1991), The Green Report II: Recommendations for Responsible Environmental Advertising.Washington, DC: National Association of Attorneys General.
104.
PatkaCarl F. (1993), “Of Diapers, Lawnbags, and Landfills: The Federal Trade Commission Cracks Down on False Advertising in the Environmental Marketplace,”Loyola Consumer Law Reporter, 5(2), 43–49.
105.
PettyRoss D., and KoppRobert J. (1995), “Advertising Challenges: A Strategic Framework and Current Reviews,”Journal of Advertising Research, 35(2), 41–55.
106.
PierceJohn P., GilpinElizabeth, BurnsDavid M., WhaleyElizabeth, RosbrookBradley, ShoplandDonald, and JohnsonMichael (1991), “Does Tobacco Advertising Target Young People to Start Smoking?”Journal of the American Medical Association, 266(December 11), 3154–58.
107.
PrestonIvan L. (1992), “The Scandalous Record of Available Errors in Expert Evidence Offered in FTC and Lanham Act Deceptiveness Cases,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 11(2), 57–67.
108.
RichardsJef I. (1990), Deceptive Advertising: Behavioral Study of a Legal Concept.Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
109.
JohnsonS.C., & Son (1990), The Environment: Public Attitudes and Individual Behavior.New York: Roper Organization.
110.
ScammonDebra L., and MayerRobert N. (1995), “Agency Review of Environmental Marketing Claims: Case-by-Case Decomposition of the Issues,”Journal of Advertising, 24(2), 33–44.
111.
ScammonDebra L., MayerRobert N., and SmithKen R. (1991), “Alcohol Warnings: How Do You Know When You Have Had One Too Many?”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10(1), 214–28.
112.
StarekRoscoe B.III (1993), “Ross Starek's Wish List: Or, a Call for Extrinsic Evidence,” prepared remarks made at the Marketing and Public Policy Conference, East Lansing, MI (June).
113.
StarekRoscoe B.III (1996), “The Federal Trade Commission's Green Guides: A Success Story,” prepared remarks before the Alliance for Beverage Cartons and the Environment Symposium, Brussels, Belgium (December 4).
114.
StarlingGrover (1998), Managing the Public Sector, 5th ed.Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace.
115.
StewartDavid W. (1995), “Deception, Materiality, and Survey Research: Some Lessons from Kraft,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 14(1), 15–28.
116.
StewartDavid W., and MartinIngrid M. (1994), “Intended and Unintended Consequences of Warning Messages: A Review and Synthesis of Empirical Research,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 13(1), 1–19.
117.
SudmanSeymour (1995), “When Experts Disagree: Comments on the Articles by Jacoby and Szybillo and Stewart,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 14(1), 29–34.
118.
WagnerEileen N. (1991), “The Alcoholic Beverages Labeling Act of 1988: A Preemptive Shield Against Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Claims,”The Journal of Legal Medicine, 12(2), 167–200.
119.
WestinAlan F., and MauriciDanielle (1998), E-Commerce & Privacy: What Net Users Want.Hackensack, NJ: Privacy & American Business.
120.
WilkieWilliam L., McNeillDennis L., and MazisMichael B. (1984), “Marketing's ‘Scarlet Letter’: The Theory and Practice of Corrective Advertising,”Journal of Marketing, 48(2), 11–31.
121.
WogalterMichael S., DeJoyDavid M., and LaugheryKenneth R., eds. (1999), Warnings and Risk Communication.London: Taylor & Francis.
122.
WrightPeter (1979), “Concrete Action Plans in TV Messages to Increase Reading of Drug Warnings,”Journal of Consumer Research, 6(December), 256–69.
