In a field experiment involving online workplace lunch orders, this study examines the impact of numeric and traffic light calorie labels on calorie intake. Employees of a large corporation ordered lunches through a website of the authors’ design, on which they were presented menus with numeric calorie labels, traffic light labels, or both together, and the authors compared the calorie content of the ordered lunches with that of diners randomized to receive no calorie information. Each label type reduced lunch calories by approximately 10%. Nutrition knowledge was not improved by any menu format. Traffic light labels achieved meaningful reductions in calories ordered even in the absence of numeric information, and the authors found no apparent benefit or detriment of combining label types. These findings suggest that consumers may benefit most from help in identifying relatively healthier choices but rely little on information about the exact caloric content of items.
CraigAndrews J., BurtonScot, and KeesJeremy (2011), “Is Simpler Always Better? Consumer Evaluations of Front-of-Package Nutrition Symbols,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 30(2), 175–90.
2.
AndrewsChung-Tung, LinJordan, LevyAlan S., and LoSerena (2014), “Consumer Research Needs from the Food and Drug Administration on Front-of-Package Nutritional Labeling,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 33(1), 10–16.
3.
BollingerBryan, LesliePhillip, and SorensenAlan (2010), Calorie Posting in Chain Restaurants. No. w15648.Washington, DC: National Bureau of Economic Research.
4.
BurtonScot, CreyerElizabeth H., KeesJeremy, and HugginsKyle (2006), “Attacking the Obesity Epidemic: The Potential Health Benefits of Providing Nutrition Information in Restaurants,”American Journal of Public Health, 96(9), 1669–75.
5.
BurtonElizabeth Howlett, and TangariAndrea Heintz (2009), “Food for Thought: How Will the Nutrition Labeling of Quick Service Restaurant Menu Items Influence Consumers’ Product Evaluations, Purchase Intentions, and Choices?”Journal of Retailing, 85(3), 258–73.
6.
BurtonElizabeth Howlett, and KeesJeremy (2012), “Flies in the Ointment? Addressing Potential Impediments to Population-Based Health Benefits of Restaurant Menu Labeling Initiatives,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 31(2), 232–39.
7.
ChandonPierre, and WansinkBrian (2007), “The Biasing Health Halos of Fast-Food Restaurant Health Claims: Lower Calorie Estimates and Higher Side-Dish Consumption Intentions,”Journal of Consumer Research, 34(3), 301–14.
8.
CastroDe, JohnM., and Marie BrewerE. (1992), “The Amount Eaten in Meals by Humans is a Power Function of the Number of People Present,”Physiology & Behavior, 51(1), 121–25.
9.
DownsJulie S., WisdomJessica, and LoewensteinGeorge (2015), “Helping Consumers Use Nutrition Information: Effects of Format and Presentation,”American Journal of Health Economics, 1(3), 326–44.
10.
DownsJulie S., WisdomJessica, WansinkBrian, and LoewensteinGeorge (2013), “Supplementing Menu Labeling with Calorie Recommendations to Test for Facilitation Effects,”American Journal of Public Health, 103(9), 1604–09.
11.
DowraySunaina, SwartzJonas J., BraxtonDanielle, and VieraAnthony J. (2013), “Potential Effect of Physical Activity Based Menu Labels on the Calorie Content of Selected Fast Food Meals,”Appetite, 62(1), 173–81.
12.
DrichoutisAndreas C., LazaridisPanagiotis, and NaygaRodolfo M. (2006), “Consumers’ Use of Nutritional Labels: A Review of Research Studies and Issues,”Academy of Marketing Science Review, 9 (9), 1–22.
EllisonBrenna, LuskJayson L., and DavisDavid (2013), “Looking at the Label and Beyond: The Effects of Calorie Labels, Health Consciousness, and Demographics on Caloric Intake in Restaurants,”International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 10(21), [DOI: http://www.ijbnpa.org/content/10/1/21].
15.
EllisonBrenna, LuskJayson L., and DavisDavid (2014), “The Impact of Restaurant Calorie Labels on Food Choice: Results from a Field Experiment,”Economic Inquiry, 52(2), 666–81.
16.
FarleyThomas A., CaffarelliAnna, BassettMary T., SilverLynn, and FriedenThomas R. (2009), “New York City's Fight Over Calorie Labeling,”Health Affairs, 28(6), w1098–109.
Federal Register (2014), “Food Labeling; Nutrition Labeling of Standard Menu Items in Restaurants and Similar Retail Food Establishments,” (December 1), (accessed December 23, 2015), [available at https://federalregister.gov/a/2014-27833].
19.
FinkelsteinEric A., TrogdonJustin G., CohenJoel W., and DietzWilliam (2009), “Annual Medical Spending Attributable to Obesity: Payer- and Service-Specific Estimates,”Health Affairs, 28(5), W822–31.
20.
FlegalKatherine M., CarrollMargaret D., KitBrian K., and OgdenCynthia L. (2012), “Prevalence of Obesity and Trends in the Distribution of Body Mass Index among US Adults, 1999–2010,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 307(5), 491–97.
21.
FlegalBrian, KitK., OrpanaHeather, and GraubardBarry I. (2013), “Association of All-Cause Mortality with Overweight and Obesity Using Standard Body Mass Index Categories: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 309(1), 71–82.
FrankenfieldDavid, Roth-YouseyLori, and CompherCharlene (2005), “Comparison of Predictive Equations for Resting Metabolic Rate in Healthy Nonobese and Obese Adults: A Systematic Review,”Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 105(5), 775–89.
24.
GlanzKaren, BasilMichael, MaibachEdward, GoldbertJeanne, and SnyderDan (1998), “Why Americans Eat What They Do: Taste, Nutrition, Cost, Convenience, and Weight Control Concerns as Influences on Food Consumption,”Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 98(October), 1118–26.
25.
GrunertKlaus G., and WillsJosephine M. (2007), “A Review of European Research on Consumer Response to Nutrition Information on Food Labels,”Journal of Public Health, 15(5), 385–99.
26.
GuthEve (2014), “Healthy Weight Loss,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 312(9), 974.
27.
HarnackLisa J., and FrenchSimone A. (2008), “Effect of Point-of-Purchase Calorie Labeling on Restaurant and Cafeteria Food Choices: A Review of the Literature,”International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 5(51), 1–6.
28.
HarnackLisa J., OakesMichael J., StoryMary T., JefferyRobert W., and RydellSarah A. (2008), “Effects of Calorie Labeling and Value Size Pricing on Fast Food Meal Choices: Results from an Experimental Trial,”International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 5(63), [DOI: 10.1186/1479-5868-5-63].
29.
HawleyKristy L., RobertoChristina A., BraggMarie A., LiuPeggy J., SchwartzMarlene B., and BrownellKelly D. (2013), “The Science on Front-of-Package Food Labels,”Public Health Nutrition, 1(1), 1–10.
30.
PeterHerman C., RothDeborah A., and PolivyJanet (2003), “Effects of the Presence of Others on Food Intake: A Normative Interpretation,”Psychological Bulletin, 129(6), 873–86.
31.
HerseyJames C., WohlgenantKelly C., ArsenaultJoanne E., KosaKatherine M., and MuthMary K. (2013), “Effects of Front-of-Package and Shelf Nutrition Labeling Systems on Consumers,”Nutrition Reviews, 71(1), 1–14.
32.
HowlettElizabeth, BurtonScot, TangariAndrea Heintz, and BuiMy (2012), “Hold the Salt! Effects of Sodium Information Provision, Sodium Content, and Hypertension on Perceived Cardiovascular Disease Risk and Purchase Intentions,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 31(1), 4–18.
KimesSheryl E. (2011), “The Current State of Online Food Ordering in the U.S. Restaurant Industry,”Cornell Hospitality Report, 11(17), 6–18.
35.
KiszkoKamila M., MartinezOlivia D., AbramsCourtney, and ElbelBrian (2014), “The Influence of Calorie Labeling on Food Orders and Consumption: A Review of the Literature,”Journal of Community Health, 39(6), 1–22.
36.
KoenigstorferJoerg, Groeppel-KleinAndrea, and KammFriederike (2014), “Healthful Food Decision Making in Response to Traffic Light Color-Coded Nutrition Labeling,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 33(1), 65–77.
37.
LoewensteinGeorge, SunsteinCass R., and GolmanRussell (2014), “Disclosure: Psychology Changes Everything,”Annual Review of Economics, 6, 391–419.
38.
LongMichael W., TobiasDeirdre K., CradockAngie L., BatchelderHolly, and GortmakerSteven L. (2015), “Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Impact of Restaurant Menu Calorie Labeling,”American Journal of Public Health, 105(5), e11–24.
39.
NambaAlexa, AuchinclossAmy, LeonbergBeth L., and WootanMargo G. (2013), “Exploratory Analysis of Fast-Food Chain Restaurant Menus Before and After Implementation of Local Calorie-Labeling Policies, 2005–2011,”Preventing Chronic Disease, 10, E101.
40.
OgdenCynthia L., CarrollMargaret D., KitBrian K., and FlegalKatherine M. (2013), “Prevalence of Obesity among Adults: United States, 2011–2012,”NCHS Data Brief, 131, 1–8.
41.
PomeranzJennifer L., and BrownellKelly D. (2008), “Legal and Public Health Considerations Affecting the Success, Reach, and Impact of Menu-Labeling Laws,”American Journal of Public Health, 98, 1578–83.
42.
RollsBarbara J., RoeLiane S., and MeengsJennifer S. (2006), “Reductions in Portion Size and Energy Density of Foods are Additive and Lead to Sustained Decreases in Energy Intake,”American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 83(1), 11–17.
43.
RothmanRussell L., HousamRyan, WeissHilary, DavisDianne, GregoryRebecca, GebretsadikTebeb, ShintaniAyumi, and ElasyTom A. (2006), “Patient Understanding of Food Labels: The Role of Literacy and Numeracy,”American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 31(5), 391–98.
44.
Schulte-MecklenbeckMichael, SohnMatthias, de BellisEmanuel, MartinNathalie, and HertwigRalph (2013), “A Lack of Appetite for Information and Computation. Simple Heuristics in Food Choice,”Appetite, 71, 242–51.
45.
SchwartzJanet, RiisJason, ElbelBrian, and ArielyDan (2012), “Inviting Consumers to Downsize Fast-Food Portions Significantly Reduces Calorie Consumption,”Health Affairs, 31(2), 399–407.
46.
SchwartzLisa M., WoloshinSteven, BlackWilliam C., and Gilbert WelchH. (1997), “The Role of Numeracy in Understanding the Benefit of Screening Mammography,”Annals of Internal Medicine, 127(11), 966–72.
47.
SwartzJonas J., BraxtonDanielle, and VieraAnthony J. (2011), “Calorie Menu Labeling on Quick-Service Restaurant Menus: An Updated Systematic Review of the Literature,”International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 8(1), 135.
48.
TakslerGlen B., and ElbelBrian (2014), “Calorie Labeling and Consumer Estimation of Calories Purchased,”International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 11(1), 91.
49.
TandonPooja S., WrightJeffrey, ZhouChuan, RogersCara Beth, and ChristakisDimitri A. (2010), “Nutrition Menu Labeling May Lead to Lower-Calorie Restaurant Meal Choices for Children,”Pediatrics, 125(2), 244–48.
50.
ThorndikeAnne N., SonnenbergLillian, RiisJason, BarracloughSusan, and LevyDouglas E. (2012), “A 2-Phase Labeling and Choice Architecture Intervention to Improve Healthy Food and Beverage Choices,”American Journal of Public Health, 102(3), 527–33.
51.
WisdomJessica, DownsJulie S., and LoewensteinGeorge (2010), “Promoting Healthy Choices: Information Versus Convenience,”American Economic Journal. Applied Economics, 2 (2), 164–78.
