Antismoking advertising is increasingly used, but its message content is controversial. In an initial study in which adolescents coded 194 advertisements, the authors identified seven common message themes. Using protection motivation theory, the authors develop hypotheses regarding the message theme effects on cognitions and intentions and test them in an experiment involving 1667 adolescents. Three of the seven message themes increased adolescents’ nonsmoking intentions compared with a control; all did so by enhancing adolescents’ perceptions that smoking poses severe social disapproval risks. Other message themes increased health risk severity perceptions but were undermined by low perceived vulnerability.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AakerDavid A., BatraRajeev, and MyersJohn G., (1992), Advertising Management.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
AmosAmanda, CurrieCandice, GrayDavid, and EltonRob, (1998), “Perceptions of Fashion Images from Youth Magazines: Does a Cigarette Make a Difference?”Health Education Research, 13(December), 491–501.
4.
ArnettJeffrey J., (2000), “Optimistic Bias in Adolescent and Adult Smokers and Nonsmokers,”Addictive Behaviors, 25(July/August), 625–32.
5.
BanduraAlbert, (1997), Self-Efficacy: The Exercise of Control.New York: W.H. Freeman.
6.
BanspachStephen W., Craig LefebvreR., and CarletonRichard A., (1989), “Increasing Awareness of the Pressures Related to Smoking: An Analysis of Two Models of Anti-smoking Curriculum in the Classroom,”Health Education Research, 4(March), 69–78.
7.
BauerUrsula E., JohnsonTammie M., HopkinsRichard S., and BrooksRobert G., (2000), “Changes in Youth Cigarette Use and Intentions Following Implementation of a Tobacco Control Program: Findings from the Florida Youth Tobacco Survey, 1998–2000,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(August), 723–34.
8.
BaumanKarl E., (1997), Written correspondence regarding “A Study of Cigarette Smoking Behavior Among Youth: Adolescent Questionnaire,” School of Public Health, Department of Maternal and Child Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (Fall).
9.
BenthinAlida, SlovicPaul, and SeversonHerbert, (1993), “A Psychometric Study of Adolescent Risk Perception,”Journal of Adolescence, 16(June), 153–68.
10.
BienerLois, (2000), “Adult and Youth Response to the Massachusetts Anti-tobacco Television Campaign,”Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 6(May), 40–44.
11.
BlankenshipAlbert B., and BreenGeorge E., (1993), State-of-the-Art Marketing Research.Lincolnwood, IL: NTC Business Books.
12.
BlockLauren G., and KellerPunam A., (1998), “Beyond Protection Motivation: an Integrative Theory of Health Appeals,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 28(September), 1548–608.
13.
BoerHenk, and SeydelErwin R., (1996), “Protection Motivation Theory,” in Predicting Health Behaviour, ConnerMark, and NormanPaul, eds. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press, 95–120.
14.
BollenKenneth A., (1989), Structural Equations with Latent Variables.New York: John Wiley & Sons.
15.
BrehmJack W., (1972), Responses to Loss of Freedom: A Theory of Psychological Reactance.Morristown, NJ: General Learning Press.
16.
BrucksMerrie, ArmstrongGary M., and GoldbergMarvin E., (1988), “Children's Use of Cognitive Defenses Against Television Advertising: A Cognitive Response Approach,”Journal of Consumer Research, 14(March), 471–82.
17.
BryanAngela D., AikenLeona S., and WestStephen G., (1996), “Increasing Condom Use: Evaluation of a Theory-Based Intervention to Prevent Sexually Transmitted Diseases in Young Women,”Health Psychology, 15(September), 371–82.
18.
BurgessErika Swift, and WurteleSandy K., (1998), “Enhancing Parent–Child Communication About Sexual Abuse: A Pilot Study,”Child Abuse and Neglect, 22(November), 1167–75.
19.
California Department of Health Services (1990), Toward a Tobacco Free California.Sacramento, CA: Department of Health Services.
20.
California Department of Health Services (2001), Independent Evaluation of the California Tobacco Control Prevention and Education Program.Sacramento, CA: Department of Health Services.
21.
Campaign for Tobacco Free-Kids (2002), “Show Us the Money: An Update on the States’ Allocation of the Tobacco Settlement Dollars,” (accessed January 13, 2003), [available at http://www.tobaccofreekids.org/].
22.
CampbellMargaret C., and KirmaniAmna, (2000), “Consumers’ Use of Persuasion Knowledge: The Effects of Accessibility and Cognitive Capacity on Perceptions of an Influence Agent,”Journal of Consumer Research, 27(June), 69–83.
23.
CastleCatherine M., Chas SkinnerT., and HampsonSarah E., (1999), “Young Women and Suntanning: An Evaluation of a Health Education Leaflet,”Psychology and Health, 14(May), 517–27.
24.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1994), “Guidelines for School Health Programs to Prevent Tobacco Use and Addiction,”Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 43(RR-2), 1–15.
25.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (1999), Best Practices for Comprehensive Tobacco Control Programs.Atlanta, GA: Office on Smoking and Health.
26.
ChassinLaurie, PressonClark C., ShermanSteven J., CortyEric, and OlshavskyRichard W., (1984), “Predicting the Onset of Cigarette Smoking in Adolescents: A Longitudinal Study,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 14(May/June), 224–43.
27.
CleeMona A., and WicklundRobert A., (1980), “Consumer Behavior and Psychological Reactance,”Journal of Consumer Research, 6(March), 389–405.
28.
CohenLawrence D., MacfarlaneSusan, YanezClaudia, and ImaiWalter K., (1995), “Risk-Perception: Differences Between Adolescents and Adults,”Health Psychology, 14(May), 217–22.
29.
CollinsLinda M., SussmanSteve, MesteJill, DentClyde W., Anderson JohnsonC., HansenWilliam B., and FlayBrian R., (1987), “Psychosocial Predictors of Adolescent Cigarette Smoking: A Sixteen-Month, Three-Wave Longitudinal Study,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 17(June), 554–73.
30.
ConnollyGregory, and RobbinsHarriett, (1998), “Designing and Effective Statewide Tobacco Control Program—Massachusetts,”Cancer, 83(December), 2722–27.
31.
ConradKaren M., FlayBrian R., and HillDavid, (1991), “Why Children Start Smoking Cigarettes: Predictors of Onset,”British Journal of Addiction, 87(December), 1711–24.
32.
DePalmaMary Turner, McCallMichael, and EnglishGary, (1996), “Increasing Perceptions of Disease Vulnerability Through Imagery,”College Health, 44(March), 227–34.
33.
DijkstraArie, De VriesHein, and RoijackersJolanda, (1998), “Computerized Tailored Feedback to Change Cognitive Determinants of Smoking: A Dutch Field Experiment,”Health Education Research, 13(June), 197–206.
34.
DorrAimee, GravesSherryl Browne, and PhelpsErin, (1980), “Television Literacy for Young Children,”Journal of Communication, 30(3), 71–83.
35.
FarrellyMatthew C., HealtonCheryl G., DavisKevin C., MesseriPeter, HerseyJames C., and Lyndon HavilandM., (2002), “Getting to the Truth: Evaluating National Tobacco Counter-marketing Campaigns,”American Journal of Public Health, 92(June), 901–907.
36.
FeshbachSeymour, FeshbachNorma D., and CohenSarale E., (1982), “Enhancing Children's Discrimination in Response to Television Advertising: The Effects of Psychoeducational Training in Two Elementary School-Age Groups,”Developmental Review, 2(December), 385–403.
37.
FischhoffBaruch, ParkerAndrew M., De BruinWandi, DownsJulie, PalmgreenClaire, DawesRobyn, Charlesand, Man-skiF., (2000), “Teen Expectations for Significant Life Events,”Public Opinion Quarterly, 64(Summer), 189–205.
38.
FloydDonna L., Prentice-DunnSteven, and RogersRonald W., (2000), “A Meta-Analysis of Research on Protection Motivation Theory,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30(February), 407–29.
39.
FlynnMary F., LymanRobert D., and Prentice-DunnSteven, (1995), “Protection Motivation Theory and Adherence to Medical Treatment Regimes for Muscular Dystrophy,”Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 14(Spring), 61–75.
40.
FornellClaes, and LarckerDavid F., (1981), “Evaluating Structural Equation Models with Unobserved Variables and Measurement Error,”Journal of Marketing Research, 18(February), 39–50.
41.
FriestadMarian, and WrightPeter, (1994), “The Persuasion Knowledge Model: How People Cope with Persuasion Attempts,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21(June), 1–31.
42.
GlynnThomas J., (1989), “Essential Elements of School-Based Smoking Prevention Programs,”Journal of School Health, 59(May), 181–88.
43.
GoldmanLisa, and GlantzStanton A., (1998), “Evaluation of Anti-smoking Advertising Campaigns,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 279(March), 772–77.
44.
GrahamJohn W., MarksGary, and HansenWilliam B., (1991), “Social Influence Processes Affecting Adolescent Substance Use,”Journal of Applied Psychology, 76(April), 291–98.
45.
GrubeJoel, (1997), Written correspondence regarding “Parents and Children: a Survey, SCR R 1206, Forms C1 and C2,”Prevention Research Center, Berkeley, CA (Fall).
46.
HoRobert, (1998), “The Intention to Give Up Smoking: Disease Versus Social Dimensions,”Journal of Social Psychology, 138(June), 368–80.
47.
JohnstonLloyd D., O'MalleyP.M., and BachmanJerald G., (2001), “Cigarette Smoking Among American Teens Declines Sharply in 2001,”University of Michigan News and Information Services, (accessed January 13, 2003), [available at http://www.monitoringthefuture.org/].
48.
JonesJody L., and LearyMark R., (1994), “Effects of Appearance-Based Admonitions Against Sun Exposure on Tanning Intentions in Young Adults,”Health Psychology, 13(January), 86–90.
49.
JöreskogKarl, and SörbomDag, (1993), LISREL 8: Structural Equation Modeling with SIMPLIS Command Language.Chicago: Scientific Software International.
KleinRichard, (1993), Cigarettes Are Sublime.Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
53.
KleinotMichael C., and RogersRonald W., (1982), “Identifying Effective Components of Alcohol Misuse Prevention Programs,”Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 43(July), 802–11.
54.
KlohnLisa S., and RogersRonald W., (1991), “Dimensions of the Severity of a Health Threat: The Persuasive Effects of Visibility, Time of Onset, and Rate of Onset on Young Women's Intentions to Prevent Osteoporosis,”Health Psychology, 10(5), 323–29.
55.
MadduxJames E., and RogersRonald W., (1983), “Protection Motivation and Self-Efficacy: A Revised Theory of Fear Appeals and Attitude Change,”Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 19(September), 469–79.
56.
MahlerHeike I.M., FitzpatrickBetsy, ParkerPatricia, and LapinAngela, (1997), “The Relative Effects of a Health-Based Versus an Appearance-Based Intervention Designed to Increase Sunscreen Use,”American Journal of Health Promotion, 11(July/August), 426–29.
57.
McNealRalph B., and HansenWilliam B., (1999), “Developmental Patterns Associated with the Onset of Drug Use: Changes in Postulated Mediators During Adolescence,”Journal of Drug Issues, 29(Spring), 381–400.
58.
MillerAnne, (1998), “Designing an Effective Counter Advertising Campaign—Massachusetts,”Cancer, 83(December), 2742–45.
59.
MilneSarah, SheeranPaschal, and OrbellShejna, (2000), “Prediction and Intervention in Health-Related Behavior: A Meta-Analytic Review of Protection Motivation Theory,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30(January), 106–43.
60.
Minnesota Department of Health, (1991), Minnesota Tobacco-Use Prevention Initiative 1989–1990: A Report to the 1991 Legislature.Minneapolis, MN: Department of Health.
61.
MulilisJohn-Paul, and LippaRichard, (1990), “Behavioral Changes in Earthquake Preparedness Due to Negative Threat Appeals: A Test of Protection Motivation Theory,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 20(May), 619–38.
62.
National Association of Attorneys General (2000), “Master Settlement Agreement,” (accessed January 13, 2003), [available at http://www.naag.org/tobac/].
PechmannCornelia, (2002), “Changing Adolescent Smoking Prevalence: Impact of Advertising Interventions,” in Changing Adolescent Smoking Prevalence: Where It Is and Why, BurnsDavid, ed. Silver Spring, MD: National Cancer Institute, 171–81.
65.
PechmannCornelia, and KnightSusan J., (2002), “An Experimental Investigation of the Joint Effects of Advertising and Peers on Adolescents’ Beliefs and Intentions About Cigarette Consumption,”Journal of Consumer Research, 29(June), 5–19.
66.
PechmannCornelia, and KnightSusan J., and RatneshwarSrinivasan, (1994), “The Effects of Anti-smoking and Cigarette Advertising on Young Adolescents’ Perceptions of Peers Who Smoke,”Journal of Consumer Research, 21(September), 236–51.
67.
PechmannCornelia, and KnightSusan J., and RatneshwarSrinivasan, and ReiblingEllen Thomas, (2000), “Planning an Effective Anti-smoking Mass Media Campaign Targeting Adolescents,”Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 6(May), 80–94.
68.
PechmannCornelia, and KnightSusan J., and RatneshwarSrinivasan, and ReiblingEllen Thomas, and ShihChuan-Fong, (1999), “Smoking in Movies and Antismoking Advertisements Before Movies: Effects on Youth,”Journal of Marketing, 63(July), 1–13.
69.
PetersonLizette, and LewisKatherine E., (1988), “Preventive Intervention to Improve Children's Discrimination of the Persuasive Tactics in Televised Advertising,”Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 13(June), 163–70.
70.
PierceJohn P., ChoiWon S., GilpinElizabeth, FarkasArthur J., and MerrittRobert K., (1996), “Validation of Susceptibility as a Predictor of Which Adolescents Take Up Smoking in the United States,”Health Psychology, 15(September), 355–61.
71.
RippetoePatricia A., and RogersRonald W., (1987), “Effects of Components of Protection-Motivation Theory on Adaptive and Maladaptive Coping with a Health Threat,”Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(March), 596–604.
72.
RogersRonald W., (1975), “A Protection Motivation Theory of Fear Appeals and Attitude Change,”Journal of Psychology, 91(September), 93–114.
73.
RogersRonald W., (1983), “Cognitive and Physiological Process in Fear Appeals and Attitude Change: A Revised Theory of Protection Motivation,” in Social Psychophysiology: A Source Book, CacioppoJohn, and PettyRichard, eds. New York: Guilford Press, 153–76.
74.
RohrbachLouise, GrahamJohn W., HansenWilliam B., FlayBrian R., and Anderson JohnsonC., (1987), “Evaluation of Resistance Skills Training Using Multitrait–Multimethod Role-Play Skills Assessment,”Health Education Research, 2(December), 401–407.
75.
RomerDaniel, and JamiesonPatrick, (2001), “Advertising, Smoker Imagery, and the Diffusion of Smoking Behavior,” in Smoking Risk, Perception, and Policy, SlovicPaul, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 127–55.
76.
RoseRichard J., (1997), Written correspondence regarding the “I.U. Smoking Questionnaire,”Department of Psychology, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN (Fall).
77.
SchoenbachlerDenise D., and WhittlerTommy E., (1996), “Adolescent Processing of Social and Physical Threat Communications,”Journal of Advertising, 25(Winter), 37–54.
78.
SchumannDavid W., PettyRichard E., and Scott ClemonsD., (1990), “Predicting the Effectiveness of Different Strategies of Advertising Variation: A Test of the Repetition–Variation Hypotheses,”Journal of Consumer Research, 17(September), 192–202.
79.
SteffenValerie J., (1990), “Men's Motivation to Perform the Testicle Self-Exam: Effects of Prior Knowledge and an Educational Brochure,”Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 20(May), 681–702.
80.
SturgesJames W., and RogersRonald W., (1996), “Preventive Health Psychology from a Developmental Perspective: An Extension of Protection Motivation Theory,”Health Psychology, 15(May), 158–66.
81.
TannerJohn F.Jr., HuntJames B., and EpprightDavid R., (1991), “The Protection Motivation Model: A Normative Model of Fear Appeals,”Journal of Marketing, 55(July), 36–45.
TeinowitzIra, (1998), “After the Tobacco Settlement: Take the Money and Run (Ads),”Washington Post, (December 6), C1.
84.
UrbergKathryn A., and RobbinsRochelle, (1984), “Perceived Vulnerability in Adolescents to the Health Consequences of Cigarette Smoking,”Preventive Medicine, 13(3), 367–76.
85.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (1999), “Summary of Findings from the 1999 National Household Survey on Drug Abuse,” (accessed January 13, 2003), [available at http://www.icpsr.umich.edu/SAMHDA/].
86.
WeinsteinNeil D., (1983), “Reducing Unrealistic Optimism About Illness Susceptibility,”Health Psychology, 2(Winter), 11–20.
87.
WeinsteinNeil D., (1993), “Testing Four Competing Theories of Health-Protective Behavior,”Health Psychology, 12(July), 324–33.
88.
WeinsteinNeil D., (2000), “Perceived Probability, Perceived Severity, and Health-Protective Behavior,”Health Psychology, 19(January), 65–74.
89.
WeinsteinNeil D., SandmanPeter M., and RobertsNancy E., (1991), “Perceived Susceptibility and Self-Protective Behavior: A Field Experiment to Encourage Home Radon Testing,”Health Psychology, 10(1), 25–33.
90.
WitteKim, (1992), “The Role of Threat and Efficacy in AIDS Prevention,”International Quarterly of Community Health Education, 12(3), 225–49.
91.
WoodPeter B., CochranJohn K., PfefferbaumBetty, and ArneklevBruce J., (1995), “Sensation-Seeking and Delinquent Substance Use: An Extension of Learning Theory,”The Journal of Drug Issues, 25(Winter), 173–93.
92.
WordenJohn K., FlynnBrian S., GellerBerta M., ChenMilton, SheltonLawrence G., Secker-WalkerRoger H., SolomonDouglas S., SolomonLaura, SoucheySidney, and CostanzaMichael C., (1988), “Development of Smoking Prevention Mass Media Program Using Diagnostic and Formative Research,”Social Science and Medicine, 17(2), 531–58.
93.
WordenJohn K., FlynnBrian S., GellerBerta M., ChenMilton, SheltonLawrence G., Secker-WalkerRoger H., SolomonDouglas S., SolomonLaura, SoucheySidney, and CostanzaMichael C., and Secker-WalkerRoger H., (1998), “Antismoking Advertising Campaigns for Youth,”Journal of the American Medical Association, 280(July), 323.
94.
WurteleSandy K., and MadduxJames E., (1987), “Relative Contributions of Protection Motivation Theory Components in Predicting Exercise Intentions and Behavior,”Health Psychology, 6(5), 453–66.
