The authors find no evidence that consumers benefit from government-mandated disclaimers in advertising. Experiments and common experience show that admonishments to change or avoid behaviors often have effects opposite to those intended. The authors examine 18 experimental studies that provide evidence relevant to mandatory disclaimers. Mandated messages increased confusion for consumers and were ineffective or harmful in the 15 studies that examined perceptions, attitudes, or decisions. The authors conduct an experiment on the effects of a government-mandated disclaimer for a Florida court case, showing two advertisements for dentists offering implant dentistry to 317 participants. Only one advertiser had implant dentistry credentials. Participants exposed to the disclaimer recommended the advertiser who lacked credentials more often, and women and less-educated participants were particularly prone to this error. In addition, participants drew false and damaging inferences about the credentialed dentist.
ScottArmstrong J. (2010), Persuasive Advertising.London: Palgrave Macmillan.
2.
ScottArmstrong J. (2012), “Illusions in Regression Analysis,”International Journal of Forecasting, 28, 689–94.
3.
ScottArmstrong J., and PatnaikSandeep (2009), “Using Quasi-Experimental Data to Develop Principles for Persuasive Advertising,”Journal of Advertising Research, 49(2), 170–75.
4.
DanielBatson C. (1975), “Rational Processing or Rationalization? The Effect of Disconfirming Evidence on a Stated Religious Belief,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 32(1), 176–84.
5.
Ben-ShaharOmri, and SchneiderCarl E. (2011), “The Failure of Mandated Disclosure,”University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 159, 647–749.
6.
BloodDeborah, and SnyderLeslie B. (1993), Why Warnings Boomerang: The Failure of the Surgeon General's Alcohol Warnings to Affect Young Adults.Storrs: Department of Communication Sciences, University of Connecticut.
7.
BookerChristopher, and NorthRichard (2007), Scared to Death: From BSE to Global Warming: Why Scares Are Costing Us The Earth.London: Continuum.
BushmanBrad J. (1998), “Effects of Warning and Information Labels on Consumption of Full-Fat, Reduced-Fat, and No-Fat Products,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 83(1), 97–101.
11.
BushmanBrad J., and StackAngela D. (1996), “Forbidden Fruit Versus Tainted Fruit: Effects of Warning Labels on Attraction to Television Violence,”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2(3), 207–226.
12.
CalfeeJohn E., and FordGary T. (1988), “Economics, Information and Consumer Behavior,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 15, HoustonMichael J., ed. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 234–38.
13.
CialdiniRobert B. (2003), “Crafting Normative Messages to Protect the Environment,”Current Directions in Psychological Science, 12(4), 105–109.
14.
CoxEli P.III, WogalterMichael S., StokesSara L., and Tipton MurffElizabeth J. (1997), “Do Product Warnings Increase Safe Behavior? A Meta-Analysis,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 16(Fall), 195–204.
15.
CraswellRichard (1991), “Regulating Deceptive Advertising: The Role of Cost-Benefit Analysis,”Southern California Law Review, 64, 549–604.
16.
DarkePeter R., AshworthLaurence, and RitchieRobin J. B. (2008), “Damage from Corrective Advertising: Causes and Cures,”Journal of Marketing, 72(November), 81–97.
17.
DeTurckMark A., and GoldhaberGerald M. (1991), “A Developmental Analysis of Warning Signs: The Case of Familiarity and Gender,”Journal of Products Liability, 13(1), 65–78.
EggersSara L., and FischhoffBaruch (2004), “Setting Policies for Consumer Communication: A Behavioral Decision Research Approach,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 23(Spring), 14–27.
20.
Ein-GarDanit, ShivBaba, and TormalaZakary L. (2012), “When Blemishing Leads to Blossoming: The Positive Effects of Negative Information,”Journal of Consumer Research, 38(5), 846–59.
21.
EmordJonathan W. (2000), “Pearson v. Shalala: The Beginning of the End for FDA Speech Suppression,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 19(Spring), 139–43.
GilbertR.J., and WatsonHeather M. (1971), “Some Laboratory Experiments on Various Meat Preparation Surfaces with Regard to Surface Contamination and Cleaning,”International Journal of Food Science & Technology, 6(2), 163–70.
24.
GlassmanMyron, and PieperWilliam J. (1980), “Processing Advertising Information: Deception, Salience, and Inferential Belief Formation,”Journal of Advertising, 9(1), 3–10.
25.
HayekFriedrich A. (1988), The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism, BartleyW.W.III, ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
26.
IppolitoPauline M., and MathiosAlan D. (1991), “Health Claims in Food Marketing: Evidence on Knowledge and Behavior in the Cereal Market,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 10(Spring), 15–32.
27.
IppolitoPauline M., and MathiosAlan D. (1995), “Information and Advertising: The Case of Fat Consumption in the United States,”The American Economic Review, 85(2), 91–95.
28.
JacobyJacob, and HandlinAmy H. (1991), “Non-Probability Sampling Designs for Litigation Surveys,”Trademark Reporter, 81(2), 169–79.
29.
JacobyJacob, NelsonMargaret C., and HoyerWayne D. (1982), “Corrective Advertising and Affirmative Disclosure Statements: Their Potential for Confusing and Misleading the Consumer,”Journal of Marketing, 46(Winter), 61–72.
30.
JacobyJacob, NelsonMargaret C., and RaskopfRobert L. (1986), “Disclaimers in Trademark Infringement Litigation: More Trouble Than They Are Worth?”Trademark Reporter, 76(1), 35–58.
31.
JacobyJacob, NelsonMargaret C., and SzybilloGeorge J. (1994), “Why Disclaimers Fail,”Trademark Reporter, 84(2), 224–44.
32.
JoharGita Venkataramani (1996), “Intended and Unintended Effects of Corrective Advertising on Beliefs and Evaluations: An Exploratory Analysis,”Journal of Consumer Psychology, 5(3), 209–230.
33.
KabatGeoffrey C. (2008), Hyping Health Risks: Environmental Hazards in Daily Life and the Science of Epidemiology.New York: Columbia University Press.
34.
LarssonSusanna C., and OrsiniNicola (2011), “Coffee Consumption and Risk of Stroke: A Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Prospective Studies,”American Journal of Epidemiology, 174(9), 993–1001.
35.
MasonMarlys J., ScammonDebra L., and FangXiang (2007), “The Impact of Warnings, Disclaimers, and Product Experience on Consumers’ Perceptions of Dietary Supplements,”Journal of Consumer Affairs, 41(1), 74–99.
36.
MathiosAlan D. (1998), “The Importance of Nutrition Labeling and Health Claim Regulations on Product Choice: An Analysis of the Cooking Oil Market,”Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 27(2), 159–68.
37.
MazisMichael B. (1975), “Antipollution Measures and Psychological Reactance Theory: A Field Experiment,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 31(4), 654–60.
38.
MazisMichael B., and AdkinsonJanice E. (1976), “An Experimental Evaluation of a Proposed Corrective Advertising Remedy,”Journal of Marketing Research, 13(May), 178–83.
39.
Meyer-HentschelGundolf (1984), “Consumer Evaluation of Informative and Non-Informative Ads,” in Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 11, KinnearThomas C., ed. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 597–600.
40.
Michael L. Potts, D.D.S., and the American Academy of Implant Dentistry v. Brian Stiger, Director, California Department of Consumer Affairs, et al. (2010), CIV-s-03-348 USDC, Eastern District of California, Sacramento.
41.
MorrisLouis A., MazisMichael B., and BrinbergDavid (1989), “Risk Disclosures in Televised Prescription Drug Advertising to Consumers,”Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 8, 64–80.
42.
OsterhouseRobert A., and BrockTimothy C. (1970), “Distraction Increases Yielding to Propaganda by Inhibiting Counterarguing,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 15(4), 344–58.
RingoldDebra Jones (2002), “Boomerang Effects in Response to Public Health Interventions: Some Unintended Consequences in the Alcoholic Beverage Market,”Journal of Consumer Policy, 25(1), 27–63.
45.
SahSunita, LoewensteinGeorge, and CainDaylian M. (2011), “How Doctors’ Disclosures Increase Patient Anxiety,” working paper, Fuqua School of Business, Duke University.
46.
SimonJulian L. (1996), The Ultimate Resource 2.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
47.
SkurnikIan, YoonCarolyn, ParkDenise C., and SchwarzNorbert (2005), “How Warnings About False Claims Become Recommendations,”Journal of Consumer Research, 31(4), 713–24.
48.
SnyderLeslie B., and BloodDeborah J. (1992), “Caution: Alcohol Advertising and the Surgeon General's Alcohol Warnings May Have Adverse Effects on Young Adults,”Journal of Applied Communication Research, 20(February), 37–53.
49.
ThiererAdam (2011), “Advertising, Commercial Speech, and First Amendment Parity,”Charleston Law Review, 5, 503–519.
50.
TwainMark (1885), Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.New York: Charles L. Webster and Company.
51.
Virginia State Board of Pharmacy et al. v. Virginia Citizens Consumer Council, Inc., et al. (1976), 425 U.S. 748, [available at http://laws.findlaw.com/us/425/748.html].
52.
WansinkBrian, and ChandonPierre (2006), “Can ‘Low-Fat’ Nutrition Labels Lead to Obesity?”Journal of Marketing Research, 43(November), 605–617.
53.
WilkieWilliam L., McNeillDennis L., and MazisMichael B. (1984), “Marketing's ‘Scarlet Letter’: The Theory and Practice of Corrective Advertising,”Journal of Marketing, 48(Spring), 11–31.
54.
WinstonClifford (2006), Government Failure Versus Market Failure: Microeconomics Policy Research and Government Performance.Washington, DC: AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies.
55.
WinstonClifford (2008), “The Efficacy of Information Policy: A Review of Archon Fung, Mary Graham, and David Weil's Full Disclosure: The Perils and Promise of Transparency,”Journal of Economic Literature, 46(3), 704–717.
56.
WinstonClifford, MaheshriVikram, and ManneringFred (2006), “An Exploration of the Offset Hypothesis Using Disaggregate Data: The Case of Airbags and Antilock Brakes,”Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 32(2), 83–99.
57.
WrightMalcolm, and Scott ArmstrongJ. (2008), “Verification of Citations: Fawlty Towers of Knowledge,”Interfaces, 38(2), 125–39.
58.
ZellingerDavid A., FromkinHoward L., SpellerDonald E., and KohnCarol A. (1975), “A Commodity Theory Analysis of the Effects of Age Restrictions upon Pornographic Materials,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 60(1), 94–99.
