Does the first entrant in a new market have a difficult time surviving or do first-mover advantages provide protection from outright failure? This empirical study of 264 new industrial product-markets yields insights into this controversial research topic. The key data analysis insights arise through a comparison of survival risks in markets that were started with a really new product and in those that were started with an incremental innovation. When a pioneer starts a new market with a really new product, it can be a major challenge just to survive. In contrast, in markets started by an incremental innovation, market pioneer survival risks are much lower. Notably, early followers have the same survival risk across both types of markets. Overall, these results indicate that in markets started by a really new product, the first to market is often the first to fail. In contrast, in markets started by an incremental innovation, it appears that first-mover advantages protect the pioneer from outright failure.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgarwalRajshree (1997), “Survival of Firms over the Product Life Cycle,”Southern Economic Journal, 63 (3), 571–84.
2.
AgarwalRajshree, and BayusBarry L. (2002), “The Market Evolution and Sales Take-Off of Product Innovations,”Management Science, 48 (August), 1024–1041.
3.
AgarwalRajshree, and GortMichael (1996), “The Evolution of Markets and Entry, Exit, and Survival of Firms,”Review of Economics and Statistics, 78 (3), 489–98.
4.
AgarwalRajshree, and GortMichael (2001), “First-Mover Advantage and the Speed of Competitive Entry,”Journal of Law and Economics, 44 (April), 161–77.
5.
AudretschDavid B. (1991), “New Firm Survival and the Technological Regime,”The Review of Economics and Statistics, 3 (August), 441–50.
6.
BanburyC. M., and MitchellW. (1995), “The Effect of Introducing Important Incremental Innovations on Market Share and Business Survival,”Strategic Management Journal, 16 (Special Issue), 161–82.
7.
BrownChristina, and LattinJames M. (1994), “Investigating the Relationship Between Time in Market and Pioneering Advantage,”Management Science, 40 (October), 1361–69.
8.
CarpenterGregory S., and NakamotoKent (1989), “Consumer Preference Formation and Pioneering Advantage,”Journal of Marketing Research, 26 (August), 285–98.
9.
CarrollGlenn R., BigelowLyda S., SeidelMarc-David L., and TsaiLucia B. (1996), “The Fates of De Novo and De Alio Producers in the American Automobile Industry 1985–1981,”Strategic Management Journal, 17 (Special Issue), 117–37.
10.
CarrollGlenn R., and HannanMichael T. (1989), “Density Delay in the Evolution of Organizational Populations: A Model and Five Empirical Tests,”Administrative Science Quarterly, 34 (September), 411–30.
11.
ChandyRajesh K., and TellisGerard J. (1998), “Organizing for Radical Product Innovation: The Overlooked Role of Willingness to Cannibalize,”Journal of Marketing Research, 35 (November), 474–87.
12.
ChandyRajesh K., and TellisGerard J. (2000), “The Incumbent's Curse? Incumbency, Size, and Radical Product Innovation,”Journal of Marketing, 64 (July), 1–17.
13.
ChristensenClayton M., SuarezFernando F., and Utter-backJames M. (1998), “Strategies for Survival in Fast-Changing Industries,”Management Science, 44 (12), S207–S220.
14.
GarciaRosanna, and CalantoneRoger (2002), “A Critical Look at Technological Innovation Typology and Innovation Terminology: A Literature Review,”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 19 (March), 110–132.
15.
GeroskiP. A. (1995), “What Do We Know About Entry,”International Journal of Industrial Organization, 13 (4), 421–40.
16.
GolderPeter N., and TellisGerard J. (1993), “Pioneer Advantage: Marketing Logic or Marketing Legend?”Journal of Marketing Research, 30 (May), 158–70.
17.
GortMichael, and KlepperStephen (1982), “Time Paths in Diffusion of Product Innovations,”Economic Journal, 92 (367), 630–53.
18.
GriffinAbbie (1997), “PDMA Research on New Product Development Practices: Updating Trends and Benchmarking Best Practices,”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 6 (November), 429–58.
19.
HanA., and HausmanJ. (1990), “Flexible Parametric Estimation of Duration and Competing Risk Models,”Journal of Econometrics, 5 (1), 1–28.
20.
HannanM.T., and CarrollG.R. (1992), Dynamics of Organizational Populations.New York: Oxford University Press.
21.
HannanM. T., and FreemanJ. (1989), Organizational Ecology.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
22.
HeckmanJ., and SingerB. (1984), “A Method for Minimizing the Impact of Distributional Assumptions in Econometric Models for Duration Data,”Econometrica, 52 (2), 271–320.
23.
HelsenKristiaan, and SchmittleinDavid C. (1993), “Analyzing Duration Times in Marketing: Evidence for Effectiveness of Hazard Rate Models,”Marketing Science, 11 (Fall), 395–414.
24.
HuffLenard C., and RobinsonWilliam T. (1994), “The Impact of Leadtime and Years in the Market on Pioneer Market Share Advantages,”Management Science, 40 (October), 1370–77.
25.
KalyanaramGurumurthy, RobinsonWilliam T., and UrbanGlen L. (1995), “Order of Market Entry: Established Empirical Generalizations, Emerging Generalizations, and Future Research,”Marketing Science, 14 (2), G212–G221.
26.
KerinRoger A., VaradarajanP. Rajan, and PetersonRobert A. (1992), “First-Mover Advantage: A Synthesis, Conceptual Framework, and Research Propositions,”Journal of Marketing, 56 (October), 33–52.
27.
LambkinMary, and DayGeorge S. (1989), “Evolutionary Processes in Competitive Markets: Beyond the Product Life Cycle,”Journal of Marketing, 53 (July), 4–20.
28.
LancasterT. (1979), “Econometric Methods for the Duration of Unemployment,”Econometrica, 47 (4), 939–56.
29.
LancasterT. (1990), The Econometric Analysis of Transition Data.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
30.
LavinMichael R. (1992), Business Information: How to Find It, How to Use It.Phoenix: Oryx Press.
31.
LiebermanMarvin B., and MontgomeryDavid B. (1988), “First-Mover Advantages,”Strategic Management Journal, 9 (5), 41–58.
32.
LilienGary L., and YoonEungsang (1990), “The Timing of Competitive Market Entry: An Exploratory Study of New Industrial Products,”Management Science, 36 (5), 568–85.
33.
MansfieldEdwin, and WagnerSamuel (1975), “Organizational and Strategic Factors Associated with Probabilities of Success in Industrial R&D,”Journal of Business, 48 (April), 179–98.
34.
MeyerB. D. (1990), “Unemployment, Insurance and Unemployment Spells,”Econometrica, 58 (4), 757–82.
35.
MitchellWill (1991), “Dual Clocks: Entry Order Influences on Incumbent and Newcomer Market Share and Survival When Specialized Assets Retain Their Value,”Strategic Management Journal, 12 (2), 85–100.
36.
OllerosFrancisco-Javier (1986), “Emerging Industries and the Burnout of Pioneers,”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 1 (1), 5–18.
37.
RobinsonWilliam T. (1988), “Sources of Market Pioneer Advantages: The Case of Industrial Goods Industries,”Journal of Marketing Research, 25 (February), 87–94.
38.
RobinsonWilliam T., and FornellClaes (1985), “Sources of Market Pioneer Advantages in Consumer Goods Industries,”Journal of Marketing Research, 22 (August), 305–317.
39.
RobinsonWilliam T., and MinSungwook (2002), “Is the First to Market the First to Fail? Empirical Evidence for Industrial Goods Businesses,”Journal of Marketing Research, 34 (February), 120–28.
SchmidtJeffery B., and CalantoneRoger J. (1998), “Are Really New Product Development Projects Harder to Shut Down?”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 15 (2), 111–23.
42.
ShepherdDean A. (1999), “Venture Capitalists' Assessment of New Venture Survival,”Management Science, 45 (May), 621–32.
43.
SongX. Michael, and Montoya-WeissMitzi M. (1998), “Critical Development Activities for Really New Versus Incremental Products,”Journal of Product Innovation Management, 15 (2), 124–35.
44.
SrinivasanRaji, LilienGary L., and RangaswamyArvind (2004), “First In, First Out? The Effects of Network Externalities on Pioneer Survival,”Journal of Marketing, 68 (January), 41–58.
45.
SzymanskiDavid M., TroyLisa C., and BharadwajSundar G. (1995), “Order of Entry and Business Performance: An Empirical Synthesis and Reexamination,”Journal of Marketing, 59 (October), 17–33.
46.
TellisGerard J., and GolderPeter (1996), “First to Market, First to Fail? Real Causes of Enduring Market Leadership,”Sloan Management Review, 2 (Winter), 65–75.
47.
UrbanGlen L., CarterTheresa, GaskinSteven, and MuchaZofia (1986), “Market Share Rewards to Pioneering Brands: An Empirical Analysis and Strategic Implications,”Management Science, 32 (June), 645–59.
48.
UrbanGlen L., WeinbergBruce D., and HauserJohn R. (1996), “Premarket Forecasting of Really-New Products,”Journal of Marketing, 60 (January), 47–60.
49.
VanderWerfPieter A., and MahonJohn F. (1997), “Meta-Analysis of the Impact of Research Methods on Findings of First-Mover Advantage,”Management Science, 43 (November), 1510–19.
50.
VanhueleMarc, DekimpeMarnik G., SharmaSunil, and MorrisonDonald G. (1995), “Probability Models for Duration: The Data Don't Tell the Whole Story,”Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 62 (April), 1–13.
51.
YamaguchiK. (1991), Event History Analysis: Applied Social Research Methods Series Vol. 28. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
